Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2603.10601

Is the existence of unbounded operators a problem for quantum mechanics? In response to Carcassi, Calderon, and Aidala

Zhonghao Lu

quant-phmath-phphysics.hist-phSubmitted Mar 11, 2026• Announced Mar 12, 2026• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

In this paper I argue against Carcassi, Calderon, and Aidala's recent claim that the Hilbert spaces are unphysical and should be replaced with the Schwartz spaces in quantum mechanics, since Hilbert spaces include states with infinite expectation values for certain observables. I also review and discuss issues regarding unbounded operators in quantum mechanics raised by Streater and Wightman, Heathcote, and Lemos. I argue that the existence of infinite expectation values does not cause problems in quantum mechanics. On the other hand, replacing the Hilbert spaces with the Schwartz spaces would cause more issues, as it would exclude a class of meaningful Hamiltonian evolutions. I also discuss the question in literature whether reformulating quantum mechanics with essentially self-adjoint operators instead of self-adjoint operators may cause problems. I further analyse the hierarchies of the notions of "physicality" and possibility in fundamental physics, and suggest that "physicality" is a vague concept. Finally, I connect the problem raised by Carcassi, Calderon, and Aidala with the problem of the Hadamard condition in quantum field theory.

Related papers

Unbounded Operators, Physicality, and Modality in Quantum Theories

Zhonghao Lu

In this paper, I address the problem regarding the physicality of Hilbert space in quantum mechanics, a topic brought into focus by Carcassi et al.'s paper "The unphysicality of Hilbert spaces" recently. I argue for the physicality of the Hilbert space in quantum mechanics, and demonstrate that there are inevitable ambiguity and arbitrariness if we want to identify the set of physical states with a proper subset of it. Moreover, I distinguish the ontological and modal reading of physicality from the pragmatic and operational reading of physicality, and then develop what I call the hierarchical view of physicality. According to this view, physicality is not a monolithic concept, but a layered one that admits degrees. I show the connection between the concept of physicality and modal metaphysics, and finally explain how it can be used to address the interpretational problem of quantum field theory brought by the existence of inequivalent representations.

quant-pharXiv:2609.28136•Sep 24, 2026•0 citations

Hilbert Spaces and Quantum Mechanics

The theory of Hilbert spaces is central to the mathematical foundation of quantum physics. In quantum mechanics, the physical state of a system is given by a vector in a Hilbert space and the possible results of measures of physical quantities correspond to the eigenvalues of self-adjoint operators. The mathematical basis for the probabilistic interpretation of quantum mechanics is provided by the spectral theorem for self-adjoint operators. In this chapter we analyse all these concepts starting with the Schrödinger equation, a cornerstone of mathematical physics. This chapter is certainly better appreciated with some familiarity with the basic principles of quantum mechanics, but it can be read independently as a collection of applications of the theory of Hilbert spaces and self-adjoint operators. For a complete introduction to quantum mechanics, see Cohen-Tannoudji et al . (1992) and Griffiths (2016).

Advanced textbooks in physics•Sep 6, 2018•3 citations

Classical Topology and Quantum States

A. P. Balachandran, Giuseppe Marmo, B.-S. Skagerstam +1 more

Any two infinite-dimensional (separable) Hilbert spaces are unitarilyisomorphic. The sets of all their self-adjoint operators are also thereforeunitarily equivalent. Thus if all self-adjoint operators can be observed, andif there is no further major axiom in quantum physics than those formulated forexample in Dirac's `Quantum Mechanics', then a quantum physicist would not beable to tell a torus from a hole in the ground. We argue that there are indeedsuch axioms involving observables with smooth time evolution: they containcommutative subalgebras from which the spatial slice of spacetime with itstopology (and with further refinements of the axiom, its $C^K-$ and $C^\\infty-$structures) can be reconstructed using Gel'fand - Naimark theory and itsextensions. Classical topology is an attribute of only certain quantumobservables for these axioms, the spatial slice emergent from quantum physicsgetting progressively less differentiable with increasingly higher excitationsof energy and eventually altogether ceasing to exist. After formulating theseaxioms, we apply them to show the possibility of topology change and to discussquantized fuzzy topologies. Fundamental issues concerning the role of time inquantum physics are also addressed.

