Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Old and New Concepts of Physics

OBSERVABLES, QUANTUM FLUCTUATIONS, AND "QUANTUM REALITY"

A.S. Shumovsky

Published Jan 1, 2004• 1 citation
OpenAlex

Abstract

AbstractWe discuss difference between the classical and quantummethods of description of Nature in terms of fundamentalobservables related to the dynamical symmetry group of theHilbert space and quantum fluctuations, specifying their mea-surement. We show that the total amount of quantum fluc-tuations of fundamental observables can be used to measurethe “remoteness” of quantum states from “classical reality”provided by the choice of observables in terms of c-numbers.The proposed picture is more general than Bell’s approach todefinition of “classical reality”.

Related papers

PROLIFERATION OF OBSERVABLES AND MEASUREMENT IN QUANTUM-CLASSICAL HYBRIDS

Hans-Thomas Elze

Following a review of quantum-classical hybrid dynamics, we discuss the ensuing proliferation of observables and relate it to measurements of (would-be) quantum mechanical degrees of freedom performed by (would-be) classical ones (if they were separable). Hybrids consist in coupled classical (CL) and quantum mechanical (QM) objects. Numerous consistency requirements for their description have been discussed and are fulfilled here. We summarize a representation of quantum mechanics in terms of classical analytical mechanics which is naturally extended to QM–CL hybrids. This framework allows for superposition, separable, and entangled states originating in the QM sector, admits experimenter's "Free Will", and is local and nonsignaling. Presently, we study the set of hybrid observables, which is larger than the Cartesian product of QM and CL observables of its components; yet it is smaller than a corresponding product of all-classical observables. Thus, quantumness and classicality infect each other.

arXiv:1212.2380•International Journal of Quantum Information•Dec 1, 2012•14 citations

Quantum Mechanics in symmetry language

H. Ziaeepour

We consider symmetry as a foundational concept in quantum mechanics and rewrite quantum mechanics and measurement axioms in this description. We argue that issues related to measurements and physical reality of states can be better understood in this view. In particular, the abstract concept of symmetry provides a basis-independent definition for observables. Moreover, we show that the apparent projection/collapse of the state as the final step of measurement or decoherence is the result of breaking of symmetries. This phenomenon is comparable with a phase transition by spontaneous symmetry breaking, and makes the process of decoherence and classicality a natural fate of complex systems consisting of many interacting subsystems. Additionally, we demonstrate that the property of state space as a vector space representing symmetries is more fundamental than being an abstract Hilbert space, and its $L2$ integrability can be obtained from the imposed condition of being a representation of a symmetry group and general properties of probability distributions.

arXiv:1305.4349•May 19, 2013•4 citations

General entanglement

Alexander A. Klyachko, A.S. Shumovsky

The paper contains a brief review of an approach to quantum entanglement based on analysis of dynamic symmetry of systems and quantum uncertainties, accompanying the measurement of mean value of certain basic observables. The latter are defined in terms of the orthogonal basis of Lie algebra, corresponding to the dynamic symmetry group. We discuss the relativity of entanglement with respect to the choice of basic observables and a way of stabilization of robust entanglement in physical systems.

arXiv:quant-ph/0512213•Journal of Physics Conference Series•Apr 1, 2006•11 citations

Classical dynamics of quantum fluctuations

Ram Brustein, David H. Oaknin

It is shown that the vacuum state of weakly interacting quantum field theories can be described, in the Heisenberg picture, as a linear combination of randomly distributed incoherent paths that obey classical equations of motion with constrained initial conditions. We call such paths ``pseudoclassical'' paths and use them to define the dynamics of quantum fluctuations. Every physical observable is assigned a time-dependent value on each path in a way that respects the uncertainty principle, but in consequence, some of the standard algebraic relations between quantum observables are not necessarily satisfied by their time-dependent values on paths. We define ``collective observables'' which depend on a large number of independent degrees of freedom and show that the dynamics of their quantum fluctuations can be described in terms of unconstrained classical stochastic processes without reference to any additional external system or to an environment. Our analysis can be generalized to states other than the vacuum. Finally, we compare our formalism to the formalism of coherent states and highlight their differences.

arXiv:hep-th/0207251•Physical review. D. Particles, fields, gravitation, and cosmology/Physical review. D. Particles and fields•Jan 22, 2003•7 citations

Experimental Noise, Idealizations and the Classical-Quantum Relation

Gebhard von Oppen

Classical dynamics and the classical concept of space-time reality is based on the assumption that the objects of physics can be observed continuously. The discrete structure of matter (atoms) and fields (quanta), however, implies that the process of observation is quantized. In this paper we discuss the consequences of this paradigm change from continuity to discreteness and from determinism to chance. By taking into account the quantized structure of observation, we are led to the conclusion that the classical concept of reality has to be replaced by a quantum concept of observability. It implies that quantum dynamics is not a generalization of classical dynamics. Rather, the two theories apply to complementary idealizations of nature representing opposite extremes on a scale of observability. They are related by correspondence rules. Both theories disregard experimental noise. Statistical and thermal noise provide the experimental foundation for statistical physics.

