Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Annual Meeting Optical Society of America

Violations of classical probability in optics

L. Mandeļ

Published Jan 1, 1992• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

A number of optical experiments in which quantum mechanics is tested and the laws of classical probability are violated will be described. These all make use of the phenomenon in non-linear optics known as parametric down-conversion, in which an incident pump photon effectively splits into two correlated, lower frequency signal and idler photons in an entangled quantum state. We show that two-photon coincidence measurements of signal and idler photons violate classical probability by at least 600 standard deviations. Other measurements involving two down-converters lead to the realization of a ″quantum eraser″ and suggest a reinterpretation of the usual quantum wave function.

DOI
10.1364/oam.1992.muu2

Related papers

Violation of Bell's Inequality and Classical Probability in a Two-Photon Correlation Experiment

Z. Y. Ou, L. Mandeļ

Correlation measurements of mixed signal and idler photons produced in the process of parametric down-conversion have been performed as a function of two linear polarizer settings. It is found that the Bell inequality for two separated particles is violated by about 6 standard deviations, and that classical probability for light waves is violated substantially also.

Physical Review Letters•Jul 4, 1988•881 citations

Violation of classical probability in parametric down-conversion

X. Y. Zou, L.J. Wang, L. Mandeļ

A classical inequality relating to photoelectric coincidence counting with two light beams is derived. It is then demonstrated in a coincidence counting experiment with the signal and idler photons produced in the process of parametric down-conversion, that the classical inequality is violated by about 600 standard deviations.

Optics Communications•Aug 1, 1991•35 citations

Further evidence of nonclassical behavior in optical interference

Z. Y. Ou, L. Mandeļ

It is demonstrated in a photon coincidence experiment with two photodetectors, in which signal and idler photons produced by parametric down-conversion are allowed to interfere, that the visibility of the interference pattern is well above 50% and remains unchanged when one of the two light beams is attenuated ninefold compared with the other. These results violate classical probability for light waves.

Physical Review Letters•Jun 19, 1989•75 citations

Theory of parametric frequency down conversion of light

C. K. Hong, L. Mandeļ

A theoretical study is made of the process in which incident pump photons that interact with a nonlinear medium (such as a crystal lacking inversion symmetry) are spontaneously split into lower-frequency signal and idler photons. The down-converted fields are quantized and described by a continuum of modes, a subset of which interacts with each photodetector. It is shown that when two ideal photodetectors are appropriately located so that they receive the conjugate signal and idler photons, then the joint probability of two-photon detection by the two detectors can equal the single-photon detection probability. The time correlation between the two detected photons is shown to be limited either by the resolving time of the detectors, or by the bandwidth of the down-converted light, and to be independent of the coherence time of the pump field or of the length of the nonlinear medium. These conclusions are compared with the results of recent experiments.

Physical Review A•Apr 1, 1985•475 citations

Experiments with Entangled Photons

Enrique J. Galvez

This chapter describes three experiments to test and demonstrate the principles of quantum mechanics using correlated photons. These include the demonstration that the photon exists; production and measurement of entangled states of photons, including a measurement of a violation of a Bell inequality; and the interference of a single photon with itself and the quantum eraser. The experiments are presented in order of difficulty. In a birefringent medium, spontaneous parametric down-conversion occurs due to the interaction of the light and the medium. The analysis given can be generalized to show that the down-converted photons are created in planes other than the horizontal plane. All the down-converted photons of a given wavelength form a cone about the pump-beam axis, but photons in each pair follow, by conservation of momentum, correlated paths in the cone. The down-converted photons are created in a cone about the pump-beam direction. The experiment uses the horizontal slice of the down-conversion cone that contains the pump beam.

CRC Press eBooks•Mar 18, 2020•1 citation

Two-Photon Ghost Image and Interference-Diffraction

Yanhua H. Shih, Alexander V. Sergienko, T. B. Pittman +2 more

One of the most surprising consequences of quantum mechanics is entanglement of two or more distance particles. The two-particle entangled state was mathematically formulated by Schrodinger. Based on this unusual quantum behavior, EPR defined their 'physical reality' and then asked the question: 'Can Quantum-Mechanical Description of Physical Reality Be Considered Complete?' One may not appreciate EPR's criterion of physical reality and insist that 'no elementary quantum phenomenon is a phenomenon until it is a recorded phenomenon'. Optical spontaneous parametric down conversion (SPDC) is the most effective mechanism to generate an EPR type entangled two-photon state. In SPDC, an optical beam, called the pump, is incident on a birefringent crystal. The pump is intense enough so that nonlinear effects lead to the conversion of pump photons into pairs of photons, historically called signal and idler. Technically, the SPDC is said to be type-1 or type-2, depending on whether the signal and idler beams have parallel or orthogonal polarization. The SPDC conversion efficiency is typically on the order of 10(exp -9) to 10(exp -11), depending on the SPDC nonlinear material. The signal and idler intensities are extremely low, only single photon detection devices can register them. The quantum entanglement nature of SPDC has been demonstrated in EPR-Bohm experiments and Bell's inequality measurements. The following two experiments were recently performed in our laboratory, which are more closely related to the original 1935 EPR gedankenezperiment. The first experiment is a two-photon optical imaging type experiment, which has been named 'ghost image' by the physics community. The signal and idler beams of SPDC are sent in different directions, so that the detection of the signal and idler photons can be performed by two distant photon counting detectors. An aperture object (mask) is placed in front of the signal photon detector and illuminated by the signal beam through a convex lens. Surprisingly, an image of this aperture is observed in the idler beam, by scanning the idler photon detector in the transverse plane of the idler beam, if we are sure that the idler photon detector 'catches' the 'twin brother' of the signal, which can be easily performed by a coincidence measurement. This effect is even more striking when we found that the object-lens-image relationship satisfies the Gaussian thin lens equation. The second experiment demonstrates two-photon 'ghost' interference-diffraction. The experimental set up is similar to the image experiment, except that rather than a lens and an aperture it is a Young's double-slit (or a single-slit) inserted into the path of the signal beam. We could not find any interference (or diffraction) pattern behind the slit. Surprisingly, an interference (or diffraction) pattern is observed when scanning the detector in the idler beam, if we are sure that the idler photon detector 'catches' the 'twin brother' of the signal.

