Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

International Journal of Quantum Chemistry

Borderline cases in density functional theory

L. Fritsche, J. Koller, Th. Reinert

Published Jan 1, 2004• 9 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Abstract We discuss two examples (antiferromagnetic order in transition metal oxides and van der Waals interaction) where density functional theory (DFT) seems to fail in giving an appropriate description of the actual physical situation. We analyze whether or not this failure reflects only a shortcoming of the approximations to the exchange‐correlation functionals that are commonly used. It is shown that the well‐known incapability of DFT to yield the correct antiferromagnetic (AF) moment and insulating properties of CoO and stoichiometric La2CuO4 may be indicative of a more fundamental deficiency, namely, absence of an exact noninteracting V‐representability of the spin densities in AF materials. By enlarging and reducing the self‐consistent DFT spin densities by an appropriate amount and simultaneously keeping the total densities fixed, one can turn CoO and La2CuO4 into insulators with the correct AF moments. We also discuss the ground‐state energy of two noble gas atoms of radius R0 at a distance R ≫ 2R0, for which situation an exact DFT should yield a 1/R6‐dependence for the difference between the total energy of the bi‐atom and the two atoms at infinite separation. Even if one improves the local density approximation to the exchange‐correlation energy by gradient corrections, this dependence remains outside the current practical framework of DFT. We report and practically check a simple idea as to how this difficulty can be overcome. The method we develop also might prove useful in actually calculating the above defect spin densities for critical AF materials. © 2004 Wiley Periodicals, Inc. Int J Quantum Chem, 2004

DOI
10.1002/qua.20113

Related papers

Characterising and approximating exact density functionals for model electronic systems

Michael Entwistle

Accurate descriptions of the electronic properties of molecules, solids and other materials are crucial in the development of many modern technologies, and are therefore the subject of much scientific research. In tandem with experimental research, computational simulations play a huge role. Density functional theory (DFT) is the most popular method for performing ground-state electronic structure calculations due to its accuracy in many situations along with its computational efficiency. Its time-dependent extension (TDDFT) allows the modelling of the dynamics of systems of interacting electrons. (TD)DFT is an exact theory in principle, but requires approximations in practice, specifically to the many-body effects of electron exchange and correlation (xc), which are described by some unknown universal functional. Despite much success, it often proves inadequate in many scenarios of increasing interest. Therefore, we aim to contribute to the development of improved approximate density functionals. \n \nIn this thesis, we take the approach of studying small model systems for which we can compute the exact functionals. These systems are designed to exhibit the key features present in realistic quantum systems, such as atoms and molecules, which the exact universal (TD)DFT functional is capable of describing, but are often ill-described by the commonly used approximations. By analysing the nature of these exact functionals, we gain valuable insight into their fundamental properties, together with identifying where the current approximations are lacking, thereby allowing us to suggest how these approximations may be improved.

•Jul 1, 2020•0 citations

Spin‐density functional theory: Some open problems and application to inhomogeneous Heisenberg models

K. Capelle, Valter L. Líbero

Abstract Spin‐density functional theory (SDFT) is the most widely implemented and applied formulation of density functional theory. However, it is still finding novel applications, and occasionally encounters unexpected problems. In this article, we first briefly describe a few of the latter, related to issues such as nonuniqueness, noncollinearity, and currents. We then turn to an example of the former, namely SDFT for the Heisenberg model. It is shown that time‐honored concepts of Coulomb DFT, such as the local‐density approximation, can be applied to this (and other) model Hamiltonians, as well, once the concept of “density” has been suitably reinterpreted. Local‐density‐type approximations for the inhomogeneous Heisenberg model are constructed. Numerical applications to finite‐size and impurity systems demonstrate that DFT is a computationally efficient and reasonably accurate alternative to conventional methods of statistical mechanics for the Heisenberg model. © 2005 Wiley Periodicals, Inc. Int J Quantum Chem, 2005

arXiv:cond-mat/0506167•International Journal of Quantum Chemistry•Jan 1, 2005•20 citations

Solving the strong-correlation problem in materials

Eva Pavarini

Abstract This article is a short introduction to the modern computational techniques used to tackle the many-body problem in materials. The aim is to present the basic ideas, using simple examples to illustrate strengths and weaknesses of each method. We will start from density-functional theory (DFT) and the Kohn–Sham construction—the standard computational tools for performing electronic structure calculations. Leaving the realm of rigorous density-functional theory, we will discuss the established practice of adopting the Kohn–Sham Hamiltonian as approximate model. After recalling the triumphs of the Kohn–Sham description, we will stress the fundamental reasons of its failure for strongly-correlated compounds, and discuss the strategies adopted to overcome the problem. The article will then focus on the most effective method so far, the DFT+DMFT technique and its extensions. Achievements, open issues and possible future developments will be reviewed. The key differences between dynamical (DFT+DMFT) and static (DFT+ U ) mean-field methods will be elucidated. In the conclusion, we will assess the apparent dichotomy between first-principles and model-based techniques, emphasizing the common ground that in fact they share.