•Jun 3, 2010•0 citations

General approach to quantum entanglement

Alexander A. Klyachko, A.S. Shumovsky

We examine quantum entanglement as a physical phenomenon independent of specific problems of quantum information technologies. Within the dynamic symmetry approach, we briefly discuss the role of quantum fluctuations in formation of entangled states, including single-particle entanglement, relativity of entanglement with respect to the choice of basic observables, and stabilization of robust entanglement.

Laser Physics•Feb 1, 2007•0 citations
AbstractWe discuss difference between the classical and quantummethods of description of Nature in terms of fundamentalobservables related to the dynamical symmetry group of theHilbert space and quantum fluctuations, specifying their mea-surement. We show that the total amount of quantum fluc-tuations of fundamental observables can be used to measurethe “remoteness” of quantum states from “classical reality”provided by the choice of observables in terms of c-numbers.The proposed picture is more general than Bell’s approach todefinition of “classical reality”.
Following a review of quantum-classical hybrid dynamics, we discuss the ensuing proliferation of observables and relate it to measurements of (would-be) quantum mechanical degrees of freedom performed by (would-be) classical ones (if they were separable). Hybrids consist in coupled classical (CL) and quantum mechanical (QM) objects. Numerous consistency requirements for their description have been discussed and are fulfilled here. We summarize a representation of quantum mechanics in terms of classical analytical mechanics which is naturally extended to QM–CL hybrids. This framework allows for superposition, separable, and entangled states originating in the QM sector, admits experimenter's "Free Will", and is local and nonsignaling. Presently, we study the set of hybrid observables, which is larger than the Cartesian product of QM and CL observables of its components; yet it is smaller than a corresponding product of all-classical observables. Thus, quantumness and classicality infect each other.
We consider symmetry as a foundational concept in quantum mechanics and rewrite quantum mechanics and measurement axioms in this description. We argue that issues related to measurements and physical reality of states can be better understood in this view. In particular, the abstract concept of symmetry provides a basis-independent definition for observables. Moreover, we show that the apparent projection/collapse of the state as the final step of measurement or decoherence is the result of breaking of symmetries. This phenomenon is comparable with a phase transition by spontaneous symmetry breaking, and makes the process of decoherence and classicality a natural fate of complex systems consisting of many interacting subsystems. Additionally, we demonstrate that the property of state space as a vector space representing symmetries is more fundamental than being an abstract Hilbert space, and its L2L2L2 integrability can be obtained from the imposed condition of being a representation of a symmetry group and general properties of probability distributions.
It is shown that the vacuum state of weakly interacting quantum field theories can be described, in the Heisenberg picture, as a linear combination of randomly distributed incoherent paths that obey classical equations of motion with constrained initial conditions. We call such paths ``pseudoclassical'' paths and use them to define the dynamics of quantum fluctuations. Every physical observable is assigned a time-dependent value on each path in a way that respects the uncertainty principle, but in consequence, some of the standard algebraic relations between quantum observables are not necessarily satisfied by their time-dependent values on paths. We define ``collective observables'' which depend on a large number of independent degrees of freedom and show that the dynamics of their quantum fluctuations can be described in terms of unconstrained classical stochastic processes without reference to any additional external system or to an environment. Our analysis can be generalized to states other than the vacuum. Finally, we compare our formalism to the formalism of coherent states and highlight their differences.
Classical dynamics and the classical concept of space-time reality is based on the assumption that the objects of physics can be observed continuously. The discrete structure of matter (atoms) and fields (quanta), however, implies that the process of observation is quantized. In this paper we discuss the consequences of this paradigm change from continuity to discreteness and from determinism to chance. By taking into account the quantized structure of observation, we are led to the conclusion that the classical concept of reality has to be replaced by a quantum concept of observability. It implies that quantum dynamics is not a generalization of classical dynamics. Rather, the two theories apply to complementary idealizations of nature representing opposite extremes on a scale of observability. They are related by correspondence rules. Both theories disregard experimental noise. Statistical and thermal noise provide the experimental foundation for statistical physics.