Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

EPJ Web of Conferences

Infinite symmetry in the quantum Hall effect

C.A. Lütken

Published Jan 1, 2014• 3 citations
Publisher

Abstract

The new states of matter and concomitant quantum critical phenomena revealed by the quantum Hall effect appear to be accompanied by an emergent modular symmetry. The extreme rigidity of this infinite symmetry makes it easy to falsify, but two decades of experiments have failed to do so, and the location of quantum critical points predicted by the symmetry is in increasingly accurate agreement with scaling experiments. The symmetry severely constrains the structure of the effective quantum field theory that encodes the low energy limit of quantum electrodynamics of 1010 charges in two dirty dimensions. If this is a non-linear σ-model the target space is a torus, rather than the more familiar sphere. One of the simplest toroidal models gives a critical (correlation length) exponent that agrees with the value obtained from numerical simulations of the quantum Hall effect.

DOI
10.1051/epjconf/20147100079

Related papers

Duality in the quantum Hall system

C.A. Lütken, G.G. Ross

We suggest that a unified description of the integer and fractional phases of the quantum Hall system may be possible if the scaling diagram of transport coefficients is invariant under linear fractional (modular) transformations. In this model the hierarchy of states, as well as the observed universality of critical exponents, are consequences of a discrete SL(2,openZ) symmetry acting on the parameter space of an effective quantum-field theory. Available scaling data on the position of delocalization fixed points in the integer case and the position of mobility fixed points in the fractional case agree with the model within experimental accuracy.

Physical review. B, Condensed matter•May 15, 1992•89 citations

Renormalization-group potential for quantum Hall effects

Jaakko Nissinen, C.A. Lütken

The phenomenological analysis of fully spin-polarized quantum Hall systems, based on holomorphic modular symmetries of the renormalization group (RG) flow, is generalized to more complicated situations where the spin or other ``flavors'' of charge carriers are relevant, and where the symmetry is different. We make the simplest possible ansatz for a family of RG potentials that can interpolate between these symmetries. It is parametrized by a single number $a$ and we show that this suffices to account for almost all scaling data obtained to date. The potential is always symmetric under the main congruence group at level two, and when $a$ takes certain values, this symmetry is enhanced to one of the maximal subgroups of the modular group. We compute the covariant RG $\ensuremath{\beta}$ function, which is a holomorphic vector field derived from the potential, and compare the geometry of this gradient flow with available temperature driven scaling data. The value of $a$ is determined from experiment by finding the location of a quantum critical point, i.e., an unstable zero of the $\ensuremath{\beta}$ function given by a saddle point of the RG potential. The data are consistent with $a\ensuremath{\in}\mathbb{R}$, which together with the symmetry leads to a generalized semicircle law.

arXiv:1111.4902•Physical Review B•Apr 13, 2012•3 citations

Quantum Hall Wave Functions on the Torus

Mikael Fremling

The fractional quantum Hall effect (FQHE), now entering it's fourth decade, continues to draw attention from the condensed matter community. New experiments in recent years are raising hopes that it will be possible to observe quasi-particles with non-abelian anyonic statistics. These particles could form the building blocks of a quantum computer. The quantum Hall states have topologically protected energy gaps to the low-lying set of excitations. This topological order is not a locally measurable quantity but rather a non-local object, and it is one of the keys to it's stability. From an early stage understanding of the FQHE has been facilitate by constructing trial wave functions. The topological classification of these wave functions have given further insight to the nature of the FQHE. An early, and successful, wave function construction for filling fractions ν=p/(2p+1) was that of composite fermions on planar and spherical geometries. Recently, new developments using conformal field theory have made it possible to also construct the full Haldane-Halperin hierarchy wave functions on planar and spherical geometries. In this thesis we extend this construction to a toroidal geometry, i.e. a flat surface with periodic boundary conditions. One of the defining features of topological states of matter in two dimensions is that the ground state is not unique on surfaces with non trivial topology, such as a torus. The archetypical example is the fractional quantum Hall effect, where a state at filling fraction ν=p/q, has at least a q-fold degeneracy on a torus. This has been shown explicitly for a few cases, such as the Laughlin states and the the Moore-Read states, by explicit construction of candidate electron wave functions with good overlap with numerically found states. In this thesis, we construct explicit torus wave functions for a large class of experimentally important quantum liquids, namely the chiral hierarchy states in the lowest Landau level. These states, which includes the prominently observed positive Jain sequence at filling fractions ν=p/(2p+1), are characterized by having boundary modes with only one chirality. Our construction relies heavily on previous work that expressed the hierarchy wave functions on a plane or a sphere in terms of correlation functions in a conformal field theory. This construction can be taken over to the torus when care is taken to ensure correct behaviour under the modular transformations that leave the geometry of the torus unchanged. Our construction solves the long standing problem of engineering torus wave functions for multi-component many-body states. Since the resulting expressions are rather complicated, we have carefully compared the simplest example, that of ν=2/5, with numerically found wave functions. We have found an extremely good overlap for arbitrary values of the modular parameter τ, that describes the geometry of the torus. Having explicit torus wave functions allows us to use the methods developed by Read and Read \\& Rezayi to numerically compute the quantum Hall viscosity. Hall viscosity is conjectured to be a topologically protected macroscopic transport coefficient characterizing the quantum Hall state. It is related to the shift of the same QH-fluid when it is put on a sphere. The good agreement with the theoretical prediction for the 2/5 state strongly suggests that our wave functions encodes all relevant topologically information. We also consider the Hall viscosity in the limit of a very thin torus. There we find that the viscosity changes as we approach the thin torus limit. Because of this we study the Laughlin state in that limit and see how the change in viscosity arises from a change in the Hamiltonian hopping elements. Finally we conclude that there are both qualitative and quantitative difference between the thin and the square torus. Thus, one has to be careful when interpreting results in the thin torus limit.

