Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Foundations of probability and physics

NONCONVENTIONAL VIEWPOINT TO ELEMENTS OF PHYSICAL REALITY BASED ON NONREAL ASYMPTOTICS OF RELATIVE FREQUENCIES

Andrei Yu. Khrennikov

Published Dec 1, 2001• 2 citations
Publisher

Abstract

We study connection between stabilization of relative frequencies and elements of physical reality. We observe that, besides the standard stabilization with respect to the real metric, there can be considered other statistical stabilizations (in particular, with respect to so called p-adic metric on the set of rational numbers). Nonconventional statistical stabilizations might be connected with new (nonconventional) elements of reality. We present a few natural examples of statistical phenomena in that relative frequencies of observed events stabilize in the p-adic metric, but fluctuate in the standard real metric.

DOI
10.1142/9789812810809_0015

Related papers

Statistical interpretation of p-adic quantum theories with p-adic valued wave functions

Andrew Khrennikov

The development of p-adic quantum mechanics has made it necessary to construct a probability theory in which the probabilities of events are p-adic numbers. The foundations of this theory are developed here. The frequency definition of probability is used. A general principle of statistical stabilization of relative frequencies is formulated. By virtue of this principle, statistical stabilization of relative frequencies, which are, like all experimental data, rational numbers, can be considered not only in the real topology but also in p-adic topologies.

Journal of Mathematical Physics•Dec 1, 1995•15 citations

On the spectrum of thep-adic position operator

Sergio A Albeverio, Roberto Cianci, Andrew Khrennikov

We propose a physical interpretation for a p-adic picture of reality. According to this interpretation, p-adic numbers describe measurements with a finite accuracy (at the same time, real numbers describe measurements with an infinite accuracy). We consider the representation of the position operator in a p-adic Hilbert space and study the spectrum of this operator.

Journal of Physics A Mathematical and General•Feb 7, 1997•28 citations

Interpretations of Probability and Their p -Adic Extensions

Andrei Yu. Khrennikov

This paper is devoted to foundations of probability theory. We discuss interpretations of probability, corresponding mathematical formalisms, and applications to quantum physics. One of the aims of this paper is to show that the probability model based on Kolmogorov's axiomatics cannot describe all stochastic phenomena, i.e., that quantum physics induces natural restrictions of the use of Kolmogorov's theory and that we need to develop non-Kolmogorov models for describing some quantum phenomena. The physical motivations are presented in a clear and brief manner. Thus the reader does not need to have preliminary knowledgeof quantum physics. Our main idea is that we cannot develop non-Kolmogorov models by the formal change of Kolmogorov's axiomatics. We begin with interpretations (classical, frequency, and proportional). Then we present a class of non-Kolmogorov models described by so-called p-adic numbers. Here, in particular, we obtain a quite natural realization of negative probabilities. These negative probability distributions might provide a solution of some quantum paradoxes.

Theory of Probability and Its Applications•Jan 1, 2002•15 citations

OBSERVABLES, QUANTUM FLUCTUATIONS, AND "QUANTUM REALITY"

A.S. Shumovsky

AbstractWe discuss difference between the classical and quantummethods of description of Nature in terms of fundamentalobservables related to the dynamical symmetry group of theHilbert space and quantum fluctuations, specifying their mea-surement. We show that the total amount of quantum fluc-tuations of fundamental observables can be used to measurethe “remoteness” of quantum states from “classical reality”provided by the choice of observables in terms of c-numbers.The proposed picture is more general than Bell’s approach todefinition of “classical reality”.

Old and New Concepts of Physics•Jan 1, 2004•1 citation

Stability Principle in Non-Inertial Physics

TF Kamalov

Quantum mechanics is traditionally formulated in terms of postulates inferred from experimentalobservations. Here we propose that the statistical regularities of quantum mechanics arise as macro-scopic manifestations of stochastic fluctuations of dynamical parameters in microscopic systems gen-erated by a non-inertial physical background. Although the specific nature of this background mayvary, the universality of quantum statistics is ensured by invariant properties of stochastic dynam-ics - analogous to the role of the equivalence principle in general relativity - and by the existence ofa fundamental action scale, Planck constant h. By extending classical mechanics to include higher-order derivatives induced by non-inertial fuctuations and imposing a stability condition on admissibletrajectories, the minimal action scale h naturally emerges. In this framework quantum mechanicsappears as an effective statistical description of systems embedded in a fluctuating non-inertial envi-ronment while preserving all standard predictions of the theory.

