Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Foundations of Physics

On Wheeler's notion of “law without law” in physics

David Deutsch

Published Jun 1, 1986• 41 citations
Publisher
DOI
10.1007/bf01886521

Related papers

Law Without Law or “Just” Limit Theorems? Some Reflections About a Proposal of Wheeler’s

S. Caprara, Angelo Vulpiani

arXiv:1810.10278•Foundations of Physics•Aug 23, 2018•3 citations

Bohr’s “Phenomenon” and “Law Without Law”

JOHN ARCHIBALD WHEELER

NATO ASI series. Series B : Physics•Jan 1, 1985•7 citations

An All-Or-Nothing Flavor to the Church-Turing Hypothesis

Stefan Wolf

Landauer's principle claims that "Information is Physical." It is not surprising that its conceptual antithesis, Wheeler's "It from Bit," has been more popular among computer scientists --- in the form of the Church-Turing hypothesis: All natural processes can be computed by a universal Turing machine; physical laws then become descriptions of subsets of observable, as opposed to merely possible, computations. Switching back and forth between the two traditional styles of thought, motivated by quantum-physical Bell correlations and the doubts they raise about fundamental space-time causality, we look for an intrinsic, physical randomness notion and find one around the second law of thermodynamics. Bell correlations combined with complexity as randomness tell us that beyond-Turing computations are either physically impossible, or they can be carried out by "devices" as simple as individual photons.

arXiv:1702.00923•Feb 3, 2017•2 citations

The value of Einstein’s mistakes

Ravi V. Gomatam

Steven Weinberg writes, “Einstein rejected the notion that the laws of physics could deal with probabilities, famously decreeing that God does not play dice with the cosmos. But history gave its verdict against Einstein—quantum mechanics went on from success to success, leaving Einstein on the sidelines.”Einstein did not reject quantum theory merely because it is probabilistic. He wrote: “There is no doubt that quantum mechanics has seized hold of a beautiful element of truth, and that it will be a test stone for any future theoretical basis.” 1 1. A. Einstein, quoted in J. Wheeler, W. Zurek, Quantum Theory and Measurement, Princeton U. Press, Princeton, NJ (1983), p. 8. Nor was Einstein unilaterally opposed to God playing dice. He expected God to either play dice all the way or not at all. If individual events were totally undetermined, then the overall events should also be undetermined, and not display remarkable regularity. “In for the penny, in for the pound,” he wrote. Thus, a more accurate quote from Einstein about God and dice playing is the following:“That the Lord should play with dice, all right; but that He should gamble according to definite rules, that is beyond me.” 1 1. A. Einstein, quoted in J. Wheeler, W. Zurek, Quantum Theory and Measurement, Princeton U. Press, Princeton, NJ (1983), p. 8. REFERENCESection:ChooseTop of pageREFERENCE <<1. A. Einstein, quoted in J. Wheeler, W. Zurek, Quantum Theory and Measurement, Princeton U. Press, Princeton, NJ (1983), p. 8. Google Scholar© 2006 American Institute of Physics.

Physics Today•Apr 1, 2006•0 citations

The Tao of It and Bit

Ovidiu Cristinel Stoica

The main mystery of quantum mechanics is contained in Wheeler's delayed choice experiment, which shows that the past is determined by our choice of what quantum property to observe. This gives the observer a participatory role in deciding the past history of the universe. Wheeler extended this participatory role to the emergence of the physical laws ("law without law"). Since what we know about the universe comes in yes/no answers to our interrogations, this led him to the idea of "it from bit" (which includes the participatory role of the observer as a key component). The yes/no answers to our observations ("bit") should always be compatible with the existence of at least a possible reality - a global solution ("it") of the Schrodinger equation. I argue that there is in fact an interplay between "it" and "bit". The requirement of global consistency leads to apparently acausal and nonlocal behavior, explaining the weirdness of quantum phenomena. As an interpretation of Wheeler's "it from bit" and "law without law", I discuss the possibility that the universe is mathematical, and that there is a "mother of all possible worlds" - named the "Axiom Zero".

arXiv:1311.0765•Nov 4, 2013•9 citations

On the Classical Limits of Physics

Valia Allori, Nino Zanghì

•Jan 1, 2009•0 citations
Landauer's principle claims that "Information is Physical." It is not surprising that its conceptual antithesis, Wheeler's "It from Bit," has been more popular among computer scientists --- in the form of the Church-Turing hypothesis: All natural processes can be computed by a universal Turing machine; physical laws then become descriptions of subsets of observable, as opposed to merely possible, computations. Switching back and forth between the two traditional styles of thought, motivated by quantum-physical Bell correlations and the doubts they raise about fundamental space-time causality, we look for an intrinsic, physical randomness notion and find one around the second law of thermodynamics. Bell correlations combined with complexity as randomness tell us that beyond-Turing computations are either physically impossible, or they can be carried out by "devices" as simple as individual photons.
Steven Weinberg writes, “Einstein rejected the notion that the laws of physics could deal with probabilities, famously decreeing that God does not play dice with the cosmos. But history gave its verdict against Einstein—quantum mechanics went on from success to success, leaving Einstein on the sidelines.”Einstein did not reject quantum theory merely because it is probabilistic. He wrote: “There is no doubt that quantum mechanics has seized hold of a beautiful element of truth, and that it will be a test stone for any future theoretical basis.” 1 1. A. Einstein, quoted in J. Wheeler, W. Zurek, Quantum Theory and Measurement, Princeton U. Press, Princeton, NJ (1983), p. 8. Nor was Einstein unilaterally opposed to God playing dice. He expected God to either play dice all the way or not at all. If individual events were totally undetermined, then the overall events should also be undetermined, and not display remarkable regularity. “In for the penny, in for the pound,” he wrote. Thus, a more accurate quote from Einstein about God and dice playing is the following:“That the Lord should play with dice, all right; but that He should gamble according to definite rules, that is beyond me.” 1 1. A. Einstein, quoted in J. Wheeler, W. Zurek, Quantum Theory and Measurement, Princeton U. Press, Princeton, NJ (1983), p. 8. REFERENCESection:ChooseTop of pageREFERENCE <<1. A. Einstein, quoted in J. Wheeler, W. Zurek, Quantum Theory and Measurement, Princeton U. Press, Princeton, NJ (1983), p. 8. Google Scholar© 2006 American Institute of Physics.
The main mystery of quantum mechanics is contained in Wheeler's delayed choice experiment, which shows that the past is determined by our choice of what quantum property to observe. This gives the observer a participatory role in deciding the past history of the universe. Wheeler extended this participatory role to the emergence of the physical laws ("law without law"). Since what we know about the universe comes in yes/no answers to our interrogations, this led him to the idea of "it from bit" (which includes the participatory role of the observer as a key component). The yes/no answers to our observations ("bit") should always be compatible with the existence of at least a possible reality - a global solution ("it") of the Schrodinger equation. I argue that there is in fact an interplay between "it" and "bit". The requirement of global consistency leads to apparently acausal and nonlocal behavior, explaining the weirdness of quantum phenomena. As an interpretation of Wheeler's "it from bit" and "law without law", I discuss the possibility that the universe is mathematical, and that there is a "mother of all possible worlds" - named the "Axiom Zero".