Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Optics and Photonics Journal

The Uncertain Energy of an Excited State

Richard A. Hutchin

Published Jan 1, 2015• 1 citation
Publisher

Abstract

This paper asks an experimental question about photon absorption and emission in a two-state electronic system where the incident frequency of exciting light is below the mean frequency of the emission line but still within the line width. Since it is well known that the absorption spectrum and the emission spectrum are identical [1]-[3], then quantum mechanics as well as astronomical observations say that excitations will still occur. Once a quantum state excites, then it is expected to decay back with a typical time constant and the usual emission spectrum. The problem is that the mean frequency of that emission spectrum will then be higher than the frequency of the exciting photon, suggesting that more energy is emitted than being received on average. A search of quantum mechanical references finds no discussion of this issue, so this paper considers the options available to resolve this inconsistency, including an experiment.

DOI
10.4236/opj.2015.56019

Related papers

Absorption and emission of light by systems with closely spaced energy levels

J. Michael Schurr

A complete solution of the time-dependent Schrodinger equation for the overall absorption-emission process is presented for a particular model system possessing an excited state manifold of (nearly) uniformly spaced molecular eigenstates with a lorentzian distribution of transition moment. Results for both narrow and broad band excitation are derived, and it is shown that the fluorescence quantum yield is essentially the same for both broad band and narrow band excitations. It is argued that the lifetime of the incident photon state is important in determining the presence or absence of structure in the absorption spectrum and, consequently, that the absorption spectrum observed depends upon both the optical density of the sample and the intensity of the incident light.

Molecular Physics•Mar 1, 1973•3 citations

Photophysics of Solid State Laser Materials

Yehoshua Y. Kalisky

Light emission occurs as a result of interaction between light and matter. Let us assume a two-level atom with levels 1 (ground state) and 2 (excited state). The energies of the ground and excited states are E 1 and E 2 , respectively, and the energy difference is therefore given by the difference ΔE 12 =E 2 −E 1 . When light with photons of energy equal to this difference is absorbed by the atomic or molecular system, an electron will be excited from level 1 to level 2. The energy of the photons is given by ΔE 12 =E 12 =hν 12 (h is Planck's constant and 1→2 is the frequency of light resulting from the level 1→2 transition). This energy is absorbed by an atom or a molecule that has energy levels, separated by ΔE, where these energy levels are the ground and the excited states. This kind of “quantum jump” of an electron between two states occurs in atomic systems between electronic levels; it can be extended to molecular systems, where vibrational and translational energy levels participate in the quantum jump. The interaction between light and matter involves the transition of electrons between different states. This interaction results in the absorption of photons (stimulated absorption) as well as spontaneous and stimulated emission. These processes can be described using Einstein's A and B coefficients, as will be described in the next paragraphs.

SPIE eBooks•Oct 22, 2009•0 citations

Induced absorption and stimulated emission in a driven two-level atom

Constantine Mavroyannis

We have considered the induced processes that occur in a driven two-level atom, where a laser photon is absorbed and emitted by the ground and by the excited states of the atom, respectively. In the low-intensity limit of the laser field, the induced spectra arising when a laser photon is absorbed by the ground state of the atom consist of two peaks describing induced-absorption and stimulated-emission processes, respectively, where the former prevails over the latter. Asymmetry of the spectral lines occurs at off-resonance and its extent depends on the detuning of the laser field. The physical, process where a laser photon is emitted by the excited state is the reverse of that arising from the absorption of a laser photon by the ground state of the atom. The former differs from the latter in that the emission of a laser photon by the excited state occurs in the low-frequency regime and that the stimulated-emission process prevails over that of the induced absorption. In this case, amplification of ultrashort pulses is likely to occur without the need of population inversion between the optical transitions. The computed spectra are graphically presented and discussed.

Canadian Journal of Physics•Jun 1, 1992•2 citations

Radiative Atomic Bound–Bound Transitions

Stefan P. Hau‐Riege

This chapter treats radiative electronic excitation and de-excitation processes in atoms. The latter are particularly important for understanding the lifetime of excited states and the associated energy width. There are multiple possible causes for finite spectral width, such as inelastic collisions, the Doppler effect, and finite lifetimes of the states due to fluorescence or Auger decay. The most fundamental cause, which the author wants to study now, is the interaction of the atom with the radiation field through the emission and reabsorption of photons, which leads to both the natural line width related to spontaneous emission and to a shift in the transition energy. The chapter considers the excitation of matter from an initial state to a higher energy state under the absorption of one photon from mode. It discusses Einstein's A and B Coefficients and radiative atomic bound-bound transitions in mixed states.