Rivista Del Nuovo Cimento•Jul 14, 2021•27 citations

Orbital Functionals in Density-Matrix- and Current-Density-Functional Theory

N. Helbig

Density-Functional Theory (DFT), although widely used and very successful in the calculation of several observables, fails to correctly describe strongly correlated materials. In the first part of this work we, therefore, introduce reduced-density-matrix-functional theory (RDMFT) which is one possible way to treat electron correlation beyond DFT. Within this theory the one-body reduced density matrix (1-RDM) is used as the basic variable. Our main interest is the calculation of the fundamental gap which proves very problematic within DFT. In order to calculate the fundamental gap we generalize RDMFT to fractional particle numbers M by describing the system as an ensemble of an N and an N+1 particle system (with N≤ M≤N+1). For each fixed particle number, M, the total energy is minimized with respect to the natural orbitals and their occupation numbers. This leads to the total energy as a function of M. The derivative of this function with respect to the particle number has a discontinuity at integer particle number which is identical to the gap. In addition, we investigate the necessary and sufficient conditions for the 1-RDM of a system with fractional particle number to be N-representable. Numerical results are presented for alkali atoms, small molecules, and periodic systems. Another problem within DFT is the description of non-relativistic many- electron systems in the presence of magnetic fields. It requires the paramagnetic current density and the spin magnetization to be used as basic variables besides the electron density. However, electron-gas-based functionals of current-spin-density-functional Theory (CSDFT) exhibit derivative discontinuities as a function of the magnetic field whenever a new Landau level is occupied, which makes them difficult to use in practice. Since the appearance of Landau levels is, intrinsically, an orbital effect it is appealing to use orbital-dependent functionals. We have developed a CSDFT version of the optimized effective potential (OEP) method which allows for the use of explicitly orbital-dependent functionals in the context of CSDFT. We present the derivation of corresponding equations and show results for a quantum dot in external magnetic fields in the second part of this thesis.

•Jan 1, 2006•4 citations

Why projection-based WF-in-DFT cannot be exact, even with the exact exchange–correlation functional. Formal and practical sources of errors

Enzo Monino, Daria Drwal, Michał Hapka +2 more

We establish theoretical foundations for embedding a correlated wavefunction in an environment formed by Kohn-Sham orbitals. We show that introducing an approximation that equates two, in principle, distinct kinetic-energy functionals yields an embedding functional identical to the projection-based wavefunction-in-density functional theory (DFT) formulation of Miller and co-workers. We demonstrate that this functional is inherently nonvariational: its minimum is not guaranteed to coincide with the exact ground-state energy and remains bounded from above by it. Building on this formal framework, we analyze the dominant sources of error in projection-based density matrix renormalization group-in-DFT embedding with approximate exchange-correlation (xc) functionals. Using molecules with dissociating covalent bonds as a diagnostic example, we demonstrate that the primary source of error is the nonadditive exchange-correlation energy describing the nonclassical coupling between the active subsystem and its environment. Eliminating the fractional-spin error by employing a pair-density xc functional (pair-density functional theory) instead of a semilocal generalized gradient approximation (GGA) does not remedy this deficiency, because the inaccuracy stems from self-interaction effects at the subsystem-environment interface.

arXiv:2603.05303•The Journal of Chemical Physics•Jun 9, 2026•2 citations

Symmetry breaking transforms strong to normal correlation and false metals to true insulators

Alex Zunger, Jia-Xin Xiong, John P. Perdew

Material scientists and condensed matter physicists have long been divided on the issue of choosing the conceptual framework for explaining why open-shell transition-metal oxides tend to be insulators, whereas otherwise successful theories such as DFT often predict them to be (false) metals. Strong correlation becomes the recommended medicine. We point out that strong correlation can be mitigated by allowing DFT to lower the energy by breaking structural, magnetic or dipolar symmetries. Such local motifs are observed experimentally by local probes beyond the 'average structure' determined by X-Ray diffraction. Observed broken symmetries can arise from slow fluctuations that persist over the observation time or longer. The surprising fact is that when symmetry breaking motifs are used as input to electronic structure calculations, false metals are converted into real insulators without the recommended medicine of strong correlation. Consistently, DFT calculations that show energy lowering symmetry breaking correct most cases where DFT, even with advanced exchange-correlation functionals, previously missed the correct metal vs insulator designation. Total energy calculations distinguish systems that support energy-lowering symmetry breaking from those that do not. This approach distinguishes between paramagnetic insulating and metallic phases and shows mass enhancement in Mott metals. The reason is that symmetry breaking removes many of the degeneracies that exist in a symmetry-unbroken system, reducing significantly the need for strong correlation. If one chooses to ignore symmetry breaking, the persistent degeneracies often call for strong correlation treatment. Thus, symmetry breaking transforms strong to normal correlation and false metals to true insulators. This view sheds light on the historic controversy between Mott and Slater that still reverberates today.

