A solvable model of an apparatus for measuring a spin component of a spin-1/2 particle is considered. The model enjoys full rotational invariance and, in the limit case in which a part of the apparatus becomes infinitely massive, works according to the ideal measurement scheme. The model is applied to the study of the deviations from the ideal measurement scheme imposed by the conservation of angular momentum. The detailed analysis of the model allows one to calculate the size of the various nonideal terms in the measurement scheme and to understand the physical mechanism which gives rise to such terms.
A solvable model of an apparatus for measuring a spin component of a spin-1/2 particle is considered. The model enjoys full rotational invariance and, in the limit case in which a part of the apparatus becomes infinitely massive, works according to the ideal measurement scheme. The model is applied to the study of the deviations from the ideal measurement scheme imposed by the conservation of angular momentum. The detailed analysis of the model allows one to calculate the size of the various nonideal terms in the measurement scheme and to understand the physical mechanism which gives rise to such terms.
The problem of determining the minimal deviation from the ideal scheme in a measurement, compatible with the existence of additive conserved quantities, is reconsidered. In the case of the measurement of a spin component of a spin-1/2 particle, we rederive in a simple and rigorous way the bound previously obtained by Yanase. The procedure allows the derivation of definite equations characterizing an optimal measuring apparatus. A detailed discussion of the possible malfunctioning of the apparatuses is also given.
An upper limit for the accuracy of the measurement of a simple quantity which does not commute with a conserved quantity is obtained in terms of the "size" of the apparatus. The "size" of the apparatus is defined as the mean square value ${\ensuremath{\hbar}}^{2}{M}^{2}$ of the conserved quantity for the apparatus which is, in the example chosen, the z component of the angular momentum. The measured quantity is the projection of a spin in a perpendicular direction. It is found that the probability of an unsuccessful measurement is at least 8M21.
The quantum mechanical measurement process is analysed in detail, especially from the group theoretical point of view. The first three chapters review the results obtained before briefly. In §1, the classical theory of measurement, originated by von Neumann, is birefly described. The importance of considering more general schemes of measurements than the original one is, however, emphasized. In §2, the role of conservation laws, in imposing limitations on the possibility of measurements, is discussed. Accurately measurable quantities are defined in this context. In §3, the role of conservation laws is further analysed. It is shown that the conserved quantity of the apparatus cannot be used for a “pointer reading.” The following two chapters discuss the nature of the exactly measurable quantities. In §4, exactly measurable quantities are explicitly determined. It is shown that the measurement of projection operators in the Hilbert space of the object which commute with the operators of the restricted Poincaré group give all the information on the states of the object that can be obtained by accurate measurements. In §5, the measurement on objects which are composed of more than one particle is discussed. The last chapter, §6, deals with approximately measurable quantities, but no complete estimate of the unavoidable inaccuracy of the measurement of these is obtained. It also contains some concluding remarks.
Quantum measurement is a dynamical process of an apparatus coupled to a test system. Ideal measurement of the z-component of a spin-21 (sz=±21) has been modeled by the Curie-Weiss model for quantum measurement. Recently, the model was generalized to higher spin and the thermodynamics was solved. Here the dynamics is considered. To this end, the dynamics for spin-21 case are cast in general notation. The dynamics of the measurement of the z-component of a spin-1 (sz=0,±1) are solved in detail and evaluated numerically. Energy costs of the measurement, which are macroscopic, are evaluated. Generalization to higher spin is straightforward.
By making use of Schwinger’s oscillator model of angular momentum, we put forward an interesting connection among three solvable Hamiltonians, widely used for discussions on the quantum measurement problem. This connection implies that a particular macroscopic limit has to be taken for these models to be physically sensible. PACS: 03.65.Fd; 03.80.+r; 42.52.+x; 03,65.BzThe quantum measurement problem [1] [2] has been a central issue in the foundations and interpretation of quantum mechanics, and is profoundly related to the investigation of the internal consistency of quantum theory. In order to find a resolution within the quantum mechanical framework, one usually describes a quantum measurement process in the following way: An elementary particle Q, on which the measurement is performed, interacts with a detection system D, which is considered to be made up of N elementary constituents. Generally, it is not easy to handle such a complicated system like Q + D, however, it is also true that several solvable models of measurement processes are now at hand. Among these are the Cini [3] and Coleman-Hepp [4] Hamiltonians and its modified version [5], which were all proposed
In textbooks, ideal quantum measurements are described in terms of the tested system only by the collapse postulate and Born's rule. This level of description offers a rather flexible position for the interpretation of quantum mechanics. Here we analyse an ideal measurement as a process of interaction between the tested system S and an apparatus A, so as to derive the properties postulated in textbooks. We thus consider within standard quantum mechanics the measurement of a quantum spin component ŝ z by an apparatus A, being a magnet coupled to a bath. We first consider the evolution of the density operator of S+A describing a large set of runs of the measurement process. The approach describes the disappearance of the off-diagonal terms (“truncation”) of the density matrix as a physical effect due to A, while the registration of the outcome has classical features due to the large size of the pointer variable, the magnetisation. A quantum ambiguity implies that the density matrix at the final time can be decomposed on many bases, not only the one of the measurement. This quantum oddity prevents to connect individual outcomes to measurements, a difficulty known as the “measurement problem”. It is shown that it is circumvented by the apparatus as well, since the evolution in a small time interval erases all decompositions, except the one on the measurement basis. Once one can derive the outcome of individual events from quantum theory, the so-called “collapse of the wave function” or the “reduction of the state” appears as the result of a selection of runs among the original large set. Hence nothing more than standard quantum mechanics is needed to explain features of measurements. The employed statistical formulation is advocated for the teaching of quantum theory.