Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Physical Review

Duration of Molecules in Upper Quantum States

Richard C. Tolman

Published Jun 1, 1924• 116 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Values of rate of decay and mean life of atoms and molecules in upper quantum states calculated from data on the intensity of absorption lines.---By combining F\"uchtbauer's method of determining from the intensity of absorption lines the probability that a molecule will absorb a quantum of energy, with Einstein's views as to the mechanism of light absorption and emission, the following equation is derived for calculating the rate at which molecules jump from upper to lower quantum states: ${A}_{21}=\left(\frac{8\ensuremath{\pi}{\ensuremath{\nu}}^{2}}{{c}^{2}{N}_{1}}\right)\left(\frac{{p}_{1}}{{p}_{2}}\right)\ensuremath{\int}{0}^{\ensuremath{\infty}}\ensuremath{\alpha}d\ensuremath{\nu}$ where ${A}_{21}$ is the chance per unit time that a molecule will jump spontaneously from quantum state 2 to quantum state 1, $\ensuremath{\nu}$ is the frequency of the light emitted in such a jump, ${p}_{1}$ and ${p}_{2}$ are the a priori probabilities of quantum states 1 and 2, and $\ensuremath{\alpha}$ is the absorption coefficient of the substance measured under conditions such that ${N}_{1}$ is the number of molecules per unit volume in the lower quantum state 1. The integral $\ensuremath{\int}\ensuremath{\alpha}d\ensuremath{\nu}$ is to be taken over the total effective width of the absorption line corresponding to the passage of molecules from quantum state 1 to quantum state 2. The mean life $\ensuremath{\tau}$ of molecules which decay from state 2 to state 1 is the reciprocal of ${A}_{21}$. Values of ${A}_{21}$ and $\ensuremath{\tau}$ are calculated from existing data for the mercury line $\ensuremath{\lambda}2537$, for a number of lines belonging to the alkali doublets, for the iodine line $\ensuremath{\lambda}5461$, and for a very considerable number of lines belonging to the rotation-oscillation spectra of the hydrogen halides. The values obtained agree with the meager data made available by other experimental methods. From these results the following conclusions are drawn.The mean life of molecules and atoms in upper quantum states may vary for different states at least over the range 1 to ${10}^{\ensuremath{-}8}$ seconds. The rate of decay is not a simple function of the frequency of the emitted light. The rate corresponding to the emission of a line of high frequency may be greater or less than that for a line of lower frequency. The data now available for the alkali doublets $1s\ensuremath{-}m{p}_{1}$ and $1s\ensuremath{-}m{p}_{2}$ indicate a higher rate of decay the smaller the change in total quantum number for the line under consideration. The rate of decay from a given $m{p}_{1}$ state is $m$ times as great as from the corresponding $m{p}_{2}$ state (already stated in another form by F\"uchtbauer and Hofmann). In the case of the rotation-oscillation spectra of the hydrogen halides the rate of decay is greater for quantum states with one unit of oscillation and many of rotation, than for those with one unit of oscillation and only a few of rotation; and in the case of different molecules but the same quantum numbers the rate of decay is greater for the molecule with the greater frequency of oscillation.Finally the possibility and method of calculating absolute values of ${A}_{21}$ from the Bohr correspondence principle is indicated.

DOI
10.1103/physrev.23.693

Related papers

Duration of Molecules in Upper Quantum States

Richard C. Tolman

In an article which has been presented to the Physical Review for publication the author has shown the possibility of calculating from data on the intensity of absorption lines the mean life τ of atoms and molecules in excited quantum states, and the specific rate A21 at which they spontaneously leave the excited state 2 to return to the lower state 1. The calculations are based on Fuchtbauer's (1) method of determining the probability that molecules will be activated by the absorption of a quantum of light, combined with Einstein's(2) views as to the mechanism of light absorption and emission.

Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences•Mar 1, 1924•17 citations

The Structure of Emission Lines

Frank C. Hoyt

A method for obtaining the intensity distribution in a spectral line is derived from Dirac's quantum theory of the radiation field. The calculations are carried out for the case of emission from a first excited state (resonance line) and show that the intensity of frequency $\ensuremath{\nu}$ is, in this case, proportional to $\frac{1}{[4{\ensuremath{\pi}}^{2}{({\ensuremath{\nu}}_{0}\ensuremath{-}\ensuremath{\nu})}^{2}+{(A\ifmmode\cdot\else\textperiodcentered\fi{}2)}^{2}]}$ were $A$ is the rate at which atoms are leaving the upper state and ${\ensuremath{\nu}}_{0}$ is the frequency of the transition. The half-width is therefore $\frac{1}{2\ensuremath{\pi}}$ times the Einstein probability coefficient for spontaneous transition to the lower state. The more general case where the lower state has a finite life time is not treated.A general method for the treatment of radiation problems, which is essentially Weyl's modification of Dirac's method, is briefly described.

Physical Review•Sep 1, 1930•19 citations

Mean Lives of Mercury Lines λ2537 and λ1849

Paul H. Garrett

The mean life of the mercury line $\ensuremath{\lambda}2537$ was measured by the alternating voltage method previously described by Webb. The radiation was excited in a quartz tube by impact with electrons from a hot cathode. The photoelectric system was contained in a separate tube also of quartz. The photoelectric surface was zinc evaporated on a nickel plate. Measurements of the apparent life were made with diminishing mercury vapor pressures until further reduction of pressure produced no change in the measured rate of decay of the radiation. At these low pressures (below 3\ifmmode\times\else\texttimes\fi{}${10}^{\ensuremath{-}4}$ mm, for the geometry used) the absorption and reemission of the radiation was negligible and the true life of a single excitation process was measured. This was found to be 1.08\ifmmode\times\else\texttimes\fi{}${10}^{\ensuremath{-}7}$ sec. with an estimated precision of one percent.Absorption coefficient of $\ensuremath{\lambda}1849$. An absorption cell with a one mm thick absorbing layer of mercury vapor was mounted so as to move in and out between the excitation and photoelectric tubes used in the above measurements. The absorption of $\ensuremath{\lambda}1849$ was measured at pressures such that the absorption of $\ensuremath{\lambda}2537$ was negligible. From this the atomic absorption coefficient for the main component of the line was found to be 6.2\ifmmode\times\else\texttimes\fi{}${10}^{\ensuremath{-}11}$ from which the mean life of the $2^{1}P_{1}$ state was calculated to be 2.9\ifmmode\times\else\texttimes\fi{}${10}^{\ensuremath{-}10}$ sec. with an estimated precision of 25 percent.

Physical Review•Jun 1, 1932•17 citations

The Uncertain Energy of an Excited State

Richard A. Hutchin

This paper asks an experimental question about photon absorption and emission in a two-state electronic system where the incident frequency of exciting light is below the mean frequency of the emission line but still within the line width. Since it is well known that the absorption spectrum and the emission spectrum are identical [1]-[3], then quantum mechanics as well as astronomical observations say that excitations will still occur. Once a quantum state excites, then it is expected to decay back with a typical time constant and the usual emission spectrum. The problem is that the mean frequency of that emission spectrum will then be higher than the frequency of the exciting photon, suggesting that more energy is emitted than being received on average. A search of quantum mechanical references finds no discussion of this issue, so this paper considers the options available to resolve this inconsistency, including an experiment.

Optics and Photonics Journal•Jan 1, 2015•1 citation

Two-Photon Absorption and Field Correlation Functions

B. R. Mollow

The probability of an atom undergoing a transition to a given final state by means of two-photon absorption is expressed for arbitrary field states in terms of the second-order normally-ordered field correlation function, evaluated at the position of the atom. In the case of stationary fields, an expression for the absorption rate is found which reduces to a particularly simple form for narrow-bandwidth fields near resonance. The effect of field statistics is illustrated by comparing the absorption rate $w_{2}^{}{}_{}{}^{(\mathrm{ch})}$ for chaotic or Gaussian light to the rate $w_{2}^{}{}_{}{}^{(l)}$ for laser light. The rate for laser light is calculated within the context of a particular model based on the assumption of fixed field amplitude and random frequency modulation, and the chaotic light to which it is compared is assumed to have the same (Lorentzian) power spectrum. When the width ${\ensuremath{\kappa}}_{f}$ of the final atomic level is much greater than the bandwidth $b$ of the field, we obtain the previously derived result $\frac{w_{2}^{}{}_{}{}^{(\mathrm{ch})}}{w_{2}^{}{}_{}{}^{(l)}}=2$. When ${\ensuremath{\kappa}}_{f}\ensuremath{\ll}b$, on the other hand, the ratio between the two rates depends on the (mean) frequency of the field, and assumes the (maximum) value 4 when the field is exactly on resonance.

