Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

International Journal of Quantum Chemistry

Double symmetrization and the linearly independent spin eigenfunctions

T. K. Lim

Published Jun 1, 1986• 8 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Abstract It is shown that the exclusion principle merely requires the electrons to be divided into two distinct groups, then, according to our assumption of the distinguishability of electrons, its mathematical representation can be the spatial double antisymmetrization or the spatial‐spin antisymmetrization; in the latter case an auxiliary spin double symmetrization is also required in order to distinguish the two types of electrons. The second requirement is used to recognize the fact that, although all electrons can be assumed to be indistinguishable under certain condition, their natural characteristic of two distinct groups must still be preserved.It is further shown that the double antisymmetrization (or double symmetrization) determines the spin quantum number M, whereas the Löwdin spin projector for nonorthogonal eigenfunctions and the Wigner matric basis for orthogonal eigenfunctions will decide the spin quantum number S, Both the spatial double antisymmetrizer and the spin double symmetrizer will reject all the unnecessary eigenfunctions and project out only one unique set of linearly independent eigenfunctions.

DOI
10.1002/qua.560290602

Related papers

Can the Pauli Exclusion Principle Be Proved?

Ilya G. Kaplan

The general formulation of the Pauli Exclusion Principle can be considered from two viewpoints. It asserts that particles with half-integer spin (fermions) are described by antisymmetric wave functions and particles with integer spin (bosons) are described by symmetric wave functions. This is the so-called spin–statistics connection. According to it, only two types of permutation symmetry are allowed: symmetric and antisymmetric. The Schrodinger equation is invariant under any permutation of identical particles and its solutions may belong to any representation of the permutation group, including the multidimensional representations that are forbidden by the Pauli Exclusion Principle. This chapter discusses the case of a spinless Hamiltonian when the total spin S is a good quantum number and labels the energy levels of the system. The permission of multidimensional representations of the permutation group for the total wave function leads to contradictions with the concepts of particle identity and their independence.

Wiley eBooks•Nov 18, 2016•0 citations

The exclusion priniciple and aperiodic systems

Nevill Francis Mott

Abstract Section I.—The exclusion principle of Pauli was introduced into the old quantum theory as an empirical fact that had been brought to light in the ordering of spectra. The new mechanics has provided some sort of explanation of the principle, for in a closed system with many electrons the mathematically possible stationary states can be separated into a number of groups, with the property that transitions between stationary states in different groups cannot occur. One of these group is made up of the stationary states corresponding occur. One of the these groups is made up of the stationary states corresponding to wave functions that are antisymmetrical in the co-ordinates of the electrons. Apart from accidental degeneracies, the stationary states in different groups have different energy values. The exclusion principle then states that only energy values belonging to the antisymmertical group are found in nature. The exclusion principle has had great success not only in explaining the spectra of helium and of more complicated atoms, but also, under the form of the Fermi-Dirac statistics, in accounting for metallic conduction and ferromagnetism. In all these phenomena we are dealing with systems is stationary states, possessing energy values which are discrete, although they may lie very close together. Now, as was first emphasised by Oppenheimer, we must also use antisymmetrical wave-functions to describe aperiodic phenomena, such as the collision between an electron and an atom. If we do not, we obtain probabilities for the formation of atoms whose wave-funtions are not antisymmetrical, as we shall show in section 4, where we consider the collision between an electron and a helium atom. A helium atom described by a symmetrical wave-function would show a singlet series in palce of the observed triplets and triplet series in place of the observed singlets. The wave-functions of open systems are essentially degenerate; the symmetical and antisymmetrical solution are not separated from one another by a finite energy difference; but for any arbitrary value of the energy (and of the other integrals of the motion) we can form a symmetrical and an antisymmetrical solution. This is somewhat fundamental difference between open and closed systems. For closed systems containing two electrons there exist only the symmetrical and the antisymmetical solution; but for open systems we might take any combination of the two. In fact, to describe an observable phenomenon such as a collision, the wave-function that it would first occur to us to use is a combination of the two. To fix our ideas we shall discuss the collision between two electrons. Our arguments could equally well be applied to the collision between an electron and a hydrogen atom, the problem originally discussed by Born; but the former is the simpler case, and perhaps illustrates our theory better.

