Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Physical Review

Further Discussion of the Role of Electromagnetic Potentials in the Quantum Theory

Yakir Aharonov, David Böhm

Published May 15, 1963• 142 citations
Publisher

Abstract

In this paper, we present a further discussion of the role of electromagnetic potentials in the quantum theory, aimed at clarifying some of the points made in earlier papers, and indicating some extensions of these earlier ideas. In addition, we go into the problem of subsidiary conditions and questions concerning the full observability of the potentials. In the course of our discussion, we answer certain recent objections of Belinfante and De Witt.

DOI
10.1103/physrev.130.1625

Related papers

Further Considerations on Electromagnetic Potentials in the Quantum Theory

Yakir Aharonov, David Böhm

In this article, we discuss in further detail the significance of potentials in the quantum theory, and in so doing, we answer a number of arguments that have been raised against the conclusions of our first paper on the same subject. We then proceed to extend our treatment to include the sources of potentials quantum-mechanically, and we show that when this is done, the same results are obtained as those of our first paper, in which the potential was taken to be a specified function of space and time. In this way, we not only answer certain additional criticisms that have been made of the original treatment, but we also bring out more clearly the importance of the potential in the expression of the local character of the interaction of charged particles and the electromagnetic field.

Physical Review•Aug 15, 1961•415 citations

Theories and Interpretations

Olímpia Lombardi

Abstract The purpose of this book is to present an interpretation of quantum mechanics. But what are we talking about when we speak of “quantum mechanics?” Are we talking about a single theory or about many related theories? And what do we mean by “interpretation” here? In this chapter, I will address these questions in an introductory way. Of course, I do not intend to take part in the extensive discussions about what a scientific theory is, what is meant by interpreting a theory, in what situation we encounter equivalent theories, and many other questions related to or derived from these. My aim here is to present some preliminary ideas in a way that I hope will be sufficient to avoid misunderstandings in the following chapters. But, above all, I will state my position as to why, after so many years and so much literature on the subject, the interpretation of quantum mechanics deserves further discussion.

Oxford University Press eBooks•Feb 19, 2026•0 citations

16. Microphysical Objects and Experimental Evidence

Giulio Peruzzi

What actually means "particle" for a physicist? Which kinds of experimental evidences can substantiate the particle picture coming from the quantum field theory approach to the physical world? A tentative answer to these questions is the chief aim of this paper. We shall not take into account explicitly many of the philosophical questions, that are discussed in other papers of this book. Our central concern here is to understand the physical point of view through an excursus on the (not so well defined) borderline between theory and experimental evidences.

Princeton University Press eBooks•Dec 31, 1999•0 citations

Einstein et la complémentarité au sens de Bohr : du retrait dans le tumulte aux arguments d'incomplétude

Michel Paty

SUMMARY. — In this article, I examine Einstein's objections to quantum mechanics, with the formalism's interpretation in terms of complementarity as the historical setting. From 1924 to 1927, the period of development of a formalised quantum theory, Einstein raised certain questions that kept him from joining the throng of ardent supporters. Against the theory and its interpretation of 1927, he at first advanced arguments with the idea of eventually finding a flaw in quantum mechanics, and casting doubts upon its pretensions of completeness. Finally acknowledging, in 1931, the theory's coherence and accuracy at describing phenomena, he then tried to put forth objections to the theory's interpretation, which aimed at demonstrating the theory's incompleteness. These arguments culminated in the « Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen » article of 1935, and Einstein repeated them continually until his death. The analysis here calls, of course, for assessments of both the import of Einstein's arguments in relation to physics today, as well as to Einstein's own conceptions where theoretical physics is concerned, but these go beyond the aims of the present article.

Revue d histoire des sciences•Jan 1, 1985•4 citations

Significance of Electromagnetic Potentials in the Quantum Theory

Yakir Aharonov, David Böhm

In this paper, we discuss some interesting properties of the electromagnetic potentials in the quantum domain. We shall show that, contrary to the conclusions of classical mechanics, there exist effects of potentials on charged particles, even in the region where all the fields (and therefore the forces on the particles) vanish. We shall then discuss possible experiments to test these conclusions; and, finally, we shall suggest further possible developments in the interpretation of the potentials.

Physical Review•Aug 1, 1959•7,074 citations

Collective Representation of the Many-Particle System Interacting through Arbitrary Two-Body Potential

Naomi Shohno

We develope a collective description of the many-particle system interacting through an arbitrary two-body potential. The description is given both in terms of the second quantized form and in terms of an auxiliary field analogous to the longitudinal electromagnetic field. As Bohm-Pines theory of the collective description has some unsatisfactory features concerning the subsidiary condition imposed on the auxiliary field, we propose here a strict method of treatment on the subsidiary condition. To obtain the useful result of the collective representation, we have to take the three steps of the canonical transformations. Though the first two transformations are the same as those of B-P, the third transformation, which is not applied by B-P and is characteristic of our theory, is necessary for obtaining a meaningful result. By using both the strict subsidiary condition and the three canonical transformations, the collective field coordinate and the particle coordinate are separated not only in the total Hamiltonian but also in the subsidiary condition. Moreover, we are able to clarify the correct meaning of the subsidiary condition and clarify also the connections between our theory and the theory of Sawada-Brueckner-Fukuda-Brout.

