Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Physical Review

The Decay of Resonance Radiation by Spontaneous Emission

Emil J. Hellund

Published Mar 1, 1953• 43 citations
Publisher

Abstract

A critical examination of the theory of resonance radiation has been carried through, employing the mathematical technique of Laplace and Stieltjes transforms. Particular attention has been devoted to the question of the temporal behavior of the excited state. With no restrictions on the interaction between atom and radiation field other than that it be real, and that processes of sufficiently high frequency contribute only negligible effects, one can prove that the probability amplitude of the excited state cannot decay according to the general law ${\ensuremath{\Sigma}}_{\ensuremath{\mu},\ensuremath{\nu}}{C}_{\ensuremath{\mu}\ensuremath{\nu}}{t}^{{\ensuremath{\lambda}}_{\ensuremath{\mu}}}{e}^{\ensuremath{-}{\ensuremath{\beta}}_{\ensuremath{\nu}}t},$ where the ${\ensuremath{\lambda}}_{\ensuremath{\mu}}$ and ${\ensuremath{\beta}}_{\ensuremath{\nu}}$ are complex constants lying in the right half-plane and the ${C}_{\ensuremath{\mu}\ensuremath{\nu}}$ are arbitrary complex coefficients. The deviation from the law just cited can be termed a straggling phenomenon since exact analysis shows that the probability amplitude, for sufficiently long times, is greater than that defined according to the radioactive decay law.Rigorous analysis of the source of this apparently anomalous behavior reveals the following explanation. Although the probability amplitude of the excited state is, strictly speaking, a functional of the interaction between the transition current in the atom and the photon states of the electromagnetic field, the essential features are determined principally by those states lying near the resonance frequency. Three elementary observations are immediately apparent. First, a particularly tractable analytical approximation for the interaction can be made such that the value of the actual interaction is reproduced at the resonance frequency and such that the behavior for high and low frequency photon states is at least qualitatively correct. Exact solutions in closed form can be obtained for this interaction. Second, in terms of the preceding representation it is possible to show that, associated with the transition between two atomic states, one is presented with a concomitant picture of a damped oscillation of charge describable in purely classical terms. Third, this classical motion can be interpreted as forming a source function for a continuous stochastic process in terms of which one finally derives the representation of the probability amplitude of the excited state. The straggling phenomenon previously cited is therefore that associated with all diffusion processes. The consideration of the exact interaction leads to more involved diffusion phenomena but does not in any case permit a radioactive decay law.

DOI
10.1103/physrev.89.919

Related papers

Allowed and Forbidden Transitions

Charlotte Froese Fischer, Tomas Brage, Per Jönsson

So far we have treated the energy levels of an atomic system as stable states with infinite lifetimes. The presence of an electromagnetic field changes this picture. Absorption of photons will excite atoms and ions to higher levels, while stimulated emission will make excited ones decay. Einstein (1917) showed, using purely statistical arguments, that an excited ion will decay through spontaneous emission in the absence of an electromagnetic field. This process can also be derived by using a rigorous quantum electrodynamic treatment, where the field is quantized. In this chapter we start by discussing transitions between atomic levels in a general sense, postulating the operators responsible for the decay. After the first few sections we will concentrate on the most important few multipoles or terms in the expansion of the electromagnetic field. We will introduce a number of different properties describing the transition, and eventually arrive at the measurable transition rate and, directly linked to it, the lifetime of an excited state. We will start, however, with the most basic property, the component strength. Our aim is to arrive at computationally useful expressions as soon as possible. For a more thorough treatment of the theory of radiative transitions we refer to the book by Sobelman (1972). For a brief review of the many factors affecting spectra of atoms, see Martin and Wiese (1996) .

Routledge eBooks•Jan 27, 2022•1 citation

Multiple-time-scale perturbation theory: Radiative decay of coupled atomic states

G. L. Brooks, Leonard M. Scarfone

The spontaneous radiative decay to the ground state of an atomic system initially in the higher of two excited states, coupled in a radiationless fashion by an external field, is investigated by the method of multiple-time-scale perturbation theory. The coupled differential equations of motion for the probability amplitudes are solved to second order, while the usual secular behavior of conventional time-dependent perturbation theory is eliminated in terms of two natural time scales: a fast time scale corresponding to the reciprocal of the level transition frequency and a slower time scale associated with the inverse of the radiation linewidth. Expressions are obtained to this order for the energy shifts and decay characteristics of the excited states and the energy distribution of the final-state photons, quantities previously determined by Fourier analysis and contour integration and by the phenomenological approach of Weisskopf and Wigner. A detailed comparison of these various methods of solution includes conditions under which the present results agree to second order with the previous calculations.