Proceedings of the Royal Society of London Series A Containing Papers of a Mathematical and Physical Character•Aug 1, 1929•24 citations

Identical Particles

Ahmad Amer

This chapter addresses the quantum mechanics of identical particles, emphasizing the role of wavefunction symmetry in determining statistical behavior. Symmetric and antisymmetric wavefunctions are defined, and the implications of particle indistinguishability are examined, particularly regarding how it influences measurable outcomes and the concept of energy exchange degeneracy. The distinguishability of identical particles is discussed and shown to affect specific calculations. For systems where particle interactions can be neglected in the zero-order approximation, the total energy eigenfunction is expressed as a product of single-particle eigenfunctions. The Pauli exclusion principle is derived as a consequence of antisymmetrization. The relationship between symmetry type (bosonic or fermionic) and quantum statistics is elaborated. As an illustration, the ground state and the first excited $s$-state of the helium atom are analyzed under a simplified approximation. Metadata/Keywords: identical particles, symmetric wavefunction, antisymmetric wavefunction, Pauli exclusion principle, quantum statistics, energy exchange degeneracy, indistinguishability, helium atom, symmetry and statistics

CRC Press eBooks•Nov 5, 2025•0 citations

The Helium Atom

Hendrik F. Hameka

Chapter 10 lists a few theorems that are essential for the description of systems containing more then one electron. The first of these is Pauli's exclusion principle, first in relation to the electronic configurations of atomic systems and subsequently in a more general form, requiring that electronic wave functions must be antisymmetric with respect to permutations of the electrons. The second theorem is the proposal by Goudsmit and Uhlenbeck of the electron spin with an angular momentum of (ħ/2). The general form of two-electron wave functions are formulated by taking into account both the exclusion principle and the electron spin, the results are either singlet or triplet eigenfunctions. Applications to the helium atom are also discussed.

Wiley eBooks•Mar 12, 2004•0 citations

The Principle of Identity and the Exclusion of Quantum States

Gilbert Newton Lewis

In classical physics it was assumed that a system of two bodies, both having the same mechanical and electrical properties, would show the same behavior regardless of their complete identity. This assumption, that gave rise to the paradoxes of Gibbs and of Einstein which are here discussed, must be abandoned in atomic physics. We must distinguish sharply between identical particles and those that are only quasiidentical, in the sense that they are the same in mass, charge and the potential fields to which they give rise. All of the results which have hitherto been obtained in quantum mechanics are valid even if we assume that two particles such as two electrons or two helium nuclei are only quasi-identical. The postulate of complete identity is a new mathematical condition which, operating simultaneously with the wave equation and its boundary conditions, restricts the number of possible solutions of the equation and thus gives rise mathematically to a number of exclusion laws such as those which have been empirically obtained.The assumption of identity is equivalent to the mathematical assumption that the ordinary configuration space is degenerate, in the sense that one portion is a mere reflection of another. By this method it is shown that if the wave function is a scalar, the laws of exclusion are obtained without ambiguity. Thus a perfectly symmetrical diatomic gas in its simplest electronic state can have only even rotational levels. It is pointed out that the experimental results with ${\mathrm{O}}_{2}$(${\mathrm{O}}_{16}$${\mathrm{O}}_{16}$) and ${\mathrm{He}}_{2}$ show that these atoms exist in a single nuclear state. It is predicted that with heavier atoms both even and odd states will be found owing to the existence of isobars. The monatomic gas is then discussed and it is shown that, if the Schr\"odinger function is a scalar, only the Bose-Einstein statistics are possible.The phenomenon of spin introduces a vector character into the wave function. If we assume that the spin factor changes sign upon reflection when the number of units of spin is odd but not when the number of units of spin is even, we have all the cases of exclusion now known, including the case of the nitrogen molecule. As an example of the method, the problem of the helium atom is discussed.

