Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Hydrogen Spectrum for the Proton Hopping Randomly Between Two Sites

José Angel Lesteiro Tejeda

Published Dec 16, 2025• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

The hydrogen spectrum is explored as a sensitive probe of a massive object being in a superposition of two distinct locations. Here I solve the simpler but instructive semiclassical problem of the proton hopping stochastically between two sites but forbidden to be anywhere else, analogous to the superposition over two locations. Although the model is semiclassical, it captures symmetry properties and the structure of the energy spectrum that one would expect in a fully quantum treatment. The hydrogen atom is a well-understood system whose spectroscopy reaches exceptional precision, and its semiclassical description displays symmetry with respect to two fixed locations. I develop a classical model for an electron and a proton, with the proton stochastically hopping between two fixed sites; and describe its classical dynamics mathematically via a one-particle effective Hamiltonian. For this Hamiltonian I identify a set of invariance properties that are characteristic of heteronuclear diatomic molecules and are not as extensive as the SO(4) symmetries present in the traditional models of the hydrogen atom. I connect the classical description of the proton-hopping model with the two-fixed-centre problem with time-dependent charges. I find that there is a lower limit to the hopping distance of the proton below which state-of-the-art measurements cannot resolve the spectral signature predicted; and also an upper limit above which approximation methods are not applicable. I gain meaningful insight into the mechanisms that shape the quantum dynamics of proton tunnelling in hydrogen by analyzing the classical counterpart, leveraging the shared symmetries between quantum and classical analogous systems. My results predict an observable spectral shift in the ground-state energy when the proton is delocalized over two sites separated by a distance large enough to be considered macroscopically distinct. With this research, I support the idea that proton tunnelling inside the hydrogen atom is worth exploring as a probe for a delocalized massive object.

DOI
10.11575/prism/50864

Related papers

Hydrogen atom as a quantum-classical hybrid system

Fei Zhan, Biao Wu

Hydrogen atom is studied as a quantum-classical hybrid system, where the proton is treated as a classical object while the electron is regarded as a quantum object. We use a well known mean-field approach to describe this hybrid hydrogen atom; the resulting dynamics for the electron and the proton is compared to their full quantum dynamics. The electron dynamics in the hybrid description is found to be only marginally different from its full quantum counterpart. The situation is very different for the proton: in the hybrid description, the proton behaves like a free particle; in the fully quantum description, the wave packet center of the proton orbits around the center of mass. Furthermore, we find that the failure to describe the proton dynamics properly can be regarded as a manifestation of the fact that there is no conservation of momentum in the mean-field hybrid approach. We expect that such a failure is a common feature for all existing approaches for quantum-classical hybrid systems of Born-Oppenheimer type.

arXiv:1302.1628•Journal of Physics Conference Series•Jun 10, 2013•0 citations

The Non-relativistic Hydrogen Atom

Pranawa C. Deshmukh

One must always do what one really cannot. —Niels Bohr A groundbreaking event in the development of the quantum theory of atomic structure is the remarkable discovery by Johann Jacob Balmer in 1884. He figured out that Anders Jonas Angstrom's measurements of the wavelengths = 4101.2, 4340.1, 4860.74, and 6562.10 Å of the four prominent lines in the spectrum of the hydrogen atom fit the formula, where b = 3645.6 Å, and n = 3, 4, 5, 6. This is an outstanding illustration of the arithmetic genius that Balmer was, being an arithmetic teacher in a girls’ school. Balmer's formula was independently rediscovered by Johannes Robert Rydberg six years later, and rationalized in the planetary model of the old quantum theory proposed by Niels Bohr in 1913. Orbits, however, are intangible, position and momentum measurements not being compatible. Solution to the Schrödinger equation with appropriate boundary conditions satisfactorily account for the Balmer–Rydberg–Bohr formula, explaining the discrete eigenenergies of the hydrogen atom. In Section 5.1, we discuss the bound-state solutions of the Schrödinger equation for the hydrogen atom. However, the Schrödinger equation does not fully account for the degeneracy of the energy levels of (even the nonrelativistic) hydrogen atom. This bemusing condition is addressed in the Sections 5.2 and 5.3 of this chapter, and the continuum eigenfunctions are discussed in Section 5.4. 5.1 Eigenvalues and Eigenfunctions of the Hydrogen Atom As the very first atom in the periodic table, the hydrogen atom is the simplest one. It is the prototype of one-electron central field atomic systems (including ions) for which exact analytical solution to the Schrödinger equation can be obtained. The electron–proton two-particles Schrödinger equation for the hydrogen atom is where and are respectively the notional position vectors in a laboratory frame of reference of the electron and the proton, and m e and m p their respective masses. The gradient operators and seek space derivatives with respect to the electron and the proton coordinates respectively, and the interaction potential energy operator depends on the relative distance between the two particles. The center of mass of the two particles is located at and the reduced mass which is located at the position vector with respect to the center of mass.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Sep 14, 2023•0 citations

