Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Journal of Physics C Solid State Physics

Replica symmetry and massless modes in spin glasses. II. Non-Ising spins

Alan J. Bray, M A Moore

Published Apr 14, 1979• 17 citations
Publisher

Abstract

For pt.I, see ibid., vol.12, p.79 (1979). A recent investigation of the Ising spin glass using the n to O replica method is generalised to m-vector spins. As for Ising spins (m=1), the order-parameter correlation functions contain, within mean-field theory, massless modes which become unstable at first order in perturbation theory about the mean-field solution. An alternative formulation of perturbation theory restores stability, giving massless modes once more, but yields an expansion for the order parameter which breaks down for dimensionalities d<or=4 due to infrared divergences. A dimensionality of four is therefore interpreted as the lower critical dimensionality of the theory, as for the Ising spin glass.

DOI
10.1088/0022-3719/12/7/023

Related papers

Replica symmetry and massless modes in the Ising spin glass

Alan J. Bray, M A Moore

The n to 0 replica method is used to study the Ising spin glass below its transition temperature. The order parameter correlation functions are shown to contain massless modes ('replicon' modes) within mean-field theory. These become unstable at first order in perturbation theory about the mean-field solution. An alternative formulation of perturbation theory, however, yields a family of new solutions which break, in general, the symmetry between the replicas. Stability requirements single out a unique member of this family which exhibits (i) massless moded, and (ii) a restoration of replica symmetry. Within the framework of the new solution, perturbation theory for the order parameter (Q alpha beta ) breaks down for dimensionalities d<or=4 due to an infrared divergence. Four dimensions is interpreted as the 'lower critical dimensionality' of the theory, below which there can be no order of the Edwards-Anderson kind (1975).

Journal of Physics C Solid State Physics•Jan 14, 1979•138 citations

On the mean field theory of spin glasses

Jairo Rolim Lopes de Almeida

This thesis is concerned with the mean field theory of spin glasses within the replica method approach. We have studied the Sherrington-Kirkpatrick model [33,4δ] both with Ising and m-component spins. It is shown that the replica symmetric solution gives an instability in the condensed phase which requires a breaking of replica symmetry in the spin glass phase. The various broken replica symmetry solutions proposed thus far (Bray and Moore [52], Blandin et al [53], Parisi [54]) are reviewed and particular attention is given to the one proposed by Parisi. The order parameter susceptibility and the stability of the solution are studied within this breaking of replica symmetry scheme which give results in agreement with the predictions of TAP [47] and Bray and Moore [52]. The breakdown of linear response theory in the spin glass phase is also discussed.

•Jan 1, 1980•0 citations

Ising spin glass: Replica-symmetric cluster expansion in finite dimensions

Anil Khurana

The replica-symmetric cluster expansion for the Ising spin glass is reviewed and explained. The expansion allows computation of various quantities and correlations directly in finite dimensions, without recourse to the mean-field theory or the saddle point. The expansion for the free energy is recovered with the use of external fields that couple to the replica-symmetric Edwards-Anderson order parameter. The expansion scheme is applied to the Edwards-Anderson susceptibility. The expansion diverges in the mean-field [infinite dimensionality] limit. The divergent expansion, when naively summed, yields the negative replicon mass of the mean-field theory. This so-called Almeida-Thouless instability of the replica-symmetric mean-field theory is argued to be absent in finite dimensions. The argument, similar to the one already reported for the entropy, depends on the low-temperature behavior of terms in the expansion at finite dimensions. \textcopyright{} 1996 The American Physical Society.

