Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Journal of Physics Condensed Matter

The Ehrenfest approximation for electrons coupled to a phonon system

J le Page, Daniel R. Mason, W. M. C. Foulkes

Published Feb 27, 2008• 31 citations
Publisher

Abstract

We investigate the accuracy of the Ehrenfest approximation for a solid modelled as an independent electron system coupled to a many-mode phonon system. We construct a quantum to classical correspondence which we use to set the initial conditions of the Ehrenfest approximation given an initial density matrix. We find that the Ehrenfest approximation is accurate when the temperature of the phonon system is much higher than the temperature of the electron system. It is therefore reasonable to use the Ehrenfest approximation in the simulation of the later stages of radiation damage processes. We trace the failure of the Ehrenfest approximation to the absence of a term accounting for spontaneous phonon emission. The analytical work is validated numerically for the model system of a single oscillator coupled to electrons on a one-dimensional chain.

DOI
10.1088/0953-8984/20/12/125212

Related papers

Polaron formation: Ehrenfest dynamics vs. exact results

Guangqi Li, Bijan Movaghar, Abraham Nitzan +1 more

We use a one-dimensional tight binding model with an impurity site characterized by electron-vibration coupling, to describe electron transfer and localization at zero temperature, aiming to examine the process of polaron formation in this system. In particular we focus on comparing a semiclassical approach that describes nuclear motion in this many vibronic-states system on the Ehrenfest dynamics level to a numerically exact fully quantum calculation based on the Bonca-Trugman method [J. Bonča and S. A. Trugman, Phys. Rev. Lett. 75, 2566 (1995)]. In both approaches, thermal relaxation in the nuclear subspace is implemented in equivalent approximate ways: In the Ehrenfest calculation the uncoupled (to the electronic subsystem) motion of the classical (harmonic) oscillator is simply damped as would be implied by coupling to a Markovian zero temperature bath. In the quantum calculation, thermal relaxation is implemented by augmenting the Liouville equation for the oscillator density matrix with kinetic terms that account for the same relaxation. In both cases we calculate the probability to trap the electron by forming a polaron and the probability that it escapes to infinity. Comparing these calculations, we find that while both result in similar long time yields for these processes, the Ehrenfest-dynamics based calculation fails to account for the correct time scale for the polaron formation. This failure results, as usual, from the fact that at the early stage of polaron formation the classical nuclear dynamics takes place on an unphysical average potential surface that reflects the distributed electronic population in the system, while the quantum calculation accounts fully for correlations between the electronic and vibrational subsystems.

arXiv:1210.7234•The Journal of Chemical Physics•Jan 28, 2013•28 citations

Hybrid quantum-classical matrix-product state and Lanczos methods for electron-phonon systems with strong electronic correlations: Application to disordered systems coupled to Einstein phonons

Heiko Georg Menzler, Suman Mondal, Fabian Heidrich-Meisner

We present two quantum-classical hybrid methods for simulating the time-dependence of electron-phonon systems that treat electronic correlations numerically exactly and optical-phonon degrees of freedom classically. These are a time-dependent Lanczos and a matrix-product state method, each combined with the multi-trajectory Ehrenfest approach. Due to the approximations, reliable results are expected for the adiabatic regime of small phonon frequencies. We discuss the convergence properties of both methods for a system of interacting spinless fermions in one dimension and provide a benchmark for the Holstein chain. As a first application, we study the decay of charge density wave order in a system of interacting spinless fermions coupled to Einstein oscillators and in the presence of quenched disorder. We investigate the dependence of the relaxation dynamics on the electron-phonon coupling strength and provide numerical evidence that the coupling of strongly disordered systems to classical oscillators leads to delocalization, thus destabilizing the (finite-size) many-body localization in this system.

cond-mat.str-elCross-listedarXiv:2512.10899•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Dec 12, 2025•4 citations

Electron-phonon thermalization in a scalable method for real-time quantum dynamics

Valerio Rizzi, Tchavdar N. Todorov, Jorge José Kohanoff +1 more

We present a quantum simulation method that follows the dynamics of out-of-equilibrium many-body systems of electrons and oscillators in real time. Its cost is linear in the number of oscillators and it can probe time scales from attoseconds to hundreds of picoseconds. Contrary to Ehrenfest dynamics, it can thermalize starting from a variety of initial conditions, including electronic population inversion. While an electronic temperature can be defined in terms of a nonequilibrium entropy, a Fermi-Dirac distribution in general emerges only after thermalization. These results can be used to construct a kinetic model of electron-phonon equilibration based on the explicit quantum dynamics.