Progress of Theoretical Physics•Nov 1, 1960•1 citation
In this paper, we present a further discussion of the role of electromagnetic potentials in the quantum theory, aimed at clarifying some of the points made in earlier papers, and indicating some extensions of these earlier ideas. In addition, we go into the problem of subsidiary conditions and questions concerning the full observability of the potentials. In the course of our discussion, we answer certain recent objections of Belinfante and De Witt.
In this article, we discuss in further detail the significance of potentials in the quantum theory, and in so doing, we answer a number of arguments that have been raised against the conclusions of our first paper on the same subject. We then proceed to extend our treatment to include the sources of potentials quantum-mechanically, and we show that when this is done, the same results are obtained as those of our first paper, in which the potential was taken to be a specified function of space and time. In this way, we not only answer certain additional criticisms that have been made of the original treatment, but we also bring out more clearly the importance of the potential in the expression of the local character of the interaction of charged particles and the electromagnetic field.
Abstract The purpose of this book is to present an interpretation of quantum mechanics. But what are we talking about when we speak of “quantum mechanics?” Are we talking about a single theory or about many related theories? And what do we mean by “interpretation” here? In this chapter, I will address these questions in an introductory way. Of course, I do not intend to take part in the extensive discussions about what a scientific theory is, what is meant by interpreting a theory, in what situation we encounter equivalent theories, and many other questions related to or derived from these. My aim here is to present some preliminary ideas in a way that I hope will be sufficient to avoid misunderstandings in the following chapters. But, above all, I will state my position as to why, after so many years and so much literature on the subject, the interpretation of quantum mechanics deserves further discussion.
What actually means "particle" for a physicist? Which kinds of experimental evidences can substantiate the particle picture coming from the quantum field theory approach to the physical world? A tentative answer to these questions is the chief aim of this paper. We shall not take into account explicitly many of the philosophical questions, that are discussed in other papers of this book. Our central concern here is to understand the physical point of view through an excursus on the (not so well defined) borderline between theory and experimental evidences.
SUMMARY. — In this article, I examine Einstein's objections to quantum mechanics, with the formalism's interpretation in terms of complementarity as the historical setting. From 1924 to 1927, the period of development of a formalised quantum theory, Einstein raised certain questions that kept him from joining the throng of ardent supporters. Against the theory and its interpretation of 1927, he at first advanced arguments with the idea of eventually finding a flaw in quantum mechanics, and casting doubts upon its pretensions of completeness. Finally acknowledging, in 1931, the theory's coherence and accuracy at describing phenomena, he then tried to put forth objections to the theory's interpretation, which aimed at demonstrating the theory's incompleteness. These arguments culminated in the « Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen » article of 1935, and Einstein repeated them continually until his death. The analysis here calls, of course, for assessments of both the import of Einstein's arguments in relation to physics today, as well as to Einstein's own conceptions where theoretical physics is concerned, but these go beyond the aims of the present article.
In this paper, we discuss some interesting properties of the electromagnetic potentials in the quantum domain. We shall show that, contrary to the conclusions of classical mechanics, there exist effects of potentials on charged particles, even in the region where all the fields (and therefore the forces on the particles) vanish. We shall then discuss possible experiments to test these conclusions; and, finally, we shall suggest further possible developments in the interpretation of the potentials.
We develope a collective description of the many-particle system interacting through an arbitrary two-body potential. The description is given both in terms of the second quantized form and in terms of an auxiliary field analogous to the longitudinal electromagnetic field. As Bohm-Pines theory of the collective description has some unsatisfactory features concerning the subsidiary condition imposed on the auxiliary field, we propose here a strict method of treatment on the subsidiary condition. To obtain the useful result of the collective representation, we have to take the three steps of the canonical transformations. Though the first two transformations are the same as those of B-P, the third transformation, which is not applied by B-P and is characteristic of our theory, is necessary for obtaining a meaningful result. By using both the strict subsidiary condition and the three canonical transformations, the collective field coordinate and the particle coordinate are separated not only in the total Hamiltonian but also in the subsidiary condition. Moreover, we are able to clarify the correct meaning of the subsidiary condition and clarify also the connections between our theory and the theory of Sawada-Brueckner-Fukuda-Brout.