Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Physical Review A

Null test of quantum mechanics using two-photon down-conversion

Mark S. Hillery

Published May 1, 1998• 1 citation
Publisher

Abstract

A null test of quantum mechanics is proposed. It is based on an arrangement in which a source sends two signals to two detectors. At each detector one of two different quantities can be measured. If the source satisfies three conditions, all of which can be verified experimentally, then, according to quantum mechanics, a particular outcome is forbidden. This result follows only from the way in which quantum mechanics constructs probabilities, and does not involve any dynamics. Looking for this outcome is a test of quantum mechanics. It is shown how this test can be realized using two-photon down-conversion.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.57.3285

Related papers

Violations of classical probability in optics

L. Mandeļ

A number of optical experiments in which quantum mechanics is tested and the laws of classical probability are violated will be described. These all make use of the phenomenon in non-linear optics known as parametric down-conversion, in which an incident pump photon effectively splits into two correlated, lower frequency signal and idler photons in an entangled quantum state. We show that two-photon coincidence measurements of signal and idler photons violate classical probability by at least 600 standard deviations. Other measurements involving two down-converters lead to the realization of a ″quantum eraser″ and suggest a reinterpretation of the usual quantum wave function.

Annual Meeting Optical Society of America•Jan 1, 1992•0 citations

On the Negative Result Experiments in Quantum Mechanics

Kenichi Konishi

We comment on the so-called negative result experiments (also known as null measurements, interaction-free measurements, and so on) in quantum mechanics (QM), in the light of the new general understanding of the quantum-measurement processes, proposed recently. All experiments of this kind (null measurements) can be understood as improper measurements with an intentionally biased detector set up, which introduces exclusion or selection of certain events. The prediction on the state of a microscopic system under study based on a null measurement is sometimes dramatically described as "wave-function collapse without any microsystem-detector interactions". Though certainly correct, such a prediction is just a consequence of the standard QM laws, not different from the situation in the so-called state-preparation procedure. Another closely related concept is the (first-class or) repeatable measurements. The verification of the prediction made by a null measurement requires eventually a standard unbiased measurement involving the microsystem-macroscopic detector interactions, which are nonadiabatic, irreversible processes of signal amplification.

arXiv:2310.01955•Entropy•Nov 7, 2024•6 citations

Experimental Test of the deBroglie Guided Wave Theory for Photons

L. J. Wang, X. Y. Zou, L. Mandeļ

An experiment has been carried out to test a prediction of the deBroglie guided wave theory for photons. According to this theory, there exist electromagnetic waves as well as photons, with the former acting as guide for the latter. The wave not only determines the probability for the detection of a photon, but it also has an independent physical reality which can result in photodetection, As a result the guided wave theory predicts an interference effect when two photons pass through an interferometer with a particular geometry and one measures the rate of simultaneous detections by two photodetectors in coincidence as a function of optical path difference, By contrast, quantum mechanics predicts no interference under the same conditions. The experimental results clearly violate the prediction of the guided wave theory, but are in agreement with quantum mechanics.

Annual Meeting Optical Society of America•Jan 1, 1990•1 citation

On the three-slit experiment and quantum mechanics

Bo-Sture Skagerstam

It has been suggested by Sorkin that a three-slit Young experiment could reveal the validity a fundamental ingredient in the foundations of one of the cornerstones in modern physics namely quantum mechanics. In terms of a certain parameter κ S , it was argued that a non-zero value could imply a breakdown of the fundamental Born's rule as well as the superposition principle. Here we argue that a physical realization of such arguments could lead to an erroneous conclusion and contradict the basic rules of quantum mechanics. In fact, we argue that a straightforward interpretation of the procedures involved in a physical determination of κ S does not necessarily lead to κ S = 0. In order to show this we consider a mono-chromatic source of photons prepared in an arbitrary quantum state and a simple version of the well-established photon detection theory of Glauber which, by construction, obeys all the rules of quantum mechanics. It is, however, also argued that after a proper identification of the relevant quantum-mechanical probability amplitudes one can be reach κ S = 0. As long as one only consider a single photon detector, it is verified that, in this context, there is no fundamental difference between quantum-mechanical interference and interference as expressed in terms of classical electro-magnetic waves.

arXiv:1807.11586•Journal of Physics Communications•Dec 6, 2018•10 citations

Pump Power, Heralding Rate and Multi-Pair Contamination in a Parametric Down-Conversion Source

William Alexander Aldred

Spontaneous parametric down-conversion produces photon pairs at a rate that grows with pump power, but the probability of producing two pairs in the same detection window grows faster. A heralded source therefore faces a direct trade between rate and purity. This study computes the quantities that follow from stated assumptions for a pulsed down-conversion source at 80 MHz repetition rate with heralding detector efficiency 0.6 and signal channel transmission 0.5, using the relations set out in the Methods. The headline results are herald rate at mu 0.02 Hz = 9.412e+05, g2 at mu 0.02 = 0.05383, g2 at mu 0.1 = 0.2314, herald rate at mu 0.1 Hz = 4.364e+06, g2 at mu 0.005 = 0.01386. The central question is stated as follows: For a stated pair-generation probability per pulse, what heralded rate, heralded second-order correlation and coincidence-to-accidental ratio follow, and where does the correlation cross a stated quality threshold? The answer obtained here is conditional on the assumptions listed in the paper and in the deposited calculation; changing an assumption changes the numbers in the way the sensitivity discussion describes. Heralded sources are commonly characterised by a conditional second-order correlation well below one half for a usable single photon, with values near 0.1 or lower at modest pump levels. The work is a computation, not a laboratory measurement, and it is labelled accordingly. Where the computed result is unfavourable to the device or effect under study, that outcome is reported in the same terms as a favourable one, because a bound that only appears when it is welcome is not a bound at all. All numerical statements in this abstract are reproduced by the deposited script from the stated inputs.

