Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Journal of Physics B Atomic and Molecular Physics

Collision problems with identical particles

Françoise Masnou-Seeuws, A. Salin

Published Dec 1, 1969• 14 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Attention is drawn to a method, formulated by Feynmann, which gives a straightforward derivation of the cross section in the case of collisions between identical particles. The difficulties encountered in the interpretation of the scattering amplitudes are stressed when the wave function is symmetrized. Ways of avoiding these difficulties are discussed, showing that it is easier to refer to physical experiments with fixed apparatus.

DOI
10.1088/0022-3700/2/12/304

Related papers

Wave packets in the quantum theory of collisions

M. I. Shirokov

Two methodological difficulties of the quantum theory of collisions are considered. The first is the undesirable interference of the incident and scattered waves in the stationary approach to scattering. The second concerns the nonstationary approach to the theory of collisions of the type a + b → c + d. In order to calculate the cross section one uses the matrix element 〈cd|S|ab〉 of the S-matrix. The element is proportional to δ-function expressing the energy conservation. The corresponding probability |〈cd|S|ab〉|2 contains δ2, which is mathematically meaningless. The known regular way to overcome the difficulty seems to be unsatisfactory. In this paper, both the problems are resolved using wave packets of incident particles.

Physics of Particles and Nuclei•Jan 1, 2008•2 citations

The collision between two electrons

N. F. Mott

Abstract It is well-known that the problem of the collision between two particles interacting according to the inverse square law is exactly soluble on the wave mechanics, and that the solution yields the same scattering laws as the classical theory. If, however, the two particles are identical, e.g., two electrons or two α-particles, this is not necessarily the case; for the wave functions used must be antisymmetrical or symmetrical in the co-ordinates of the two particles; and this may affect the scattering laws. In this paper we shall discuss the collision between two particles possessing spin, such as electrons, and also between two particles without spin, such as α-particles. Assuming an inverse square law force between the particles, and neglecting the actual spin forces, we shall deduce from the symmetry properties of the wave functions a scatter­ing law differing considerably from the classical. We shall also mention the various methods by which the effect could be observed, and give some experi­mental evidence in its favour. The application of the exclusion principle to collision problems has been discussed by the author in a previous paper. Suppose we wish to describe the motion of two particles interacting in any field of force. We obtain a solution w(r1 r2) of the wave equation, where r1 refers to the position of the first particle, and r2 to that of the second. If we did not use antisymmetrical wave functions, we should argue that the probability that the first particle should be at r1 and the second at r 2 would be |w (r1 r2)|2, and therefore the probability that one particle should be at r1 and the other at r2 would be |w (r1 r2)|2 + |w(r2 r1)|

Proceedings of the Royal Society of London Series A Containing Papers of a Mathematical and Physical Character•Jan 1, 1930•226 citations

An unambiguous method of avoiding divergence difficulties in quantum theory [67]

THE classical theory of a point charge and the quantum theory of wave packets contain in their usual form well-known divergences. Dirae1 has elaborated a classical particle theory which avoids these difficulties, but his results cannot as yet be applied to quantum theory. On the other hand, Heisenberg1 has recently proposed a new formalism which permits the calculation of collision cross-sections in quantum theory without being disturbed by diverging terms. However, no connecting link such as the correspondence principle has been given in order to apply this quantum formalism to a given problem such as Rutherford scattering, Compton effect or radiation damping.