cond-mat.mtrl-sciCross-listedarXiv:2512.18236•Dec 23, 2025
Abstract We discuss two examples (antiferromagnetic order in transition metal oxides and van der Waals interaction) where density functional theory (DFT) seems to fail in giving an appropriate description of the actual physical situation. We analyze whether or not this failure reflects only a shortcoming of the approximations to the exchange‐correlation functionals that are commonly used. It is shown that the well‐known incapability of DFT to yield the correct antiferromagnetic (AF) moment and insulating properties of CoO and stoichiometric La2CuO4 may be indicative of a more fundamental deficiency, namely, absence of an exact noninteracting V‐representability of the spin densities in AF materials. By enlarging and reducing the self‐consistent DFT spin densities by an appropriate amount and simultaneously keeping the total densities fixed, one can turn CoO and La2CuO4 into insulators with the correct AF moments. We also discuss the ground‐state energy of two noble gas atoms of radius R0 at a distance R ≫ 2R0, for which situation an exact DFT should yield a 1/R6‐dependence for the difference between the total energy of the bi‐atom and the two atoms at infinite separation. Even if one improves the local density approximation to the exchange‐correlation energy by gradient corrections, this dependence remains outside the current practical framework of DFT. We report and practically check a simple idea as to how this difficulty can be overcome. The method we develop also might prove useful in actually calculating the above defect spin densities for critical AF materials. © 2004 Wiley Periodicals, Inc. Int J Quantum Chem, 2004
Accurate descriptions of the electronic properties of molecules, solids and other materials are crucial in the development of many modern technologies, and are therefore the subject of much scientific research. In tandem with experimental research, computational simulations play a huge role. Density functional theory (DFT) is the most popular method for performing ground-state electronic structure calculations due to its accuracy in many situations along with its computational efficiency. Its time-dependent extension (TDDFT) allows the modelling of the dynamics of systems of interacting electrons. (TD)DFT is an exact theory in principle, but requires approximations in practice, specifically to the many-body effects of electron exchange and correlation (xc), which are described by some unknown universal functional. Despite much success, it often proves inadequate in many scenarios of increasing interest. Therefore, we aim to contribute to the development of improved approximate density functionals. \n \nIn this thesis, we take the approach of studying small model systems for which we can compute the exact functionals. These systems are designed to exhibit the key features present in realistic quantum systems, such as atoms and molecules, which the exact universal (TD)DFT functional is capable of describing, but are often ill-described by the commonly used approximations. By analysing the nature of these exact functionals, we gain valuable insight into their fundamental properties, together with identifying where the current approximations are lacking, thereby allowing us to suggest how these approximations may be improved.
Abstract Spin‐density functional theory (SDFT) is the most widely implemented and applied formulation of density functional theory. However, it is still finding novel applications, and occasionally encounters unexpected problems. In this article, we first briefly describe a few of the latter, related to issues such as nonuniqueness, noncollinearity, and currents. We then turn to an example of the former, namely SDFT for the Heisenberg model. It is shown that time‐honored concepts of Coulomb DFT, such as the local‐density approximation, can be applied to this (and other) model Hamiltonians, as well, once the concept of “density” has been suitably reinterpreted. Local‐density‐type approximations for the inhomogeneous Heisenberg model are constructed. Numerical applications to finite‐size and impurity systems demonstrate that DFT is a computationally efficient and reasonably accurate alternative to conventional methods of statistical mechanics for the Heisenberg model. © 2005 Wiley Periodicals, Inc. Int J Quantum Chem, 2005
Abstract This article is a short introduction to the modern computational techniques used to tackle the many-body problem in materials. The aim is to present the basic ideas, using simple examples to illustrate strengths and weaknesses of each method. We will start from density-functional theory (DFT) and the Kohn–Sham construction—the standard computational tools for performing electronic structure calculations. Leaving the realm of rigorous density-functional theory, we will discuss the established practice of adopting the Kohn–Sham Hamiltonian as approximate model. After recalling the triumphs of the Kohn–Sham description, we will stress the fundamental reasons of its failure for strongly-correlated compounds, and discuss the strategies adopted to overcome the problem. The article will then focus on the most effective method so far, the DFT+DMFT technique and its extensions. Achievements, open issues and possible future developments will be reviewed. The key differences between dynamical (DFT+DMFT) and static (DFT+ U ) mean-field methods will be elucidated. In the conclusion, we will assess the apparent dichotomy between first-principles and model-based techniques, emphasizing the common ground that in fact they share.