WORLD SCIENTIFIC eBooks•Jan 1, 1991•221 citations

Quantum mechanical reality according to Copenhagen 2.0

A.M. Din

The long-standing conceptual controversies concerning the interpretation of nonrelativistic quantum mechanics are argued, on one hand, to be due to its incompleteness, as affirmed by Einstein. But on the other hand, it appears to be possible to complete it at least partially, as Bohr might have appreciated it, in the framework of its standard mathematical formalism with observables as appropriately defined self-adjoint operators. This completion of quantum mechanics is based on the requirement on laboratory physics to be effectively confined to a bounded space region and on the application of the von Neumann deficiency theorem to properly define a set of self-adjoint extensions of standard observables, e.g. the momenta and the Hamiltonian, in terms of certain isometries on the region boundary. This is formalized mathematically in the setting of a boundary ontology for the so-called Qbox in which the wave function acquires a supplementary dependence on a set of Additional Boundary Variables (ABV). It is argued that a certain geometric subset of the ABV parametrizing Quasi-Periodic Translational Isometries (QPTI) has a particular physical importance by allowing for the definition of an ontic wave function, which has the property of epitomizing the spatial wave function “collapse.” Concomitantly the standard wave function in an unbounded geometry is interpreted as an epistemic wave function, which together with the ontic QPTI wave function gives rise to the notion of two-wave duality, replacing the standard concept of wave-particle duality. More generally, this approach to quantum physics in a bounded geometry provides a novel analytical basis for a better understanding of several conceptual notions of quantum mechanics, including reality, nonlocality, entanglement and Heisenberg’s uncertainty relation. The scope of this analysis may be seen as a foundational update of the multiple versions 1.x of the Copenhagen interpretation of quantum mechanics, which is sufficiently incremental so as to be appropriately characterized as Copenhagen 2.0.

International Journal of Modern Physics A•May 26, 2016•0 citations

A Simple Survey on the Problems in Quantum Mechanics

Ghosh Ak

Schrodinger wave equation, Hilbert space formalism, born’s rule for probability and hermitian operator are mainly the core of quantum theory and quantum description is generally based on Hilbert space of states, observables are described by self adjoint operators on the space of states, physical symmetries are explained by unitary transformations, and time evolution is a one-parameter group of unitary transformations on the Hilbert space of states. In this paper, I have discussed why a generalized philosophy is required before the development of quantum probability to fill up the gap.

Journal of Physics & Astronomy•Jan 1, 2018•0 citations

On the space of Schwartz operators in the symmetric Fock space and its dual

Grigori Gennadievich Amosov, Egor Leonidovich Baitenov

A long-standing problem that arises when constructing the mathematical apparatus of quantum mechanics is the need to work with unbounded operators. Since the space of nuclear operators is preconjugate for the algebra of all bounded operators, we can consider the states of a quantum system as nuclear operators, and consider bounded operators as observables. In this case, taking the trace for the product of a nuclear operator (a quantum state) and a bounded operator (a quantum observable) gives the average value of a quantum observable in a fixed state. The existence of such an average for unbounded operators is not guaranteed. If we want to define a space of observables that includes such naturally occurring unbounded operators as the position and momentum operators, for which average values are always determined, we should consider a space of states smaller than all nuclear operators. Recently, this approach has been mathematically correct implemented in the Hilbert space H = L^2(R^N). The so-called space of Schwarz operators, equipped with a system of semi-norms and being a Frechet space, was chosen as the space of states. Schwarz operators appeared to be integral operators whose kernels are functions belonging to the usual Schwarz space. The dual space to the space of Schwarz operators should be considered as the space of quantum observables and it really includes such standard observables as polynomials from the products of the position and momentum operators. In the present work we transfer this approach to the symmetric Fock space H = F(H) over an infinite dimensional separable Hilbert space H. We introduce the space of Schwartz operators in F(H) over an infinite dimensional separable space H and investigate which of the standard operators of quantum white noise belong to the space dual to the space of Schwartz operators.