Physical Review•Oct 1, 1930•6 citations

On the permutation symmetry of atomic and molecular wavefunctions

Francisco Marcelo Fernández

In this paper we analyze a recently proposed approach for the construction of antisymmetric functions for atomic and molecular systems. It is based on the assumption that the main problems with Hartree-Fock wavefunctions stem from their lack of proper permutation symmetry. This alternative building approach is based on products of a space times a spin function with opposite permutation symmetry. The main argument for devising such factors is that the eigenfunctions of the non-relativistic Hamiltonian are either symmetric or antisymmetric with respect to the transposition of the variables of a pair of electrons. However, since the eigenfunctions of the non-relativistic Hamiltonian are basis for the irreducible representations of the symmetric group they are not necessarily symmetric or antisymmetric, except in the trivial case of two electrons. We carry out a simple and straightforward general analysis of the symmetry of the eigenfunctions of the non-relativistic Hamiltonian and illustrate our conclusions by means of two exactly-solvable models of $N=2$ and $N=3$ identical interacting particles.

arXiv:1904.06378•Apr 12, 2019•1 citation
Abstract It is shown that the exclusion principle merely requires the electrons to be divided into two distinct groups, then, according to our assumption of the distinguishability of electrons, its mathematical representation can be the spatial double antisymmetrization or the spatial‐spin antisymmetrization; in the latter case an auxiliary spin double symmetrization is also required in order to distinguish the two types of electrons. The second requirement is used to recognize the fact that, although all electrons can be assumed to be indistinguishable under certain condition, their natural characteristic of two distinct groups must still be preserved.It is further shown that the double antisymmetrization (or double symmetrization) determines the spin quantum number M, whereas the Löwdin spin projector for nonorthogonal eigenfunctions and the Wigner matric basis for orthogonal eigenfunctions will decide the spin quantum number S, Both the spatial double antisymmetrizer and the spin double symmetrizer will reject all the unnecessary eigenfunctions and project out only one unique set of linearly independent eigenfunctions.
The general formulation of the Pauli Exclusion Principle can be considered from two viewpoints. It asserts that particles with half-integer spin (fermions) are described by antisymmetric wave functions and particles with integer spin (bosons) are described by symmetric wave functions. This is the so-called spin–statistics connection. According to it, only two types of permutation symmetry are allowed: symmetric and antisymmetric. The Schrodinger equation is invariant under any permutation of identical particles and its solutions may belong to any representation of the permutation group, including the multidimensional representations that are forbidden by the Pauli Exclusion Principle. This chapter discusses the case of a spinless Hamiltonian when the total spin S is a good quantum number and labels the energy levels of the system. The permission of multidimensional representations of the permutation group for the total wave function leads to contradictions with the concepts of particle identity and their independence.
Abstract Section I.—The exclusion principle of Pauli was introduced into the old quantum theory as an empirical fact that had been brought to light in the ordering of spectra. The new mechanics has provided some sort of explanation of the principle, for in a closed system with many electrons the mathematically possible stationary states can be separated into a number of groups, with the property that transitions between stationary states in different groups cannot occur. One of these group is made up of the stationary states corresponding occur. One of the these groups is made up of the stationary states corresponding to wave functions that are antisymmetrical in the co-ordinates of the electrons. Apart from accidental degeneracies, the stationary states in different groups have different energy values. The exclusion principle then states that only energy values belonging to the antisymmertical group are found in nature. The exclusion principle has had great success not only in explaining the spectra of helium and of more complicated atoms, but also, under the form of the Fermi-Dirac statistics, in accounting for metallic conduction and ferromagnetism. In all these phenomena we are dealing with systems is stationary states, possessing energy values which are discrete, although they may lie very close together. Now, as was first emphasised by Oppenheimer, we must also use antisymmetrical wave-functions to describe aperiodic phenomena, such as the collision between an electron and an atom. If we do not, we obtain probabilities for the formation of atoms whose wave-funtions are not antisymmetrical, as we shall show in section 4, where we consider the collision between an electron and a helium atom. A helium atom described by a symmetrical wave-function would show a singlet series in palce of the observed triplets and triplet series in place of the observed singlets. The wave-functions of open systems are essentially degenerate; the symmetical and antisymmetrical solution are not separated from one another by a finite energy difference; but for any arbitrary value of the energy (and of the other integrals of the motion) we can form a symmetrical and an antisymmetrical solution. This is somewhat fundamental difference between open and closed systems. For closed systems containing two electrons there exist only the symmetrical and the antisymmetical solution; but for open systems we might take any combination of the two. In fact, to describe an observable phenomenon such as a collision, the wave-function that it would first occur to us to use is a combination of the two. To fix our ideas we shall discuss the collision between two electrons. Our arguments could equally well be applied to the collision between an electron and a hydrogen atom, the problem originally discussed by Born; but the former is the simpler case, and perhaps illustrates our theory better.
