Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Physical Review A

Comment on "Spontaneous radiative coupling of atomic energy levels"

Richard J. Cook

Published Mar 1, 1984• 5 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Recently Cardimona and Stroud emphasized that, when the energy levels of an atom are degenerate or nearly so, there can exist a strong radiative interaction between different spontaneous transitions of the atom. This interaction is described by the generalized damping terms and generalized frequency-shift terms in the equation of motion for the atomic density matrix. We here point out that the generalized damping terms can play an important role in the absence of degeneracy for systems other than atoms, and cite the harmonic oscillator as an example. Specifically, we show that these terms are needed for a proper classical limit of radiation damping, and that a small anharmonicity can have a very large effect on the radiative decay rate of the oscillator's amplitude.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.29.1583

Related papers

Spontaneous radiative coupling of atomic energy levels

David A. Cardimona, Carlos R. Stroud

Density-matrix equations of motion derived from Heisenberg picture source-field quantum electrodynamics contain damping constants and frequency shifts which are not associated with a single radiative transition but which instead couple two separate transitions together. In the absence of degeneracies in the atomic levels, these coupling terms are normally neglected when the rotating-wave approximation is invoked. These terms cannot be neglected when there are degeneracies or near degeneracies. In this paper, we interpret the generalized frequency shifts, show how they can be renormalized and included in shifts of atomic energy levels and altered damping constants, and discuss their experimental significance.

Physical Review A•May 1, 1983•35 citations

The Decay of Resonance Radiation by Spontaneous Emission

Emil J. Hellund

A critical examination of the theory of resonance radiation has been carried through, employing the mathematical technique of Laplace and Stieltjes transforms. Particular attention has been devoted to the question of the temporal behavior of the excited state. With no restrictions on the interaction between atom and radiation field other than that it be real, and that processes of sufficiently high frequency contribute only negligible effects, one can prove that the probability amplitude of the excited state cannot decay according to the general law ${\ensuremath{\Sigma}}_{\ensuremath{\mu},\ensuremath{\nu}}{C}_{\ensuremath{\mu}\ensuremath{\nu}}{t}^{{\ensuremath{\lambda}}_{\ensuremath{\mu}}}{e}^{\ensuremath{-}{\ensuremath{\beta}}_{\ensuremath{\nu}}t},$ where the ${\ensuremath{\lambda}}_{\ensuremath{\mu}}$ and ${\ensuremath{\beta}}_{\ensuremath{\nu}}$ are complex constants lying in the right half-plane and the ${C}_{\ensuremath{\mu}\ensuremath{\nu}}$ are arbitrary complex coefficients. The deviation from the law just cited can be termed a straggling phenomenon since exact analysis shows that the probability amplitude, for sufficiently long times, is greater than that defined according to the radioactive decay law.Rigorous analysis of the source of this apparently anomalous behavior reveals the following explanation. Although the probability amplitude of the excited state is, strictly speaking, a functional of the interaction between the transition current in the atom and the photon states of the electromagnetic field, the essential features are determined principally by those states lying near the resonance frequency. Three elementary observations are immediately apparent. First, a particularly tractable analytical approximation for the interaction can be made such that the value of the actual interaction is reproduced at the resonance frequency and such that the behavior for high and low frequency photon states is at least qualitatively correct. Exact solutions in closed form can be obtained for this interaction. Second, in terms of the preceding representation it is possible to show that, associated with the transition between two atomic states, one is presented with a concomitant picture of a damped oscillation of charge describable in purely classical terms. Third, this classical motion can be interpreted as forming a source function for a continuous stochastic process in terms of which one finally derives the representation of the probability amplitude of the excited state. The straggling phenomenon previously cited is therefore that associated with all diffusion processes. The consideration of the exact interaction leads to more involved diffusion phenomena but does not in any case permit a radioactive decay law.

Physical Review•Mar 1, 1953•43 citations

Theory of generalized damping and quantum interference in multi-level atomic systems

M. Artoni, Arturo Bambini

When a monochromatic laser resonantly excites a multi-level atom the optical Bloch equations for the reduced atomic density matrix, which describe the evolution of such a system, may exhibit generalized damping terms. We justify the origin of these damping terms within the radiative cascade description of resonance fluorescence in the dressed-atom picture and in the spin-orbit coupling picture. We describe the connection between generalized damping terms and quantum interference in the process of spontaneous emission.