•Jan 1, 2015•1 citation

Quantum Hall Edges Beyond Luttinger Liquid

Richard Fern

We consider a series of problems regarding quantum Hall edges, focusing on both dynamics and the mathematical structure of edge states. We begin in Chapter 3 with a limiting case of the Laughlin state placed in a very steep confining potential, but which is weak compared to the interactions. We find that the eigenstates have a Jack polynomial structure and an energy spectrum which is extremely different from the well-known Luttinger liquid edge. In Chapter 5 we analyse the inner products of edge state wavefunctions, using an effective description given by a large-N expansion ansatz proposed by J. Dubail, N. Read and E. Rezayi, PRB 86, 245310 (2012). As noted by these authors, the terms in this ansatz can be constrained using symmetry, a procedure we perform to high orders. We then check the conjecture by calculating overlaps exactly for small system sizes and comparing the numerics with our high-order expansion to find excellent agreement. Finally, Chapter 6 considers the behaviour of quantum Hall edges close to the Luttinger liquid fixed point that occurs in the low energy, large system limit. We construct effective Hamiltonians using a local field theory description and then consider the effect of bulk symmetries on this edge. The symmetry analysis produces remarkable simplifications which allow for very accurate descriptions of the low-energy edge physics even relatively far away from the Luttinger liquid fixed point.

•Jan 1, 2018•0 citations

Non-Abelian bosonization and modular transformation approach to superuniversality

Aaron Hui, Eun-Ah Kim, Michael Mulligan

Quantum Hall inter-plateau transitions are physical exemplars of quantum phase transitions. Near each of these transitions, the measured electrical conductivity scales with the same correlation length and dynamical critical exponents, i.e., the critical points are superuniversal. In apparent contradiction to these experiments, prior theoretical studies of quantum Hall phase transitions within the framework of Abelian Chern-Simons theory coupled to matter found correlation length exponents that depend on the value of the quantum critical Hall conductivity. Here, we use non-Abelian bosonization and modular transformations to theoretically study the phenomenon of superuniversality. Specifically, we introduce a new effective theory that has an emergent $U(N)$ gauge symmetry with any $N>1$ for a quantum phase transition between an integer quantum Hall state and an insulator. We then use modular transformations to generate from this theory effective descriptions for transitions between a large class of fractional quantum Hall states whose quasiparticle excitations have Abelian statistics. We find the correlation length and dynamical critical exponents are independent of the particular transition within a controlled 't Hooft large $N$ expansion, i.e., superuniversal! We argue that this superuniversality could survive away from this controlled large $N$ limit using recent duality conjectures.

arXiv:1712.04942•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Mar 20, 2019•27 citations

Implications of experimental probes of the RG-flow in quantum Hall systems

C.A. Lütken, G.G. Ross

We review the implications of the scaling data for the emergent symmetry of the quantum Hall system. The location of the fixed points in the conductivity plane is consistent with the global, non-Abelian discrete symmetry $Γ_{0}(2)$, and the renormalisation group (RG) flow-lines agree closely with that found if the symmetry acts anti-holomorphically. We extend the analysis to consider the rate of the RG flow. For a specific model in which the $Γ_{0}(2)$ symmetry acts anti-holomorphically the scaling close to the fixed points gives a critical delocalisation exponent $ν= 2.38\pm 0.02$, in excellent greement with direct measurements and with numerical simulations. Both the predicted flow-lines and the flow rate also agree with the experimental measurements far away from the critical points, suggesting an emergent topological structure capable of stabilising the symmetry predictions. We hope that this agreement will stimulate further experimental study capable of conclusively testing the symmetry and exploring its associated dynamics.