•Nov 12, 2026•0 citations

Testing Born's rule in quantum mechanics for three nutually exclusive events

Immo Söllner, Urbasi Sinha, Christophe Couteau +4 more

This study sets out to test Born's rule to verify the fundamental postulates of quantum mechanics. This study looks for any deviation from the quantum mechanical triadditivity of three mutually exclusive events. Experimentally, a "three-path interference" that can not be explained through the Born interpretation of probabilities is investigated. An upper bound on any such possible deviation from Born's rule is determined.

Conference on Lasers and Electro-Optics Europe & European Quantum Electronics Conference (CLEO/Europe-EQEC)•Jun 1, 2009•0 citations
A null test of quantum mechanics is proposed. It is based on an arrangement in which a source sends two signals to two detectors. At each detector one of two different quantities can be measured. If the source satisfies three conditions, all of which can be verified experimentally, then, according to quantum mechanics, a particular outcome is forbidden. This result follows only from the way in which quantum mechanics constructs probabilities, and does not involve any dynamics. Looking for this outcome is a test of quantum mechanics. It is shown how this test can be realized using two-photon down-conversion.
A number of optical experiments in which quantum mechanics is tested and the laws of classical probability are violated will be described. These all make use of the phenomenon in non-linear optics known as parametric down-conversion, in which an incident pump photon effectively splits into two correlated, lower frequency signal and idler photons in an entangled quantum state. We show that two-photon coincidence measurements of signal and idler photons violate classical probability by at least 600 standard deviations. Other measurements involving two down-converters lead to the realization of a ″quantum eraser″ and suggest a reinterpretation of the usual quantum wave function.
We comment on the so-called negative result experiments (also known as null measurements, interaction-free measurements, and so on) in quantum mechanics (QM), in the light of the new general understanding of the quantum-measurement processes, proposed recently. All experiments of this kind (null measurements) can be understood as improper measurements with an intentionally biased detector set up, which introduces exclusion or selection of certain events. The prediction on the state of a microscopic system under study based on a null measurement is sometimes dramatically described as "wave-function collapse without any microsystem-detector interactions". Though certainly correct, such a prediction is just a consequence of the standard QM laws, not different from the situation in the so-called state-preparation procedure. Another closely related concept is the (first-class or) repeatable measurements. The verification of the prediction made by a null measurement requires eventually a standard unbiased measurement involving the microsystem-macroscopic detector interactions, which are nonadiabatic, irreversible processes of signal amplification.
An experiment has been carried out to test a prediction of the deBroglie guided wave theory for photons. According to this theory, there exist electromagnetic waves as well as photons, with the former acting as guide for the latter. The wave not only determines the probability for the detection of a photon, but it also has an independent physical reality which can result in photodetection, As a result the guided wave theory predicts an interference effect when two photons pass through an interferometer with a particular geometry and one measures the rate of simultaneous detections by two photodetectors in coincidence as a function of optical path difference, By contrast, quantum mechanics predicts no interference under the same conditions. The experimental results clearly violate the prediction of the guided wave theory, but are in agreement with quantum mechanics.
It has been suggested by Sorkin that a three-slit Young experiment could reveal the validity a fundamental ingredient in the foundations of one of the cornerstones in modern physics namely quantum mechanics. In terms of a certain parameter κ S , it was argued that a non-zero value could imply a breakdown of the fundamental Born's rule as well as the superposition principle. Here we argue that a physical realization of such arguments could lead to an erroneous conclusion and contradict the basic rules of quantum mechanics. In fact, we argue that a straightforward interpretation of the procedures involved in a physical determination of κ S does not necessarily lead to κ S = 0. In order to show this we consider a mono-chromatic source of photons prepared in an arbitrary quantum state and a simple version of the well-established photon detection theory of Glauber which, by construction, obeys all the rules of quantum mechanics. It is, however, also argued that after a proper identification of the relevant quantum-mechanical probability amplitudes one can be reach κ S = 0. As long as one only consider a single photon detector, it is verified that, in this context, there is no fundamental difference between quantum-mechanical interference and interference as expressed in terms of classical electro-magnetic waves.
Spontaneous parametric down-conversion produces photon pairs at a rate that grows with pump power, but the probability of producing two pairs in the same detection window grows faster. A heralded source therefore faces a direct trade between rate and purity. This study computes the quantities that follow from stated assumptions for a pulsed down-conversion source at 80 MHz repetition rate with heralding detector efficiency 0.6 and signal channel transmission 0.5, using the relations set out in the Methods. The headline results are herald rate at mu 0.02 Hz = 9.412e+05, g2 at mu 0.02 = 0.05383, g2 at mu 0.1 = 0.2314, herald rate at mu 0.1 Hz = 4.364e+06, g2 at mu 0.005 = 0.01386. The central question is stated as follows: For a stated pair-generation probability per pulse, what heralded rate, heralded second-order correlation and coincidence-to-accidental ratio follow, and where does the correlation cross a stated quality threshold? The answer obtained here is conditional on the assumptions listed in the paper and in the deposited calculation; changing an assumption changes the numbers in the way the sensitivity discussion describes. Heralded sources are commonly characterised by a conditional second-order correlation well below one half for a usable single photon, with values near 0.1 or lower at modest pump levels. The work is a computation, not a laboratory measurement, and it is labelled accordingly. Where the computed result is unfavourable to the device or effect under study, that outcome is reported in the same terms as a favourable one, because a bound that only appears when it is welcome is not a bound at all. All numerical statements in this abstract are reproduced by the deposited script from the stated inputs.