arXiv:1511.03875•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Jan 27, 2016•31 citations

Stochastic semiclassical theory for nonequilibrium electron-phonon coupled systems

Antonio Picano, Francesco Grandi, Philipp Werner +1 more

We discuss a semiclassical approach to solve the quantum impurity model within nonequilibrium dynamical mean-field theory for electron-lattice models. The effect of electronic fluctuations on the phonon is kept beyond Ehrenfest dynamics, leading to a stochastic phonon evolution with damping and noise terms that are self-consistently determined by the electronic correlation functions in the fluctuating phonon field. Together with a solution of the electronic model based on a nonperturbative quantum Boltzmann equation, the approach can be used to address the coupled dynamics of the electrons and the lattice during photoinduced phase transitions. Results for the Anderson-Holstein model are benchmarked against numerically exact quantum Monte Carlo data. We find good agreement for the phonon distribution function at temperatures comparable to the charge ordering temperature. The general formulation can be extended to models with electron-electron interactions or multiorbital systems.

arXiv:2209.00428•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Jul 10, 2023•14 citations

Ehrenfest approach to open double-well dynamics

Stephen U. S. Choi, Roberto Onofrio, Bala Sundaram

We consider an Ehrenfest approximation for a particle in a double-well potential in the presence of an external environment schematized as a finite resource heat bath. This allows us to explore how the limitations in the applicability of Ehrenfest dynamics to nonlinear systems are modified in an open system setting. Within this framework, we have identified an environment-induced spontaneous symmetry breaking mechanism, and we argue that the Ehrenfest approximation becomes increasingly valid in the limit of strong coupling to the external reservoir, either in the form of an increasing number of oscillators or increasing temperature. The analysis also suggests a rather intuitive picture for the general phenomenon of quantum tunneling and its interplay with classical thermal activation processes, which may be of relevance in physical chemistry, ultracold atom physics, and fast-switching dynamics such as in superconducting digital electronics.

arXiv:1510.02156•Physical Review E•Oct 5, 2015•8 citations

Electron and phonon correlations in systems of one-dimensional electrons coupled to phonons

Leiming Chen

Electron and phonon correlations in systems of one-dimensional electrons coupled to phonons are studied at low temperatures by emphasizing on the effect of electron-phonon backward scattering. It is found that the $2{k}_{F}$-wave components of the electron density and phonon displacement field share the same correlations. Both correlations are quasi-long-ranged for a single conducting chain coupled to one-dimensional or three-dimensional phonons, and they are long-ranged for repulsive electron-electron interactions for a three-dimensional array of parallel one-dimensional conducting chains coupled to three-dimensional phonons.