Birkhäuser Basel eBooks•Jan 1, 2009•1 citation

A collision problem in the wave mechanics

C. G. DARWIN

Abstract In the present work the wave mechanics are applied to the discussion of a collision problem of a more complicated type than has, I think, hitherto been done. Though there is nothing very new in the process it is rather interesting to see how a wave function behaves which involves two bodies, and is therefore outside our ordinary space intuitions. But the work had a much more general aim, as an attempt to see whether a sharper line of demarcation could be drawn between the particle-like and the wave-like properties of matter. Put briefly, I take a problem which would be regarded at first sight as irreconcilable with a pure wave theory, but thoroughly typical of the behaviour of particles, and show how in fact the correct result arises naturally from the consideration of wave alone. I have been led in this way to certain not very original speculation on the basis of the quantum theory and these are given at the end of the paper. These are not in the least intended to be a general formulation of the theory, but rather as an examination of a particular type of attempted formulation. I fear that the views expressed will be found partly obvious and perhaps partly inconsistent or even erroneous. My excuse for giving them is that the quantum theory seem already sufficiently developed for us to attempt something more than a mathematical formulation of it, and that a generally accepted physical understanding will be more quickly reached by agreement or disagreement with expressed opinions, than by waiting for the arrival of a full-grown theory. It has been an extraordinarily difficult task to express the ideas I intended, and I wish to thank Prof. D. R. Hartree for many valuable criticisms of my first attempts to do so, though he must be exonerated from all blame if the final result is unintelligible or erroneous. 1. The quantum mechanics have been expressed in a variety of ways, which place the emphasis differently, but it has been shown that they are all exactly equivalent, so what may choose which we will. I shall use the following description, limiting myself to the simpler cases which do not involve considerations of relativity. We take a partial differential equation of the wave type, set down according to certain rules depending on the particular system considered. We solve this subject to certain boundary conditions, expressive of all the limitations imposed by silts, mirrors, diffraction, gratings, moving shutters, etc., that may occur in the proposed system, and obtain as result the wave function Ψ, a function of all the co-ordinates of the system and of the time. From this we from a set of functions, of which the simplest is |Ψ|2; this process may be called taking the intensities. We next have to prepare for the particle aspect, by applying certain rules so as to normalise the intensities, a process entirely foreign to the idea of waves. Finally, we make the interpretation, in which we say that the normalised intensities measure the probability of the particles having such and such positions, momenta, energies, etc., and these are the results verified by observation.

Proceedings of the Royal Society of London Series A Containing Papers of a Mathematical and Physical Character•Jun 4, 1929•49 citations

The quantum mechanical theory of collisions

Roy J. Glauber

The Quantum Mechanical Theory of Collis3ions. I»-In the present course we shall consider the quantum mechanical treatment of problems of particle interactions in which at least one of the particles is unbound and therefore able to travel large distances freely.In effect such particles are able to communicate the results of their interaction directly to macroscopic detection apparatus* The interpretation of the resulting data is in general the most direct way of forming conclusions about the interactions.A considerable variety of physical phenomena involves unbound particles» Among the simplest are scattering processes ;in particular the deflection of particles from a collinated beam.More general collision processes which induce reactions of various sorts also lie within the class we shall examine, Our chief concern willbe with the means of solving problems in which well-defined models have been postulated to describe the basic interactions.We shall restrict ourselves, in fact, to the treatment of fairly simple models, and shall discuss a number of approaches to the problems they raise.We begin by discussing the scattering of particles by a simple potential field, fixed in space» The problem of two free particles with a potential between them of course assumes this form in the center-of-mass system.By imagining that a beam of particles of constant strenght is at all times being scattered by the potential, we cay seek to describe the situation with the stationary-state Schrb'dinger equation.

•Jan 1, 1954•0 citations

Coupled-Equations Method for the Scattering of Identical Particles

F. S. Levin

The completely antisymmetric solution ${\ensuremath{\Psi}}^{A}$ to the problem of the scattering of a fermion by a finite system of identical fermions is studied by means of the expansion ${\ensuremath{\Psi}}^{A}=\ensuremath{\Sigma}{\ensuremath{\phi}}_{\ensuremath{\alpha}}{\ensuremath{\psi}}_{\ensuremath{\alpha}}$, where ${{\ensuremath{\phi}}_{\ensuremath{\alpha}}}$ is a complete set of antisymmetric states for the target and ${\ensuremath{\psi}}_{\ensuremath{\alpha}}$ are one-particle functions. Coupled equations for the ${\ensuremath{\psi}}_{\ensuremath{\alpha}}$ are found that obey the proper boundary conditions. This is done by means of the integral equation for ${\ensuremath{\Psi}}^{A}$ and the use of projection operators. The elastic-scattering (optical-model) wave function ${\ensuremath{\psi}}_{0}$ is shown to obey an inhomogeneous differential equation, rather than a Schr\"odinger equation. The homogeneous solution is identical to the elastic wave function obtained when the projectile is distinguishable, while the inhomogeneous solution is due entirely to exchange effects. The function ${\ensuremath{\psi}}_{0}$ is identical to the optical-model wave function found by Bell and Squires, who showed that ${\ensuremath{\psi}}_{0}$ obeys a Schr\"odinger equation with an optical potential containing direct and exchange contributions. It is shown that ${\ensuremath{\psi}}_{0}$ yields the exact elastic amplitude including direct and exchange contributions, and a phase-shift analysis of the exchange term is given. The more standard form of solution ${\ensuremath{\Psi}}^{A}=\ensuremath{\Sigma}\mathcal{a}{{\ensuremath{\phi}}_{\ensuremath{\alpha}}{f}_{\ensuremath{\alpha}}}$, where $\mathcal{a}$ is an antisymmetrizer, is briefly discussed. The extension to the cases of inelastic scattering and deuteron elastic scattering is made.