Journal of Physics B Atomic Molecular and Optical Physics•Oct 28, 1998•2 citations

Radiation from an N -Atom System. II. Spontaneous Emission from a Pair of Atoms

Robert H. Lehmberg

Using the formalism developed earlier, we treat spontaneous emission from a pair of identical two-level atoms ${A}_{1}$, ${A}_{2}$, whose separation ${r}_{21}$ can be comparable to the wavelength $\ensuremath{\lambda}$. We obtain expressions for time-dependent intensities and damping rates with the initial conditions (a) both atoms inverted, (b) prior excitation by a short $\frac{1}{2}\ensuremath{\pi}$ pulse, and (c) only ${A}_{1}$ inverted. The results in (a) are compared with those obtained for a model consisting of two initially excited harmonic oscillators ${O}_{1}$, ${O}_{2}$. The atoms exhibit superradiant behavior, whereas ${O}_{1}$, ${O}_{2}$ tend to trap radiation. In (a), the intensity pattern $\mathcal{R}(\ensuremath{\theta},t)$ develops lobes in different directions at different times, so that the spatial distribution of photons at time $t\ensuremath{\rightarrow}\ensuremath{\infty}$ is the same as in the independent-atom case ${r}_{21}\ensuremath{\gg}\ensuremath{\lambda}$. For the oscillators, the lobes of $\mathcal{R}(\ensuremath{\theta},t)$ do not change direction, but only become more pronounced as time increases. In (b) and (c), the lobes oscillate back and forth at frequency $2{\ensuremath{\Omega}}_{12}$ corresponding to the shifts $\ifmmode\pm\else\textpm\fi{}{\ensuremath{\Omega}}_{12}$ of the triplet and singlet states due to the ${A}_{1}\ensuremath{-}{A}_{2}$ interaction. The intensity can therefore have a sinusoidal component. Field correlation functions calculated for (a) and (c) show that ${A}_{2}$ and ${A}_{2}$ radiate simultaneously around the frequencies $\ensuremath{\epsilon}\ifmmode\pm\else\textpm\fi{}{\ensuremath{\Omega}}_{12}$, where $\ensuremath{\epsilon}$ is the single-atom resonant frequency. The spectrum is calculated for case (c), and shows the effects of coherent linewidth enhancement in addition to the frequency shifts.

Physical Review A•Sep 1, 1970•288 citations

Transition Operators in Radiative Damping Theory

Robert H. Lehmberg

The application of transition operators ${\mathcal{P}}_{m,{m}^{\ensuremath{'}}}(t)=\mathrm{exp}(\mathrm{iHt})|m〉〈{m}^{\ensuremath{'}}|\mathrm{exp}(\ensuremath{-}iHt)$ is studied for the problem of an atomic system $S$ with eigenstates ${m}$ interacting with one or more damping reservoirs $R$. The average value of these operators gives the reduced density matrix ${{\ensuremath{\rho}}_{{m}^{\ensuremath{'}},m}}^{(S)}(t)$ for $S$. If $R$ consists of broad-band distributions of harmonic oscillators, (e.g., radiative damping), then damped equations of motion can be derived for all ${\mathcal{P}}_{m,{m}^{\ensuremath{'}}}(t)$, even if $S$ is a multilevel system. One need not specify the initial states of $R$, nor restrict the treatment to second order in the S-R coupling. The formalism is illustrated for the case where $S$ consists of (i) a four-level atom in a resonant cavity (with broad-band modes also present), and (ii) a collection of atoms that can be treated as a multilevel spin system. Density-matrix equations are obtained for the case where no damping radiation is present initially. In (ii), the formalism is used to derive a two-time corrleation function without the aid of the fluctuation-regression theorem.

Physical Review•May 5, 1969•31 citations

Atom and quantum oscillator coupled by the vacuum field: Radiation pattern, emission spectrum, and decay dynamics

P. R. Berman, C. H. Raymond Ooi

We study the dynamics of a system consisting of a two-level atom and a quantum oscillator coupled by the vacuum radiation field. The oscillator and the atom are assumed to have the same resonance frequency. In contrast to the two-atom or two-oscillator case, the atom-oscillator system leads to an unclosed hierarchy of equations for the operators that determine the radiation pattern emitted by the atom-oscillator system. Instead of using the operator equations, we formulate the problem in terms of density-matrix equations which can be solved once the initial conditions are specified. As an example, we looked at the radiation pattern, the decay dynamics, and the spectrum for an initial condition in which the oscillator is in its $n=1$ state and the atom is in its excited state. Dressed states (dressed by the static interaction between the atom and oscillator) prove to be especially useful for interpreting the results and comparing them with the two-atom and two-oscillator systems. All calculations are carried out using the resonance or rotating-wave approximation. The relationship of our work to damped Jaynes-Cummings models is noted.