Density-Functional Theory (DFT), although widely used and very successful in the calculation of several observables, fails to correctly describe strongly correlated materials. In the first part of this work we, therefore, introduce reduced-density-matrix-functional theory (RDMFT) which is one possible way to treat electron correlation beyond DFT. Within this theory the one-body reduced density matrix (1-RDM) is used as the basic variable. Our main interest is the calculation of the fundamental gap which proves very problematic within DFT. In order to calculate the fundamental gap we generalize RDMFT to fractional particle numbers M by describing the system as an ensemble of an N and an N+1 particle system (with N≤ M≤N+1). For each fixed particle number, M, the total energy is minimized with respect to the natural orbitals and their occupation numbers. This leads to the total energy as a function of M. The derivative of this function with respect to the particle number has a discontinuity at integer particle number which is identical to the gap. In addition, we investigate the necessary and sufficient conditions for the 1-RDM of a system with fractional particle number to be N-representable. Numerical results are presented for alkali atoms, small molecules, and periodic systems. Another problem within DFT is the description of non-relativistic many- electron systems in the presence of magnetic fields. It requires the paramagnetic current density and the spin magnetization to be used as basic variables besides the electron density. However, electron-gas-based functionals of current-spin-density-functional Theory (CSDFT) exhibit derivative discontinuities as a function of the magnetic field whenever a new Landau level is occupied, which makes them difficult to use in practice. Since the appearance of Landau levels is, intrinsically, an orbital effect it is appealing to use orbital-dependent functionals. We have developed a CSDFT version of the optimized effective potential (OEP) method which allows for the use of explicitly orbital-dependent functionals in the context of CSDFT. We present the derivation of corresponding equations and show results for a quantum dot in external magnetic fields in the second part of this thesis.
We establish theoretical foundations for embedding a correlated wavefunction in an environment formed by Kohn-Sham orbitals. We show that introducing an approximation that equates two, in principle, distinct kinetic-energy functionals yields an embedding functional identical to the projection-based wavefunction-in-density functional theory (DFT) formulation of Miller and co-workers. We demonstrate that this functional is inherently nonvariational: its minimum is not guaranteed to coincide with the exact ground-state energy and remains bounded from above by it. Building on this formal framework, we analyze the dominant sources of error in projection-based density matrix renormalization group-in-DFT embedding with approximate exchange-correlation (xc) functionals. Using molecules with dissociating covalent bonds as a diagnostic example, we demonstrate that the primary source of error is the nonadditive exchange-correlation energy describing the nonclassical coupling between the active subsystem and its environment. Eliminating the fractional-spin error by employing a pair-density xc functional (pair-density functional theory) instead of a semilocal generalized gradient approximation (GGA) does not remedy this deficiency, because the inaccuracy stems from self-interaction effects at the subsystem-environment interface.
Material scientists and condensed matter physicists have long been divided on the issue of choosing the conceptual framework for explaining why open-shell transition-metal oxides tend to be insulators, whereas otherwise successful theories such as DFT often predict them to be (false) metals. Strong correlation becomes the recommended medicine. We point out that strong correlation can be mitigated by allowing DFT to lower the energy by breaking structural, magnetic or dipolar symmetries. Such local motifs are observed experimentally by local probes beyond the 'average structure' determined by X-Ray diffraction. Observed broken symmetries can arise from slow fluctuations that persist over the observation time or longer. The surprising fact is that when symmetry breaking motifs are used as input to electronic structure calculations, false metals are converted into real insulators without the recommended medicine of strong correlation. Consistently, DFT calculations that show energy lowering symmetry breaking correct most cases where DFT, even with advanced exchange-correlation functionals, previously missed the correct metal vs insulator designation. Total energy calculations distinguish systems that support energy-lowering symmetry breaking from those that do not. This approach distinguishes between paramagnetic insulating and metallic phases and shows mass enhancement in Mott metals. The reason is that symmetry breaking removes many of the degeneracies that exist in a symmetry-unbroken system, reducing significantly the need for strong correlation. If one chooses to ignore symmetry breaking, the persistent degeneracies often call for strong correlation treatment. Thus, symmetry breaking transforms strong to normal correlation and false metals to true insulators. This view sheds light on the historic controversy between Mott and Slater that still reverberates today.