Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Physical Review A

Instability of tunneling and the concept of molecular structure in quantum mechanics: The case of pyramidal molecules and the enantiomer problem

P. Claverie, Giovanni Jona-Lasinio

Published Apr 1, 1986• 90 citations
Publisher

Abstract

In this paper we propose a possible explanation of the fact that certain molecules exhibiting symmetric configurations are localized in one of them, instead of being delocalized as predicted by a naive application of quantum mechanics. Our mechanism is based upon the instability, in the semiclassical regime, of delocalized states under small perturbations (among which we consider the reaction field due to the environment). This mechanism predicts, for example, a different behavior for ${\mathrm{NH}}_{3}$ and ${\mathrm{AsH}}_{3}$ (delocalized ground state in the former case, localized ground state in the latter case), and similar to the case of ${\mathrm{AsH}}_{3}$ we expect localized states in the case of optical isomers, in agreement with the empirical evidence. Possible consequences concerning the understanding of the ``classical limit'' in general are briefly outlined.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.33.2245

Related papers

Environment induced localization and superselection rules in a gas of pyramidal molecules

Giovanni Jona-Lasinio, Carlo Presilla A, Cristina Toninelli

We propose a model to describe a gas of pyramidal molecules interacting via dipole-dipole interactions.A cooperative effect induced by the interaction modifies the tunneling properties between the classical equilibrium configurations of the single molecule.The model suggests that, for sufficiently high gas density, the molecules become localized in these classical configurations.On this basis it is possible to explain the shift and the disappearance of the inversion line observed upon increase of the pressure in a gas of ammonia or deuterated ammonia.The same mechanism also accounts for the presence of stable optical activity of certain pyramidal molecules.We discuss the concept of environment induced superselection rule which has been invoked in connection with this problem.

American Mathematical Society eBooks•Nov 27, 2001•3 citations

Environment induced localization and superselection rules in a gas of pyramidal molecules

Giovanni Jona-Lasinio, Carlo Presilla A, Cristina Toninelli

We propose a model to describe a gas of pyramidal molecules interacting via dipole-dipole interactions. A cooperative effect induced by the interaction modifies the tunneling properties between the classical equilibrium configurations of the single molecule. The model suggests that, for sufficiently high gas density, the molecules become localized in these classical configurations. On this basis it is possible to explain the shift and the disappearance of the inversion line observed upon increase of the pressure in a gas of ammonia or deuterated ammonia. The same mechanism also accounts for the presence of stable optical activity of certain pyramidal molecules. We discuss the concept of environment induced superselection rule which has been invoked in connection with this problem.

arXiv:cond-mat/0107341•Jul 16, 2001•0 citations

Hydrogen Spectrum for the Proton Hopping Randomly Between Two Sites

José Angel Lesteiro Tejeda

The hydrogen spectrum is explored as a sensitive probe of a massive object being in a superposition of two distinct locations. Here I solve the simpler but instructive semiclassical problem of the proton hopping stochastically between two sites but forbidden to be anywhere else, analogous to the superposition over two locations. Although the model is semiclassical, it captures symmetry properties and the structure of the energy spectrum that one would expect in a fully quantum treatment. The hydrogen atom is a well-understood system whose spectroscopy reaches exceptional precision, and its semiclassical description displays symmetry with respect to two fixed locations. I develop a classical model for an electron and a proton, with the proton stochastically hopping between two fixed sites; and describe its classical dynamics mathematically via a one-particle effective Hamiltonian. For this Hamiltonian I identify a set of invariance properties that are characteristic of heteronuclear diatomic molecules and are not as extensive as the SO(4) symmetries present in the traditional models of the hydrogen atom. I connect the classical description of the proton-hopping model with the two-fixed-centre problem with time-dependent charges. I find that there is a lower limit to the hopping distance of the proton below which state-of-the-art measurements cannot resolve the spectral signature predicted; and also an upper limit above which approximation methods are not applicable. I gain meaningful insight into the mechanisms that shape the quantum dynamics of proton tunnelling in hydrogen by analyzing the classical counterpart, leveraging the shared symmetries between quantum and classical analogous systems. My results predict an observable spectral shift in the ground-state energy when the proton is delocalized over two sites separated by a distance large enough to be considered macroscopically distinct. With this research, I support the idea that proton tunnelling inside the hydrogen atom is worth exploring as a probe for a delocalized massive object.