Physical Review A•Dec 1, 1982•4 citations

The dynamics of spontaneous emission

M. Baldo

The spontaneous decay of an excited atom by photon emission is one of the most common and elementary physical process present in nature and in laboratories. The decay is random in time with constant probability density, as it can be inferred by the exponential law observed experimentally. Despite the simplicity of the process, in Quantum Mechanics the decay itself is considered a law of nature which is not further analyzed or explained. However it is legitimate to ask for the reason of its randomness and for the dynamics of the atom around the decay. The decay process of an isolated atom is usually assumed to be instantaneous, the so called Quantum jumps. Particular experimental arrangements can widen the duration of the transition from an excited state to the ground state to a finite time. In general this is due to the quantum back action of the detector. The development of Quantum Optics has enormously enriched the possibilities to study in detail the process, and new illuminating insights have been obtained, but the question is still valid and its answer is still elusive. In this paper we analyze the spontaneous decay within the new prospect introduced by a recent model that complete standard Quantum Mechanics in a formalism which is able to describe the dynamics of measurement and of spontaneous decay. Comparison is made with more phenomenological theories, the Quantum Mechanics of open system and the Stochastic wave function model. In the new model the stochastic photon emission by an excited atom is triggered by the vacuum fluctuations. It is suggested how to re-analyze three types of experiments, already realized in many laboratories, in order to reveal the presence and the effect of these fluctuations.

arXiv:2505.22164•May 28, 2025•1 citation

Effects of coupled atomic states on the resonance scattering of radiation

Rajat Srivastava, Peter R. Fontana

The excitation and decay probabilities for resonance scattering of radiation from an atom with two coupled excited states in an external static field are calculated as a function of time and frequency. Various oscillatory terms are found in the probabilities. These oscillations depend on the frequency of radiation, the external coupling and the energy difference between the excited states. Two special cases are investigated in detail. In the first case where one of the excited states does not decay a 'hole' appears in the emission line at a frequency equal to the frequency difference between the ground state and the unperturbed non-decaying excited state. In the second case where the two excited states decay with the same rate, one of the two lines in the emission spectrum is suppressed and the other is enhanced.

Journal of Physics B Atomic and Molecular Physics•Jun 1, 1974•3 citations

Basic Processes of Interaction of Radiation with Matter

M.G. Brik, Chong‐Geng Ma

The absorbed/emitted radiation will be treated classically, as a monochromatic plane wave, whereas the atomic system that can absorb/emit such radiation will be described quantum-mechanically. However, no incident radiation beam is needed, and the atom “falls down” after a certain time interval to the ground state without any external reason. In the spontaneous emission processes the emitting atom can be thought of as a classical oscillating dipole, whose amplitude decreases due to the energy loss through the radiation. If an ensemble of identical atoms is considered and if, for simplicity, each atom emits radiation with the same spectral shape and full width at half maximum, it is impossible to ascribe a definite spectral component with intensity to a definite atom. In this case, such a broadening is identical for all atoms in the ensemble. On the microscopic scale, absorption of radiation is reduced to the transitions between pairs of energy levels of a discrete atomic spectrum.

•Dec 11, 2019•0 citations

Rigorous dynamics and radiation theory for a Pauli-Fierz model in the ultraviolet limit

Massimo Bertini, Diego Noja, Andrea Posilicano

The present paper is devoted to the detailed study of quantization and evolution of the point limit of the Pauli-Fierz model for a charged oscillator interacting with the electromagnetic field in dipole approximation. In particular, a well defined dynamics is constructed for the classical model, which is subsequently quantized according to the Segal scheme. To this end, the classical model in the point limit, already obtained by Noja and Posilicano [Ann. I.H.P. Phys. Theor. 71, 425 (1999)], is reformulated as a second order abstract wave equation, and a consistent quantum evolution is given. This allows a study of the behavior of the survival and transition amplitudes for the process of decay of the excited states of the charged particle, and the emission of photons in the decay process. In particular, for the survival amplitude the exact time behavior is found. This is completely determined by the resonances of the systems plus a tail term prevailing in the asymptotic, long time regime. Moreover, the survival amplitude exhibits in a fairly clear way the Lamb shift correction to the unperturbed frequencies of the oscillator.