Wiley eBooks•Oct 20, 2014•0 citations

The dynamics of spontaneous emission

M. Baldo

The spontaneous decay of an excited atom by photon emission is one of the most common and elementary physical process present in nature and in laboratories. The decay is random in time with constant probability density, as it can be inferred by the exponential law observed experimentally. Despite the simplicity of the process, in Quantum Mechanics the decay itself is considered a law of nature which is not further analyzed or explained. However it is legitimate to ask for the reason of its randomness and for the dynamics of the atom around the decay. The decay process of an isolated atom is usually assumed to be instantaneous, the so called Quantum jumps. Particular experimental arrangements can widen the duration of the transition from an excited state to the ground state to a finite time. In general this is due to the quantum back action of the detector. The development of Quantum Optics has enormously enriched the possibilities to study in detail the process, and new illuminating insights have been obtained, but the question is still valid and its answer is still elusive. In this paper we analyze the spontaneous decay within the new prospect introduced by a recent model that complete standard Quantum Mechanics in a formalism which is able to describe the dynamics of measurement and of spontaneous decay. Comparison is made with more phenomenological theories, the Quantum Mechanics of open system and the Stochastic wave function model. In the new model the stochastic photon emission by an excited atom is triggered by the vacuum fluctuations. It is suggested how to re-analyze three types of experiments, already realized in many laboratories, in order to reveal the presence and the effect of these fluctuations.

