Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2312.06523 · International Journal of Modern Physics B

Role of the action function in defining electronic wavefunctions for large systems

Peter Fulde

Published Aug 23, 2024• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

The dimension of the Hilbert space needed for the description of an interacting electron system increases exponentially with electron number N. As pointed out by Kohn this exponential wall problem (EWP) limits the concept of many-electron wavefunctions based on solutions of Schrödinger’s equation to [Formula: see text], where [Formula: see text] [Rev. Mod. Phys. 71, 1253 (1999)]. This limitation does not hold when the electronic interactions are neglected or treated in a mean-field approximation. The EWP has directed electronic structure calculations for solids to methods like density-functional theory which avoid dealing with many-electron wavefunctions. We show that the highly unsatisfactory limitation of many-electron wavefunctions to [Formula: see text] can be overcome by generalizing their definition. We show for the ground state of a large system that it is the logarithm of the solution of Schrödinger’s equation which should be used to characterize this system. In this case the wavefunctions of independent subsystems add up rather than multiply. This feature is realized by the action function. It provides a simple physical picture for the resolution of the EWP.

DOI
10.1142/s0217979225500997

Related papers

Ground state of many-electron systems based on the action function

Peter Fulde

The Hilbert space for an interacting electron system increases exponentially with electron number $N$. This limits the concept of wavefunctions $ψ$ based on solutions of the Schrödinger equation to $N \leq N_0$ with $N_0 \simeq 10^3$ \cite{Kohn1999}. It is argued that this exponential wall problem (EWP) is connected with an increasing redundance of information contained, e.g., in the ground-state of the system and it's wavefunction. The EWP as well as redundance of information are avoided when the characterization of the ground state is based on the action function $R$ rather than on the solutions $ψ$ of the Schödinger equation. Both are related through a logarithm, i.e., $R = -i \hbar \ ln ψ$. Working with the logarithm is made possible by the use of cumulants. It is pointed out the way electronic structure calculations for periodic solids may use this concept.

arXiv:2005.03072•May 5, 2020•0 citations

Wavefunctions of macroscopic electron systems

Peter Fulde

Wavefunctions for large electron numbers N are plagued by the Exponential Wall Problem (EWP), i.e., an exponential increase in the dimensions of Hilbert space with N. Therefore, they lose their meaning for macroscopic systems, a point stressed, in particular, by Kohn. The EWP has to be resolved in order to provide a solid basis for wavefunction based electronic structure calculations of macroscopic systems, e.g., solids. The origin of the EWP is the multiplicative property of wavefunctions when independent subsystems are considered. Therefore, it can only be avoided when wavefunctions are formulated so that they are additive instead, in particular, when matrix elements involving them are calculated. We describe how this is done for the ground state of a macroscopic electron system. Going over from a multiplicative to an additive quantity requires taking a logarithm. Here it implies going over from Hilbert space to the operator- or Liouville space with a metric based on cumulants. The operators which define the ground-state wavefunction generate fluctuations from a mean-field state. The latter does not suffer from an EWP and therefore may serve as a vacuum state. The fluctuations have to be connected like the ones caused by pair interactions in a classical gas when the free energy is calculated (Meyer's cluster expansion). This fixes the metric in Liouville space. The scheme presented here provides a solid basis for electronic structure calculations for the ground state of solids. In fact, its applicability has already been proven. We discuss also matrix product states, which have been applied to one-dimensional systems with results of high precision. Although these states are formulated in Hilbert space, they are processed by using operators in Liouville space. We show that they fit into the general formalism described above.

arXiv:1803.06834•The Journal of Chemical Physics•Jan 15, 2019•5 citations

Wavefunctions for extended electron Systems

Peter Fulde

Wavefunctions for large interacting electron systems lose their meaning due to an exponential growth of the dimensions of Hilbert space with increasing electron number. In order to base electronic-structure calculations for solids on wavefunctions instead on density functional theory one has to resolve this exponential wall problem (EWP). It is shown that the origin of it is the multiplicative character of a wavefunction with respect to independent systems A and B, i.e., ψA/B = ψA ⨂ ψB. The EWP is avoided, if we characterize the system by an additive quantity like an action instead. This can be done by describing the system through the fluctuations of a mean-field state imposed by the interactions. The operators defining these fluctuations span an operator- or Liouville space. In order to obtain additive quantities the metric in Liouville space must be a special one, i.e., based on cumulants. The situation resembles the one of a classical gas, where the interaction contributions to the energy are included by a linked cluster expansion. In this way the EWP is avoided and one obtains a solid basis for wavefunction-based electronic-structure calculations of large systems. Examples are given for the application of the theory.

