Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Applied Physics Letters

X-ray detection using a superconducting transition-edge sensor microcalorimeter with electrothermal feedback

K. D. Irwin, Gene C Hilton, David A. Wollman, John M. Martinis

Published Sep 23, 1996• 230 citations
Publisher

Abstract

We have developed a new type of x-ray detector based on a superconducting transition-edge thermometer operated near 100 mK. A superconducting quantum interference device is used to measure the current through the thermometer, and negative electrothermal feedback is used to improve the energy resolution and shorten the thermal time constant. We have used a detector mounted on a scanning electron microscope to measure the energy of titanium Kα (4.5 keV) fluorescence x rays with a resolution better than 14 eV full width at half-maximum. Using two other devices, we have measured an energy resolution for Joule heat pulses of 2.6 eV at 1 keV and 0.2 eV at 4 eV, the best reported for any calorimeter. An electrical noise equivalent power of 3×10−18 W/√Hz was also measured, suggesting the use of these detectors as infrared bolometers.

DOI
10.1063/1.117630

Related papers

A superconducting bolometer with strong electrothermal feedback

Adrian Tae-Jin Lee, Paul L. Richards, Sae Woo Nam +2 more

We present a theoretical analysis and experimental evaluation of a transition-edge superconducting bolometer for detecting infrared and millimeter waves. The superconducting film is voltage biased and the current is read by a superconducting quantum interference device ammeter. Strong electrothermal feedback maintains the sensor temperature within the transition, gives a current responsivity that is simply the inverse of the bias voltage, and reduces the response time by several orders of magnitude below the intrinsic time constant C/G. We evaluated a voltage-biased bolometer that operates on the Tc∼95 mK transition of a tungsten film with a thermal conductance of G∼1.2×10−9 W/K. As expected, the electrical noise equivalent power of 3.3×10−17/W√Hz is close to the thermal fluctuation noise limit and is lower than that of other technologies for these values of G and temperature. The measured time constant of 10 μs is ∼100 times faster than the intrinsic time constant.

Applied Physics Letters•Sep 16, 1996•203 citations

Voltage-biased superconducting transition-edge bolometer with strong electrothermal feedback operated at 370 mK

Shih-Fu Lee, Jan M. Gildemeister, Warren A. Holmes +2 more

We present an experimental study of a composite voltage-biased superconducting bolometer (VSB). The tested VSB consists of a Ti-film superconducting thermometer (T(c) ~375 mK) on a Si substrate suspended by NbTi superconducting leads. A resistor attached to the substrate provides calibrated heat input into the bolometer. The current through the bolometer is measured with a superconducting quantum interference device ammeter. Strong negative electrothermal feedback fixes the bolometer temperature at T(c) and reduces the measured response time from 2.6 s to 13 ms. As predicted, the measured current responsivity of the bolometer is equal to the inverse of the bias voltage. A noise equivalent power of 5 x 10(-17) W/ radicalHz was measured for a thermal conductance G ~ 4.7 x 10(-10) W/K, which is consistent with the expected thermal noise. Excess noise was observed for bias conditions for which the electrothermal feedback strength was close to maximum.

Applied Optics•Jun 1, 1998•98 citations

Low-noise microwave SQUID multiplexed readout of 38 x-ray transition-edge sensor microcalorimeters

Y. Nakashima, Fuminori Hirayama, Satoshi Kohjiro +15 more

We report very-low-noise, fast-response, middle-scale multiplexing in a microwave superconducting quantum interference device multiplexer (MW-Mux) as a transition-edge sensor (TES) readout. Our MW-Mux is able to read 40 channels with 500 kHz sampling and has a low readout noise of 0.9 μΦ0/Hz (where Φ0 is the magnetic flux quantum), equivalent to 9 pA/Hz. By contrast, a multiplexer of less than 10 pixels with 500 kHz sampling and ∼2 μΦ0/Hz readout noise has so far been reported in the literature. Owing to the 500 kHz sampling, our MW-Mux exhibits a fast response to detect a TES pulse with a rise time around 12 μs. We demonstrated simultaneous readout of 38 pixels from an array of x-ray TES microcalorimeters. The measured full-width values at half-maximum spectral resolution ranged from 2.79 to 4.56 eV, with a median value of 3.30 eV at 5.9 keV, including a ∼10% contribution of readout noise, i.e., 0.9–1.7 eV.

