Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

ACM Symposium on Principles of Distributed Computing (PODC)

Detectable byzantine agreement secure against faulty majorities

Matthias Fitzi, Daniel Gottesman, Martin Hirt, Thomas Holenstein, Adam Smith

Published Jul 21, 2002• 72 citations
Publisher

Abstract

It is well-known that n players, connected only by pairwise secure channels, can achieve Byzantine agreement only if the number t of cheaters satisfies t < n/3, even with respect to computational security. However, for many applications it is sufficient to achieve detectable broadcast. With this primitive, broadcast is only guaranteed when all players are non-faulty ("honest"), but all non-faulty players always reach agreement on whether broadcast was achieved or not. We show that detectable broadcast can be achieved regardless of the number of faulty players (i.e., for all t < n). We give a protocol which is unconditionally secure, as well as two more efficient protocols which are secure with respect to computational assumptions, and the existence of quantum channels, respectively.These protocols allow for secure multi-party computation tolerating any t < n, assuming only pairwise authenticated channels. Moreover, they allow for the setup of public-key infrastructures that are consistent among all participants --- using neither a trusted party nor broadcast channels.Finally, we show that it is not even necessary for players to begin the protocol at the same time step. We give a "detectable Firing Squad" protocol which can be initiated by a single user at any time and such that either all honest players end up with synchronized clocks, or all honest players abort.

DOI
10.1145/571825.571841

Related papers

Broadcast and verifiable secret sharing: new security models and round optimal constructions

Jonathan I. Katz, Ranjit Kumaresan

Broadcast and verifiable secret sharing (VSS) are central building blocks for secure multi-party computation. These protocols are required to be resilient against a Byzantine adversary who controls at most t out of the n parties running the protocol. In this dissertation, we consider the design of fault-tolerant protocols for broadcast and verifiable secret sharing with stronger security guarantees and improved round complexity. Broadcast allows a party to send the same message to all parties, and all parties are assured they have received identical messages. Given a public-key infrastructure (PKI) and digital signatures, it is possible to construct broadcast protocols tolerating any number of corrupted parties. We address two important issues related to broadcast: (1) Almost all existing protocols do not distinguish between corrupted parties (who do not follow the protocol) and honest parties whose secret (signing) keys have been compromised (but who continue to behave honestly); (2) all existing protocols for broadcast are insecure against an adaptive adversary who can choose which parties to corrupt as the protocol progresses. We propose new security models that capture these issues, and present tight feasibility and impossibility results. In the problem of verifiable secret sharing, there is a designated player who shares a secret during an initial sharing phase such that the secret is hidden from an adversary that corrupts at most t parties. In a subsequent reconstruction phase of the protocol, a unique secret, well-defined by the view of honest players in the sharing phase, is reconstructed. The round complexity of VSS protocols is a very important metric of their efficiency. We show two improvements regarding the round complexity of information-theoretic VSS. First, we construct an efficient perfectly secure VSS protocol tolerating t < n/3 corrupted parties that is simultaneously optimal in both the number of rounds and the number of invocations of broadcast. Second, we construct a statistically secure VSS protocol tolerating t < n/2 corrupted parties that has optimal round complexity, and an efficient statistical VSS protocol tolerating t < n/2 corrupted parties that requires one additional round.

•Jan 1, 2012•1 citation

Verifiable secret sharing and multiparty protocols with honest majority

Tal Rabin, Michael Ben-Or

Under the assumption that each participant can broadcast a message to all other participants and that each pair of participants can communicate secretly, we present a verifiable secret sharing protocol, and show that any multiparty protocol, or game with incomplete information, can be achieved if a majority of the players are honest. The secrecy achieved is unconditional and does not rely on any assumption about computational intractability. Applications of these results to Byzantine Agreement are also presented.