Physical Review A•Jan 4, 2016•2 citations
Recently Cardimona and Stroud emphasized that, when the energy levels of an atom are degenerate or nearly so, there can exist a strong radiative interaction between different spontaneous transitions of the atom. This interaction is described by the generalized damping terms and generalized frequency-shift terms in the equation of motion for the atomic density matrix. We here point out that the generalized damping terms can play an important role in the absence of degeneracy for systems other than atoms, and cite the harmonic oscillator as an example. Specifically, we show that these terms are needed for a proper classical limit of radiation damping, and that a small anharmonicity can have a very large effect on the radiative decay rate of the oscillator's amplitude.
Density-matrix equations of motion derived from Heisenberg picture source-field quantum electrodynamics contain damping constants and frequency shifts which are not associated with a single radiative transition but which instead couple two separate transitions together. In the absence of degeneracies in the atomic levels, these coupling terms are normally neglected when the rotating-wave approximation is invoked. These terms cannot be neglected when there are degeneracies or near degeneracies. In this paper, we interpret the generalized frequency shifts, show how they can be renormalized and included in shifts of atomic energy levels and altered damping constants, and discuss their experimental significance.
A critical examination of the theory of resonance radiation has been carried through, employing the mathematical technique of Laplace and Stieltjes transforms. Particular attention has been devoted to the question of the temporal behavior of the excited state. With no restrictions on the interaction between atom and radiation field other than that it be real, and that processes of sufficiently high frequency contribute only negligible effects, one can prove that the probability amplitude of the excited state cannot decay according to the general law ${\ensuremath{\Sigma}}_{\ensuremath{\mu},\ensuremath{\nu}}{C}_{\ensuremath{\mu}\ensuremath{\nu}}{t}^{{\ensuremath{\lambda}}_{\ensuremath{\mu}}}{e}^{\ensuremath{-}{\ensuremath{\beta}}_{\ensuremath{\nu}}t},$ where the ${\ensuremath{\lambda}}_{\ensuremath{\mu}}$ and ${\ensuremath{\beta}}_{\ensuremath{\nu}}$ are complex constants lying in the right half-plane and the ${C}_{\ensuremath{\mu}\ensuremath{\nu}}$ are arbitrary complex coefficients. The deviation from the law just cited can be termed a straggling phenomenon since exact analysis shows that the probability amplitude, for sufficiently long times, is greater than that defined according to the radioactive decay law.Rigorous analysis of the source of this apparently anomalous behavior reveals the following explanation. Although the probability amplitude of the excited state is, strictly speaking, a functional of the interaction between the transition current in the atom and the photon states of the electromagnetic field, the essential features are determined principally by those states lying near the resonance frequency. Three elementary observations are immediately apparent. First, a particularly tractable analytical approximation for the interaction can be made such that the value of the actual interaction is reproduced at the resonance frequency and such that the behavior for high and low frequency photon states is at least qualitatively correct. Exact solutions in closed form can be obtained for this interaction. Second, in terms of the preceding representation it is possible to show that, associated with the transition between two atomic states, one is presented with a concomitant picture of a damped oscillation of charge describable in purely classical terms. Third, this classical motion can be interpreted as forming a source function for a continuous stochastic process in terms of which one finally derives the representation of the probability amplitude of the excited state. The straggling phenomenon previously cited is therefore that associated with all diffusion processes. The consideration of the exact interaction leads to more involved diffusion phenomena but does not in any case permit a radioactive decay law.