This chapter addresses the quantum mechanics of identical particles, emphasizing the role of wavefunction symmetry in determining statistical behavior. Symmetric and antisymmetric wavefunctions are defined, and the implications of particle indistinguishability are examined, particularly regarding how it influences measurable outcomes and the concept of energy exchange degeneracy. The distinguishability of identical particles is discussed and shown to affect specific calculations. For systems where particle interactions can be neglected in the zero-order approximation, the total energy eigenfunction is expressed as a product of single-particle eigenfunctions. The Pauli exclusion principle is derived as a consequence of antisymmetrization. The relationship between symmetry type (bosonic or fermionic) and quantum statistics is elaborated. As an illustration, the ground state and the first excited sss-state of the helium atom are analyzed under a simplified approximation. Metadata/Keywords: identical particles, symmetric wavefunction, antisymmetric wavefunction, Pauli exclusion principle, quantum statistics, energy exchange degeneracy, indistinguishability, helium atom, symmetry and statistics
Chapter 10 lists a few theorems that are essential for the description of systems containing more then one electron. The first of these is Pauli's exclusion principle, first in relation to the electronic configurations of atomic systems and subsequently in a more general form, requiring that electronic wave functions must be antisymmetric with respect to permutations of the electrons. The second theorem is the proposal by Goudsmit and Uhlenbeck of the electron spin with an angular momentum of (ħ/2). The general form of two-electron wave functions are formulated by taking into account both the exclusion principle and the electron spin, the results are either singlet or triplet eigenfunctions. Applications to the helium atom are also discussed.
In classical physics it was assumed that a system of two bodies, both having the same mechanical and electrical properties, would show the same behavior regardless of their complete identity. This assumption, that gave rise to the paradoxes of Gibbs and of Einstein which are here discussed, must be abandoned in atomic physics. We must distinguish sharply between identical particles and those that are only quasiidentical, in the sense that they are the same in mass, charge and the potential fields to which they give rise. All of the results which have hitherto been obtained in quantum mechanics are valid even if we assume that two particles such as two electrons or two helium nuclei are only quasi-identical. The postulate of complete identity is a new mathematical condition which, operating simultaneously with the wave equation and its boundary conditions, restricts the number of possible solutions of the equation and thus gives rise mathematically to a number of exclusion laws such as those which have been empirically obtained.The assumption of identity is equivalent to the mathematical assumption that the ordinary configuration space is degenerate, in the sense that one portion is a mere reflection of another. By this method it is shown that if the wave function is a scalar, the laws of exclusion are obtained without ambiguity. Thus a perfectly symmetrical diatomic gas in its simplest electronic state can have only even rotational levels. It is pointed out that the experimental results with O2{\mathrm{O}}_{2}O2​(O16{\mathrm{O}}_{16}O16​O16{\mathrm{O}}_{16}O16​) and He2{\mathrm{He}}_{2}He2​ show that these atoms exist in a single nuclear state. It is predicted that with heavier atoms both even and odd states will be found owing to the existence of isobars. The monatomic gas is then discussed and it is shown that, if the Schr\"odinger function is a scalar, only the Bose-Einstein statistics are possible.The phenomenon of spin introduces a vector character into the wave function. If we assume that the spin factor changes sign upon reflection when the number of units of spin is odd but not when the number of units of spin is even, we have all the cases of exclusion now known, including the case of the nitrogen molecule. As an example of the method, the problem of the helium atom is discussed.
In this paper we analyze a recently proposed approach for the construction of antisymmetric functions for atomic and molecular systems. It is based on the assumption that the main problems with Hartree-Fock wavefunctions stem from their lack of proper permutation symmetry. This alternative building approach is based on products of a space times a spin function with opposite permutation symmetry. The main argument for devising such factors is that the eigenfunctions of the non-relativistic Hamiltonian are either symmetric or antisymmetric with respect to the transposition of the variables of a pair of electrons. However, since the eigenfunctions of the non-relativistic Hamiltonian are basis for the irreducible representations of the symmetric group they are not necessarily symmetric or antisymmetric, except in the trivial case of two electrons. We carry out a simple and straightforward general analysis of the symmetry of the eigenfunctions of the non-relativistic Hamiltonian and illustrate our conclusions by means of two exactly-solvable models of N=2N=2N=2 and N=3N=3N=3 identical interacting particles.