arXiv:math-ph/0407002•Journal of Mathematical Physics•Oct 1, 2005•5 citations
A critical examination of the theory of resonance radiation has been carried through, employing the mathematical technique of Laplace and Stieltjes transforms. Particular attention has been devoted to the question of the temporal behavior of the excited state. With no restrictions on the interaction between atom and radiation field other than that it be real, and that processes of sufficiently high frequency contribute only negligible effects, one can prove that the probability amplitude of the excited state cannot decay according to the general law \ensuremathΣ\ensuremathμ,\ensuremathνC\ensuremathμ\ensuremathνt\ensuremathλ\ensuremathμe\ensuremath−\ensuremathβ\ensuremathνt,{\ensuremath{\Sigma}}_{\ensuremath{\mu},\ensuremath{\nu}}{C}_{\ensuremath{\mu}\ensuremath{\nu}}{t}^{{\ensuremath{\lambda}}_{\ensuremath{\mu}}}{e}^{\ensuremath{-}{\ensuremath{\beta}}_{\ensuremath{\nu}}t},\ensuremathΣ\ensuremathμ,\ensuremathν​C\ensuremathμ\ensuremathν​t\ensuremathλ\ensuremathμ​e\ensuremath−\ensuremathβ\ensuremathν​t, where the \ensuremathλ\ensuremathμ{\ensuremath{\lambda}}_{\ensuremath{\mu}}\ensuremathλ\ensuremathμ​ and \ensuremathβ\ensuremathν{\ensuremath{\beta}}_{\ensuremath{\nu}}\ensuremathβ\ensuremathν​ are complex constants lying in the right half-plane and the C\ensuremathμ\ensuremathν{C}_{\ensuremath{\mu}\ensuremath{\nu}}C\ensuremathμ\ensuremathν​ are arbitrary complex coefficients. The deviation from the law just cited can be termed a straggling phenomenon since exact analysis shows that the probability amplitude, for sufficiently long times, is greater than that defined according to the radioactive decay law.Rigorous analysis of the source of this apparently anomalous behavior reveals the following explanation. Although the probability amplitude of the excited state is, strictly speaking, a functional of the interaction between the transition current in the atom and the photon states of the electromagnetic field, the essential features are determined principally by those states lying near the resonance frequency. Three elementary observations are immediately apparent. First, a particularly tractable analytical approximation for the interaction can be made such that the value of the actual interaction is reproduced at the resonance frequency and such that the behavior for high and low frequency photon states is at least qualitatively correct. Exact solutions in closed form can be obtained for this interaction. Second, in terms of the preceding representation it is possible to show that, associated with the transition between two atomic states, one is presented with a concomitant picture of a damped oscillation of charge describable in purely classical terms. Third, this classical motion can be interpreted as forming a source function for a continuous stochastic process in terms of which one finally derives the representation of the probability amplitude of the excited state. The straggling phenomenon previously cited is therefore that associated with all diffusion processes. The consideration of the exact interaction leads to more involved diffusion phenomena but does not in any case permit a radioactive decay law.
So far we have treated the energy levels of an atomic system as stable states with infinite lifetimes. The presence of an electromagnetic field changes this picture. Absorption of photons will excite atoms and ions to higher levels, while stimulated emission will make excited ones decay. Einstein (1917) showed, using purely statistical arguments, that an excited ion will decay through spontaneous emission in the absence of an electromagnetic field. This process can also be derived by using a rigorous quantum electrodynamic treatment, where the field is quantized. In this chapter we start by discussing transitions between atomic levels in a general sense, postulating the operators responsible for the decay. After the first few sections we will concentrate on the most important few multipoles or terms in the expansion of the electromagnetic field. We will introduce a number of different properties describing the transition, and eventually arrive at the measurable transition rate and, directly linked to it, the lifetime of an excited state. We will start, however, with the most basic property, the component strength. Our aim is to arrive at computationally useful expressions as soon as possible. For a more thorough treatment of the theory of radiative transitions we refer to the book by Sobelman (1972). For a brief review of the many factors affecting spectra of atoms, see Martin and Wiese (1996) .
The spontaneous radiative decay to the ground state of an atomic system initially in the higher of two excited states, coupled in a radiationless fashion by an external field, is investigated by the method of multiple-time-scale perturbation theory. The coupled differential equations of motion for the probability amplitudes are solved to second order, while the usual secular behavior of conventional time-dependent perturbation theory is eliminated in terms of two natural time scales: a fast time scale corresponding to the reciprocal of the level transition frequency and a slower time scale associated with the inverse of the radiation linewidth. Expressions are obtained to this order for the energy shifts and decay characteristics of the excited states and the energy distribution of the final-state photons, quantities previously determined by Fourier analysis and contour integration and by the phenomenological approach of Weisskopf and Wigner. A detailed comparison of these various methods of solution includes conditions under which the present results agree to second order with the previous calculations.
