Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1210.7234 · The Journal of Chemical Physics

Polaron formation: Ehrenfest dynamics vs. exact results

Guangqi Li, Bijan Movaghar, Abraham Nitzan, Mark A. Ratner

Published Jan 28, 2013• 28 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We use a one-dimensional tight binding model with an impurity site characterized by electron-vibration coupling, to describe electron transfer and localization at zero temperature, aiming to examine the process of polaron formation in this system. In particular we focus on comparing a semiclassical approach that describes nuclear motion in this many vibronic-states system on the Ehrenfest dynamics level to a numerically exact fully quantum calculation based on the Bonca-Trugman method [J. Bonča and S. A. Trugman, Phys. Rev. Lett. 75, 2566 (1995)]. In both approaches, thermal relaxation in the nuclear subspace is implemented in equivalent approximate ways: In the Ehrenfest calculation the uncoupled (to the electronic subsystem) motion of the classical (harmonic) oscillator is simply damped as would be implied by coupling to a Markovian zero temperature bath. In the quantum calculation, thermal relaxation is implemented by augmenting the Liouville equation for the oscillator density matrix with kinetic terms that account for the same relaxation. In both cases we calculate the probability to trap the electron by forming a polaron and the probability that it escapes to infinity. Comparing these calculations, we find that while both result in similar long time yields for these processes, the Ehrenfest-dynamics based calculation fails to account for the correct time scale for the polaron formation. This failure results, as usual, from the fact that at the early stage of polaron formation the classical nuclear dynamics takes place on an unphysical average potential surface that reflects the distributed electronic population in the system, while the quantum calculation accounts fully for correlations between the electronic and vibrational subsystems.

DOI
10.1063/1.4776230

Related papers

Dynamic electron localization initiated by particle-bath coupling

Guangqi Li, Bijan Movaghar, Mark A. Ratner

We consider the quantum evolution and relaxation of an electron or hole which is coupled to a set of bath modes. In most applications the bath modes would be the vibronic coordinates but the model considered applies to any type of dynamic boson environment. The method is developed specifically for the problem of dynamic polaron formation in small nonperiodic systems. It can describe a broad group of experimental situations, including in particular electron localization in organics and polymeric materials and devices. The immediate bath is allowed to dissipate energy to a secondary bath. The bath obeys classical dynamics which puts some restriction on the range of validity of this approach. Using the density matrix formalism on a tight binding model consisting of a linear chain coupled to vibronic coordinates, we demonstrate in real time how the interaction with a dissipative bath makes the initial quantum distribution reach a steady-state population. This calculation is based on the Ehrenfest dynamics approximation. As an example we consider coupling at a single impurity site and find that for given parameters (bath coupling, site energy, and relaxation rate), the particle becomes dynamically localized in space on a particular time scale. This localized particle can be called a polaron. We define a population formation time in the same way as done in the experimental measurement. This formation time is studied as a function of the coupling strength, bandwidth, and energy dissipation rate. Energy dissipation plays a crucial role in the spatial localization process. The formation time shortens as the electron-vibration coupling increases, and as the intersite tunneling increases, but lengthens with impurity trap depth. Polaron formation is suppressed for sufficiently wide electronic bands.

Physical Review B•Mar 6, 2013•11 citations

Electron-phonon interaction, localization, and polaron formation in one-dimensional systems

Georgios Kopidakis, C. M. Soukoulis, Eleftherios N. Economou

We present results for the time evolution of a one-dimensional system consisting of an electron, described by a tight-binding Hamiltonian and a harmonic latttice, coupled by a deformation-type potential. We solve numerically the nonlinear system of equations of motion for this model in order to study the effects of varying the electronic effective mass for several initial conditions and coupling strengths. Different types of localized and extended states are formed with features that are absent from the traditional polaronic states and depend very strongly on the initial electronic configuration and effective mass in a very often unexpected manner. We find that, in general, an increase of the initial electronic energy decreases the ability of the system to form localized states. However, a large effective mass favors localized polaron formation for initially localized electrons, but this is not always the case for initially extended electronic states. In the latter case, increasing the effective mass of an electron initially close to the bottom of the band makes localization more difficult, while for an initially highly excited electron, localized polaron formation is possible only when the electronic effective mass and the atomic masses of the lattice become of the same order. Finally, for a small parameter range, we find an impressive recurrence, a periodic and a complete exchange between the electronic and vibrational degrees of freedom of a small part of the initial electronic energy.