AAPPS bulletin•Jan 17, 2019•1 citation

Elements of Green Function and Density Functional Theory

F. Aryasetiawan

If there were no Coulomb interaction among electrons, it would be relatively straightforward to solve the many-electron Schrödinger equation. It is, however, precisely this interaction that is at the heart of numerous fascinating phenomena in condensed matter physics such as superconductivity, Kondo physics, magnetism, etc. Due to the large number of electrons in a material being of the order of Avogadro's number, it is at present — and perhaps in the foreseeable future — not feasible or even desirable to solve the Schrödinger equation to obtain the many-electron wavefunction. Fortunately, a large number of important physical properties can be calculated without explicit knowledge of the wavefunction. Two of the most important formalisms for dealing with the many-electron problem which avoid a direct use of the many-electron wavefunction are the Green function and the density functional theory. Within the Kohn-Sham scheme the latter is used to calculate ground-state properties whereas the former for excitation spectra. The book presents the fundamentals of these two theories in detail with essential many-body tools, such as the occupation number representation and Grassmann algebra developed from scratch. Prior knowledge of many-body theory is not a prerequisite so that it is readable for final-year undergraduates and graduate students in physics and chemistry as well as researchers in the field of electronic structure and many-body theory. The book includes in the last chapter an exposition of a density-functional path for determining the Green function, a new formalism recently proposed by the author. The book should be a valuable companion for those embarking in the field of many-electron physics.

WORLD SCIENTIFIC eBooks•Oct 17, 2024•0 citations

Density functional theory

Philip L. Taylor, Olle Heinonen

The Hohenberg–Kohn theorem In Chapter 2 we explored some of the consequences of electron–electron interactions, albeit in some simple perturbative approaches and within the random phase approximation. There we found that the problem of treating these interactions is exceedingly difficult, even in the case where there is no external one–particle potential applied to the system. We have also explored some of the properties of noninteracting electrons in an external potential, in this case the periodic lattice potential. This led to the concepts of electron bands and band structure, subjects of fundamental importance in understanding the physics of metals, insulators, and semiconductors. Of course, in the real world, electrons in matter are subjected both to electron–electron interactions and to external potentials. How to include systematically and correctly the electron–electron interactions in calculations of real systems is truly a formidable problem. Why that is so is easily demonstrated. Suppose that we want to solve the problem of N electrons interacting in some external potential. The N -electron wavefunction can be expanded in Slater determinants of some suitable single-particle basis such as plane waves. We can describe the Slater determinants by occupation numbers in our second–quantized notation. Suppose furthermore that we have a basis of a total of N k plane wave states at our disposal. Here N k must be large enough that all reasonable “wiggles” of the many-body wavefunction can be included.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Feb 28, 2002•4 citations

Quantum Chemistry

Kolla Bhanu Prakash

The simulation of quantum chemical systems is widely regarded as the "killer app" for quantum computing.While classical computers have made tremendous strides in computational chemistry-earning the 1998 Nobel Prize for Density Functional Theory (DFT)-they face a fundamental wall: the "Exponential Catastrophe." The Hilbert space of a quantum many-body system scales exponentially with the number of particles.For a system of orbitals, the dimension is 1.To store the wavefunction of a molecule with just 50 electrons exactly would require more classical bits than there are atoms in the Milky Way [121].Quantum computers bypass this limit by mapping the quantum system of electrons directly onto the quantum system of qubits.This chapter provides a definitive guide to this field, moving from the foundational Schrödinger equation to the cutting-edge of Variational Quantum Eigensolvers (VQE) and beyond [191]. Theoretical Foundations of Electronic StructureTo program a quantum computer for chemistry, one must first understand the physics we are trying to simulate.The central problem is finding the stationary states of the Schrödinger equation [122]. The Many-Body HamiltonianThe non-relativistic, time-independent Schrödinger equation is given by:Here, Ĥ is the Hamiltonian operator representing the total energy of the molecular system.