arXiv:0906.5551•Jun 30, 2009•7 citations
The new states of matter and concomitant quantum critical phenomena revealed by the quantum Hall effect appear to be accompanied by an emergent modular symmetry. The extreme rigidity of this infinite symmetry makes it easy to falsify, but two decades of experiments have failed to do so, and the location of quantum critical points predicted by the symmetry is in increasingly accurate agreement with scaling experiments. The symmetry severely constrains the structure of the effective quantum field theory that encodes the low energy limit of quantum electrodynamics of 1010 charges in two dirty dimensions. If this is a non-linear σ-model the target space is a torus, rather than the more familiar sphere. One of the simplest toroidal models gives a critical (correlation length) exponent that agrees with the value obtained from numerical simulations of the quantum Hall effect.
We suggest that a unified description of the integer and fractional phases of the quantum Hall system may be possible if the scaling diagram of transport coefficients is invariant under linear fractional (modular) transformations. In this model the hierarchy of states, as well as the observed universality of critical exponents, are consequences of a discrete SL(2,openZ) symmetry acting on the parameter space of an effective quantum-field theory. Available scaling data on the position of delocalization fixed points in the integer case and the position of mobility fixed points in the fractional case agree with the model within experimental accuracy.
The phenomenological analysis of fully spin-polarized quantum Hall systems, based on holomorphic modular symmetries of the renormalization group (RG) flow, is generalized to more complicated situations where the spin or other ``flavors'' of charge carriers are relevant, and where the symmetry is different. We make the simplest possible ansatz for a family of RG potentials that can interpolate between these symmetries. It is parametrized by a single number aaa and we show that this suffices to account for almost all scaling data obtained to date. The potential is always symmetric under the main congruence group at level two, and when aaa takes certain values, this symmetry is enhanced to one of the maximal subgroups of the modular group. We compute the covariant RG $\ensuremath{\beta}$ function, which is a holomorphic vector field derived from the potential, and compare the geometry of this gradient flow with available temperature driven scaling data. The value of aaa is determined from experiment by finding the location of a quantum critical point, i.e., an unstable zero of the $\ensuremath{\beta}$ function given by a saddle point of the RG potential. The data are consistent with $a\ensuremath{\in}\mathbb{R}$, which together with the symmetry leads to a generalized semicircle law.
The fractional quantum Hall effect (FQHE), now entering it's fourth decade, continues to draw attention from the condensed matter community. New experiments in recent years are raising hopes that it will be possible to observe quasi-particles with non-abelian anyonic statistics. These particles could form the building blocks of a quantum computer. The quantum Hall states have topologically protected energy gaps to the low-lying set of excitations. This topological order is not a locally measurable quantity but rather a non-local object, and it is one of the keys to it's stability. From an early stage understanding of the FQHE has been facilitate by constructing trial wave functions. The topological classification of these wave functions have given further insight to the nature of the FQHE. An early, and successful, wave function construction for filling fractions ν=p/(2p+1) was that of composite fermions on planar and spherical geometries. Recently, new developments using conformal field theory have made it possible to also construct the full Haldane-Halperin hierarchy wave functions on planar and spherical geometries. In this thesis we extend this construction to a toroidal geometry, i.e. a flat surface with periodic boundary conditions. One of the defining features of topological states of matter in two dimensions is that the ground state is not unique on surfaces with non trivial topology, such as a torus. The archetypical example is the fractional quantum Hall effect, where a state at filling fraction ν=p/q, has at least a q-fold degeneracy on a torus. This has been shown explicitly for a few cases, such as the Laughlin states and the the Moore-Read states, by explicit construction of candidate electron wave functions with good overlap with numerically found states. In this thesis, we construct explicit torus wave functions for a large class of experimentally important quantum liquids, namely the chiral hierarchy states in the lowest Landau level. These states, which includes the prominently observed positive Jain sequence at filling fractions ν=p/(2p+1), are characterized by having boundary modes with only one chirality. Our construction relies heavily on previous work that expressed the hierarchy wave functions on a plane or a sphere in terms of correlation functions in a conformal field theory. This construction can be taken over to the torus when care is taken to ensure correct behaviour under the modular transformations that leave the geometry of the torus