Applied Physics Letters•Sep 21, 2020•30 citations

Noise properties of high-T c superconducting transition edge bolometers with electrothermal feedback

I. A. Khrebtov, Konstantin V. Ivanov, V. G. Malyarov

Numerical and experimental modeling of the characteristics (sensitivity, constant time, noise properties) of high-Tc transition edge superconducting bolometers, operating in the various modes with an electrothermal feedback, are carried out: the mode with constant bias current, i.e. passive positive electrothermal feedback, the mode with constant bias voltage, i.e. passive negative electrothermal feedback and the mode with active electronic negative electrothermal feedback . It is shown, that in the modes with negative electrothermal feedback it is possible essentially to reduce constant time of bolometers till 5-15 of times in at some prize of the noise equivalent power on high frequencies. The estimation of influence of various noise components on a performance of the bolometers, operating with positive or negative electrothermal feedbacks, is carried out at the variation of bolometer parameters.

Proceedings of SPIE, the International Society for Optical Engineering/Proceedings of SPIE•Jun 7, 2007•1 citation

Titanium TES based photon number resolving detectors with 1 MHz counting rate and 65% quantum efficiency

Daiji Fukuda, Go Fujii, Takayuki Numata +4 more

A transition edge sensor (TES) is one of superconducting photon detectors, which has a photon number resolving ability in light pulses. The TES device is a kind of calorimeters operated at an extremely low temperature, and the energy of the photons is measured as a resistance change in a superconducting transition region of the TES. The advantages of the TESs are an excellent energy resolution and a high quantum efficiency. However a response speed is limited due to slow thermal recovery time. To overcome this, we fabricated new TES devices which are based on a titanium superconductor. The critical temperature of our titanium films is around 410 mK, which greatly improves the thermal recovery time. The observed decay time constant of response signals to the light pulses is around several hundreds of ns, that make it possible to operate the devices at a counting rate over 1 MHz. The photon number resolving power is 0.35 eV(FWHM) for a 5 μm size device even at the high operating temperature. The system quantum efficiency is 65 % by embedding the TES films in an optical structure with a high reflection dielectric mirror and an anti-reflection coatings fabricated by an ion beam assisted sputtering method. These features are very promising for high speed photon number resolving applications in the quantum information field.

Proceedings of SPIE, the International Society for Optical Engineering/Proceedings of SPIE•Dec 2, 2008•12 citations

Thermal-response time of superconducting transition-edge microcalorimeters

K. D. Irwin, Gene C Hilton, David A. Wollman +1 more

We investigate limits on the thermal-response time of superconducting transition-edge microcalorimeters. For operation at 0.1 K, we show that the lower limit on the response time of a superconducting transition-edge microcalorimeter is of order 1 μs due to the heat diffusion time, electrical instabilities, the amplifier noise, and the critical current of the superconducting film. The response time is not limited by self-heating effects and is independent of the intended photon energy. However, design constraints associated with the inductance of the bias circuit make it difficult to achieve the fastest response times for devices with heat capacities high enough for x-ray and gamma-ray detection.