Physical review. B, Condensed matter•Jun 1, 1995•50 citations

The Ehrenfest approximation for electrons coupled to a phonon system

J le Page, Daniel R. Mason, W. M. C. Foulkes

We investigate the accuracy of the Ehrenfest approximation for a solid modelled as an independent electron system coupled to a many-mode phonon system. We construct a quantum to classical correspondence which we use to set the initial conditions of the Ehrenfest approximation given an initial density matrix. We find that the Ehrenfest approximation is accurate when the temperature of the phonon system is much higher than the temperature of the electron system. It is therefore reasonable to use the Ehrenfest approximation in the simulation of the later stages of radiation damage processes. We trace the failure of the Ehrenfest approximation to the absence of a term accounting for spontaneous phonon emission. The analytical work is validated numerically for the model system of a single oscillator coupled to electrons on a one-dimensional chain.

Journal of Physics Condensed Matter•Feb 27, 2008•31 citations

Real-time non-adiabatic dynamics in the one-dimensional Holstein model: Trajectory-based vs exact methods

Martijn ten Brink, S. Gräber, Miroslav Hopjan +4 more

We benchmark a set of quantum-chemistry methods, including multitrajectory Ehrenfest, fewest-switches surface-hopping, and multiconfigurational-Ehrenfest dynamics, against exact quantum-many-body techniques by studying real-time dynamics in the Holstein model. This is a paradigmatic model in condensed matter theory incorporating a local coupling of electrons to Einstein phonons. For the two-site and three-site Holstein model, we discuss the exact and quantum-chemistry methods in terms of the Born-Huang formalism, covering different initial states, which either start on a single Born-Oppenheimer surface, or with the electron localized to a single site. For extended systems with up to 51 sites, we address both the physics of single Holstein polarons and the dynamics of charge-density waves at finite electron densities. For these extended systems, we compare the quantum-chemistry methods to exact dynamics obtained from time-dependent density matrix renormalization group calculations with local basis optimization (DMRG-LBO). We observe that the multitrajectory Ehrenfest method, in general, only captures the ultrashort time dynamics accurately. In contrast, the surface-hopping method with suitable corrections provides a much better description of the long-time behavior but struggles with the short-time description of coherences between different Born-Oppenheimer states. We show that the multiconfigurational Ehrenfest method yields a significant improvement over the multitrajectory Ehrenfest method and can be converged to the exact results in small systems with moderate computational efforts. We further observe that for extended systems, this convergence is slower with respect to the number of configurations. Our benchmark study demonstrates that DMRG-LBO is a useful tool for assessing the quality of the quantum-chemistry methods.

arXiv:2203.07245•The Journal of Chemical Physics•Jun 17, 2022•22 citations

Quantum versus semiclassical description of self-trapping: Anharmonic effects

S. Raghavan, A. R. Bishop, V. M. Kenkre

Self-trapping has been traditionally studied on the assumption that quasiparticles interact with harmonic phonons and that this interaction is linear in the displacement of the phonon. To complement recent semiclassical studies of anharmonicity and nonlinearity in this context, we present below a fully quantum-mechanical analysis of a two-site system, where the oscillator is described by a tunably anharmonic potential, with a square well with infinite walls and the harmonic potential as its extreme limits, and wherein the interaction is nonlinear in the oscillator displacement. We find that even highly anharmonic polarons behave similar to their harmonic counterparts in that self-trapping is preserved for long times in the limit of strong coupling, and that the polaronic tunneling time scale depends exponentially on the polaron binding energy. Further, in agreement, with earlier results related to harmonic polarons, the semiclassical approximation agrees with the full quantum result in the massive oscillator limit of small oscillator frequency and strong quasiparticle-oscillator coupling.

arXiv:cond-mat/9902058•Physical review. B, Condensed matter•Apr 15, 1999•10 citations

Capturing Transient Polaron Formation Dynamics: A Time-Dependent Polaron Transformation Approach