Wiley eBooks•Aug 17, 2026•0 citations
The dimension of the Hilbert space needed for the description of an interacting electron system increases exponentially with electron number N. As pointed out by Kohn this exponential wall problem (EWP) limits the concept of many-electron wavefunctions based on solutions of Schrödinger’s equation to [Formula: see text], where [Formula: see text] [Rev. Mod. Phys. 71, 1253 (1999)]. This limitation does not hold when the electronic interactions are neglected or treated in a mean-field approximation. The EWP has directed electronic structure calculations for solids to methods like density-functional theory which avoid dealing with many-electron wavefunctions. We show that the highly unsatisfactory limitation of many-electron wavefunctions to [Formula: see text] can be overcome by generalizing their definition. We show for the ground state of a large system that it is the logarithm of the solution of Schrödinger’s equation which should be used to characterize this system. In this case the wavefunctions of independent subsystems add up rather than multiply. This feature is realized by the action function. It provides a simple physical picture for the resolution of the EWP.
The Hilbert space for an interacting electron system increases exponentially with electron number NNN. This limits the concept of wavefunctions ψψψ based on solutions of the Schrödinger equation to N≤N0N \leq N_0N≤N0​ with N0≃103N_0 \simeq 10^3N0​≃103 \cite{Kohn1999}. It is argued that this exponential wall problem (EWP) is connected with an increasing redundance of information contained, e.g., in the ground-state of the system and it's wavefunction. The EWP as well as redundance of information are avoided when the characterization of the ground state is based on the action function RRR rather than on the solutions ψψψ of the Schödinger equation. Both are related through a logarithm, i.e., R=−iℏ lnψR = -i \hbar \ ln ψR=−iℏ lnψ. Working with the logarithm is made possible by the use of cumulants. It is pointed out the way electronic structure calculations for periodic solids may use this concept.
Wavefunctions for large electron numbers N are plagued by the Exponential Wall Problem (EWP), i.e., an exponential increase in the dimensions of Hilbert space with N. Therefore, they lose their meaning for macroscopic systems, a point stressed, in particular, by Kohn. The EWP has to be resolved in order to provide a solid basis for wavefunction based electronic structure calculations of macroscopic systems, e.g., solids. The origin of the EWP is the multiplicative property of wavefunctions when independent subsystems are considered. Therefore, it can only be avoided when wavefunctions are formulated so that they are additive instead, in particular, when matrix elements involving them are calculated. We describe how this is done for the ground state of a macroscopic electron system. Going over from a multiplicative to an additive quantity requires taking a logarithm. Here it implies going over from Hilbert space to the operator- or Liouville space with a metric based on cumulants. The operators which define the ground-state wavefunction generate fluctuations from a mean-field state. The latter does not suffer from an EWP and therefore may serve as a vacuum state. The fluctuations have to be connected like the ones caused by pair interactions in a classical gas when the free energy is calculated (Meyer's cluster expansion). This fixes the metric in Liouville space. The scheme presented here provides a solid basis for electronic structure calculations for the ground state of solids. In fact, its applicability has already been proven. We discuss also matrix product states, which have been applied to one-dimensional systems with results of high precision. Although these states are formulated in Hilbert space, they are processed by using operators in Liouville space. We show that they fit into the general formalism described above.
Wavefunctions for large interacting electron systems lose their meaning due to an exponential growth of the dimensions of Hilbert space with increasing electron number. In order to base electronic-structure calculations for solids on wavefunctions instead on density functional theory one has to resolve this exponential wall problem (EWP). It is shown that the origin of it is the multiplicative character of a wavefunction with respect to independent systems A and B, i.e., ψA/B = ψA ⨂ ψB. The EWP is avoided, if we characterize the system by an additive quantity like an action instead. This can be done by describing the system through the fluctuations of a mean-field state imposed by the interactions. The operators defining these fluctuations span an operator- or Liouville space. In order to obtain additive quantities the metric in Liouville space must be a special one, i.e., based on cumulants. The situation resembles the one of a classical gas, where the interaction contributions to the energy are included by a linked cluster expansion. In this way the EWP is avoided and one obtains a solid basis for wavefunction-based electronic-structure calculations of large systems. Examples are given for the application of the theory.