Hubbard Hamiltonian for the hydrogen molecule

G. Chiappe, Enrique Louis, Emilio San‐Fabián +1 more

An attempt is made to derive the parameters of the Hubbard Hamiltonian for the hydrogen molecule from state-of-the-art quantum chemistry calculations of the ground and excited states of the neutral and singly ionized molecules (eight states altogether). Calculations are carried out for interatomic distances in the range $0.6--4.3\phantom{\rule{0.3em}{0ex}}\mathrm{\AA{}}$. The results clearly indicate that the on-site repulsion $U$ is not enough to fit the ab initio energies and that it is necessary to incorporate the intersite repulsion (usually referred to as $J$). If $J$ is ignored, the fitted on-site repulsion approaches the atomic value very slowly as the interatomic distance is increased, a clearly unphysical behavior. For finite $J$ and at the equilibrium interatomic distance, the energies of the eight states mentioned above are reasonably fitted with an atomic orbital energy ${ϵ}_{0}\ensuremath{\approx}\ensuremath{-}24.6\phantom{\rule{0.3em}{0ex}}\mathrm{eV}$, Coulomb interaction parameters $U\ensuremath{\approx}11.6\phantom{\rule{0.3em}{0ex}}\mathrm{eV}$ and $J\ensuremath{\approx}8.9\phantom{\rule{0.3em}{0ex}}\mathrm{eV}$, and a hopping integral $t\ensuremath{\approx}7.9\phantom{\rule{0.3em}{0ex}}\mathrm{eV}$.

Physical Review B•May 4, 2007•22 citations

A quantum Monte Carlo calculation of the ground state energy of the hydrogen molecule

Carol A. Traynor, James B. Anderson, Bruce M. Boghosian

Abstract Since the wavefunction for the ground state of the hydrogen molecule has no nodes, its energy can be determined in QMC without node location error. This paper reports such calculations for the full four-body (two-electron, two-proton) problem to obtain the energy without the use of the Born-Oppenheimer approximation or any other adiabatic approximations. The calculations were carried out with diffusion QMC and with Green’s function QMC. Importance sampling was incorporated into each of the calculations. For the diffusion calculations, extrapolation of energies obtained at several different time-step sizes was required. For the Green’s function calculations there was no time-step error, and sign changes for walkers were avoided by use of a potential energy offset and a minor approximation to eliminate positive potential energies. The energies so determined were not exact but had extremely small systematic errors. The large differences in electron and proton masses led to extensive computation requirements due to the slow equilibration and serial correlation induced by the heavier protons. The calculations were executed on one of the first massively parallel computers, a Thinking Machines CM-2 with 65,536 processors. Frequent communication among the processors was required to balance the number of walkers treated in each.

Oxford University Press eBooks•Jun 18, 2007•0 citations

Quantum chaos of the hydrogen atom in a generalized van der Waals potential

K. Ganesan, M. Lakshmanan

The quantum manifestations of chaos in the hydrogen atom in a generalized van der Waals potential, which includes the celebrated quadratic-Zeeman-effect problem under an appropriate limiting condition, are studied in detail. Using group-theoretical methods, we derive the matrix elements in an algebraic form. As the Hamiltonian is scale invariant, we introduce an appropriate scaling parameter. By considering the unperturbed hydrogen-atom problem, we demonstrate that suitable changes in the scaling parameter stabilize different parts of the spectrum depending upon the parameter's value. For the present generalized van der Waals potential problem, we utilize this property of the scaling parameter effectively to improve the convergence of eigenvalues while diagonalizing the matrices for various parametric values. Then, we vary one of the system parameters in the range [0,3], study the level statistics, and observe a GOE-Poisson-Brody-Poisson-Brody-Poisson-GOE-type (where GOE means Gaussian orthogonal ensemble) of transition regime hitherto unidentified in any of the perturbed hydrogen-atom problems. Our results are not only in agreement with random-matrix-theory predictions but also justify classical and semiclassical investigations.