•Dec 16, 2025•0 citations

The Concept of Molecular Structure in Quantum Theory: Interpretation Problems

P. Claverie, Simon Diner

Abstract The classical concept of molecular structure (namely, a set of atoms with a well‐defined geometrical arrangement in space) originated well before the advent of quantum theory, and, contrary to widespread views, these two conceptual schemes (classical molecular structure and quantum theory) are not easy to reconcile. We begin with a preliminary discussion of molecular structure in terms of space and time correlations in the framework of quantum theory. Then we summarize the salient features of some critical views raised‐during recent years (essentially by Woolley) concerning the concept of molecular structure. The essential claim of this viewpoint is that “molecular structure” is not an intrinsic attribute of an isolated molecule, and appears rather as an effect of the environment (other molecules? vacuum electromagnetic field, according to quantum electrodynamics?). Afterwards, we discuss these issues in detail: we show that it is necessary to distinguish between a “quantum” or “potential” structure (which may be deduced in a straightforward way from the quantum treatment of the molecule), and the “classical” molecular structure (according to which the molecule is considered as a set of rotating and vibrating material points, corresponding to the atoms); we briefly discuss some aspects of the Born–Oppenheimer approximation. From our discussion, we deduce that the “classical structure” concept is indeed non‐trivial from a purely quantum‐mechanical point of view; in actual fact, it is related to the problem of the “classical limit” of quantum mechanics, and it appears that, at the present time, none of these classical concepts and behaviours is convincingly derivable from a strict quantum mechanical basis. Finally, we consider these same problems from the point of view of stochastic electrodynamics (SED), which is one of the stochastic models for microphysics proposed so far as a possible alternative or extension of usual quantum theory. In the framework of such a theory, the “classical limit” and, in particular, the “classical molecular structure” no longer poses a problem, but aside from these satisfactory qualitative aspects, several quantitative failures of SED prevent us from accepting it, at least in its present state, as a genuine physical alternative to quantum theory. We therefore conclude that “classical molecular structure”, and classical concepts in general, remain an open problem in the framework of present‐day quantum physics.

Israel Journal of Chemistry•Jan 1, 1980•88 citations

Particle-localized ground state of atom-molecule Bose-Einstein condensates in a double-well potential

篤 本橋, Tetsuro Nikuni

We study the effect of atom-molecule internal tunneling on the ground state of atom-molecule Bose-Einstein condensates in a double-well potential. In the absence of internal tunneling between atomic and molecular states, the ground state is symmetric, which has equal-particle populations in two wells. From the linear stability analysis, we show that the symmetric stationary state becomes dynamically unstable at a certain value of the atom-molecule internal tunneling strength. Above the critical value of the internal tunneling strength, the ground state bifurcates to the particle-localized ground states. The origin of this transition can be attributed to the effective attractive interatomic interaction induced by the atom-molecule internal tunneling. This effective interaction is similar to that familiar in the context of BCS-BEC crossover in a Fermi gas with Feshbach resonance. Furthermore, we point out the possibility of reentrant transition in the case of the large detuning between the atomic and molecular states.

