Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

On the mean field theory of spin glasses

Jairo Rolim Lopes de Almeida

Published Jan 1, 1980• 0 citations
OpenAlex

Abstract

This thesis is concerned with the mean field theory of spin glasses within the replica method approach. We have studied the Sherrington-Kirkpatrick model [33,4δ] both with Ising and m-component spins. It is shown that the replica symmetric solution gives an instability in the condensed phase which requires a breaking of replica symmetry in the spin glass phase. The various broken replica symmetry solutions proposed thus far (Bray and Moore [52], Blandin et al [53], Parisi [54]) are reviewed and particular attention is given to the one proposed by Parisi. The order parameter susceptibility and the stability of the solution are studied within this breaking of replica symmetry scheme which give results in agreement with the predictions of TAP [47] and Bray and Moore [52]. The breakdown of linear response theory in the spin glass phase is also discussed.

Related papers

Mean field theory I: Ising model, equilibrium theory

K. H. Fischer, John Hertz

In this chapter we will put the concepts we have developed in Chapter 2 to work in constructing the mean field theory for an Ising spin glass. The term ‘mean field theory’ (henceforth frequently abbreviated ‘MFT’) can be interpreted in many ways. Here we will take it to mean the exact solution of a model in which the forces are of infinitely long range, so that each spin interacts equally strongly with every other one. For spin glasses, this is the Sherrington–Kirkpatrick (SK) model (1975), which we solve heuristically (though unfortunately incorrectly) in Section 3.1. The error is a somewhat subtle one, as is evident from the fact that we obtain exactly the same result in the more systematic calculations of Sections 3.2 (a direct summation of the leading terms in N −1 in high-temperature perturbation theory) and 3.3 (which uses the replica formalism). In both these approaches, we can also see how the theory itself reveals that it is wrong, since they lead to negative values of quantities which are necessarily positive. We then study the correct mean field theory, with replica symmetry breaking, in Section 3.4, including the remarkable nature of the broken ergodicity it implies and an examination of its stability. Further physical insight into the problem is obtained in Section 3.5 from the mean field equations first introduced by Thouless, Anderson and Palmer (TAP) (1977).

Cambridge University Press eBooks•May 2, 1991•0 citations

Replica-symmetry breaking for the Ising spin glass in a transverse field

G. Büttner, Klaus D. Usadel

Parisi's replica-symmetry-breaking scheme is applied to the quantum Sherrington-Kirkpatrick Ising spin glass in a transverse magnetic field. The order-parameter function q(x) is calculated near ${\mathit{T}}_{\mathit{f}}$, while for all temperatures the first stage of replica-symmetry breaking is calculated. Internal energy, entropy, and magnetic susceptibility are calculated in order to investigate the quality of both the replica-symmetric and the replica-symmetry-broken theories.

Physical review. B, Condensed matter•Oct 1, 1990•37 citations

Replica symmetry breaking solution for the fermionic Ising spin-glass and the Ghatak-Sherrington model

H Feldmann, R Oppermann

We solve the fermionic version of the Ising spin glass for arbitrary filling µ and temperature T taking into account replica symmetry breaking. Using a simple exact mapping from µ to the anisotropy parameter D , we also obtain the solution of the S = 1 Sherrington-Kirkpatrick model. An analytic expression for T = 0 gives an improved critical value for the first-order phase transition. We revisit the question of stability against replica-diagonal fluctuations and find that the appearance of complex eigenvalues of the Almeida-Thouless matrix is not an artefact of the replica-symmetric approximation.

arXiv:cond-mat/9910034•Journal of Physics A Mathematical and General•Feb 10, 2000•15 citations

