Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Nature

Towards an exact description of electronic wavefunctions in real solids

George H. Booth, Andreas Grüneis, Georg Kresse, Ali Alavi

Published Dec 18, 2012• 564 citations
Publisher
DOI
10.1038/nature11770

Related papers

Wavefunction-based electronic-structure calculations for solids

Peter Fulde

arXiv:1509.08712•Nature Physics•Feb 1, 2016•11 citations

Role of the action function in defining electronic wavefunctions for large systems

Peter Fulde

The dimension of the Hilbert space needed for the description of an interacting electron system increases exponentially with electron number N. As pointed out by Kohn this exponential wall problem (EWP) limits the concept of many-electron wavefunctions based on solutions of Schrödinger’s equation to [Formula: see text], where [Formula: see text] [Rev. Mod. Phys. 71, 1253 (1999)]. This limitation does not hold when the electronic interactions are neglected or treated in a mean-field approximation. The EWP has directed electronic structure calculations for solids to methods like density-functional theory which avoid dealing with many-electron wavefunctions. We show that the highly unsatisfactory limitation of many-electron wavefunctions to [Formula: see text] can be overcome by generalizing their definition. We show for the ground state of a large system that it is the logarithm of the solution of Schrödinger’s equation which should be used to characterize this system. In this case the wavefunctions of independent subsystems add up rather than multiply. This feature is realized by the action function. It provides a simple physical picture for the resolution of the EWP.

arXiv:2312.06523•International Journal of Modern Physics B•Aug 23, 2024•0 citations

Wavefunction methods in electronic-structure theory of solids

Peter Fulde

The electronic-structure theory of solids is presently dominated by density-functional methods which avoid calculations of the many-body wavefunction, and instead compute directly properties of the ground state. We argue that methods which determine the many-electron wavefunctions should receive particular attention in the future. A survey is given of our present knowledge of how to calculate these wavefunctions for a solid. The accuracy we envisage compares with the one obtainable for small molecules when applying quantum-chemical methods.

Advances In Physics•May 1, 2002•49 citations

On the computation of electronic excitations in solids

Peter Fulde, Wolf-Dieter Lukas

The European Physical Journal B•Jun 1, 1982•12 citations

Two-particle approach to the electronic structure of solids

Antonios Gonis

Journal of Electron Spectroscopy and Related Phenomena•Feb 14, 2007•1 citation

Spin-adapted neural network wavefunctions in real space

Ruichen Li, Yuzhi Liu A, Jiang Du +7 more

Spin plays a fundamental role in understanding electronic structure, yet many real-space wavefunction methods fail to adequately consider it. We introduce the spin-adapted antisymmetrization method, a general procedure that enforces exact total spin symmetry for antisymmetric many-electron wavefunctions in real space. In the context of neural network-based quantum Monte Carlo, our method leverages the expressiveness of deep neural networks to capture electron correlation while enforcing exact spin adaptation via group representation theory. This framework provides a principled route to embed physical priors into otherwise black-box neural network wavefunctions, yielding a compact representation of correlated systems with neural network orbitals. To demonstrate its effectiveness, we study the spin ladder of iron-sulfur clusters, a long-standing challenge for many-body methods due to their dense spectrum of nearly degenerate spin states. Our results reveal accurate resolution of low-lying spin states and spin gaps in [Fe2S2] and [Fe4S4] clusters, offering insights into their electronic structures. In sum, these findings establish our framework as a practical route toward spin-adapted neural network-based quantum Monte Carlo for strongly correlated systems. The authors introduce a general framework that embeds exact spin symmetry directly into the neural network wavefunction, guaranteeing spin-pure states by construction. This design enables accurate resolution of near-degenerate spin states in challenging chemical systems.

arXiv:2511.01671•Nature Communications•Oct 24, 2026•8 citations
The dimension of the Hilbert space needed for the description of an interacting electron system increases exponentially with electron number N. As pointed out by Kohn this exponential wall problem (EWP) limits the concept of many-electron wavefunctions based on solutions of Schrödinger’s equation to [Formula: see text], where [Formula: see text] [Rev. Mod. Phys. 71, 1253 (1999)]. This limitation does not hold when the electronic interactions are neglected or treated in a mean-field approximation. The EWP has directed electronic structure calculations for solids to methods like density-functional theory which avoid dealing with many-electron wavefunctions. We show that the highly unsatisfactory limitation of many-electron wavefunctions to [Formula: see text] can be overcome by generalizing their definition. We show for the ground state of a large system that it is the logarithm of the solution of Schrödinger’s equation which should be used to characterize this system. In this case the wavefunctions of independent subsystems add up rather than multiply. This feature is realized by the action function. It provides a simple physical picture for the resolution of the EWP.
The electronic-structure theory of solids is presently dominated by density-functional methods which avoid calculations of the many-body wavefunction, and instead compute directly properties of the ground state. We argue that methods which determine the many-electron wavefunctions should receive particular attention in the future. A survey is given of our present knowledge of how to calculate these wavefunctions for a solid. The accuracy we envisage compares with the one obtainable for small molecules when applying quantum-chemical methods.
Spin plays a fundamental role in understanding electronic structure, yet many real-space wavefunction methods fail to adequately consider it. We introduce the spin-adapted antisymmetrization method, a general procedure that enforces exact total spin symmetry for antisymmetric many-electron wavefunctions in real space. In the context of neural network-based quantum Monte Carlo, our method leverages the expressiveness of deep neural networks to capture electron correlation while enforcing exact spin adaptation via group representation theory. This framework provides a principled route to embed physical priors into otherwise black-box neural network wavefunctions, yielding a compact representation of correlated systems with neural network orbitals. To demonstrate its effectiveness, we study the spin ladder of iron-sulfur clusters, a long-standing challenge for many-body methods due to their dense spectrum of nearly degenerate spin states. Our results reveal accurate resolution of low-lying spin states and spin gaps in [Fe2S2] and [Fe4S4] clusters, offering insights into their electronic structures. In sum, these findings establish our framework as a practical route toward spin-adapted neural network-based quantum Monte Carlo for strongly correlated systems. The authors introduce a general framework that embeds exact spin symmetry directly into the neural network wavefunction, guaranteeing spin-pure states by construction. This design enables accurate resolution of near-degenerate spin states in challenging chemical systems.