unchanged. Our construction solves the long standing problem of engineering torus wave functions for multi-component many-body states. Since the resulting expressions are rather complicated, we have carefully compared the simplest example, that of ν=2/5, with numerically found wave functions. We have found an extremely good overlap for arbitrary values of the modular parameter τ, that describes the geometry of the torus. Having explicit torus wave functions allows us to use the methods developed by Read and Read \\& Rezayi to numerically compute the quantum Hall viscosity. Hall viscosity is conjectured to be a topologically protected macroscopic transport coefficient characterizing the quantum Hall state. It is related to the shift of the same QH-fluid when it is put on a sphere. The good agreement with the theoretical prediction for the 2/5 state strongly suggests that our wave functions encodes all relevant topologically information. We also consider the Hall viscosity in the limit of a very thin torus. There we find that the viscosity changes as we approach the thin torus limit. Because of this we study the Laughlin state in that limit and see how the change in viscosity arises from a change in the Hamiltonian hopping elements. Finally we conclude that there are both qualitative and quantitative difference between the thin and the square torus. Thus, one has to be careful when interpreting results in the thin torus limit.
We consider a series of problems regarding quantum Hall edges, focusing on both dynamics and the mathematical structure of edge states. We begin in Chapter 3 with a limiting case of the Laughlin state placed in a very steep confining potential, but which is weak compared to the interactions. We find that the eigenstates have a Jack polynomial structure and an energy spectrum which is extremely different from the well-known Luttinger liquid edge. In Chapter 5 we analyse the inner products of edge state wavefunctions, using an effective description given by a large-N expansion ansatz proposed by J. Dubail, N. Read and E. Rezayi, PRB 86, 245310 (2012). As noted by these authors, the terms in this ansatz can be constrained using symmetry, a procedure we perform to high orders. We then check the conjecture by calculating overlaps exactly for small system sizes and comparing the numerics with our high-order expansion to find excellent agreement. Finally, Chapter 6 considers the behaviour of quantum Hall edges close to the Luttinger liquid fixed point that occurs in the low energy, large system limit. We construct effective Hamiltonians using a local field theory description and then consider the effect of bulk symmetries on this edge. The symmetry analysis produces remarkable simplifications which allow for very accurate descriptions of the low-energy edge physics even relatively far away from the Luttinger liquid fixed point.
Quantum Hall inter-plateau transitions are physical exemplars of quantum phase transitions. Near each of these transitions, the measured electrical conductivity scales with the same correlation length and dynamical critical exponents, i.e., the critical points are superuniversal. In apparent contradiction to these experiments, prior theoretical studies of quantum Hall phase transitions within the framework of Abelian Chern-Simons theory coupled to matter found correlation length exponents that depend on the value of the quantum critical Hall conductivity. Here, we use non-Abelian bosonization and modular transformations to theoretically study the phenomenon of superuniversality. Specifically, we introduce a new effective theory that has an emergent U(N)U(N)U(N) gauge symmetry with any N>1N>1N>1 for a quantum phase transition between an integer quantum Hall state and an insulator. We then use modular transformations to generate from this theory effective descriptions for transitions between a large class of fractional quantum Hall states whose quasiparticle excitations have Abelian statistics. We find the correlation length and dynamical critical exponents are independent of the particular transition within a controlled 't Hooft large NNN expansion, i.e., superuniversal! We argue that this superuniversality could survive away from this controlled large NNN limit using recent duality conjectures.
We review the implications of the scaling data for the emergent symmetry of the quantum Hall system. The location of the fixed points in the conductivity plane is consistent with the global, non-Abelian discrete symmetry Γ0(2)Γ_{0}(2)Γ0​(2), and the renormalisation group (RG) flow-lines agree closely with that found if the symmetry acts anti-holomorphically. We extend the analysis to consider the rate of the RG flow. For a specific model in which the Γ0(2)Γ_{0}(2)Γ0​(2) symmetry acts anti-holomorphically the scaling close to the fixed points gives a critical delocalisation exponent ν=2.38±0.02ν= 2.38\pm 0.02ν=2.38±0.02, in excellent greement with direct measurements and with numerical simulations. Both the predicted flow-lines and the flow rate also agree with the experimental measurements far away from the critical points, suggesting an emergent topological structure capable of stabilising the symmetry predictions. We hope that this agreement will stimulate further experimental study capable of conclusively testing the symmetry and exploring its associated dynamics.