Physical Review•Nov 1, 1968•210 citations

Jump time and passage time: the duration of a quantum transition

Lawrence S. Schulman

Under unitary evolution, systems move gradually from state to state. An unstable atom has amplitude in its original state after many lifetimes ($τ_L$). But in the laboratory, transitions seem to go instantaneously, as suggested by the term "quantum jump." The problem studied here is whether the "jump" can be assigned a duration, in theory and in experiment. Two characteristic times are defined, jump time ($τ_J$) and passage time ($τ_P$). Both use Zeno time, $τ_Z$, defined in terms of $H$ and its initial state as $τ_Z \equiv \hbar/\sqrt{}$, with $E_ψ\equiv $. $τ_J$ is defined in terms of the time needed to slow (à la the quantum Zeno effect) the decay: $τ_J \equiv τ_Z^2/τ_L$. It appears in several contexts. It is related to tunneling time in barrier penetration. Its inverse is the bandwidth of the Hamiltonian, in a time-energy uncertainty principle. $τ_J$ is also an indicator of the duration of the quadratic decay regime in both experiment and in numerical calculations (cf. Fig.~2 of PRA 57,1509 (1998).) The passage time, $τ_P$, arises from unitary evolution sans interpretation. It is based on a bound of Fleming (Nuov. Cim. 16 A, 232 (1973)): for any $H$ and $ψ$ a system cannot evolve to a state orthogonal to $ψ$ for $t< τ_P \equiv πτ_Z/2$. By including apparatus in $H$, $τ_P$ limits the observation of decay according to the quantum measurement ideas proposed in "Time's Arrows and Quantum Measurement," Cambridge U. Press, 1997, thereby allowing an experimental test of these ideas.

