In this paper I argue against Carcassi, Calderon, and Aidala's recent claim that the Hilbert spaces are unphysical and should be replaced with the Schwartz spaces in quantum mechanics, since Hilbert spaces include states with infinite expectation values for certain observables. I also review and discuss issues regarding unbounded operators in quantum mechanics raised by Streater and Wightman, Heathcote, and Lemos. I argue that the existence of infinite expectation values does not cause problems in quantum mechanics. On the other hand, replacing the Hilbert spaces with the Schwartz spaces would cause more issues, as it would exclude a class of meaningful Hamiltonian evolutions. I also discuss the question in literature whether reformulating quantum mechanics with essentially self-adjoint operators instead of self-adjoint operators may cause problems. I further analyse the hierarchies of the notions of "physicality" and possibility in fundamental physics, and suggest that "physicality" is a vague concept. Finally, I connect the problem raised by Carcassi, Calderon, and Aidala with the problem of the Hadamard condition in quantum field theory.
In quantum mechanics, many observables for a quantum system are represented as self-adjoint linear operators (possibly unbounded) on a complex Hilbert space
H. In this paper, we introduce a binary relation
⊥ on
S(H) of all self-adjoint linear operators (including unbounded) on
H. We obtain that
A⊥B implies that
A,B are affiliated with some abelian von Neumann algebra at the same time. Depending on
⊥,S(H) can be constructed to be a generalized orthoalgebra. Then we present the orthoalgebra order
⪯ and the traditional order
≤ on
S(H) and give some properties about these two orders. We prove that for
A,B∈S(H),
A⪯B if and only if
A has a value in
Δ implies that
B has a value in
Δ for every Borel set
Δ not containing
0. Moreover, we study the existence of the infimum
A∧B and supremum
A∨B for
A,B∈S(H) with respect to
⪯. Finally, we prove that
Q∧P=0 where
Q and
P are the significant quantum observables corresponding to the position and momentum.}
A long-standing problem that arises when constructing the mathematical apparatus of quantum mechanics is the need to work with unbounded operators. Since the space of nuclear operators is preconjugate for the algebra of all bounded operators, we can consider the states of a quantum system as nuclear operators, and consider bounded operators as observables. In this case, taking the trace for the product of a nuclear operator (a quantum state) and a bounded operator (a quantum observable) gives the average value of a quantum observable in a fixed state. The existence of such an average for unbounded operators is not guaranteed. If we want to define a space of observables that includes such naturally occurring unbounded operators as the position and momentum operators, for which average values are always determined, we should consider a space of states smaller than all nuclear operators. Recently, this approach has been mathematically correct implemented in the Hilbert space H = L^2(R^N). The so-called space of Schwarz operators, equipped with a system of semi-norms and being a Frechet space, was chosen as the space of states. Schwarz operators appeared to be integral operators whose kernels are functions belonging to the usual Schwarz space. The dual space to the space of Schwarz operators should be considered as the space of quantum observables and it really includes such standard observables as polynomials from the products of the position and momentum operators. In the present work we transfer this approach to the symmetric Fock space H = F(H) over an infinite dimensional separable Hilbert space H. We introduce the space of Schwartz operators in F(H) over an infinite dimensional separable space H and investigate which of the standard operators of quantum white noise belong to the space dual to the space of Schwartz operators.