arXiv:2505.22164•May 28, 2025•1 citation

Radiative Transfer between Quantum States

Gabriel Laufer

Until now, our discussion of the interaction between radiation and matter has concentrated only on the spectral aspects of radiation. The results could determine the wavelengths for absorption and emission or the selection rules for such transitions, but could not be used to determine the actual extent of emission or absorption. These too are important considerations which are needed to fully quantify radiative energy transfer. Unfortunately, none of the classical theories can predict the extent of emission from an excited medium, or even the extent of absorption. Although the discussion in Section 4.9 (on the propagation of electromagnetic waves through lossy media) touched briefly on the concept of attenuation by absorption, it failed to show the reasons for the spectral properties of the absorption or to accurately predict its extent. We will see later that the classical results are useful only as a benchmark against which the actual absorber is compared. The objective of this chapter is therefore to present an introduction to quantum mechanical processes that control the emission and absorption by microscopic systems consisting of atoms and molecules. The results will then be used to predict the extent of emission by media when excited by an external energy source and to evaluate the absorption of incident radiation.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Jul 13, 1996•0 citations
This paper asks an experimental question about photon absorption and emission in a two-state electronic system where the incident frequency of exciting light is below the mean frequency of the emission line but still within the line width. Since it is well known that the absorption spectrum and the emission spectrum are identical [1]-[3], then quantum mechanics as well as astronomical observations say that excitations will still occur. Once a quantum state excites, then it is expected to decay back with a typical time constant and the usual emission spectrum. The problem is that the mean frequency of that emission spectrum will then be higher than the frequency of the exciting photon, suggesting that more energy is emitted than being received on average. A search of quantum mechanical references finds no discussion of this issue, so this paper considers the options available to resolve this inconsistency, including an experiment.
A complete solution of the time-dependent Schrodinger equation for the overall absorption-emission process is presented for a particular model system possessing an excited state manifold of (nearly) uniformly spaced molecular eigenstates with a lorentzian distribution of transition moment. Results for both narrow and broad band excitation are derived, and it is shown that the fluorescence quantum yield is essentially the same for both broad band and narrow band excitations. It is argued that the lifetime of the incident photon state is important in determining the presence or absence of structure in the absorption spectrum and, consequently, that the absorption spectrum observed depends upon both the optical density of the sample and the intensity of the incident light.
Light emission occurs as a result of interaction between light and matter. Let us assume a two-level atom with levels 1 (ground state) and 2 (excited state). The energies of the ground and excited states are E 1 and E 2 , respectively, and the energy difference is therefore given by the difference ΔE 12 =E 2 −E 1 . When light with photons of energy equal to this difference is absorbed by the atomic or molecular system, an electron will be excited from level 1 to level 2. The energy of the photons is given by ΔE 12 =E 12 =hν 12 (h is Planck's constant and 1→2 is the frequency of light resulting from the level 1→2 transition). This energy is absorbed by an atom or a molecule that has energy levels, separated by ΔE, where these energy levels are the ground and the excited states. This kind of “quantum jump” of an electron between two states occurs in atomic systems between electronic levels; it can be extended to molecular systems, where vibrational and translational energy levels participate in the quantum jump. The interaction between light and matter involves the transition of electrons between different states. This interaction results in the absorption of photons (stimulated absorption) as well as spontaneous and stimulated emission. These processes can be described using Einstein's A and B coefficients, as will be described in the next paragraphs.
We have considered the induced processes that occur in a driven two-level atom, where a laser photon is absorbed and emitted by the ground and by the excited states of the atom, respectively. In the low-intensity limit of the laser field, the induced spectra arising when a laser photon is absorbed by the ground state of the atom consist of two peaks describing induced-absorption and stimulated-emission processes, respectively, where the former prevails over the latter. Asymmetry of the spectral lines occurs at off-resonance and its extent depends on the detuning of the laser field. The physical, process where a laser photon is emitted by the excited state is the reverse of that arising from the absorption of a laser photon by the ground state of the atom. The former differs from the latter in that the emission of a laser photon by the excited state occurs in the low-frequency regime and that the stimulated-emission process prevails over that of the induced absorption. In this case, amplification of ultrashort pulses is likely to occur without the need of population inversion between the optical transitions. The computed spectra are graphically presented and discussed.
This chapter treats radiative electronic excitation and de-excitation processes in atoms. The latter are particularly important for understanding the lifetime of excited states and the associated energy width. There are multiple possible causes for finite spectral width, such as inelastic collisions, the Doppler effect, and finite lifetimes of the states due to fluorescence or Auger decay. The most fundamental cause, which the author wants to study now, is the interaction of the atom with the radiation field through the emission and reabsorption of photons, which leads to both the natural line width related to spontaneous emission and to a shift in the transition energy. The chapter considers the excitation of matter from an initial state to a higher energy state under the absorption of one photon from mode. It discusses Einstein's A and B Coefficients and radiative atomic bound-bound transitions in mixed states.
The spontaneous decay of an excited atom by photon emission is one of the most common and elementary physical process present in nature and in laboratories. The decay is random in time with constant probability density, as it can be inferred by the exponential law observed experimentally. Despite the simplicity of the process, in Quantum Mechanics the decay itself is considered a law of nature which is not further analyzed or explained. However it is legitimate to ask for the reason of its randomness and for the dynamics of the atom around the decay. The decay process of an isolated atom is usually assumed to be instantaneous, the so called Quantum jumps. Particular experimental arrangements can widen the duration of the transition from an excited state to the ground state to a finite time. In general this is due to the quantum back action of the detector. The development of Quantum Optics has enormously enriched the possibilities to study in detail the process, and new illuminating insights have been obtained, but the question is still valid and its answer is still elusive. In this paper we analyze the spontaneous decay within the new prospect introduced by a recent model that complete standard Quantum Mechanics in a formalism which is able to describe the dynamics of measurement and of spontaneous decay. Comparison is made with more phenomenological theories, the Quantum Mechanics of open system and the Stochastic wave function model. In the new model the stochastic photon emission by an excited atom is triggered by the vacuum fluctuations. It is suggested how to re-analyze three types of experiments, already realized in many laboratories, in order to reveal the presence and the effect of these fluctuations.
Until now, our discussion of the interaction between radiation and matter has concentrated only on the spectral aspects of radiation. The results could determine the wavelengths for absorption and emission or the selection rules for such transitions, but could not be used to determine the actual extent of emission or absorption. These too are important considerations which are needed to fully quantify radiative energy transfer. Unfortunately, none of the classical theories can predict the extent of emission from an excited medium, or even the extent of absorption. Although the discussion in Section 4.9 (on the propagation of electromagnetic waves through lossy media) touched briefly on the concept of attenuation by absorption, it failed to show the reasons for the spectral properties of the absorption or to accurately predict its extent. We will see later that the classical results are useful only as a benchmark against which the actual absorber is compared. The objective of this chapter is therefore to present an introduction to quantum mechanical processes that control the emission and absorption by microscopic systems consisting of atoms and molecules. The results will then be used to predict the extent of emission by media when excited by an external energy source and to evaluate the absorption of incident radiation.