Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Physical Review

Optimal Measuring Apparatus

Mutsuo M. Yanase

Published Jul 15, 1961• 180 citations
Publisher

Abstract

An upper limit for the accuracy of the measurement of a simple quantity which does not commute with a conserved quantity is obtained in terms of the "size" of the apparatus. The "size" of the apparatus is defined as the mean square value ${\ensuremath{\hbar}}^{2}{M}^{2}$ of the conserved quantity for the apparatus which is, in the example chosen, the $z$ component of the angular momentum. The measured quantity is the projection of a spin in a perpendicular direction. It is found that the probability of an unsuccessful measurement is at least $\frac{1}{8{M}^{2}}$.

DOI
10.1103/physrev.123.666

Related papers

Limitations on quantum measurements. II. Analysis of a model example

G. C. Ghirardi, F. Miglietta, A. Rimini +1 more

A solvable model of an apparatus for measuring a spin component of a spin-1/2 particle is considered. The model enjoys full rotational invariance and, in the limit case in which a part of the apparatus becomes infinitely massive, works according to the ideal measurement scheme. The model is applied to the study of the deviations from the ideal measurement scheme imposed by the conservation of angular momentum. The detailed analysis of the model allows one to calculate the size of the various nonideal terms in the measurement scheme and to understand the physical mechanism which gives rise to such terms.

Physical review. D. Particles, fields, gravitation, and cosmology/Physical review. D. Particles and fields•Jul 15, 1981•16 citations

Limitations on quantum measurements. I. Determination of the minimal amount of nonideality and identification of the optimal measuring apparatuses

G. C. Ghirardi, F. Miglietta, A. Rimini +1 more

The problem of determining the minimal deviation from the ideal scheme in a measurement, compatible with the existence of additive conserved quantities, is reconsidered. In the case of the measurement of a spin component of a spin-1/2 particle, we rederive in a simple and rigorous way the bound previously obtained by Yanase. The procedure allows the derivation of definite equations characterizing an optimal measuring apparatus. A detailed discussion of the possible malfunctioning of the apparatuses is also given.

Physical review. D. Particles, fields, gravitation, and cosmology/Physical review. D. Particles and fields•Jul 15, 1981•48 citations

Exact Solutions for Spin Conserving Models and the Wigner-Araki-Yanase Theorem

Michael Steiner, Ronald Rendell

The Wigner-Araki-Yanase (WAY) theorem is a well-known theorem regarding limitations of quantum measurement in the presence of additive conservation laws. Under the assumptions of the von Neumann measurement model, for which the system conserved quantity $L_{S}$ is bounded, given a conserved total additive system plus apparatus quantity $L_{SA}$, the measurement operator $E_{S}$ must commute with $L_{S}$. Prior proofs have exploited the properties of unitary evolution constrained by momentum conserving operations that tend to obscure the physical nature of the WAY theorem and as well lead to bounds on performance. As it is generally agreed that momentum is always exactly conserved in measurement, we instead develop a general angular momentum conserving model of measurement. This model is shown to lead to a simple explanation of the major implications of the WAY theorem and provides exact results of the effects of measurement based on the apparatus model. This is shown by both tracing the apparatus from the density matrix and also via a system-only channel model based on Kraus operators.

quant-pharXiv:2606.02861•Jun 3, 2026•0 citations

CONSERVATION OF ANGULAR MOMENTUM IN QUANTUM MECHANICS

Lele FAN, Feng Wang, Tianhai ZENG

The recent two papers have successively proposed the concepts and more precise expressions of strict conservation or statistical conservation of physical quantities, which are different from the expression of a conserved quantity in quantum mechanics. The Hamiltonian operator of the system discussed in this paper are independent of time, so it is commutative with the operators of an angular momentum itself, its component and its square, so that all these quantities are conserved quantities. In an isolated composite system, one of the angular momentum components of the total system are strictly conserved, while the angular momentum components of the subsystems can only be conserved statistically, both of which can be expressed in terms of eigenvalues and eigenfunctions. Generally, angular momentum itself does not have eigenvalues and eigenfunctions, so it cannot be expressed as strict conservation in terms of these concepts. Although there are eigenvalues and eigenfunctions for the square of angular momentum, they cannot express strict conservation either. And they can only be expressed as statistical conservation.

Wuli yu gongcheng.•Oct 1, 2024•0 citations

INFORMATION CONTENTS OF DISTRIBUTIONS

Eugene Paul Wigner, Mutsuo M. Yanase

The entropy, as usually defined, is a measure of our ignorance and, if multiplied by — 1, can be considered as a measure of our knowledge of the state of a system.1 It is a measure of our total knowledge into which the knowledge of the value of any observable enters in the same way (cf. section 3). It is this last circumstance which prompted the considerations leading to the present note. According to quantum mechanical theory, some observables can be measured much more easily than others: the observables which commute with the additive conserved quantities (energy, components of the linear and angular momenta, electric charge) can be measured with microscopic apparatuses; those which do not commute with these quantities need for their measurement macroscopic systems.2 Hence, the problem of defining a measure of our knowledge with respect to the latter quantities arises. The present note will be restricted to the case in which there is only one conserved additive quantity; this will be denoted by k. The name “skew information” has been proposed3 for the amount of information which an ensemble described by a state vector or a statistical matrix contains with respect to the not easily measured quantities. This information relates to the transition probabilities into states which lie askew to the characteristic vectors of the additive conserved quantities.

Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences•Jun 1, 1963•700 citations

Approximate measurement in quantum mechanics

Mary H. Fehrs

This is the first of two papers showing that the quantum problem of measurement remains unsolved even when the initial state of the apparatus is described by a statistical operator and when the results of measurement have a small probability of being erroneous. A realistic treatment of the measurement of observables of microscopic objects (e.g., the position or the spin of an electron) by means of observables of macroscopic apparatus (e.g., the position of a spot on a photographic plate) requires the consideration of errors. The first paper considers measurement procedures of the following type: An initial eigenstate of the object observable leads to a final statistical operator of the object plus apparatus which describes a mixture of “approximate” eigenstates of the apparatus observable. It is proved that each of a large class of initial states leads to a final statistical operator which does not describe any mixture containing even one “approximate” eigenstate of the apparatus observable.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Feb 26, 1993•1 citation
An upper limit for the accuracy of the measurement of a simple quantity which does not commute with a conserved quantity is obtained in terms of the "size" of the apparatus. The "size" of the apparatus is defined as the mean square value \ensuremathℏ2M2{\ensuremath{\hbar}}^{2}{M}^{2}\ensuremathℏ2M2 of the conserved quantity for the apparatus which is, in the example chosen, the zzz component of the angular momentum. The measured quantity is the projection of a spin in a perpendicular direction. It is found that the probability of an unsuccessful measurement is at least 18M2\frac{1}{8{M}^{2}}8M21​.
A solvable model of an apparatus for measuring a spin component of a spin-1/2 particle is considered. The model enjoys full rotational invariance and, in the limit case in which a part of the apparatus becomes infinitely massive, works according to the ideal measurement scheme. The model is applied to the study of the deviations from the ideal measurement scheme imposed by the conservation of angular momentum. The detailed analysis of the model allows one to calculate the size of the various nonideal terms in the measurement scheme and to understand the physical mechanism which gives rise to such terms.
The problem of determining the minimal deviation from the ideal scheme in a measurement, compatible with the existence of additive conserved quantities, is reconsidered. In the case of the measurement of a spin component of a spin-1/2 particle, we rederive in a simple and rigorous way the bound previously obtained by Yanase. The procedure allows the derivation of definite equations characterizing an optimal measuring apparatus. A detailed discussion of the possible malfunctioning of the apparatuses is also given.
The Wigner-Araki-Yanase (WAY) theorem is a well-known theorem regarding limitations of quantum measurement in the presence of additive conservation laws. Under the assumptions of the von Neumann measurement model, for which the system conserved quantity LSL_{S}LS​ is bounded, given a conserved total additive system plus apparatus quantity LSAL_{SA}LSA​, the measurement operator ESE_{S}ES​ must commute with LSL_{S}LS​. Prior proofs have exploited the properties of unitary evolution constrained by momentum conserving operations that tend to obscure the physical nature of the WAY theorem and as well lead to bounds on performance. As it is generally agreed that momentum is always exactly conserved in measurement, we instead develop a general angular momentum conserving model of measurement. This model is shown to lead to a simple explanation of the major implications of the WAY theorem and provides exact results of the effects of measurement based on the apparatus model. This is shown by both tracing the apparatus from the density matrix and also via a system-only channel model based on Kraus operators.
The recent two papers have successively proposed the concepts and more precise expressions of strict conservation or statistical conservation of physical quantities, which are different from the expression of a conserved quantity in quantum mechanics. The Hamiltonian operator of the system discussed in this paper are independent of time, so it is commutative with the operators of an angular momentum itself, its component and its square, so that all these quantities are conserved quantities. In an isolated composite system, one of the angular momentum components of the total system are strictly conserved, while the angular momentum components of the subsystems can only be conserved statistically, both of which can be expressed in terms of eigenvalues and eigenfunctions. Generally, angular momentum itself does not have eigenvalues and eigenfunctions, so it cannot be expressed as strict conservation in terms of these concepts. Although there are eigenvalues and eigenfunctions for the square of angular momentum, they cannot express strict conservation either. And they can only be expressed as statistical conservation.
The entropy, as usually defined, is a measure of our ignorance and, if multiplied by — 1, can be considered as a measure of our knowledge of the state of a system.1 It is a measure of our total knowledge into which the knowledge of the value of any observable enters in the same way (cf. section 3). It is this last circumstance which prompted the considerations leading to the present note. According to quantum mechanical theory, some observables can be measured much more easily than others: the observables which commute with the additive conserved quantities (energy, components of the linear and angular momenta, electric charge) can be measured with microscopic apparatuses; those which do not commute with these quantities need for their measurement macroscopic systems.2 Hence, the problem of defining a measure of our knowledge with respect to the latter quantities arises. The present note will be restricted to the case in which there is only one conserved additive quantity; this will be denoted by k. The name “skew information” has been proposed3 for the amount of information which an ensemble described by a state vector or a statistical matrix contains with respect to the not easily measured quantities. This information relates to the transition probabilities into states which lie askew to the characteristic vectors of the additive conserved quantities.
This is the first of two papers showing that the quantum problem of measurement remains unsolved even when the initial state of the apparatus is described by a statistical operator and when the results of measurement have a small probability of being erroneous. A realistic treatment of the measurement of observables of microscopic objects (e.g., the position or the spin of an electron) by means of observables of macroscopic apparatus (e.g., the position of a spot on a photographic plate) requires the consideration of errors. The first paper considers measurement procedures of the following type: An initial eigenstate of the object observable leads to a final statistical operator of the object plus apparatus which describes a mixture of “approximate” eigenstates of the apparatus observable. It is proved that each of a large class of initial states leads to a final statistical operator which does not describe any mixture containing even one “approximate” eigenstate of the apparatus observable.