Vestnik of Saint Petersburg University Mathematics Mechanics Astronomy•Jan 1, 2022•0 citations
In this paper I argue against Carcassi, Calderon, and Aidala's recent claim that the Hilbert spaces are unphysical and should be replaced with the Schwartz spaces in quantum mechanics, since Hilbert spaces include states with infinite expectation values for certain observables. I also review and discuss issues regarding unbounded operators in quantum mechanics raised by Streater and Wightman, Heathcote, and Lemos. I argue that the existence of infinite expectation values does not cause problems in quantum mechanics. On the other hand, replacing the Hilbert spaces with the Schwartz spaces would cause more issues, as it would exclude a class of meaningful Hamiltonian evolutions. I also discuss the question in literature whether reformulating quantum mechanics with essentially self-adjoint operators instead of self-adjoint operators may cause problems. I further analyse the hierarchies of the notions of "physicality" and possibility in fundamental physics, and suggest that "physicality" is a vague concept. Finally, I connect the problem raised by Carcassi, Calderon, and Aidala with the problem of the Hadamard condition in quantum field theory.
In this paper, I address the problem regarding the physicality of Hilbert space in quantum mechanics, a topic brought into focus by Carcassi et al.'s paper "The unphysicality of Hilbert spaces" recently. I argue for the physicality of the Hilbert space in quantum mechanics, and demonstrate that there are inevitable ambiguity and arbitrariness if we want to identify the set of physical states with a proper subset of it. Moreover, I distinguish the ontological and modal reading of physicality from the pragmatic and operational reading of physicality, and then develop what I call the hierarchical view of physicality. According to this view, physicality is not a monolithic concept, but a layered one that admits degrees. I show the connection between the concept of physicality and modal metaphysics, and finally explain how it can be used to address the interpretational problem of quantum field theory brought by the existence of inequivalent representations.
The theory of Hilbert spaces is central to the mathematical foundation of quantum physics. In quantum mechanics, the physical state of a system is given by a vector in a Hilbert space and the possible results of measures of physical quantities correspond to the eigenvalues of self-adjoint operators. The mathematical basis for the probabilistic interpretation of quantum mechanics is provided by the spectral theorem for self-adjoint operators. In this chapter we analyse all these concepts starting with the Schrödinger equation, a cornerstone of mathematical physics. This chapter is certainly better appreciated with some familiarity with the basic principles of quantum mechanics, but it can be read independently as a collection of applications of the theory of Hilbert spaces and self-adjoint operators. For a complete introduction to quantum mechanics, see Cohen-Tannoudji et al . (1992) and Griffiths (2016).
Any two infinite-dimensional (separable) Hilbert spaces are unitarilyisomorphic. The sets of all their self-adjoint operators are also thereforeunitarily equivalent. Thus if all self-adjoint operators can be observed, andif there is no further major axiom in quantum physics than those formulated forexample in Dirac's `Quantum Mechanics', then a quantum physicist would not beable to tell a torus from a hole in the ground. We argue that there are indeedsuch axioms involving observables with smooth time evolution: they containcommutative subalgebras from which the spatial slice of spacetime with itstopology (and with further refinements of the axiom, its CK−C^K-CK− and $C^\\infty-$structures) can be reconstructed using Gel'fand - Naimark theory and itsextensions. Classical topology is an attribute of only certain quantumobservables for these axioms, the spatial slice emergent from quantum physicsgetting progressively less differentiable with increasingly higher excitationsof energy and eventually altogether ceasing to exist. After formulating theseaxioms, we apply them to show the possibility of topology change and to discussquantized fuzzy topologies. Fundamental issues concerning the role of time inquantum physics are also addressed.
The long-standing conceptual controversies concerning the interpretation of nonrelativistic quantum mechanics are argued, on one hand, to be due to its incompleteness, as affirmed by Einstein. But on the other hand, it appears to be possible to complete it at least partially, as Bohr might have appreciated it, in the framework of its standard mathematical formalism with observables as appropriately defined self-adjoint operators. This completion of quantum mechanics is based on the requirement on laboratory physics to be effectively confined to a bounded space region and on the application of the von Neumann deficiency theorem to properly define a set of self-adjoint extensions of standard observables, e.g. the momenta and the Hamiltonian, in terms of certain isometries on the region boundary. This is formalized mathematically in the setting of a boundary ontology for the so-called Qbox in which the wave function acquires a supplementary dependence on a set of Additional Boundary Variables (ABV). It is argued that a certain geometric subset of the ABV parametrizing Quasi-Periodic Translational Isometries (QPTI) has a particular physical importance by allowing for the definition of an ontic wave function, which has the property of epitomizing the spatial wave function “collapse.” Concomitantly the standard wave function in an unbounded geometry is interpreted as an epistemic wave function, which together with the ontic QPTI wave function gives rise to the notion of two-wave duality, replacing the standard concept of wave-particle duality. More generally, this approach to quantum physics in a bounded geometry provides a novel analytical basis for a better understanding of several conceptual notions of quantum mechanics, including reality, nonlocality, entanglement and Heisenberg’s uncertainty relation. The scope of this analysis may be seen as a foundational update of the multiple versions 1.x of the Copenhagen interpretation of quantum mechanics, which is sufficiently incremental so as to be appropriately characterized as Copenhagen 2.0.
Schrodinger wave equation, Hilbert space formalism, born’s rule for probability and hermitian operator are mainly the core of quantum theory and quantum description is generally based on Hilbert space of states, observables are described by self adjoint operators on the space of states, physical symmetries are explained by unitary transformations, and time evolution is a one-parameter group of unitary transformations on the Hilbert space of states. In this paper, I have discussed why a generalized philosophy is required before the development of quantum probability to fill up the gap.
A long-standing problem that arises when constructing the mathematical apparatus of quantum mechanics is the need to work with unbounded operators. Since the space of nuclear operators is preconjugate for the algebra of all bounded operators, we can consider the states of a quantum system as nuclear operators, and consider bounded operators as observables. In this case, taking the trace for the product of a nuclear operator (a quantum state) and a bounded operator (a quantum observable) gives the average value of a quantum observable in a fixed state. The existence of such an average for unbounded operators is not guaranteed. If we want to define a space of observables that includes such naturally occurring unbounded operators as the position and momentum operators, for which average values are always determined, we should consider a space of states smaller than all nuclear operators. Recently, this approach has been mathematically correct implemented in the Hilbert space H = L^2(R^N). The so-called space of Schwarz operators, equipped with a system of semi-norms and being a Frechet space, was chosen as the space of states. Schwarz operators appeared to be integral operators whose kernels are functions belonging to the usual Schwarz space. The dual space to the space of Schwarz operators should be considered as the space of quantum observables and it really includes such standard observables as polynomials from the products of the position and momentum operators. In the present work we transfer this approach to the symmetric Fock space H = F(H) over an infinite dimensional separable Hilbert space H. We introduce the space of Schwartz operators in F(H) over an infinite dimensional separable space H and investigate which of the standard operators of quantum white noise belong to the space dual to the space of Schwartz operators.