Physical Review A•Aug 1, 1993•24 citations

Hydrogen closure and the electron–photon channel. BKT-107-A01-EPH_V1.12

Robert Kupski

Hydrogen closure and the electron–photon channelThe relational information layer, retention and measurement of proton structure BKT-107-A01-EPH_V1.12 Introduction A hydrogen atom can emit a photon and change its energy state while the proton and electron remain bound. The 2P → 1S transition therefore provides a concrete example of persistent physical organisation during a state change and energy exchange with the environment. This raises the question of how to describe such persistence quantitatively and connect it to the information accessible in the emitted field. The article addresses this problem through a shared specification of structure, dynamics, system preparation and measurement. Within the Law of One Mechanism programme PJM the organisation of relations is the overarching object of description. The Universal Structural Code ( USC ) expresses this perspective through compatibility classes, defects and tolerance bands, while GTWSSF connects the couplings and responses of different system components through shared parameters and operators. In the hydrogen application, closure denotes compatibility with a selected state class, while its preservation under evolution receives a separate dynamical condition. Non-closure measures deviation from specified relations. Contact denotes a relation with explicitly identified arguments, such as coupling between an atomic state and a field mode or a shared observable response to a parameter change. The physical basis is a quantum description of the proton, electron and electromagnetic field. Shared parameters connect the Hamiltonian, level energies, transition amplitudes, emission rate and detection statistics. The surface channel denotes the electromagnetically accessible response sector of the proton and atom. Transmission information is defined for a specified alphabet, understood as a set of symbols assigned to selected physical preparations, and for a particular receiver. This construction allows bound-state retention, preparation information and sensitivity to structural parameters to be determined separately. The principal numerical result connects retention with positive information capacity. In a model with radiative emission rate Γ and competing loss rate κ, at κ/Γ = 0.01, detection efficiency 0.8 and gate ΓT = 1, an excited-state preparation fraction of 0.101 ensures mean retention of at least 0.999 throughout the evolution of the ensemble of individual preparations. The maximum classical information for the specified energy alphabet and binary receiver is 0.189053 bits per channel use. Restricting protection to the readout interval gives 0.243325 bits per use. The difference quantifies the information cost of extending the persistence guarantee beyond the measurement window. The amount of recovered information also depends on preparation and measurement. In the model without competing loss, at ideal detection and ΓT = 1, optimal measurement of an equiprobable phase alphabet gives 0.523223 bits per use. An optimised energy alphabet with photon counting gives 0.436401 bits, while ordinary homodyne readout of the phase alphabet gives 0.381458 bits. These values characterise different tasks implemented through the same emission map. Separating the alphabet, dynamics and receiver gives information a precise operational meaning. The connection to proton structure proceeds through a shared proton–atom–photon response map. As a reference scale, the leading finite-proton-size contribution to the 1S–2S transition frequency is calculated: for a radius of 0.84075 fm, it is −0.967262 MHz. Information geometry then relates the compatibility residual to distribution divergence and decision error. Nuisance-parameter profiling determines the signal component that remains distinguishable after refitting the reference parameters, while a controlled error budget establishes the validity range of that distinction. The single-emission model further shows that recording photon arrival times retains information about the emission rate when detector efficiency is unknown, whereas a single binary readout at one fixed gate is degenerate in this respect. The analysis also addresses memory and persistence under repeated transitions. Memory receives an operational characterisation through the influence of earlier interventions on subsequent outcomes, and reduction of memory-dependent dynamics to an exponential description is subject to an error bound. In a continuously pumped model with irreversible loss, retention vanishes at long times. A separate realisation with explicit return to the protected sector establishes tolerance-band preservation with nonzero heat currents and positive entropy production. Persistence of organisation thereby acquires a description encompassing both dynamical conditions and energy balance. The significance of the work lies in connecting three problems within one physical realisation: preservation of a selected structure, information transmission and identification of its parameters. Comparison with QCD and the Standard Model uses shared observables and the same measurement protocol. The analysis specifies conditions under which additional dynamics or new constraints on shared parameters can acquire distinct predictive content tested against independent data. The results concern specified atomic models; the GTCW cosmological module is a separate part of the programme. The resulting framework expresses closure, tolerance and coupling through operators, mathematical conditions and quantitatively specified measurement outcomes.