ACM Symposium on Theory of Computing (STOC)•Jan 1, 1989•956 citations

Complete characterization of adversaries tolerable in secure multi-party computation (extended abstract)

Martin Hirt, Ueli M. Maurer

The classical results in unconditional multi-party computation among a set of n players state that less than n/2 passive or Iess than n/3 active adversaries can be tolerated; assuming a broadcast channel the threshold for active adversaries is ta/2.Strictly generalizing these results we specify the set of potential y misbehaving players as an arbitrary set of subsets of the player set.We prove the necessary and sufficient conditions for the existence of secure multi-party protocols in terms of the potentially misbehaving player sets.For every function there exists a protocol secure against a set of potential passive collusions if and only if no two of these collusions add up to the full player set.The same condition applies for active adversaries when assuming a broadcast chzmnel.Without broadcast channels, for every function there exists a protocol secure against a set of potential active adverse player sets if and only if no three of these sets add up to the full player set.The complexities of the protocols not using a broadcast channel are polynomial, that of the protocol with broadcast is only slightly higher.

ACM Symposium on Principles of Distributed Computing (PODC)•Jan 1, 1997•165 citations

Broadcast-Efficient Secure Multiparty Computation.

Juan A. Garay, Clint Givens, Rafail Ostrovsky

Secure multiparty computation (MPC) is perhaps the most popular paradigm in the area of cryptographic protocols. It allows several mutually untrustworthy parties to jointly compute a function of their private inputs, without revealing to each other information about those inputs. In the case of unconditional (information-theoretic) security, protocols are known which tolerate a dishonest minority of players, who may coordinate their attack and deviate arbitrarily from the protocol specification. It is typically assumed in these results that parties are connected pairwise by authenticated, private channels, and that in addition they have access to a “broadcast ” channel. Broadcast allows one party to send a consistent message to all other parties, guaranteeing consistency even if the broadcaster is corrupted. Because broadcast cannot be simulated on the point-to-point network when more than a third of the parties are corrupt, it is impossible to construct general MPC protocols in this setting without using a broadcast channel (or some equivalent addition to the model). A great deal of research has focused on increasing the efficiency of MPC, primarily in terms of round complexity and communication complexity. In this work we propose a refinement of the round complexity which we term broadcast complexity. We view the broadcast channel as an expensive resource

•Jan 1, 2012•2 citations

Secure Multiparty Quantum Computation with (Only) a Strict Honest Majority

Michael Ben-Or, Claude Crépeau, Daniel Gottesman +2 more

Secret sharing and multiparty computation (also called "secure function evaluation") are fundamental primitives in modern cryptography, allowing a group of mutually distrustful players to perform correct, distributed computations under the sole assumption that some number of them will follow the protocol honestly. This paper investigates how much trust is necessary -- that is, how many players must remain honest -- in order for distributed quantum computations to be possible. We present a verifiable quantum secret sharing (VQSS) protocol, and a general secure multiparty quantum computation (MPQC) protocol, which can tolerate any \left[ {\frac{{n - 1}} {2}} \right] cheaters among n players. Previous protocols for these tasks tolerated \left[ {\frac{{n - 1}} {4}} \right] and \left[ {\frac{{n - 1}} {6}} \right] cheaters, respectively. The threshold we achieve is tight -- even in the classical case, "fair" multiparty computation is not possible if any set of n/2 players can cheat. Our protocols rely on approximate quantum errorcorrecting codes, which can tolerate a larger fraction of errors than traditional, exact codes. We introduce new families of authentication schemes and approximate codes tailored to the needs of our protocols, as well as new state purification techniques along the lines of those used in faulttolerant quantum circuits.

arXiv:0801.1544•Annual Symposium on Foundations of Computer Science•Jan 1, 2006•102 citations

Almost-Asynchronous MPC with Faulty Minority.

Zuzana Beerliová-Trubíniová, Martin Hirt, Jesper Buus Nielsen

Abstract. Secure multiparty computation (MPC) allows a set of parties to securely evaluate any agreed function of their inputs, even when up to t of the n parties are faulty. Protocols for synchronous networks (where every sent message is assumed to arrive within a constant time) tolerate up to t < n/2 faulty parties, whereas in the more realistic asynchronous setting (with no a priory information on maximal message delay) only security against t < n/3 is possible. Note that even asynchronous Byzantine agreement requires t < n/3. In this paper, we are interested in the minimal synchronicity assumption for achieving security against t < n/2. It turns out that the bottleneck of asynchronous MPC is the distribution of the inputs: Once the inputs are correctly distributed, any deterministic function can be computed over a fully asynchronous network with t < n/2. Furthermore, we show that the inputs can be verifiably distributed with t < n/2, if a single round of synchronous broadcast is available. Composing the above, we obtain the first MPC protocol that achieves security against t < n/2 without assuming a fully synchronous network. Actually our protocol guarantees security against any faulty minority in an almost asynchronous network, i.e. in a network with one single round of synchronous broadcast (followed by a fully asynchronous communication). Furthermore our protocol takes inputs of all parties (in a fully asynchronous network only inputs of n−t parties can be guaranteed), and so achieves everything that is possible in synchronous networks (but impossible in fully asynchronous networks) at the price of just one synchronous broadcast round. As tools for our protocol we introduce the notions of almost non-interactive verifiable secret-sharing and almost non-interactive zero-knowledge proof of knowledge, which are of independent interest as they can serve as efficient replacements for fully non-interactive verifiable secret-sharing and fully non-interactive zero-knowledge proof of knowledge.