arXiv:quant-ph/0103151•Mar 27, 2001•6 citations
Values of rate of decay and mean life of atoms and molecules in upper quantum states calculated from data on the intensity of absorption lines.---By combining F"uchtbauer's method of determining from the intensity of absorption lines the probability that a molecule will absorb a quantum of energy, with Einstein's views as to the mechanism of light absorption and emission, the following equation is derived for calculating the rate at which molecules jump from upper to lower quantum states: A21=(8\ensuremathπ\ensuremathν2c2N1)(p1p2)\ensuremath∫0\ensuremath∞\ensuremathαd\ensuremathν{A}_{21}=\left(\frac{8\ensuremath{\pi}{\ensuremath{\nu}}^{2}}{{c}^{2}{N}_{1}}\right)\left(\frac{{p}_{1}}{{p}_{2}}\right)\ensuremath{\int}{0}^{\ensuremath{\infty}}\ensuremath{\alpha}d\ensuremath{\nu}A21​=(c2N1​8\ensuremathπ\ensuremathν2​)(p2​p1​​)\ensuremath∫0\ensuremath∞\ensuremathαd\ensuremathν where A21{A}_{21}A21​ is the chance per unit time that a molecule will jump spontaneously from quantum state 2 to quantum state 1, \ensuremathν\ensuremath{\nu}\ensuremathν is the frequency of the light emitted in such a jump, p1{p}_{1}p1​ and p2{p}_{2}p2​ are the a priori probabilities of quantum states 1 and 2, and \ensuremathα\ensuremath{\alpha}\ensuremathα is the absorption coefficient of the substance measured under conditions such that N1{N}_{1}N1​ is the number of molecules per unit volume in the lower quantum state 1. The integral \ensuremath∫\ensuremathαd\ensuremathν\ensuremath{\int}\ensuremath{\alpha}d\ensuremath{\nu}\ensuremath∫\ensuremathαd\ensuremathν is to be taken over the total effective width of the absorption line corresponding to the passage of molecules from quantum state 1 to quantum state 2. The mean life \ensuremathτ\ensuremath{\tau}\ensuremathτ of molecules which decay from state 2 to state 1 is the reciprocal of A21{A}_{21}A21​. Values of A21{A}_{21}A21​ and \ensuremathτ\ensuremath{\tau}\ensuremathτ are calculated from existing data for the mercury line \ensuremathλ2537\ensuremath{\lambda}2537\ensuremathλ2537, for a number of lines belonging to the alkali doublets, for the iodine line \ensuremathλ5461\ensuremath{\lambda}5461\ensuremathλ5461, and for a very considerable number of lines belonging to the rotation-oscillation spectra of the hydrogen halides. The values obtained agree with the meager data made available by other experimental methods. From these results the following conclusions are drawn.The mean life of molecules and atoms in upper quantum states may vary for different states at least over the range 1 to 10\ensuremath−8{10}^{\ensuremath{-}8}10\ensuremath−8 seconds. The rate of decay is not a simple function of the frequency of the emitted light. The rate corresponding to the emission of a line of high frequency may be greater or less than that for a line of lower frequency. The data now available for the alkali doublets 1s\ensuremath−mp11s\ensuremath{-}m{p}_{1}1s\ensuremath−mp1​ and 1s\ensuremath−mp21s\ensuremath{-}m{p}_{2}1s\ensuremath−mp2​ indicate a higher rate of decay the smaller the change in total quantum number for the line under consideration. The rate of decay from a given mp1m{p}_{1}mp1​ state is mmm times as great as from the corresponding mp2m{p}_{2}mp2​ state (already stated in another form by F"uchtbauer and Hofmann). In the case of the rotation-oscillation spectra of the hydrogen halides the rate of decay is greater for quantum states with one unit of oscillation and many of rotation, than for those with one unit of oscillation and only a few of rotation; and in the case of different molecules but the same quantum numbers the rate of decay is greater for the molecule with the greater frequency of oscillation.Finally the possibility and method of calculating absolute values of A21{A}_{21}A21​ from the Bohr correspondence principle is indicated.
In an article which has been presented to the Physical Review for publication the author has shown the possibility of calculating from data on the intensity of absorption lines the mean life τ of atoms and molecules in excited quantum states, and the specific rate A21 at which they spontaneously leave the excited state 2 to return to the lower state 1. The calculations are based on Fuchtbauer's (1) method of determining the probability that molecules will be activated by the absorption of a quantum of light, combined with Einstein's(2) views as to the mechanism of light absorption and emission.
A method for obtaining the intensity distribution in a spectral line is derived from Dirac's quantum theory of the radiation field. The calculations are carried out for the case of emission from a first excited state (resonance line) and show that the intensity of frequency $\ensuremath{\nu}$ is, in this case, proportional to $\frac{1}{[4{\ensuremath{\pi}}^{2}{({\ensuremath{\nu}}_{0}\ensuremath{-}\ensuremath{\nu})}^{2}+{(A\ifmmode\cdot\else\textperiodcentered\fi{}2)}^{2}]}$ were AAA is the rate at which atoms are leaving the upper state and ${\ensuremath{\nu}}_{0}$ is the frequency of the transition. The half-width is therefore $\frac{1}{2\ensuremath{\pi}}$ times the Einstein probability coefficient for spontaneous transition to the lower state. The more general case where the lower state has a finite life time is not treated.A general method for the treatment of radiation problems, which is essentially Weyl's modification of Dirac's method, is briefly described.
