Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Philosophy of Science

EPR: The Correlations are Still A Mystery

Frederick M. Kronz

Published Dec 1, 1988• 3 citations
Publisher

Abstract

This paper is a critical discussion of a recent article by Bas van Fraassen (1985) in which he suggests the following view: we should admit that we have no explanation of the EPR correlations, but refuse to consider the correlations as mysterious nevertheless (pp. 126–128). We shall focus on just three of the claims made by van Fraassen in support of this view. The three claims are these: (1) The EPR correlations cannot be explained by signals being transmitted from one component of an EPR compound to the other (pp. 114–115). (2) There is, in the EPR situation, no empirically verifiable action at a distance (pp. 124–126). (3) The demand for an explanation of the EPR correlations is similar to the Aristotelian demand of the post-Newtonian proponents of the law of inertia to explain what keeps a body moving if there are no forces impressed on it (pp. 126–128).

DOI
10.1086/289465

Related papers

A Discussion of the EPR Contained in Quantum Mechanical Terms without Arguments of Realities or Bell's Relations

Oreste Piccioni, Werner A. W. Mehlhop

Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences•Dec 1, 1986•3 citations

Explanations in Microphysics: A response to van Fraassen's argument

Silvio Seno Chibeni

The aim of this article is to offer a rejoinder to an argument against scientific realism put forward by van Fraassen, based on theoretical considerations regarding microphysics. At a certain stage of his general attack to scientific realism, van Fraassen argues, in contrast to what realists typically hold, that empirical regularities should sometimes be regarded as “brute facts”, which do not ask for explanation in terms of deeper, unobservable mechanisms. The argument from microphysics formulated by van Fraassen is based on the claim that in microphysics the demand for explanation leads to a demand for the so-called hidden-variable theories, which “runs contrary to at least one major school of thought in twentieth-century physics”. It is shown here that this argument does not represent an insurmountable obstacle to scientific realism, not even when a series of important theoretical and experimental results against hidden-variable theories — and not merely a conflict with a certain school of thought—is taken into account.

Principia an international journal of epistemology•May 31, 2008•0 citations

Chapter 9. Causality in the Epr Paradox: Part 1. The Physics

Raphael Neelamkavil

Peter Lang eBooks•Jul 11, 2016•0 citations

The Common Cause Explanation for Quantum Correlations of the EPR Type

Tomasz Bigaj

In the article van Fraassen's argument against the possibility of the com- mon cause explanation of EPR correlations is analyzed. It is pointed out that the crucial assumption of this argument is given in an ambiguous way, and that only one of its interpretations leads to the above conclusion. Several other omissions and misleading statements in van Fraassen's analysis are brought into considerations. At the end the corrected version of the original argument is given and its negative result is finally accepted.

•Jan 1, 2003•1 citation

Chapter 10. Causality in the Epr Paradox: Part 2. The Physical Ontology

Raphael Neelamkavil

Peter Lang eBooks•Jul 11, 2016•0 citations

In Defence of `This Worldly' Causality: Comments on van Fraassen's Laws and Symmetry

Nancy Delaney Cartwright

Recall van Fraassen's general scheme. Scientific models can depict both observable and unobservable processes. Science itself is supposed to tell us what is and what is not observable. We are to accept the theory if it gets right all that is observable; the rest can be of no matter to us, van Fraassen has suggested, because we could have no evidence about whether the model gets it right or not. We may believe in the model's picture of the unobservable world but that belief is based on faith not evidence, and should be recognised as such. Most of the stuff of modem physics, then, turns out to be in the unobservable part of the model: photons, quarks, gravity-waves, the electromagnetic field, forces, I suppose and even space-time itself. Where are causes? that is the question I want to discuss. We can begin with causal laws. They are surely for van Fraassen not in the model itself any more than any other kinds of laws. They enter, rather, as a constraint on the kinds of structures we will allow our models to have. In a full model for the entire history of the world, or more realistically, in a small model for a given scientific experiment, event-kinds will recur with some frequency. These frequencies are represented by probabilities-though note that the probabilities are not in the models either. If we insist that our scientific theory in a given domain be causal, that will restrict the form of the probability functions which are allowed and hence, in some way, constrain the actual models, which have finite frequencies in them only. Some patterns of correlation will be allowed and some will be prohibited. Consider van Fraassen's discussion of the Einstein-Podalsky-Rosen (EPR) paradox in the follow-up to Laws and Symmetry, Quantum Mechanics: An Empiricist View.' There van Fraassen takes a particular relationship between probabilities-calledfactoriz-