•Jan 1, 2008•6 citations
It is well-known that n players, connected only by pairwise secure channels, can achieve Byzantine agreement only if the number t of cheaters satisfies t < n/3, even with respect to computational security. However, for many applications it is sufficient to achieve detectable broadcast. With this primitive, broadcast is only guaranteed when all players are non-faulty ("honest"), but all non-faulty players always reach agreement on whether broadcast was achieved or not. We show that detectable broadcast can be achieved regardless of the number of faulty players (i.e., for all t < n). We give a protocol which is unconditionally secure, as well as two more efficient protocols which are secure with respect to computational assumptions, and the existence of quantum channels, respectively.These protocols allow for secure multi-party computation tolerating any t < n, assuming only pairwise authenticated channels. Moreover, they allow for the setup of public-key infrastructures that are consistent among all participants --- using neither a trusted party nor broadcast channels.Finally, we show that it is not even necessary for players to begin the protocol at the same time step. We give a "detectable Firing Squad" protocol which can be initiated by a single user at any time and such that either all honest players end up with synchronized clocks, or all honest players abort.
Broadcast and verifiable secret sharing (VSS) are central building blocks for secure multi-party computation. These protocols are required to be resilient against a Byzantine adversary who controls at most t out of the n parties running the protocol. In this dissertation, we consider the design of fault-tolerant protocols for broadcast and verifiable secret sharing with stronger security guarantees and improved round complexity. Broadcast allows a party to send the same message to all parties, and all parties are assured they have received identical messages. Given a public-key infrastructure (PKI) and digital signatures, it is possible to construct broadcast protocols tolerating any number of corrupted parties. We address two important issues related to broadcast: (1) Almost all existing protocols do not distinguish between corrupted parties (who do not follow the protocol) and honest parties whose secret (signing) keys have been compromised (but who continue to behave honestly); (2) all existing protocols for broadcast are insecure against an adaptive adversary who can choose which parties to corrupt as the protocol progresses. We propose new security models that capture these issues, and present tight feasibility and impossibility results. In the problem of verifiable secret sharing, there is a designated player who shares a secret during an initial sharing phase such that the secret is hidden from an adversary that corrupts at most t parties. In a subsequent reconstruction phase of the protocol, a unique secret, well-defined by the view of honest players in the sharing phase, is reconstructed. The round complexity of VSS protocols is a very important metric of their efficiency. We show two improvements regarding the round complexity of information-theoretic VSS. First, we construct an efficient perfectly secure VSS protocol tolerating t < n/3 corrupted parties that is simultaneously optimal in both the number of rounds and the number of invocations of broadcast. Second, we construct a statistically secure VSS protocol tolerating t < n/2 corrupted parties that has optimal round complexity, and an efficient statistical VSS protocol tolerating t < n/2 corrupted parties that requires one additional round.
Under the assumption that each participant can broadcast a message to all other participants and that each pair of participants can communicate secretly, we present a verifiable secret sharing protocol, and show that any multiparty protocol, or game with incomplete information, can be achieved if a majority of the players are honest. The secrecy achieved is unconditional and does not rely on any assumption about computational intractability. Applications of these results to Byzantine Agreement are also presented.
The classical results in unconditional multi-party computation among a set of n players state that less than n/2 passive or Iess than n/3 active adversaries can be tolerated; assuming a broadcast channel the threshold for active adversaries is ta/2.Strictly generalizing these results we specify the set of potential y misbehaving players as an arbitrary set of subsets of the player set.We prove the necessary and sufficient conditions for the existence of secure multi-party protocols in terms of the potentially misbehaving player sets.For every function there exists a protocol secure against a set of potential passive collusions if and only if no two of these collusions add up to the full player set.The same condition applies for active adversaries when assuming a broadcast chzmnel.Without broadcast channels, for every function there exists a protocol secure against a set of potential active adverse player sets if and only if no three of these sets add up to the full player set.The complexities of the protocols not using a broadcast channel are polynomial, that of the protocol with broadcast is only slightly higher.