Zeyu Dong, Wenxiang Ying, Feng-Feng Song +2 more

Abstract Static polaron transformations impose an equilibrium environmental displacement at the initial time and can therefore misrepresent transient polaron formation. We introduce a time-dependent (TD) polaron transformation that describes the dynamical formation of polarons. We first present the TD polaron transformation for the spin–boson model via an infinite sequence of interaction-picture transformations. Each transformation in the sequence cancels the residual term generated by its predecessor; the ordered transformation sequence combines exactly into a displacement operator whose amplitude is zero at the initial time. We then generalize this recursive elimination to any suitably partitioned Hamiltonian. When the generated operator algebra closes, the ordered sequence of transformations reduces to an exact closed form; otherwise, a truncated sequence provides a systematic short-time approximation. For the transformed spin–boson Hamiltonian, we derive a second-order Nakajima–Zwanzig quantum master equation with two-time bath correlation functions. We benchmark this quantum master equation against numerically exact matrix-product-state dynamics and hierarchical equations of motion using Landau–Zener sweeps coupled to a thermal bath, whose tunable crossing time acts as a clock for polaron formation. We find that the TD-polaron quantum master equation outperforms the static formulation in regimes where transient polaron formation competes with the system evolution. The TD-polaron transformation is therefore applicable to nonequilibrium processes such as sudden charge injection, while the underlying sequential elimination scheme extends to other suitably partitioned Hamiltonians.