Philosophy and Phenomenological Research•Jun 1, 1993•51 citations
This paper is a critical discussion of a recent article by Bas van Fraassen (1985) in which he suggests the following view: we should admit that we have no explanation of the EPR correlations, but refuse to consider the correlations as mysterious nevertheless (pp. 126–128). We shall focus on just three of the claims made by van Fraassen in support of this view. The three claims are these: (1) The EPR correlations cannot be explained by signals being transmitted from one component of an EPR compound to the other (pp. 114–115). (2) There is, in the EPR situation, no empirically verifiable action at a distance (pp. 124–126). (3) The demand for an explanation of the EPR correlations is similar to the Aristotelian demand of the post-Newtonian proponents of the law of inertia to explain what keeps a body moving if there are no forces impressed on it (pp. 126–128).
The aim of this article is to offer a rejoinder to an argument against scientific realism put forward by van Fraassen, based on theoretical considerations regarding microphysics. At a certain stage of his general attack to scientific realism, van Fraassen argues, in contrast to what realists typically hold, that empirical regularities should sometimes be regarded as “brute facts”, which do not ask for explanation in terms of deeper, unobservable mechanisms. The argument from microphysics formulated by van Fraassen is based on the claim that in microphysics the demand for explanation leads to a demand for the so-called hidden-variable theories, which “runs contrary to at least one major school of thought in twentieth-century physics”. It is shown here that this argument does not represent an insurmountable obstacle to scientific realism, not even when a series of important theoretical and experimental results against hidden-variable theories — and not merely a conflict with a certain school of thought—is taken into account.
In the article van Fraassen's argument against the possibility of the com- mon cause explanation of EPR correlations is analyzed. It is pointed out that the crucial assumption of this argument is given in an ambiguous way, and that only one of its interpretations leads to the above conclusion. Several other omissions and misleading statements in van Fraassen's analysis are brought into considerations. At the end the corrected version of the original argument is given and its negative result is finally accepted.
Recall van Fraassen's general scheme. Scientific models can depict both observable and unobservable processes. Science itself is supposed to tell us what is and what is not observable. We are to accept the theory if it gets right all that is observable; the rest can be of no matter to us, van Fraassen has suggested, because we could have no evidence about whether the model gets it right or not. We may believe in the model's picture of the unobservable world but that belief is based on faith not evidence, and should be recognised as such. Most of the stuff of modem physics, then, turns out to be in the unobservable part of the model: photons, quarks, gravity-waves, the electromagnetic field, forces, I suppose and even space-time itself. Where are causes? that is the question I want to discuss. We can begin with causal laws. They are surely for van Fraassen not in the model itself any more than any other kinds of laws. They enter, rather, as a constraint on the kinds of structures we will allow our models to have. In a full model for the entire history of the world, or more realistically, in a small model for a given scientific experiment, event-kinds will recur with some frequency. These frequencies are represented by probabilities-though note that the probabilities are not in the models either. If we insist that our scientific theory in a given domain be causal, that will restrict the form of the probability functions which are allowed and hence, in some way, constrain the actual models, which have finite frequencies in them only. Some patterns of correlation will be allowed and some will be prohibited. Consider van Fraassen's discussion of the Einstein-Podalsky-Rosen (EPR) paradox in the follow-up to Laws and Symmetry, Quantum Mechanics: An Empiricist View.' There van Fraassen takes a particular relationship between probabilities-calledfactoriz-