arXiv:0806.0310•Physical Review B•Nov 19, 2008•0 citations
We investigate the accuracy of the Ehrenfest approximation for a solid modelled as an independent electron system coupled to a many-mode phonon system. We construct a quantum to classical correspondence which we use to set the initial conditions of the Ehrenfest approximation given an initial density matrix. We find that the Ehrenfest approximation is accurate when the temperature of the phonon system is much higher than the temperature of the electron system. It is therefore reasonable to use the Ehrenfest approximation in the simulation of the later stages of radiation damage processes. We trace the failure of the Ehrenfest approximation to the absence of a term accounting for spontaneous phonon emission. The analytical work is validated numerically for the model system of a single oscillator coupled to electrons on a one-dimensional chain.
We use a one-dimensional tight binding model with an impurity site characterized by electron-vibration coupling, to describe electron transfer and localization at zero temperature, aiming to examine the process of polaron formation in this system. In particular we focus on comparing a semiclassical approach that describes nuclear motion in this many vibronic-states system on the Ehrenfest dynamics level to a numerically exact fully quantum calculation based on the Bonca-Trugman method [J. Bonča and S. A. Trugman, Phys. Rev. Lett. 75, 2566 (1995)]. In both approaches, thermal relaxation in the nuclear subspace is implemented in equivalent approximate ways: In the Ehrenfest calculation the uncoupled (to the electronic subsystem) motion of the classical (harmonic) oscillator is simply damped as would be implied by coupling to a Markovian zero temperature bath. In the quantum calculation, thermal relaxation is implemented by augmenting the Liouville equation for the oscillator density matrix with kinetic terms that account for the same relaxation. In both cases we calculate the probability to trap the electron by forming a polaron and the probability that it escapes to infinity. Comparing these calculations, we find that while both result in similar long time yields for these processes, the Ehrenfest-dynamics based calculation fails to account for the correct time scale for the polaron formation. This failure results, as usual, from the fact that at the early stage of polaron formation the classical nuclear dynamics takes place on an unphysical average potential surface that reflects the distributed electronic population in the system, while the quantum calculation accounts fully for correlations between the electronic and vibrational subsystems.
We present two quantum-classical hybrid methods for simulating the time-dependence of electron-phonon systems that treat electronic correlations numerically exactly and optical-phonon degrees of freedom classically. These are a time-dependent Lanczos and a matrix-product state method, each combined with the multi-trajectory Ehrenfest approach. Due to the approximations, reliable results are expected for the adiabatic regime of small phonon frequencies. We discuss the convergence properties of both methods for a system of interacting spinless fermions in one dimension and provide a benchmark for the Holstein chain. As a first application, we study the decay of charge density wave order in a system of interacting spinless fermions coupled to Einstein oscillators and in the presence of quenched disorder. We investigate the dependence of the relaxation dynamics on the electron-phonon coupling strength and provide numerical evidence that the coupling of strongly disordered systems to classical oscillators leads to delocalization, thus destabilizing the (finite-size) many-body localization in this system.
We present a quantum simulation method that follows the dynamics of out-of-equilibrium many-body systems of electrons and oscillators in real time. Its cost is linear in the number of oscillators and it can probe time scales from attoseconds to hundreds of picoseconds. Contrary to Ehrenfest dynamics, it can thermalize starting from a variety of initial conditions, including electronic population inversion. While an electronic temperature can be defined in terms of a nonequilibrium entropy, a Fermi-Dirac distribution in general emerges only after thermalization. These results can be used to construct a kinetic model of electron-phonon equilibration based on the explicit quantum dynamics.
We discuss a semiclassical approach to solve the quantum impurity model within nonequilibrium dynamical mean-field theory for electron-lattice models. The effect of electronic fluctuations on the phonon is kept beyond Ehrenfest dynamics, leading to a stochastic phonon evolution with damping and noise terms that are self-consistently determined by the electronic correlation functions in the fluctuating phonon field. Together with a solution of the electronic model based on a nonperturbative quantum Boltzmann equation, the approach can be used to address the coupled dynamics of the electrons and the lattice during photoinduced phase transitions. Results for the Anderson-Holstein model are benchmarked against numerically exact quantum Monte Carlo data. We find good agreement for the phonon distribution function at temperatures comparable to the charge ordering temperature. The general formulation can be extended to models with electron-electron interactions or multiorbital systems.
We consider an Ehrenfest approximation for a particle in a double-well potential in the presence of an external environment schematized as a finite resource heat bath. This allows us to explore how the limitations in the applicability of Ehrenfest dynamics to nonlinear systems are modified in an open system setting. Within this framework, we have identified an environment-induced spontaneous symmetry breaking mechanism, and we argue that the Ehrenfest approximation becomes increasingly valid in the limit of strong coupling to the external reservoir, either in the form of an increasing number of oscillators or increasing temperature. The analysis also suggests a rather intuitive picture for the general phenomenon of quantum tunneling and its interplay with classical thermal activation processes, which may be of relevance in physical chemistry, ultracold atom physics, and fast-switching dynamics such as in superconducting digital electronics.
Electron and phonon correlations in systems of one-dimensional electrons coupled to phonons are studied at low temperatures by emphasizing on the effect of electron-phonon backward scattering. It is found that the 2kF2{k}_{F}2kF​-wave components of the electron density and phonon displacement field share the same correlations. Both correlations are quasi-long-ranged for a single conducting chain coupled to one-dimensional or three-dimensional phonons, and they are long-ranged for repulsive electron-electron interactions for a three-dimensional array of parallel one-dimensional conducting chains coupled to three-dimensional phonons.