•Jan 1, 1996•0 citations
A number of optical experiments in which quantum mechanics is tested and the laws of classical probability are violated will be described. These all make use of the phenomenon in non-linear optics known as parametric down-conversion, in which an incident pump photon effectively splits into two correlated, lower frequency signal and idler photons in an entangled quantum state. We show that two-photon coincidence measurements of signal and idler photons violate classical probability by at least 600 standard deviations. Other measurements involving two down-converters lead to the realization of a ″quantum eraser″ and suggest a reinterpretation of the usual quantum wave function.
A theoretical study is made of the process in which incident pump photons that interact with a nonlinear medium (such as a crystal lacking inversion symmetry) are spontaneously split into lower-frequency signal and idler photons. The down-converted fields are quantized and described by a continuum of modes, a subset of which interacts with each photodetector. It is shown that when two ideal photodetectors are appropriately located so that they receive the conjugate signal and idler photons, then the joint probability of two-photon detection by the two detectors can equal the single-photon detection probability. The time correlation between the two detected photons is shown to be limited either by the resolving time of the detectors, or by the bandwidth of the down-converted light, and to be independent of the coherence time of the pump field or of the length of the nonlinear medium. These conclusions are compared with the results of recent experiments.
This chapter describes three experiments to test and demonstrate the principles of quantum mechanics using correlated photons. These include the demonstration that the photon exists; production and measurement of entangled states of photons, including a measurement of a violation of a Bell inequality; and the interference of a single photon with itself and the quantum eraser. The experiments are presented in order of difficulty. In a birefringent medium, spontaneous parametric down-conversion occurs due to the interaction of the light and the medium. The analysis given can be generalized to show that the down-converted photons are created in planes other than the horizontal plane. All the down-converted photons of a given wavelength form a cone about the pump-beam axis, but photons in each pair follow, by conservation of momentum, correlated paths in the cone. The down-converted photons are created in a cone about the pump-beam direction. The experiment uses the horizontal slice of the down-conversion cone that contains the pump beam.
One of the most surprising consequences of quantum mechanics is entanglement of two or more distance particles. The two-particle entangled state was mathematically formulated by Schrodinger. Based on this unusual quantum behavior, EPR defined their 'physical reality' and then asked the question: 'Can Quantum-Mechanical Description of Physical Reality Be Considered Complete?' One may not appreciate EPR's criterion of physical reality and insist that 'no elementary quantum phenomenon is a phenomenon until it is a recorded phenomenon'. Optical spontaneous parametric down conversion (SPDC) is the most effective mechanism to generate an EPR type entangled two-photon state. In SPDC, an optical beam, called the pump, is incident on a birefringent crystal. The pump is intense enough so that nonlinear effects lead to the conversion of pump photons into pairs of photons, historically called signal and idler. Technically, the SPDC is said to be type-1 or type-2, depending on whether the signal and idler beams have parallel or orthogonal polarization. The SPDC conversion efficiency is typically on the order of 10(exp -9) to 10(exp -11), depending on the SPDC nonlinear material. The signal and idler intensities are extremely low, only single photon detection devices can register them. The quantum entanglement nature of SPDC has been demonstrated in EPR-Bohm experiments and Bell's inequality measurements. The following two experiments were recently performed in our laboratory, which are more closely related to the original 1935 EPR gedankenezperiment. The first experiment is a two-photon optical imaging type experiment, which has been named 'ghost image' by the physics community. The signal and idler beams of SPDC are sent in different directions, so that the detection of the signal and idler photons can be performed by two distant photon counting detectors. An aperture object (mask) is placed in front of the signal photon detector and illuminated by the signal beam through a convex lens. Surprisingly, an image of this aperture is observed in the idler beam, by scanning the idler photon detector in the transverse plane of the idler beam, if we are sure that the idler photon detector 'catches' the 'twin brother' of the signal, which can be easily performed by a coincidence measurement. This effect is even more striking when we found that the object-lens-image relationship satisfies the Gaussian thin lens equation. The second experiment demonstrates two-photon 'ghost' interference-diffraction. The experimental set up is similar to the image experiment, except that rather than a lens and an aperture it is a Young's double-slit (or a single-slit) inserted into the path of the signal beam. We could not find any interference (or diffraction) pattern behind the slit. Surprisingly, an interference (or diffraction) pattern is observed when scanning the detector in the idler beam, if we are sure that the idler photon detector 'catches' the 'twin brother' of the signal.