The spontaneous decay of an excited atom by photon emission is one of the most common and elementary physical process present in nature and in laboratories. The decay is random in time with constant probability density, as it can be inferred by the exponential law observed experimentally. Despite the simplicity of the process, in Quantum Mechanics the decay itself is considered a law of nature which is not further analyzed or explained. However it is legitimate to ask for the reason of its randomness and for the dynamics of the atom around the decay. The decay process of an isolated atom is usually assumed to be instantaneous, the so called Quantum jumps. Particular experimental arrangements can widen the duration of the transition from an excited state to the ground state to a finite time. In general this is due to the quantum back action of the detector. The development of Quantum Optics has enormously enriched the possibilities to study in detail the process, and new illuminating insights have been obtained, but the question is still valid and its answer is still elusive. In this paper we analyze the spontaneous decay within the new prospect introduced by a recent model that complete standard Quantum Mechanics in a formalism which is able to describe the dynamics of measurement and of spontaneous decay. Comparison is made with more phenomenological theories, the Quantum Mechanics of open system and the Stochastic wave function model. In the new model the stochastic photon emission by an excited atom is triggered by the vacuum fluctuations. It is suggested how to re-analyze three types of experiments, already realized in many laboratories, in order to reveal the presence and the effect of these fluctuations.
The excitation and decay probabilities for resonance scattering of radiation from an atom with two coupled excited states in an external static field are calculated as a function of time and frequency. Various oscillatory terms are found in the probabilities. These oscillations depend on the frequency of radiation, the external coupling and the energy difference between the excited states. Two special cases are investigated in detail. In the first case where one of the excited states does not decay a 'hole' appears in the emission line at a frequency equal to the frequency difference between the ground state and the unperturbed non-decaying excited state. In the second case where the two excited states decay with the same rate, one of the two lines in the emission spectrum is suppressed and the other is enhanced.
The absorbed/emitted radiation will be treated classically, as a monochromatic plane wave, whereas the atomic system that can absorb/emit such radiation will be described quantum-mechanically. However, no incident radiation beam is needed, and the atom “falls down” after a certain time interval to the ground state without any external reason. In the spontaneous emission processes the emitting atom can be thought of as a classical oscillating dipole, whose amplitude decreases due to the energy loss through the radiation. If an ensemble of identical atoms is considered and if, for simplicity, each atom emits radiation with the same spectral shape and full width at half maximum, it is impossible to ascribe a definite spectral component with intensity to a definite atom. In this case, such a broadening is identical for all atoms in the ensemble. On the microscopic scale, absorption of radiation is reduced to the transitions between pairs of energy levels of a discrete atomic spectrum.
The present paper is devoted to the detailed study of quantization and evolution of the point limit of the Pauli-Fierz model for a charged oscillator interacting with the electromagnetic field in dipole approximation. In particular, a well defined dynamics is constructed for the classical model, which is subsequently quantized according to the Segal scheme. To this end, the classical model in the point limit, already obtained by Noja and Posilicano [Ann. I.H.P. Phys. Theor. 71, 425 (1999)], is reformulated as a second order abstract wave equation, and a consistent quantum evolution is given. This allows a study of the behavior of the survival and transition amplitudes for the process of decay of the excited states of the charged particle, and the emission of photons in the decay process. In particular, for the survival amplitude the exact time behavior is found. This is completely determined by the resonances of the systems plus a tail term prevailing in the asymptotic, long time regime. Moreover, the survival amplitude exhibits in a fairly clear way the Lamb shift correction to the unperturbed frequencies of the oscillator.