arXiv:1006.2954•Physical Review A•Sep 30, 2010•6 citations

Weak Interactions ,Tunneling Racemization and Chiral Stability

M. Cattani, José Maria Filardo Bassalo

We study in the framework of the Schrodinger equation the effect of intermolecular interactions on the tunneling racemization of the active molecule. The active molecule is assumed as a two-level system and the left-right isomerism is viewed in terms of a double-bottomed harmonic potential well. The active molecule is assumed to be embedded in a gas, liquid or solid, submitted to a perturbing potential U created by the molecules of the sample. In our model we take into account the difference of energy E due to the weak interactions between the left (L) and right (R) configurations. We have shown that when E is equal to zero the system cannot be optically stable: the optical activity tends asymptotically to zero in the case of dilute gases or compressed gases and liquids or oscillates periodically around zero when the molecules are isolated or submitted to a static potential. Only when E is different of zero the system can be optically stable depending on the strength parameters of the potential U and on the magnitude of the spontaneous tunneling.

arXiv:0910.4133•Oct 21, 2009•0 citations
In this paper we propose a possible explanation of the fact that certain molecules exhibiting symmetric configurations are localized in one of them, instead of being delocalized as predicted by a naive application of quantum mechanics. Our mechanism is based upon the instability, in the semiclassical regime, of delocalized states under small perturbations (among which we consider the reaction field due to the environment). This mechanism predicts, for example, a different behavior for NH3{\mathrm{NH}}_{3}NH3​ and AsH3{\mathrm{AsH}}_{3}AsH3​ (delocalized ground state in the former case, localized ground state in the latter case), and similar to the case of AsH3{\mathrm{AsH}}_{3}AsH3​ we expect localized states in the case of optical isomers, in agreement with the empirical evidence. Possible consequences concerning the understanding of the ``classical limit'' in general are briefly outlined.
We propose a model to describe a gas of pyramidal molecules interacting via dipole-dipole interactions.A cooperative effect induced by the interaction modifies the tunneling properties between the classical equilibrium configurations of the single molecule.The model suggests that, for sufficiently high gas density, the molecules become localized in these classical configurations.On this basis it is possible to explain the shift and the disappearance of the inversion line observed upon increase of the pressure in a gas of ammonia or deuterated ammonia.The same mechanism also accounts for the presence of stable optical activity of certain pyramidal molecules.We discuss the concept of environment induced superselection rule which has been invoked in connection with this problem.
We propose a model to describe a gas of pyramidal molecules interacting via dipole-dipole interactions. A cooperative effect induced by the interaction modifies the tunneling properties between the classical equilibrium configurations of the single molecule. The model suggests that, for sufficiently high gas density, the molecules become localized in these classical configurations. On this basis it is possible to explain the shift and the disappearance of the inversion line observed upon increase of the pressure in a gas of ammonia or deuterated ammonia. The same mechanism also accounts for the presence of stable optical activity of certain pyramidal molecules. We discuss the concept of environment induced superselection rule which has been invoked in connection with this problem.
The hydrogen spectrum is explored as a sensitive probe of a massive object being in a superposition of two distinct locations. Here I solve the simpler but instructive semiclassical problem of the proton hopping stochastically between two sites but forbidden to be anywhere else, analogous to the superposition over two locations. Although the model is semiclassical, it captures symmetry properties and the structure of the energy spectrum that one would expect in a fully quantum treatment. The hydrogen atom is a well-understood system whose spectroscopy reaches exceptional precision, and its semiclassical description displays symmetry with respect to two fixed locations. I develop a classical model for an electron and a proton, with the proton stochastically hopping between two fixed sites; and describe its classical dynamics mathematically via a one-particle effective Hamiltonian. For this Hamiltonian I identify a set of invariance properties that are characteristic of heteronuclear diatomic molecules and are not as extensive as the SO(4) symmetries present in the traditional models of the hydrogen atom. I connect the classical description of the proton-hopping model with the two-fixed-centre problem with time-dependent charges. I find that there is a lower limit to the hopping distance of the proton below which state-of-the-art measurements cannot resolve the spectral signature predicted; and also an upper limit above which approximation methods are not applicable. I gain meaningful insight into the mechanisms that shape the quantum dynamics of proton tunnelling in hydrogen by analyzing the classical counterpart, leveraging the shared symmetries between quantum and classical analogous systems. My results predict an observable spectral shift in the ground-state energy when the proton is delocalized over two sites separated by a distance large enough to be considered macroscopically distinct. With this research, I support the idea that proton tunnelling inside the hydrogen atom is worth exploring as a probe for a delocalized massive object.