•Nov 12, 2026•0 citations
The hydrogen spectrum is explored as a sensitive probe of a massive object being in a superposition of two distinct locations. Here I solve the simpler but instructive semiclassical problem of the proton hopping stochastically between two sites but forbidden to be anywhere else, analogous to the superposition over two locations. Although the model is semiclassical, it captures symmetry properties and the structure of the energy spectrum that one would expect in a fully quantum treatment. The hydrogen atom is a well-understood system whose spectroscopy reaches exceptional precision, and its semiclassical description displays symmetry with respect to two fixed locations. I develop a classical model for an electron and a proton, with the proton stochastically hopping between two fixed sites; and describe its classical dynamics mathematically via a one-particle effective Hamiltonian. For this Hamiltonian I identify a set of invariance properties that are characteristic of heteronuclear diatomic molecules and are not as extensive as the SO(4) symmetries present in the traditional models of the hydrogen atom. I connect the classical description of the proton-hopping model with the two-fixed-centre problem with time-dependent charges. I find that there is a lower limit to the hopping distance of the proton below which state-of-the-art measurements cannot resolve the spectral signature predicted; and also an upper limit above which approximation methods are not applicable. I gain meaningful insight into the mechanisms that shape the quantum dynamics of proton tunnelling in hydrogen by analyzing the classical counterpart, leveraging the shared symmetries between quantum and classical analogous systems. My results predict an observable spectral shift in the ground-state energy when the proton is delocalized over two sites separated by a distance large enough to be considered macroscopically distinct. With this research, I support the idea that proton tunnelling inside the hydrogen atom is worth exploring as a probe for a delocalized massive object.
Hydrogen atom is studied as a quantum-classical hybrid system, where the proton is treated as a classical object while the electron is regarded as a quantum object. We use a well known mean-field approach to describe this hybrid hydrogen atom; the resulting dynamics for the electron and the proton is compared to their full quantum dynamics. The electron dynamics in the hybrid description is found to be only marginally different from its full quantum counterpart. The situation is very different for the proton: in the hybrid description, the proton behaves like a free particle; in the fully quantum description, the wave packet center of the proton orbits around the center of mass. Furthermore, we find that the failure to describe the proton dynamics properly can be regarded as a manifestation of the fact that there is no conservation of momentum in the mean-field hybrid approach. We expect that such a failure is a common feature for all existing approaches for quantum-classical hybrid systems of Born-Oppenheimer type.
One must always do what one really cannot. —Niels Bohr A groundbreaking event in the development of the quantum theory of atomic structure is the remarkable discovery by Johann Jacob Balmer in 1884. He figured out that Anders Jonas Angstrom's measurements of the wavelengths = 4101.2, 4340.1, 4860.74, and 6562.10 Å of the four prominent lines in the spectrum of the hydrogen atom fit the formula, where b = 3645.6 Å, and n = 3, 4, 5, 6. This is an outstanding illustration of the arithmetic genius that Balmer was, being an arithmetic teacher in a girls’ school. Balmer's formula was independently rediscovered by Johannes Robert Rydberg six years later, and rationalized in the planetary model of the old quantum theory proposed by Niels Bohr in 1913. Orbits, however, are intangible, position and momentum measurements not being compatible. Solution to the Schrödinger equation with appropriate boundary conditions satisfactorily account for the Balmer–Rydberg–Bohr formula, explaining the discrete eigenenergies of the hydrogen atom. In Section 5.1, we discuss the bound-state solutions of the Schrödinger equation for the hydrogen atom. However, the Schrödinger equation does not fully account for the degeneracy of the energy levels of (even the nonrelativistic) hydrogen atom. This bemusing condition is addressed in the Sections 5.2 and 5.3 of this chapter, and the continuum eigenfunctions are discussed in Section 5.4. 5.1 Eigenvalues and Eigenfunctions of the Hydrogen Atom As the very first atom in the periodic table, the hydrogen atom is the simplest one. It is the prototype of one-electron central field atomic systems (including ions) for which exact analytical solution to the Schrödinger equation can be obtained. The electron–proton two-particles Schrödinger equation for the hydrogen atom is where and are respectively the notional position vectors in a laboratory frame of reference of the electron and the proton, and m e and m p their respective masses. The gradient operators and seek space derivatives with respect to the electron and the proton coordinates respectively, and the interaction potential energy operator depends on the relative distance between the two particles. The center of mass of the two particles is located at and the reduced mass which is located at the position vector with respect to the center of mass.