Analytic and computational studies of spin glasses

Shreyans Jain

The Sherrington-Kirkpatrick and the nearest-neighbour X-Y spin-glass models are studied.The effect of a small uniform symmetry breaking field on the infinite-ranged Sherrington-Kirkpatrick Ising spin-glass model is discussed.It is shown that the off-diagonal contributions to the fluctuation-dissipation formula vanish for a symmetric distribution of interactions and the limit of zero field.This contradicts the result of Young and Kirkpatrick based on numerical evidence for small samples.The dynamics of the Sherrington-Kirkpatrick spin-glass are investigated.Below the critical temperature this model exhibits non-ergodic behaviour.Consequently, in order to obtain timedependent correlation functions it is necessary to average over the initial states with a Boltzmann weight.This necessitates the use of "replicas".It is shown that in Parisi's scheme the "dynamical" Edwards-Anderson order parameter is given by q(x =1), whereas the statistical mechanics order parameter is given by r 1 q(x)dx.The result for the statistical mechanics order parameter j 0 implies that there is no violation of the fluctuation-dissipation theorem once an average over samples is performed.It is also shown that the system in general keeps its memory of the initial state for all time.However, this memory is "lost" if one makes a replica symmetric ansatz for the order parameters.This illus trates the connection between replica symmetry breaking and nonergodicity.The nearest neighbour X-Y spin-glass in both two-and threedimensions is investigated by Monte Carlo simulation.In two--11ln[ln Xcn + 1-42] versus In T SG } X2 (Tq ) for T (3D) 4.11 4.12a 4.12b 4.12c 4.13a ' 4.13b > Plots of the data for T (3D) 4.13c 4.14a 4.14b 4.15a 4.15b Plots of £ ^ for 3D SG A plot of the data for £ assuming that LCD = 3 SG A plot of the data for £ assuming that LCD = 3 SG and p__ = 1.2 SG A5.1a A5.

•Jan 1, 1985•0 citations

Stability analysis of an Ising spin glass with transverse field

G. Büttner, Klaus D. Usadel

The stability of the replica-symmetric solution of the Sherrington-Kirkpatrick Ising spin glass with transverse field is investigated. We show that the replica-symmetric solution becomes unstable in the whole spin-glass phase.

Physical review. B, Condensed matter•Jan 1, 1990•68 citations

Thermodynamic properties of a full-replica-symmetry-breaking Ising spin glass on lattice gas: The random Blume-Emery-Griffiths-Capel model

A. Crisanti, Luca Leuzzi

An extensive study of the mean-field static solution of the random Blume-Emery-Griffiths-Capel model, an Ising-spin lattice gas with quenched random magnetic interaction, is performed. The model exhibits a paramagnetic phase, described by a stable replica-symmetric solution. When the temperature is decreased or the density increases, the system undergoes a phase transition to a full-replica-symmetry-breaking spin-glass phase. The nature of the transition can be either of the second order (such as in the Sherrington-Kirkpatrick model) or, at temperatures below a given critical value, of the first order in the Ehrenfest sense, with a discontinuous jump of the order parameter and accompanied by a latent heat. In this last case, coexistence of phases takes place. The thermodynamics is worked out in the full-replica-symmetry-breaking scheme, and the related Parisi equations are solved using a pseudospectral method down to zero temperature.