Abstract The classical concept of molecular structure (namely, a set of atoms with a well‐defined geometrical arrangement in space) originated well before the advent of quantum theory, and, contrary to widespread views, these two conceptual schemes (classical molecular structure and quantum theory) are not easy to reconcile. We begin with a preliminary discussion of molecular structure in terms of space and time correlations in the framework of quantum theory. Then we summarize the salient features of some critical views raised‐during recent years (essentially by Woolley) concerning the concept of molecular structure. The essential claim of this viewpoint is that “molecular structure” is not an intrinsic attribute of an isolated molecule, and appears rather as an effect of the environment (other molecules? vacuum electromagnetic field, according to quantum electrodynamics?). Afterwards, we discuss these issues in detail: we show that it is necessary to distinguish between a “quantum” or “potential” structure (which may be deduced in a straightforward way from the quantum treatment of the molecule), and the “classical” molecular structure (according to which the molecule is considered as a set of rotating and vibrating material points, corresponding to the atoms); we briefly discuss some aspects of the Born–Oppenheimer approximation. From our discussion, we deduce that the “classical structure” concept is indeed non‐trivial from a purely quantum‐mechanical point of view; in actual fact, it is related to the problem of the “classical limit” of quantum mechanics, and it appears that, at the present time, none of these classical concepts and behaviours is convincingly derivable from a strict quantum mechanical basis. Finally, we consider these same problems from the point of view of stochastic electrodynamics (SED), which is one of the stochastic models for microphysics proposed so far as a possible alternative or extension of usual quantum theory. In the framework of such a theory, the “classical limit” and, in particular, the “classical molecular structure” no longer poses a problem, but aside from these satisfactory qualitative aspects, several quantitative failures of SED prevent us from accepting it, at least in its present state, as a genuine physical alternative to quantum theory. We therefore conclude that “classical molecular structure”, and classical concepts in general, remain an open problem in the framework of present‐day quantum physics.
We study the effect of atom-molecule internal tunneling on the ground state of atom-molecule Bose-Einstein condensates in a double-well potential. In the absence of internal tunneling between atomic and molecular states, the ground state is symmetric, which has equal-particle populations in two wells. From the linear stability analysis, we show that the symmetric stationary state becomes dynamically unstable at a certain value of the atom-molecule internal tunneling strength. Above the critical value of the internal tunneling strength, the ground state bifurcates to the particle-localized ground states. The origin of this transition can be attributed to the effective attractive interatomic interaction induced by the atom-molecule internal tunneling. This effective interaction is similar to that familiar in the context of BCS-BEC crossover in a Fermi gas with Feshbach resonance. Furthermore, we point out the possibility of reentrant transition in the case of the large detuning between the atomic and molecular states.
We study in the framework of the Schrodinger equation the effect of intermolecular interactions on the tunneling racemization of the active molecule. The active molecule is assumed as a two-level system and the left-right isomerism is viewed in terms of a double-bottomed harmonic potential well. The active molecule is assumed to be embedded in a gas, liquid or solid, submitted to a perturbing potential U created by the molecules of the sample. In our model we take into account the difference of energy E due to the weak interactions between the left (L) and right (R) configurations. We have shown that when E is equal to zero the system cannot be optically stable: the optical activity tends asymptotically to zero in the case of dilute gases or compressed gases and liquids or oscillates periodically around zero when the molecules are isolated or submitted to a static potential. Only when E is different of zero the system can be optically stable depending on the strength parameters of the potential U and on the magnitude of the spontaneous tunneling.