Journal of Applied Physics•Apr 15, 1998•176 citations
We have developed a new type of x-ray detector based on a superconducting transition-edge thermometer operated near 100 mK. A superconducting quantum interference device is used to measure the current through the thermometer, and negative electrothermal feedback is used to improve the energy resolution and shorten the thermal time constant. We have used a detector mounted on a scanning electron microscope to measure the energy of titanium Kα (4.5 keV) fluorescence x rays with a resolution better than 14 eV full width at half-maximum. Using two other devices, we have measured an energy resolution for Joule heat pulses of 2.6 eV at 1 keV and 0.2 eV at 4 eV, the best reported for any calorimeter. An electrical noise equivalent power of 3×10−18 W/√Hz was also measured, suggesting the use of these detectors as infrared bolometers.
We present a theoretical analysis and experimental evaluation of a transition-edge superconducting bolometer for detecting infrared and millimeter waves. The superconducting film is voltage biased and the current is read by a superconducting quantum interference device ammeter. Strong electrothermal feedback maintains the sensor temperature within the transition, gives a current responsivity that is simply the inverse of the bias voltage, and reduces the response time by several orders of magnitude below the intrinsic time constant C/G. We evaluated a voltage-biased bolometer that operates on the Tc∼95 mK transition of a tungsten film with a thermal conductance of G∼1.2×10−9 W/K. As expected, the electrical noise equivalent power of 3.3×10−17/W√Hz is close to the thermal fluctuation noise limit and is lower than that of other technologies for these values of G and temperature. The measured time constant of 10 μs is ∼100 times faster than the intrinsic time constant.
We present an experimental study of a composite voltage-biased superconducting bolometer (VSB). The tested VSB consists of a Ti-film superconducting thermometer (T(c) ~375 mK) on a Si substrate suspended by NbTi superconducting leads. A resistor attached to the substrate provides calibrated heat input into the bolometer. The current through the bolometer is measured with a superconducting quantum interference device ammeter. Strong negative electrothermal feedback fixes the bolometer temperature at T(c) and reduces the measured response time from 2.6 s to 13 ms. As predicted, the measured current responsivity of the bolometer is equal to the inverse of the bias voltage. A noise equivalent power of 5 x 10(-17) W/ radicalHz was measured for a thermal conductance G ~ 4.7 x 10(-10) W/K, which is consistent with the expected thermal noise. Excess noise was observed for bias conditions for which the electrothermal feedback strength was close to maximum.
We report very-low-noise, fast-response, middle-scale multiplexing in a microwave superconducting quantum interference device multiplexer (MW-Mux) as a transition-edge sensor (TES) readout. Our MW-Mux is able to read 40 channels with 500 kHz sampling and has a low readout noise of 0.9 μΦ0/Hz (where Φ0 is the magnetic flux quantum), equivalent to 9 pA/Hz. By contrast, a multiplexer of less than 10 pixels with 500 kHz sampling and ∼2 μΦ0/Hz readout noise has so far been reported in the literature. Owing to the 500 kHz sampling, our MW-Mux exhibits a fast response to detect a TES pulse with a rise time around 12 μs. We demonstrated simultaneous readout of 38 pixels from an array of x-ray TES microcalorimeters. The measured full-width values at half-maximum spectral resolution ranged from 2.79 to 4.56 eV, with a median value of 3.30 eV at 5.9 keV, including a ∼10% contribution of readout noise, i.e., 0.9–1.7 eV.
Numerical and experimental modeling of the characteristics (sensitivity, constant time, noise properties) of high-Tc transition edge superconducting bolometers, operating in the various modes with an electrothermal feedback, are carried out: the mode with constant bias current, i.e. passive positive electrothermal feedback, the mode with constant bias voltage, i.e. passive negative electrothermal feedback and the mode with active electronic negative electrothermal feedback . It is shown, that in the modes with negative electrothermal feedback it is possible essentially to reduce constant time of bolometers till 5-15 of times in at some prize of the noise equivalent power on high frequencies. The estimation of influence of various noise components on a performance of the bolometers, operating with positive or negative electrothermal feedbacks, is carried out at the variation of bolometer parameters.
A transition edge sensor (TES) is one of superconducting photon detectors, which has a photon number resolving ability in light pulses. The TES device is a kind of calorimeters operated at an extremely low temperature, and the energy of the photons is measured as a resistance change in a superconducting transition region of the TES. The advantages of the TESs are an excellent energy resolution and a high quantum efficiency. However a response speed is limited due to slow thermal recovery time. To overcome this, we fabricated new TES devices which are based on a titanium superconductor. The critical temperature of our titanium films is around 410 mK, which greatly improves the thermal recovery time. The observed decay time constant of response signals to the light pulses is around several hundreds of ns, that make it possible to operate the devices at a counting rate over 1 MHz. The photon number resolving power is 0.35 eV(FWHM) for a 5 μm size device even at the high operating temperature. The system quantum efficiency is 65 % by embedding the TES films in an optical structure with a high reflection dielectric mirror and an anti-reflection coatings fabricated by an ion beam assisted sputtering method. These features are very promising for high speed photon number resolving applications in the quantum information field.
We investigate limits on the thermal-response time of superconducting transition-edge microcalorimeters. For operation at 0.1 K, we show that the lower limit on the response time of a superconducting transition-edge microcalorimeter is of order 1 μs due to the heat diffusion time, electrical instabilities, the amplifier noise, and the critical current of the superconducting film. The response time is not limited by self-heating effects and is independent of the intended photon energy. However, design constraints associated with the inductance of the bias circuit make it difficult to achieve the fastest response times for devices with heat capacities high enough for x-ray and gamma-ray detection.