Physical review. B, Condensed matter•Sep 1, 1996•2 citations

Mean field theory I: Ising model, equilibrium theory

K. H. Fischer, John Hertz

In this chapter we will put the concepts we have developed in Chapter 2 to work in constructing the mean field theory for an Ising spin glass. The term ‘mean field theory’ (henceforth frequently abbreviated ‘MFT’) can be interpreted in many ways. Here we will take it to mean the exact solution of a model in which the forces are of infinitely long range, so that each spin interacts equally strongly with every other one. For spin glasses, this is the Sherrington–Kirkpatrick (SK) model (1975), which we solve heuristically (though unfortunately incorrectly) in Section 3.1. The error is a somewhat subtle one, as is evident from the fact that we obtain exactly the same result in the more systematic calculations of Sections 3.2 (a direct summation of the leading terms in N −1 in high-temperature perturbation theory) and 3.3 (which uses the replica formalism). In both these approaches, we can also see how the theory itself reveals that it is wrong, since they lead to negative values of quantities which are necessarily positive. We then study the correct mean field theory, with replica symmetry breaking, in Section 3.4, including the remarkable nature of the broken ergodicity it implies and an examination of its stability. Further physical insight into the problem is obtained in Section 3.5 from the mean field equations first introduced by Thouless, Anderson and Palmer (TAP) (1977).

Cambridge University Press eBooks•May 2, 1991•0 citations

Replica symmetry breaking in the transverse-field Ising spin-glass model: Two fermionic representations

Eduardo Muccillo Monteiro Santos, Alba Theumann

We analyze the infinite range Ising spin glass in a transverse-field $\ensuremath{\Gamma}$ below the critical temperature by a one step replica symmetry breaking theory. The set of $n$ replicas is divided in $r$ blocks of $m$ replicas each. We present results for different values of the block-size parameter $m$. The spin operators are represented by bilinear combinations of fermionic fields and we compare the results of two models: In the four-states (4-S) model the diagonal ${S}_{i}^{z}$ operator has two unphysical vanishing eigenvalues, that are suppressed by a restraint in the two-states (2-S) model. In the static approximation we obtain qualitatively similar results for both models. They both exhibit a critical temperature ${T}_{c}(\ensuremath{\Gamma})$ that decreases when $\ensuremath{\Gamma}$ increases, until it reaches a quantum critical point at the same value of ${\ensuremath{\Gamma}}_{c}$ and they are both unstable under replica symmetry breaking in the whole spin glass phase. Below the critical temperature we present results for the order parameters and free energy.

arXiv:cond-mat/0505522•Physical Review B•Jul 19, 2005•4 citations

Replica symmetry breaking in four-dimensional spin glasses

Giorgio Parisi A, Félix Ritort

In this paper we present a new numerical method to test mean-field ideas in the Ising spin glass at finite dimensions. Very large sizes can be studied and numerical results are presented in the case of the four-dimensional Ising spin glass. New exponents are introduced within the spin-glass phase and we find evidence of a phase with replica broken features.