Secure multiparty computation (MPC) is perhaps the most popular paradigm in the area of cryptographic protocols. It allows several mutually untrustworthy parties to jointly compute a function of their private inputs, without revealing to each other information about those inputs. In the case of unconditional (information-theoretic) security, protocols are known which tolerate a dishonest minority of players, who may coordinate their attack and deviate arbitrarily from the protocol specification. It is typically assumed in these results that parties are connected pairwise by authenticated, private channels, and that in addition they have access to a “broadcast ” channel. Broadcast allows one party to send a consistent message to all other parties, guaranteeing consistency even if the broadcaster is corrupted. Because broadcast cannot be simulated on the point-to-point network when more than a third of the parties are corrupt, it is impossible to construct general MPC protocols in this setting without using a broadcast channel (or some equivalent addition to the model). A great deal of research has focused on increasing the efficiency of MPC, primarily in terms of round complexity and communication complexity. In this work we propose a refinement of the round complexity which we term broadcast complexity. We view the broadcast channel as an expensive resource
Secret sharing and multiparty computation (also called "secure function evaluation") are fundamental primitives in modern cryptography, allowing a group of mutually distrustful players to perform correct, distributed computations under the sole assumption that some number of them will follow the protocol honestly. This paper investigates how much trust is necessary -- that is, how many players must remain honest -- in order for distributed quantum computations to be possible. We present a verifiable quantum secret sharing (VQSS) protocol, and a general secure multiparty quantum computation (MPQC) protocol, which can tolerate any \left[ {\frac{{n - 1}} {2}} \right] cheaters among n players. Previous protocols for these tasks tolerated \left[ {\frac{{n - 1}} {4}} \right] and \left[ {\frac{{n - 1}} {6}} \right] cheaters, respectively. The threshold we achieve is tight -- even in the classical case, "fair" multiparty computation is not possible if any set of n/2 players can cheat. Our protocols rely on approximate quantum errorcorrecting codes, which can tolerate a larger fraction of errors than traditional, exact codes. We introduce new families of authentication schemes and approximate codes tailored to the needs of our protocols, as well as new state purification techniques along the lines of those used in faulttolerant quantum circuits.
Abstract. Secure multiparty computation (MPC) allows a set of parties to securely evaluate any agreed function of their inputs, even when up to t of the n parties are faulty. Protocols for synchronous networks (where every sent message is assumed to arrive within a constant time) tolerate up to t < n/2 faulty parties, whereas in the more realistic asynchronous setting (with no a priory information on maximal message delay) only security against t < n/3 is possible. Note that even asynchronous Byzantine agreement requires t < n/3. In this paper, we are interested in the minimal synchronicity assumption for achieving security against t < n/2. It turns out that the bottleneck of asynchronous MPC is the distribution of the inputs: Once the inputs are correctly distributed, any deterministic function can be computed over a fully asynchronous network with t < n/2. Furthermore, we show that the inputs can be verifiably distributed with t < n/2, if a single round of synchronous broadcast is available. Composing the above, we obtain the first MPC protocol that achieves security against t < n/2 without assuming a fully synchronous network. Actually our protocol guarantees security against any faulty minority in an almost asynchronous network, i.e. in a network with one single round of synchronous broadcast (followed by a fully asynchronous communication). Furthermore our protocol takes inputs of all parties (in a fully asynchronous network only inputs of n−t parties can be guaranteed), and so achieves everything that is possible in synchronous networks (but impossible in fully asynchronous networks) at the price of just one synchronous broadcast round. As tools for our protocol we introduce the notions of almost non-interactive verifiable secret-sharing and almost non-interactive zero-knowledge proof of knowledge, which are of independent interest as they can serve as efficient replacements for fully non-interactive verifiable secret-sharing and fully non-interactive zero-knowledge proof of knowledge.