An attempt is made to derive the parameters of the Hubbard Hamiltonian for the hydrogen molecule from state-of-the-art quantum chemistry calculations of the ground and excited states of the neutral and singly ionized molecules (eight states altogether). Calculations are carried out for interatomic distances in the range 0.6−−4.3A˚0.6--4.3\phantom{\rule{0.3em}{0ex}}\mathrm{\AA{}}0.6−−4.3A˚. The results clearly indicate that the on-site repulsion UUU is not enough to fit the ab initio energies and that it is necessary to incorporate the intersite repulsion (usually referred to as JJJ). If JJJ is ignored, the fitted on-site repulsion approaches the atomic value very slowly as the interatomic distance is increased, a clearly unphysical behavior. For finite JJJ and at the equilibrium interatomic distance, the energies of the eight states mentioned above are reasonably fitted with an atomic orbital energy ${ϵ}_{0}\ensuremath{\approx}\ensuremath{-}24.6\phantom{\rule{0.3em}{0ex}}\mathrm{eV}$, Coulomb interaction parameters $U\ensuremath{\approx}11.6\phantom{\rule{0.3em}{0ex}}\mathrm{eV}$ and $J\ensuremath{\approx}8.9\phantom{\rule{0.3em}{0ex}}\mathrm{eV}$, and a hopping integral $t\ensuremath{\approx}7.9\phantom{\rule{0.3em}{0ex}}\mathrm{eV}$.
Abstract Since the wavefunction for the ground state of the hydrogen molecule has no nodes, its energy can be determined in QMC without node location error. This paper reports such calculations for the full four-body (two-electron, two-proton) problem to obtain the energy without the use of the Born-Oppenheimer approximation or any other adiabatic approximations. The calculations were carried out with diffusion QMC and with Green’s function QMC. Importance sampling was incorporated into each of the calculations. For the diffusion calculations, extrapolation of energies obtained at several different time-step sizes was required. For the Green’s function calculations there was no time-step error, and sign changes for walkers were avoided by use of a potential energy offset and a minor approximation to eliminate positive potential energies. The energies so determined were not exact but had extremely small systematic errors. The large differences in electron and proton masses led to extensive computation requirements due to the slow equilibration and serial correlation induced by the heavier protons. The calculations were executed on one of the first massively parallel computers, a Thinking Machines CM-2 with 65,536 processors. Frequent communication among the processors was required to balance the number of walkers treated in each.
The quantum manifestations of chaos in the hydrogen atom in a generalized van der Waals potential, which includes the celebrated quadratic-Zeeman-effect problem under an appropriate limiting condition, are studied in detail. Using group-theoretical methods, we derive the matrix elements in an algebraic form. As the Hamiltonian is scale invariant, we introduce an appropriate scaling parameter. By considering the unperturbed hydrogen-atom problem, we demonstrate that suitable changes in the scaling parameter stabilize different parts of the spectrum depending upon the parameter's value. For the present generalized van der Waals potential problem, we utilize this property of the scaling parameter effectively to improve the convergence of eigenvalues while diagonalizing the matrices for various parametric values. Then, we vary one of the system parameters in the range [0,3], study the level statistics, and observe a GOE-Poisson-Brody-Poisson-Brody-Poisson-GOE-type (where GOE means Gaussian orthogonal ensemble) of transition regime hitherto unidentified in any of the perturbed hydrogen-atom problems. Our results are not only in agreement with random-matrix-theory predictions but also justify classical and semiclassical investigations.