Physical Review•Nov 22, 1965•21 citations
Attention is drawn to a method, formulated by Feynmann, which gives a straightforward derivation of the cross section in the case of collisions between identical particles. The difficulties encountered in the interpretation of the scattering amplitudes are stressed when the wave function is symmetrized. Ways of avoiding these difficulties are discussed, showing that it is easier to refer to physical experiments with fixed apparatus.
Two methodological difficulties of the quantum theory of collisions are considered. The first is the undesirable interference of the incident and scattered waves in the stationary approach to scattering. The second concerns the nonstationary approach to the theory of collisions of the type a + b → c + d. In order to calculate the cross section one uses the matrix element 〈cd|S|ab〉 of the S-matrix. The element is proportional to δ-function expressing the energy conservation. The corresponding probability |〈cd|S|ab〉|2 contains δ2, which is mathematically meaningless. The known regular way to overcome the difficulty seems to be unsatisfactory. In this paper, both the problems are resolved using wave packets of incident particles.
Abstract It is well-known that the problem of the collision between two particles interacting according to the inverse square law is exactly soluble on the wave mechanics, and that the solution yields the same scattering laws as the classical theory. If, however, the two particles are identical, e.g., two electrons or two α-particles, this is not necessarily the case; for the wave functions used must be antisymmetrical or symmetrical in the co-ordinates of the two particles; and this may affect the scattering laws. In this paper we shall discuss the collision between two particles possessing spin, such as electrons, and also between two particles without spin, such as α-particles. Assuming an inverse square law force between the particles, and neglecting the actual spin forces, we shall deduce from the symmetry properties of the wave functions a scatter­ing law differing considerably from the classical. We shall also mention the various methods by which the effect could be observed, and give some experi­mental evidence in its favour. The application of the exclusion principle to collision problems has been discussed by the author in a previous paper. Suppose we wish to describe the motion of two particles interacting in any field of force. We obtain a solution w(r1 r2) of the wave equation, where r1 refers to the position of the first particle, and r2 to that of the second. If we did not use antisymmetrical wave functions, we should argue that the probability that the first particle should be at r1 and the second at r 2 would be |w (r1 r2)|2, and therefore the probability that one particle should be at r1 and the other at r2 would be |w (r1 r2)|2 + |w(r2 r1)|
THE classical theory of a point charge and the quantum theory of wave packets contain in their usual form well-known divergences. Dirae1 has elaborated a classical particle theory which avoids these difficulties, but his results cannot as yet be applied to quantum theory. On the other hand, Heisenberg1 has recently proposed a new formalism which permits the calculation of collision cross-sections in quantum theory without being disturbed by diverging terms. However, no connecting link such as the correspondence principle has been given in order to apply this quantum formalism to a given problem such as Rutherford scattering, Compton effect or radiation damping.
Abstract In the present work the wave mechanics are applied to the discussion of a collision problem of a more complicated type than has, I think, hitherto been done. Though there is nothing very new in the process it is rather interesting to see how a wave function behaves which involves two bodies, and is therefore outside our ordinary space intuitions. But the work had a much more general aim, as an attempt to see whether a sharper line of demarcation could be drawn between the particle-like and the wave-like properties of matter. Put briefly, I take a problem which would be regarded at first sight as irreconcilable with a pure wave theory, but thoroughly typical of the behaviour of particles, and show how in fact the correct result arises naturally from the consideration of wave alone. I have been led in this way to certain not very original speculation on the basis of the quantum theory and these are given at the end of the paper. These are not in the least intended to be a general formulation of the theory, but rather as an examination of a particular type of attempted formulation. I fear that the views expressed will be found partly obvious and perhaps partly inconsistent or even erroneous. My excuse for giving them is that the quantum theory seem already sufficiently developed for us to attempt something more than a mathematical formulation of it, and that a generally accepted physical understanding will be more quickly reached by agreement or disagreement with expressed opinions, than by waiting for the arrival of a full-grown theory. It has been an extraordinarily difficult task to express the ideas I intended, and I wish to thank Prof. D. R. Hartree for many valuable criticisms of my first attempts to do so, though he must be exonerated from all blame if the final result is unintelligible or erroneous. 