If there were no Coulomb interaction among electrons, it would be relatively straightforward to solve the many-electron Schrödinger equation. It is, however, precisely this interaction that is at the heart of numerous fascinating phenomena in condensed matter physics such as superconductivity, Kondo physics, magnetism, etc. Due to the large number of electrons in a material being of the order of Avogadro's number, it is at present — and perhaps in the foreseeable future — not feasible or even desirable to solve the Schrödinger equation to obtain the many-electron wavefunction. Fortunately, a large number of important physical properties can be calculated without explicit knowledge of the wavefunction. Two of the most important formalisms for dealing with the many-electron problem which avoid a direct use of the many-electron wavefunction are the Green function and the density functional theory. Within the Kohn-Sham scheme the latter is used to calculate ground-state properties whereas the former for excitation spectra. The book presents the fundamentals of these two theories in detail with essential many-body tools, such as the occupation number representation and Grassmann algebra developed from scratch. Prior knowledge of many-body theory is not a prerequisite so that it is readable for final-year undergraduates and graduate students in physics and chemistry as well as researchers in the field of electronic structure and many-body theory. The book includes in the last chapter an exposition of a density-functional path for determining the Green function, a new formalism recently proposed by the author. The book should be a valuable companion for those embarking in the field of many-electron physics.
The Hohenberg–Kohn theorem In Chapter 2 we explored some of the consequences of electron–electron interactions, albeit in some simple perturbative approaches and within the random phase approximation. There we found that the problem of treating these interactions is exceedingly difficult, even in the case where there is no external one–particle potential applied to the system. We have also explored some of the properties of noninteracting electrons in an external potential, in this case the periodic lattice potential. This led to the concepts of electron bands and band structure, subjects of fundamental importance in understanding the physics of metals, insulators, and semiconductors. Of course, in the real world, electrons in matter are subjected both to electron–electron interactions and to external potentials. How to include systematically and correctly the electron–electron interactions in calculations of real systems is truly a formidable problem. Why that is so is easily demonstrated. Suppose that we want to solve the problem of N electrons interacting in some external potential. The N -electron wavefunction can be expanded in Slater determinants of some suitable single-particle basis such as plane waves. We can describe the Slater determinants by occupation numbers in our second–quantized notation. Suppose furthermore that we have a basis of a total of N k plane wave states at our disposal. Here N k must be large enough that all reasonable “wiggles” of the many-body wavefunction can be included.
The simulation of quantum chemical systems is widely regarded as the "killer app" for quantum computing.While classical computers have made tremendous strides in computational chemistry-earning the 1998 Nobel Prize for Density Functional Theory (DFT)-they face a fundamental wall: the "Exponential Catastrophe." The Hilbert space of a quantum many-body system scales exponentially with the number of particles.For a system of orbitals, the dimension is 1.To store the wavefunction of a molecule with just 50 electrons exactly would require more classical bits than there are atoms in the Milky Way [121].Quantum computers bypass this limit by mapping the quantum system of electrons directly onto the quantum system of qubits.This chapter provides a definitive guide to this field, moving from the foundational Schrödinger equation to the cutting-edge of Variational Quantum Eigensolvers (VQE) and beyond [191]. Theoretical Foundations of Electronic StructureTo program a quantum computer for chemistry, one must first understand the physics we are trying to simulate.The central problem is finding the stationary states of the Schrödinger equation [122]. The Many-Body HamiltonianThe non-relativistic, time-independent Schrödinger equation is given by:Here, Ĥ is the Hamiltonian operator representing the total energy of the molecular system.