Journal of Physics A Mathematical and General•Dec 7, 1993•18 citations
For pt.I, see ibid., vol.12, p.79 (1979). A recent investigation of the Ising spin glass using the n to O replica method is generalised to m-vector spins. As for Ising spins (m=1), the order-parameter correlation functions contain, within mean-field theory, massless modes which become unstable at first order in perturbation theory about the mean-field solution. An alternative formulation of perturbation theory restores stability, giving massless modes once more, but yields an expansion for the order parameter which breaks down for dimensionalities d<or=4 due to infrared divergences. A dimensionality of four is therefore interpreted as the lower critical dimensionality of the theory, as for the Ising spin glass.
The n to 0 replica method is used to study the Ising spin glass below its transition temperature. The order parameter correlation functions are shown to contain massless modes ('replicon' modes) within mean-field theory. These become unstable at first order in perturbation theory about the mean-field solution. An alternative formulation of perturbation theory, however, yields a family of new solutions which break, in general, the symmetry between the replicas. Stability requirements single out a unique member of this family which exhibits (i) massless moded, and (ii) a restoration of replica symmetry. Within the framework of the new solution, perturbation theory for the order parameter (Q alpha beta ) breaks down for dimensionalities d<or=4 due to an infrared divergence. Four dimensions is interpreted as the 'lower critical dimensionality' of the theory, below which there can be no order of the Edwards-Anderson kind (1975).
This thesis is concerned with the mean field theory of spin glasses within the replica method approach. We have studied the Sherrington-Kirkpatrick model [33,4δ] both with Ising and m-component spins. It is shown that the replica symmetric solution gives an instability in the condensed phase which requires a breaking of replica symmetry in the spin glass phase. The various broken replica symmetry solutions proposed thus far (Bray and Moore [52], Blandin et al [53], Parisi [54]) are reviewed and particular attention is given to the one proposed by Parisi. The order parameter susceptibility and the stability of the solution are studied within this breaking of replica symmetry scheme which give results in agreement with the predictions of TAP [47] and Bray and Moore [52]. The breakdown of linear response theory in the spin glass phase is also discussed.
The replica-symmetric cluster expansion for the Ising spin glass is reviewed and explained. The expansion allows computation of various quantities and correlations directly in finite dimensions, without recourse to the mean-field theory or the saddle point. The expansion for the free energy is recovered with the use of external fields that couple to the replica-symmetric Edwards-Anderson order parameter. The expansion scheme is applied to the Edwards-Anderson susceptibility. The expansion diverges in the mean-field [infinite dimensionality] limit. The divergent expansion, when naively summed, yields the negative replicon mass of the mean-field theory. This so-called Almeida-Thouless instability of the replica-symmetric mean-field theory is argued to be absent in finite dimensions. The argument, similar to the one already reported for the entropy, depends on the low-temperature behavior of terms in the expansion at finite dimensions. \textcopyright{} 1996 The American Physical Society.
In this chapter we will put the concepts we have developed in Chapter 2 to work in constructing the mean field theory for an Ising spin glass. The term ‘mean field theory’ (henceforth frequently abbreviated ‘MFT’) can be interpreted in many ways. Here we will take it to mean the exact solution of a model in which the forces are of infinitely long range, so that each spin interacts equally strongly with every other one. For spin glasses, this is the Sherrington–Kirkpatrick (SK) model (1975), which we solve heuristically (though unfortunately incorrectly) in Section 3.1. The error is a somewhat subtle one, as is evident from the fact that we obtain exactly the same result in the more systematic calculations of Sections 3.2 (a direct summation of the leading terms in N −1 in high-temperature perturbation theory) and 3.3 (which uses the replica formalism). In both these approaches, we can also see how the theory itself reveals that it is wrong, since they lead to negative values of quantities which are necessarily positive. We then study the correct mean field theory, with replica symmetry breaking, in Section 3.4, including the remarkable nature of the broken ergodicity it implies and an examination of its stability. Further physical insight into the problem is obtained in Section 3.5 from the mean field equations first introduced by Thouless, Anderson and Palmer (TAP) (1977).
We analyze the infinite range Ising spin glass in a transverse-field $\ensuremath{\Gamma}$ below the critical temperature by a one step replica symmetry breaking theory. The set of nnn replicas is divided in rrr blocks of mmm replicas each. We present results for different values of the block-size parameter mmm. The spin operators are represented by bilinear combinations of fermionic fields and we compare the results of two models: In the four-states (4-S) model the diagonal Siz{S}_{i}^{z}Siz​ operator has two unphysical vanishing eigenvalues, that are suppressed by a restraint in the two-states (2-S) model. In the static approximation we obtain qualitatively similar results for both models. They both exhibit a critical temperature ${T}_{c}(\ensuremath{\Gamma})$ that decreases when $\ensuremath{\Gamma}$ increases, until it reaches a quantum critical point at the same value of ${\ensuremath{\Gamma}}_{c}$ and they are both unstable under replica symmetry breaking in the whole spin glass phase. Below the critical temperature we present results for the order parameters and free energy.