•Mar 11, 2026•0 citations

Free Choice in Quantum Theory: A p-adic View

Vladimir Anashin

In this paper, it is rigorously proven that since observational data (i.e., numerical values of physical quantities) are rational numbers only due to inevitably nonzero measurements errors, the conclusion about whether Nature at the smallest scales is discrete or continuous, random and chaotic, or strictly deterministic, solely depends on experimentalist’s free choice of the metrics (real or p-adic) he chooses to process the observational data. The main mathematical tools are p-adic 1-Lipschitz maps (which therefore are continuous with respect to the p-adic metric). The maps are exactly the ones defined by sequential Mealy machines (rather than by cellular automata) and therefore are causal functions over discrete time. A wide class of the maps can naturally be expanded to continuous real functions, so the maps may serve as mathematical models of open physical systems both over discrete and over continuous time. For these models, wave functions are constructed, entropic uncertainty relation is proven, and no hidden parameters are assumed. The paper is motivated by the ideas of I. Volovich on p-adic mathematical physics, by G. ‘t Hooft’s cellular automaton interpretation of quantum mechanics, and to some extent, by recent papers on superdeterminism by J. Hance, S. Hossenfelder, and T. Palmer.

Entropy•May 22, 2023•9 citations
We study connection between stabilization of relative frequencies and elements of physical reality. We observe that, besides the standard stabilization with respect to the real metric, there can be considered other statistical stabilizations (in particular, with respect to so called p-adic metric on the set of rational numbers). Nonconventional statistical stabilizations might be connected with new (nonconventional) elements of reality. We present a few natural examples of statistical phenomena in that relative frequencies of observed events stabilize in the p-adic metric, but fluctuate in the standard real metric.
The development of p-adic quantum mechanics has made it necessary to construct a probability theory in which the probabilities of events are p-adic numbers. The foundations of this theory are developed here. The frequency definition of probability is used. A general principle of statistical stabilization of relative frequencies is formulated. By virtue of this principle, statistical stabilization of relative frequencies, which are, like all experimental data, rational numbers, can be considered not only in the real topology but also in p-adic topologies.
This paper is devoted to foundations of probability theory. We discuss interpretations of probability, corresponding mathematical formalisms, and applications to quantum physics. One of the aims of this paper is to show that the probability model based on Kolmogorov's axiomatics cannot describe all stochastic phenomena, i.e., that quantum physics induces natural restrictions of the use of Kolmogorov's theory and that we need to develop non-Kolmogorov models for describing some quantum phenomena. The physical motivations are presented in a clear and brief manner. Thus the reader does not need to have preliminary knowledgeof quantum physics. Our main idea is that we cannot develop non-Kolmogorov models by the formal change of Kolmogorov's axiomatics. We begin with interpretations (classical, frequency, and proportional). Then we present a class of non-Kolmogorov models described by so-called p-adic numbers. Here, in particular, we obtain a quite natural realization of negative probabilities. These negative probability distributions might provide a solution of some quantum paradoxes.
AbstractWe discuss difference between the classical and quantummethods of description of Nature in terms of fundamentalobservables related to the dynamical symmetry group of theHilbert space and quantum fluctuations, specifying their mea-surement. We show that the total amount of quantum fluc-tuations of fundamental observables can be used to measurethe “remoteness” of quantum states from “classical reality”provided by the choice of observables in terms of c-numbers.The proposed picture is more general than Bell’s approach todefinition of “classical reality”.
Quantum mechanics is traditionally formulated in terms of postulates inferred from experimentalobservations. Here we propose that the statistical regularities of quantum mechanics arise as macro-scopic manifestations of stochastic fluctuations of dynamical parameters in microscopic systems gen-erated by a non-inertial physical background. Although the specific nature of this background mayvary, the universality of quantum statistics is ensured by invariant properties of stochastic dynam-ics - analogous to the role of the equivalence principle in general relativity - and by the existence ofa fundamental action scale, Planck constant h. By extending classical mechanics to include higher-order derivatives induced by non-inertial fuctuations and imposing a stability condition on admissibletrajectories, the minimal action scale h naturally emerges. In this framework quantum mechanicsappears as an effective statistical description of systems embedded in a fluctuating non-inertial envi-ronment while preserving all standard predictions of the theory.
In this paper, it is rigorously proven that since observational data (i.e., numerical values of physical quantities) are rational numbers only due to inevitably nonzero measurements errors, the conclusion about whether Nature at the smallest scales is discrete or continuous, random and chaotic, or strictly deterministic, solely depends on experimentalist’s free choice of the metrics (real or p-adic) he chooses to process the observational data. The main mathematical tools are p-adic 1-Lipschitz maps (which therefore are continuous with respect to the p-adic metric). The maps are exactly the ones defined by sequential Mealy machines (rather than by cellular automata) and therefore are causal functions over discrete time. A wide class of the maps can naturally be expanded to continuous real functions, so the maps may serve as mathematical models of open physical systems both over discrete and over continuous time. For these models, wave functions are constructed, entropic uncertainty relation is proven, and no hidden parameters are assumed. The paper is motivated by the ideas of I. Volovich on p-adic mathematical physics, by G. ‘t Hooft’s cellular automaton interpretation of quantum mechanics, and to some extent, by recent papers on superdeterminism by J. Hance, S. Hossenfelder, and T. Palmer.