1. The quantum mechanics have been expressed in a variety of ways, which place the emphasis differently, but it has been shown that they are all exactly equivalent, so what may choose which we will. I shall use the following description, limiting myself to the simpler cases which do not involve considerations of relativity. We take a partial differential equation of the wave type, set down according to certain rules depending on the particular system considered. We solve this subject to certain boundary conditions, expressive of all the limitations imposed by silts, mirrors, diffraction, gratings, moving shutters, etc., that may occur in the proposed system, and obtain as result the wave function Ψ, a function of all the co-ordinates of the system and of the time. From this we from a set of functions, of which the simplest is |Ψ|2; this process may be called taking the intensities. We next have to prepare for the particle aspect, by applying certain rules so as to normalise the intensities, a process entirely foreign to the idea of waves. Finally, we make the interpretation, in which we say that the normalised intensities measure the probability of the particles having such and such positions, momenta, energies, etc., and these are the results verified by observation.
The Quantum Mechanical Theory of Collis3ions. I»-In the present course we shall consider the quantum mechanical treatment of problems of particle interactions in which at least one of the particles is unbound and therefore able to travel large distances freely.In effect such particles are able to communicate the results of their interaction directly to macroscopic detection apparatus* The interpretation of the resulting data is in general the most direct way of forming conclusions about the interactions.A considerable variety of physical phenomena involves unbound particles» Among the simplest are scattering processes ;in particular the deflection of particles from a collinated beam.More general collision processes which induce reactions of various sorts also lie within the class we shall examine, Our chief concern willbe with the means of solving problems in which well-defined models have been postulated to describe the basic interactions.We shall restrict ourselves, in fact, to the treatment of fairly simple models, and shall discuss a number of approaches to the problems they raise.We begin by discussing the scattering of particles by a simple potential field, fixed in space» The problem of two free particles with a potential between them of course assumes this form in the center-of-mass system.By imagining that a beam of particles of constant strenght is at all times being scattered by the potential, we cay seek to describe the situation with the stationary-state Schrb'dinger equation.
The completely antisymmetric solution ${\ensuremath{\Psi}}^{A}$ to the problem of the scattering of a fermion by a finite system of identical fermions is studied by means of the expansion ${\ensuremath{\Psi}}^{A}=\ensuremath{\Sigma}{\ensuremath{\phi}}_{\ensuremath{\alpha}}{\ensuremath{\psi}}_{\ensuremath{\alpha}}$, where ${{\ensuremath{\phi}}_{\ensuremath{\alpha}}}$ is a complete set of antisymmetric states for the target and ${\ensuremath{\psi}}_{\ensuremath{\alpha}}$ are one-particle functions. Coupled equations for the ${\ensuremath{\psi}}_{\ensuremath{\alpha}}$ are found that obey the proper boundary conditions. This is done by means of the integral equation for ${\ensuremath{\Psi}}^{A}$ and the use of projection operators. The elastic-scattering (optical-model) wave function ${\ensuremath{\psi}}_{0}$ is shown to obey an inhomogeneous differential equation, rather than a Schr\"odinger equation. The homogeneous solution is identical to the elastic wave function obtained when the projectile is distinguishable, while the inhomogeneous solution is due entirely to exchange effects. The function ${\ensuremath{\psi}}_{0}$ is identical to the optical-model wave function found by Bell and Squires, who showed that ${\ensuremath{\psi}}_{0}$ obeys a Schr\"odinger equation with an optical potential containing direct and exchange contributions. It is shown that ${\ensuremath{\psi}}_{0}$ yields the exact elastic amplitude including direct and exchange contributions, and a phase-shift analysis of the exchange term is given. The more standard form of solution ${\ensuremath{\Psi}}^{A}=\ensuremath{\Sigma}\mathcal{a}{{\ensuremath{\phi}}_{\ensuremath{\alpha}}{f}_{\ensuremath{\alpha}}}$, where a\mathcal{a}a is an antisymmetrizer, is briefly discussed. The extension to the cases of inelastic scattering and deuteron elastic scattering is made.