Hydrogen closure and the electron–photon channelThe relational information layer, retention and measurement of proton structure BKT-107-A01-EPH_V1.12 Introduction A hydrogen atom can emit a photon and change its energy state while the proton and electron remain bound. The 2P → 1S transition therefore provides a concrete example of persistent physical organisation during a state change and energy exchange with the environment. This raises the question of how to describe such persistence quantitatively and connect it to the information accessible in the emitted field. The article addresses this problem through a shared specification of structure, dynamics, system preparation and measurement. Within the Law of One Mechanism programme PJM the organisation of relations is the overarching object of description. The Universal Structural Code ( USC ) expresses this perspective through compatibility classes, defects and tolerance bands, while GTWSSF connects the couplings and responses of different system components through shared parameters and operators. In the hydrogen application, closure denotes compatibility with a selected state class, while its preservation under evolution receives a separate dynamical condition. Non-closure measures deviation from specified relations. Contact denotes a relation with explicitly identified arguments, such as coupling between an atomic state and a field mode or a shared observable response to a parameter change. The physical basis is a quantum description of the proton, electron and electromagnetic field. Shared parameters connect the Hamiltonian, level energies, transition amplitudes, emission rate and detection statistics. The surface channel denotes the electromagnetically accessible response sector of the proton and atom. Transmission information is defined for a specified alphabet, understood as a set of symbols assigned to selected physical preparations, and for a particular receiver. This construction allows bound-state retention, preparation information and sensitivity to structural parameters to be determined separately. The principal numerical result connects retention with positive information capacity. In a model with radiative emission rate Γ and competing loss rate κ, at κ/Γ = 0.01, detection efficiency 0.8 and gate ΓT = 1, an excited-state preparation fraction of 0.101 ensures mean retention of at least 0.999 throughout the evolution of the ensemble of individual preparations. The maximum classical information for the specified energy alphabet and binary receiver is 0.189053 bits per channel use. Restricting protection to the readout interval gives 0.243325 bits per use. The difference quantifies the information cost of extending the persistence guarantee beyond the measurement window. The amount of recovered information also depends on preparation and measurement. In the model without competing loss, at ideal detection and ΓT = 1, optimal measurement of an equiprobable phase alphabet gives 0.523223 bits per use. An optimised energy alphabet with photon counting gives 0.436401 bits, while ordinary homodyne readout of the phase alphabet gives 0.381458 bits. These values characterise different tasks implemented through the same emission map. Separating the alphabet, dynamics and receiver gives information a precise operational meaning. The connection to proton structure proceeds through a shared proton–atom–photon response map. As a reference scale, the leading finite-proton-size contribution to the 1S–2S transition frequency is calculated: for a radius of 0.84075 fm, it is −0.967262 MHz. Information geometry then relates the compatibility residual to distribution divergence and decision error. Nuisance-parameter profiling determines the signal component that remains distinguishable after refitting the reference parameters, while a controlled error budget establishes the validity range of that distinction. The single-emission model further shows that recording photon arrival times retains information about the emission rate when detector efficiency is unknown, whereas a single binary readout at one fixed gate is degenerate in this respect. The analysis also addresses memory and persistence under repeated transitions. Memory receives an operational characterisation through the influence of earlier interventions on subsequent outcomes, and reduction of memory-dependent dynamics to an exponential description is subject to an error bound. In a continuously pumped model with irreversible loss, retention vanishes at long times. A separate realisation with explicit return to the protected sector establishes tolerance-band preservation with nonzero heat currents and positive entropy production. Persistence of organisation thereby acquires a description encompassing both dynamical conditions and energy balance. The significance of the work lies in connecting three problems within one physical realisation: preservation of a selected structure, information transmission and identification of its parameters. Comparison with QCD and the Standard Model uses shared observables and the same measurement protocol. The analysis specifies conditions under which additional dynamics or new constraints on shared parameters can acquire distinct predictive content tested against independent data. The results concern specified atomic models; the GTCW cosmological module is a separate part of the programme. The resulting framework expresses closure, tolerance and coupling through operators, mathematical conditions and quantitatively specified measurement outcomes.