When a monochromatic laser resonantly excites a multi-level atom the optical Bloch equations for the reduced atomic density matrix, which describe the evolution of such a system, may exhibit generalized damping terms. We justify the origin of these damping terms within the radiative cascade description of resonance fluorescence in the dressed-atom picture and in the spin-orbit coupling picture. We describe the connection between generalized damping terms and quantum interference in the process of spontaneous emission.
Using the formalism developed earlier, we treat spontaneous emission from a pair of identical two-level atoms A1{A}_{1}A1​, A2{A}_{2}A2​, whose separation r21{r}_{21}r21​ can be comparable to the wavelength $\ensuremath{\lambda}$. We obtain expressions for time-dependent intensities and damping rates with the initial conditions (a) both atoms inverted, (b) prior excitation by a short $\frac{1}{2}\ensuremath{\pi}$ pulse, and (c) only A1{A}_{1}A1​ inverted. The results in (a) are compared with those obtained for a model consisting of two initially excited harmonic oscillators O1{O}_{1}O1​, O2{O}_{2}O2​. The atoms exhibit superradiant behavior, whereas O1{O}_{1}O1​, O2{O}_{2}O2​ tend to trap radiation. In (a), the intensity pattern $\mathcal{R}(\ensuremath{\theta},t)$ develops lobes in different directions at different times, so that the spatial distribution of photons at time $t\ensuremath{\rightarrow}\ensuremath{\infty}$ is the same as in the independent-atom case ${r}_{21}\ensuremath{\gg}\ensuremath{\lambda}$. For the oscillators, the lobes of $\mathcal{R}(\ensuremath{\theta},t)$ do not change direction, but only become more pronounced as time increases. In (b) and (c), the lobes oscillate back and forth at frequency $2{\ensuremath{\Omega}}_{12}$ corresponding to the shifts $\ifmmode\pm\else\textpm\fi{}{\ensuremath{\Omega}}_{12}$ of the triplet and singlet states due to the ${A}_{1}\ensuremath{-}{A}_{2}$ interaction. The intensity can therefore have a sinusoidal component. Field correlation functions calculated for (a) and (c) show that A2{A}_{2}A2​ and A2{A}_{2}A2​ radiate simultaneously around the frequencies $\ensuremath{\epsilon}\ifmmode\pm\else\textpm\fi{}{\ensuremath{\Omega}}_{12}$, where $\ensuremath{\epsilon}$ is the single-atom resonant frequency. The spectrum is calculated for case (c), and shows the effects of coherent linewidth enhancement in addition to the frequency shifts.
The application of transition operators ${\mathcal{P}}_{m,{m}^{\ensuremath{'}}}(t)=\mathrm{exp}(\mathrm{iHt})|m〉〈{m}^{\ensuremath{'}}|\mathrm{exp}(\ensuremath{-}iHt)$ is studied for the problem of an atomic system SSS with eigenstates m{m}m interacting with one or more damping reservoirs RRR. The average value of these operators gives the reduced density matrix ${{\ensuremath{\rho}}_{{m}^{\ensuremath{'}},m}}^{(S)}(t)$ for SSS. If RRR consists of broad-band distributions of harmonic oscillators, (e.g., radiative damping), then damped equations of motion can be derived for all ${\mathcal{P}}_{m,{m}^{\ensuremath{'}}}(t)$, even if SSS is a multilevel system. One need not specify the initial states of RRR, nor restrict the treatment to second order in the S-R coupling. The formalism is illustrated for the case where SSS consists of (i) a four-level atom in a resonant cavity (with broad-band modes also present), and (ii) a collection of atoms that can be treated as a multilevel spin system. Density-matrix equations are obtained for the case where no damping radiation is present initially. In (ii), the formalism is used to derive a two-time corrleation function without the aid of the fluctuation-regression theorem.
We study the dynamics of a system consisting of a two-level atom and a quantum oscillator coupled by the vacuum radiation field. The oscillator and the atom are assumed to have the same resonance frequency. In contrast to the two-atom or two-oscillator case, the atom-oscillator system leads to an unclosed hierarchy of equations for the operators that determine the radiation pattern emitted by the atom-oscillator system. Instead of using the operator equations, we formulate the problem in terms of density-matrix equations which can be solved once the initial conditions are specified. As an example, we looked at the radiation pattern, the decay dynamics, and the spectrum for an initial condition in which the oscillator is in its n=1n=1n=1 state and the atom is in its excited state. Dressed states (dressed by the static interaction between the atom and oscillator) prove to be especially useful for interpreting the results and comparing them with the two-atom and two-oscillator systems. All calculations are carried out using the resonance or rotating-wave approximation. The relationship of our work to damped Jaynes-Cummings models is noted.