Journal of Chemical Theory and Computation•Nov 3, 2026•0 citations
We use a one-dimensional tight binding model with an impurity site characterized by electron-vibration coupling, to describe electron transfer and localization at zero temperature, aiming to examine the process of polaron formation in this system. In particular we focus on comparing a semiclassical approach that describes nuclear motion in this many vibronic-states system on the Ehrenfest dynamics level to a numerically exact fully quantum calculation based on the Bonca-Trugman method [J. Bonča and S. A. Trugman, Phys. Rev. Lett. 75, 2566 (1995)]. In both approaches, thermal relaxation in the nuclear subspace is implemented in equivalent approximate ways: In the Ehrenfest calculation the uncoupled (to the electronic subsystem) motion of the classical (harmonic) oscillator is simply damped as would be implied by coupling to a Markovian zero temperature bath. In the quantum calculation, thermal relaxation is implemented by augmenting the Liouville equation for the oscillator density matrix with kinetic terms that account for the same relaxation. In both cases we calculate the probability to trap the electron by forming a polaron and the probability that it escapes to infinity. Comparing these calculations, we find that while both result in similar long time yields for these processes, the Ehrenfest-dynamics based calculation fails to account for the correct time scale for the polaron formation. This failure results, as usual, from the fact that at the early stage of polaron formation the classical nuclear dynamics takes place on an unphysical average potential surface that reflects the distributed electronic population in the system, while the quantum calculation accounts fully for correlations between the electronic and vibrational subsystems.
We consider the quantum evolution and relaxation of an electron or hole which is coupled to a set of bath modes. In most applications the bath modes would be the vibronic coordinates but the model considered applies to any type of dynamic boson environment. The method is developed specifically for the problem of dynamic polaron formation in small nonperiodic systems. It can describe a broad group of experimental situations, including in particular electron localization in organics and polymeric materials and devices. The immediate bath is allowed to dissipate energy to a secondary bath. The bath obeys classical dynamics which puts some restriction on the range of validity of this approach. Using the density matrix formalism on a tight binding model consisting of a linear chain coupled to vibronic coordinates, we demonstrate in real time how the interaction with a dissipative bath makes the initial quantum distribution reach a steady-state population. This calculation is based on the Ehrenfest dynamics approximation. As an example we consider coupling at a single impurity site and find that for given parameters (bath coupling, site energy, and relaxation rate), the particle becomes dynamically localized in space on a particular time scale. This localized particle can be called a polaron. We define a population formation time in the same way as done in the experimental measurement. This formation time is studied as a function of the coupling strength, bandwidth, and energy dissipation rate. Energy dissipation plays a crucial role in the spatial localization process. The formation time shortens as the electron-vibration coupling increases, and as the intersite tunneling increases, but lengthens with impurity trap depth. Polaron formation is suppressed for sufficiently wide electronic bands.
We present results for the time evolution of a one-dimensional system consisting of an electron, described by a tight-binding Hamiltonian and a harmonic latttice, coupled by a deformation-type potential. We solve numerically the nonlinear system of equations of motion for this model in order to study the effects of varying the electronic effective mass for several initial conditions and coupling strengths. Different types of localized and extended states are formed with features that are absent from the traditional polaronic states and depend very strongly on the initial electronic configuration and effective mass in a very often unexpected manner. We find that, in general, an increase of the initial electronic energy decreases the ability of the system to form localized states. However, a large effective mass favors localized polaron formation for initially localized electrons, but this is not always the case for initially extended electronic states. In the latter case, increasing the effective mass of an electron initially close to the bottom of the band makes localization more difficult, while for an initially highly excited electron, localized polaron formation is possible only when the electronic effective mass and the atomic masses of the lattice become of the same order. Finally, for a small parameter range, we find an impressive recurrence, a periodic and a complete exchange between the electronic and vibrational degrees of freedom of a small part of the initial electronic energy.
We investigate the accuracy of the Ehrenfest approximation for a solid modelled as an independent electron system coupled to a many-mode phonon system. We construct a quantum to classical correspondence which we use to set the initial conditions of the Ehrenfest approximation given an initial density matrix. We find that the Ehrenfest approximation is accurate when the temperature of the phonon system is much higher than the temperature of the electron system. It is therefore reasonable to use the Ehrenfest approximation in the simulation of the later stages of radiation damage processes. We trace the failure of the Ehrenfest approximation to the absence of a term accounting for spontaneous phonon emission. The analytical work is validated numerically for the model system of a single oscillator coupled to electrons on a one-dimensional chain.
We benchmark a set of quantum-chemistry methods, including multitrajectory Ehrenfest, fewest-switches surface-hopping, and multiconfigurational-Ehrenfest dynamics, against exact quantum-many-body techniques by studying real-time dynamics in the Holstein model. This is a paradigmatic model in condensed matter theory incorporating a local coupling of electrons to Einstein phonons. For the two-site and three-site Holstein model, we discuss the exact and quantum-chemistry methods in terms of the Born-Huang formalism, covering different initial states, which either start on a single Born-Oppenheimer surface, or with the electron localized to a single site. For extended systems with up to 51 sites, we address both the physics of single Holstein polarons and the dynamics of charge-density waves at finite electron densities. For these extended systems, we compare the quantum-chemistry methods to exact dynamics obtained from time-dependent density matrix renormalization group calculations with local basis optimization (DMRG-LBO). We observe that the multitrajectory Ehrenfest method, in general, only captures the ultrashort time dynamics accurately. In contrast, the surface-hopping method with suitable corrections provides a much better description of the long-time behavior but struggles with the short-time description of coherences between different Born-Oppenheimer states. We show that the multiconfigurational Ehrenfest method yields a significant improvement over the multitrajectory Ehrenfest method and can be converged to the exact results in small systems with moderate computational efforts. We further observe that for extended systems, this convergence is slower with respect to the number of configurations. Our benchmark study demonstrates that DMRG-LBO is a useful tool for assessing the quality of the quantum-chemistry methods.
Self-trapping has been traditionally studied on the assumption that quasiparticles interact with harmonic phonons and that this interaction is linear in the displacement of the phonon. To complement recent semiclassical studies of anharmonicity and nonlinearity in this context, we present below a fully quantum-mechanical analysis of a two-site system, where the oscillator is described by a tunably anharmonic potential, with a square well with infinite walls and the harmonic potential as its extreme limits, and wherein the interaction is nonlinear in the oscillator displacement. We find that even highly anharmonic polarons behave similar to their harmonic counterparts in that self-trapping is preserved for long times in the limit of strong coupling, and that the polaronic tunneling time scale depends exponentially on the polaron binding energy. Further, in agreement, with earlier results related to harmonic polarons, the semiclassical approximation agrees with the full quantum result in the massive oscillator limit of small oscillator frequency and strong quasiparticle-oscillator coupling.
Abstract Static polaron transformations impose an equilibrium environmental displacement at the initial time and can therefore misrepresent transient polaron formation. We introduce a time-dependent (TD) polaron transformation that describes the dynamical formation of polarons. We first present the TD polaron transformation for the spin–boson model via an infinite sequence of interaction-picture transformations. Each transformation in the sequence cancels the residual term generated by its predecessor; the ordered transformation sequence combines exactly into a displacement operator whose amplitude is zero at the initial time. We then generalize this recursive elimination to any suitably partitioned Hamiltonian. When the generated operator algebra closes, the ordered sequence of transformations reduces to an exact closed form; otherwise, a truncated sequence provides a systematic short-time approximation. For the transformed spin–boson Hamiltonian, we derive a second-order Nakajima–Zwanzig quantum master equation with two-time bath correlation functions. We benchmark this quantum master equation against numerically exact matrix-product-state dynamics and hierarchical equations of motion using Landau–Zener sweeps coupled to a thermal bath, whose tunable crossing time acts as a clock for polaron formation. We find that the TD-polaron quantum master equation outperforms the static formulation in regimes where transient polaron formation competes with the system evolution. The TD-polaron transformation is therefore applicable to nonequilibrium processes such as sudden charge injection, while the underlying sequential elimination scheme extends to other suitably partitioned Hamiltonians.