arXiv:cond-mat/0402243•Physical Review B•Jul 12, 2004•29 citations
This thesis is concerned with the mean field theory of spin glasses within the replica method approach. We have studied the Sherrington-Kirkpatrick model [33,4δ] both with Ising and m-component spins. It is shown that the replica symmetric solution gives an instability in the condensed phase which requires a breaking of replica symmetry in the spin glass phase. The various broken replica symmetry solutions proposed thus far (Bray and Moore [52], Blandin et al [53], Parisi [54]) are reviewed and particular attention is given to the one proposed by Parisi. The order parameter susceptibility and the stability of the solution are studied within this breaking of replica symmetry scheme which give results in agreement with the predictions of TAP [47] and Bray and Moore [52]. The breakdown of linear response theory in the spin glass phase is also discussed.
In this chapter we will put the concepts we have developed in Chapter 2 to work in constructing the mean field theory for an Ising spin glass. The term ‘mean field theory’ (henceforth frequently abbreviated ‘MFT’) can be interpreted in many ways. Here we will take it to mean the exact solution of a model in which the forces are of infinitely long range, so that each spin interacts equally strongly with every other one. For spin glasses, this is the Sherrington–Kirkpatrick (SK) model (1975), which we solve heuristically (though unfortunately incorrectly) in Section 3.1. The error is a somewhat subtle one, as is evident from the fact that we obtain exactly the same result in the more systematic calculations of Sections 3.2 (a direct summation of the leading terms in N −1 in high-temperature perturbation theory) and 3.3 (which uses the replica formalism). In both these approaches, we can also see how the theory itself reveals that it is wrong, since they lead to negative values of quantities which are necessarily positive. We then study the correct mean field theory, with replica symmetry breaking, in Section 3.4, including the remarkable nature of the broken ergodicity it implies and an examination of its stability. Further physical insight into the problem is obtained in Section 3.5 from the mean field equations first introduced by Thouless, Anderson and Palmer (TAP) (1977).
Parisi's replica-symmetry-breaking scheme is applied to the quantum Sherrington-Kirkpatrick Ising spin glass in a transverse magnetic field. The order-parameter function q(x) is calculated near Tf{\mathit{T}}_{\mathit{f}}Tf​, while for all temperatures the first stage of replica-symmetry breaking is calculated. Internal energy, entropy, and magnetic susceptibility are calculated in order to investigate the quality of both the replica-symmetric and the replica-symmetry-broken theories.
We solve the fermionic version of the Ising spin glass for arbitrary filling µ and temperature T taking into account replica symmetry breaking. Using a simple exact mapping from µ to the anisotropy parameter D , we also obtain the solution of the S = 1 Sherrington-Kirkpatrick model. An analytic expression for T = 0 gives an improved critical value for the first-order phase transition. We revisit the question of stability against replica-diagonal fluctuations and find that the appearance of complex eigenvalues of the Almeida-Thouless matrix is not an artefact of the replica-symmetric approximation.
The Sherrington-Kirkpatrick and the nearest-neighbour X-Y spin-glass models are studied.The effect of a small uniform symmetry breaking field on the infinite-ranged Sherrington-Kirkpatrick Ising spin-glass model is discussed.It is shown that the off-diagonal contributions to the fluctuation-dissipation formula vanish for a symmetric distribution of interactions and the limit of zero field.This contradicts the result of Young and Kirkpatrick based on numerical evidence for small samples.The dynamics of the Sherrington-Kirkpatrick spin-glass are investigated.Below the critical temperature this model exhibits non-ergodic behaviour.Consequently, in order to obtain timedependent correlation functions it is necessary to average over the initial states with a Boltzmann weight.This necessitates the use of "replicas".It is shown that in Parisi's scheme the "dynamical" Edwards-Anderson order parameter is given by q(x =1), whereas the statistical mechanics order parameter is given by r 1 q(x)dx.The result for the statistical mechanics order parameter j 0 implies that there is no violation of the fluctuation-dissipation theorem once an average over samples is performed.It is also shown that the system in general keeps its memory of the initial state for all time.However, this memory is "lost" if one makes a replica symmetric ansatz for the order parameters.This illus trates the connection between replica symmetry breaking and nonergodicity.The nearest neighbour X-Y spin-glass in both two-and threedimensions is investigated by Monte Carlo simulation.In two--11ln[ln Xcn + 1-42] versus In T SG } X2 (Tq ) for T (3D) 4.11 4.12a 4.12b 4.12c 4.13a ' 4.13b > Plots of the data for T (3D) 4.13c 4.14a 4.14b 4.15a 4.15b Plots of £ ^ for 3D SG A plot of the data for £ assuming that LCD = 3 SG A plot of the data for £ assuming that LCD = 3 SG and p__ = 1.2 SG A5.1a A5.
An extensive study of the mean-field static solution of the random Blume-Emery-Griffiths-Capel model, an Ising-spin lattice gas with quenched random magnetic interaction, is performed. The model exhibits a paramagnetic phase, described by a stable replica-symmetric solution. When the temperature is decreased or the density increases, the system undergoes a phase transition to a full-replica-symmetry-breaking spin-glass phase. The nature of the transition can be either of the second order (such as in the Sherrington-Kirkpatrick model) or, at temperatures below a given critical value, of the first order in the Ehrenfest sense, with a discontinuous jump of the order parameter and accompanied by a latent heat. In this last case, coexistence of phases takes place. The thermodynamics is worked out in the full-replica-symmetry-breaking scheme, and the related Parisi equations are solved using a pseudospectral method down to zero temperature.