The mean life of the mercury line $\ensuremath{\lambda}2537$ was measured by the alternating voltage method previously described by Webb. The radiation was excited in a quartz tube by impact with electrons from a hot cathode. The photoelectric system was contained in a separate tube also of quartz. The photoelectric surface was zinc evaporated on a nickel plate. Measurements of the apparent life were made with diminishing mercury vapor pressures until further reduction of pressure produced no change in the measured rate of decay of the radiation. At these low pressures (below 3\ifmmode\times\else\texttimes\fi{}${10}^{\ensuremath{-}4}$ mm, for the geometry used) the absorption and reemission of the radiation was negligible and the true life of a single excitation process was measured. This was found to be 1.08\ifmmode\times\else\texttimes\fi{}${10}^{\ensuremath{-}7}$ sec. with an estimated precision of one percent.Absorption coefficient of $\ensuremath{\lambda}1849$. An absorption cell with a one mm thick absorbing layer of mercury vapor was mounted so as to move in and out between the excitation and photoelectric tubes used in the above measurements. The absorption of $\ensuremath{\lambda}1849$ was measured at pressures such that the absorption of $\ensuremath{\lambda}2537$ was negligible. From this the atomic absorption coefficient for the main component of the line was found to be 6.2\ifmmode\times\else\texttimes\fi{}${10}^{\ensuremath{-}11}$ from which the mean life of the 21P12^{1}P_{1}21P1​ state was calculated to be 2.9\ifmmode\times\else\texttimes\fi{}${10}^{\ensuremath{-}10}$ sec. with an estimated precision of 25 percent.
This paper asks an experimental question about photon absorption and emission in a two-state electronic system where the incident frequency of exciting light is below the mean frequency of the emission line but still within the line width. Since it is well known that the absorption spectrum and the emission spectrum are identical [1]-[3], then quantum mechanics as well as astronomical observations say that excitations will still occur. Once a quantum state excites, then it is expected to decay back with a typical time constant and the usual emission spectrum. The problem is that the mean frequency of that emission spectrum will then be higher than the frequency of the exciting photon, suggesting that more energy is emitted than being received on average. A search of quantum mechanical references finds no discussion of this issue, so this paper considers the options available to resolve this inconsistency, including an experiment.
The probability of an atom undergoing a transition to a given final state by means of two-photon absorption is expressed for arbitrary field states in terms of the second-order normally-ordered field correlation function, evaluated at the position of the atom. In the case of stationary fields, an expression for the absorption rate is found which reduces to a particularly simple form for narrow-bandwidth fields near resonance. The effect of field statistics is illustrated by comparing the absorption rate w2(ch)w_{2}^{}{}_{}{}^{(\mathrm{ch})}w2​​(ch) for chaotic or Gaussian light to the rate w2(l)w_{2}^{}{}_{}{}^{(l)}w2​​(l) for laser light. The rate for laser light is calculated within the context of a particular model based on the assumption of fixed field amplitude and random frequency modulation, and the chaotic light to which it is compared is assumed to have the same (Lorentzian) power spectrum. When the width ${\ensuremath{\kappa}}_{f}$ of the final atomic level is much greater than the bandwidth bbb of the field, we obtain the previously derived result w2(ch)w2(l)=2\frac{w_{2}^{}{}_{}{}^{(\mathrm{ch})}}{w_{2}^{}{}_{}{}^{(l)}}=2w2​​(l)w2​​(ch)​=2. When ${\ensuremath{\kappa}}_{f}\ensuremath{\ll}b$, on the other hand, the ratio between the two rates depends on the (mean) frequency of the field, and assumes the (maximum) value 4 when the field is exactly on resonance.
Under unitary evolution, systems move gradually from state to state. An unstable atom has amplitude in its original state after many lifetimes (τLτ_LτL​). But in the laboratory, transitions seem to go instantaneously, as suggested by the term "quantum jump." The problem studied here is whether the "jump" can be assigned a duration, in theory and in experiment. Two characteristic times are defined, jump time (τJτ_JτJ​) and passage time (τPτ_PτP​). Both use Zeno time, τZτ_ZτZ​, defined in terms of HHH and its initial state as τZ≡ℏ/τ_Z \equiv \hbar/\sqrt{}τZ​≡ℏ/​, with $E_ψ\equiv $. τJτ_JτJ​ is defined in terms of the time needed to slow (à la the quantum Zeno effect) the decay: τJ≡τZ2/τLτ_J \equiv τ_Z^2/τ_LτJ​≡τZ2​/τL​. It appears in several contexts. It is related to tunneling time in barrier penetration. Its inverse is the bandwidth of the Hamiltonian, in a time-energy uncertainty principle. τJτ_JτJ​ is also an indicator of the duration of the quadratic decay regime in both experiment and in numerical calculations (cf. Fig.~2 of PRA 57,1509 (1998).) The passage time, τPτ_PτP​, arises from unitary evolution sans interpretation. It is based on a bound of Fleming (Nuov. Cim. 16 A, 232 (1973)): for any HHH and ψψψ a system cannot evolve to a state orthogonal to ψψψ for t<τP≡πτZ/2t< τ_P \equiv πτ_Z/2t<τP​≡πτZ​/2. By including apparatus in HHH, τPτ_PτP​ limits the observation of decay according to the quantum measurement ideas proposed in "Time's Arrows and Quantum Measurement," Cambridge U. Press, 1997, thereby allowing an experimental test of these ideas.