Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:0906.5551

Implications of experimental probes of the RG-flow in quantum Hall systems

C.A. Lütken, G.G. Ross

Published Jun 30, 2009• 7 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We review the implications of the scaling data for the emergent symmetry of the quantum Hall system. The location of the fixed points in the conductivity plane is consistent with the global, non-Abelian discrete symmetry $Γ_{0}(2)$, and the renormalisation group (RG) flow-lines agree closely with that found if the symmetry acts anti-holomorphically. We extend the analysis to consider the rate of the RG flow. For a specific model in which the $Γ_{0}(2)$ symmetry acts anti-holomorphically the scaling close to the fixed points gives a critical delocalisation exponent $ν= 2.38\pm 0.02$, in excellent greement with direct measurements and with numerical simulations. Both the predicted flow-lines and the flow rate also agree with the experimental measurements far away from the critical points, suggesting an emergent topological structure capable of stabilising the symmetry predictions. We hope that this agreement will stimulate further experimental study capable of conclusively testing the symmetry and exploring its associated dynamics.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.0906.5551

Related papers

Gamma(2) modular symmetry, renormalization group flow and the quantum hall effect

Yvon Georgelin, Thierry Masson, Jean-Christophe Wallet

We construct a family of holomorphic -functions whose renormalization group (RG) flow preserves the (2) modular symmetry and reproduces the observed stability of the Hall plateaus. The semicircle law relating the longitudinal and Hall conductivities that has been experimentally observed is obtained from the integration of the RG equations for any permitted transition which can be identified from the selection rules encoded in the flow diagram. The generic scale dependence of the conductivities is found to agree qualitatively with the present experimental data. The existence of a crossing point occurring in the crossover of the permitted transitions is discussed.

arXiv:cond-mat/9906193•Journal of Physics A Mathematical and General•Dec 15, 1999•18 citations

Renormalization-group potential for quantum Hall effects

Jaakko Nissinen, C.A. Lütken

The phenomenological analysis of fully spin-polarized quantum Hall systems, based on holomorphic modular symmetries of the renormalization group (RG) flow, is generalized to more complicated situations where the spin or other ``flavors'' of charge carriers are relevant, and where the symmetry is different. We make the simplest possible ansatz for a family of RG potentials that can interpolate between these symmetries. It is parametrized by a single number $a$ and we show that this suffices to account for almost all scaling data obtained to date. The potential is always symmetric under the main congruence group at level two, and when $a$ takes certain values, this symmetry is enhanced to one of the maximal subgroups of the modular group. We compute the covariant RG $\ensuremath{\beta}$ function, which is a holomorphic vector field derived from the potential, and compare the geometry of this gradient flow with available temperature driven scaling data. The value of $a$ is determined from experiment by finding the location of a quantum critical point, i.e., an unstable zero of the $\ensuremath{\beta}$ function given by a saddle point of the RG potential. The data are consistent with $a\ensuremath{\in}\mathbb{R}$, which together with the symmetry leads to a generalized semicircle law.

arXiv:1111.4902•Physical Review B•Apr 13, 2012•3 citations

Global phase diagrams for charge transport in two dimensions

C.A. Lütken

It is suggested that it is not necessary to solve the full non-perturbative problem of two-dimensional charge transport in order to obtain global information about the phase and flow diagrams for the quantum Hall system and its relatives. It is argued that the effective quantum field theories encoding the macroscopic properties of these systems are invariant under a symmetry contained in the modular group. New phase and flow diagrams are obtained which exhibit a hierarchy of only odd or only even phases (Hall plateaus). The Kramers-Wannier-like symmetry determines the exact location of all renormalization group fixed points, which appear to be in agreement with available scaling experiments on the quantum Hall system. It also explains the observed 'super-universality', of the delocalization exponent.

Journal of Physics A Mathematical and General•Sep 7, 1993•21 citations

Infinite symmetry in the quantum Hall effect

C.A. Lütken

The new states of matter and concomitant quantum critical phenomena revealed by the quantum Hall effect appear to be accompanied by an emergent modular symmetry. The extreme rigidity of this infinite symmetry makes it easy to falsify, but two decades of experiments have failed to do so, and the location of quantum critical points predicted by the symmetry is in increasingly accurate agreement with scaling experiments. The symmetry severely constrains the structure of the effective quantum field theory that encodes the low energy limit of quantum electrodynamics of 1010 charges in two dirty dimensions. If this is a non-linear σ-model the target space is a torus, rather than the more familiar sphere. One of the simplest toroidal models gives a critical (correlation length) exponent that agrees with the value obtained from numerical simulations of the quantum Hall effect.

EPJ Web of Conferences•Jan 1, 2014•3 citations

The integer quantum Hall plateau transition is a current algebra after all

Martin R. Zirnbauer

The scaling behavior near the transition between plateaus of the Integer Quantum Hall Effect (IQHE) has traditionally been interpreted on the basis of a two-parameter renormalization group (RG) flow conjectured from Pruisken's non-linear sigma model (NL σ M). Yet, the conformal field theory (CFT) describing the critical point remained elusive, and only fragments of a quantitative analytical understanding existed up to now. In the present paper we carry out a detailed analysis of the current-current correlation function for the conductivity tensor, initially in the Chalker-Coddington network model for the IQHE plateau transition and then in its exact reformulation as a supersymmetric vertex model. We develop a heuristic argument for the continuum limit of the non-local conductivity response function at criticality and thus identify a non-Abelian current algebra at level n = 4 . Based on precise lattice expressions for the CFT primary fields we predict the multifractal scaling exponents of critical wavefunctions to be Δ q = q ( 1 − q ) / 4 . The Lagrangian of the RG-fixed point theory for r retarded and r advanced replicas is proposed to be the GL ( r | r ) n = 4 Wess-Zumino-Witten model deformed by a truly marginal perturbation. The latter emerges from the NL σ M by a natural scenario of spontaneous symmetry breaking.

arXiv:1805.12555•Nuclear Physics B•Feb 19, 2019•62 citations

Delocalization, duality, and scaling in the quantum Hall system

C.A. Lütken, G.G. Ross

We construct an effective-field theory for the quantum Hall system which embodies both localization and fractional statistics. The latter involves a Chern-Simons interaction, while the former involves a generalization of conventional localization theory. The theory is invariant under ``complexified'' duality transformations of the conductivities which appear as effective parameters of the model. By exploiting these parameter space symmetries, as well as the conformal symmetry which appears at renormalization-group fixed points, we are able to extract a precise prediction for the whole scaling diagram. It exhibits both fractional and integer phases, the exact location of all fixed points, and universal scaling exponents. With a plausible identification of the universality class of the theory in the replica limit, the value of the critical exponent for the delocalization transition between plateaus in the Hall conductivity is found to be 7/3, in apparent agreement with available scaling experiments.

Physical review. B, Condensed matter•Jul 15, 1993•89 citations
We review the implications of the scaling data for the emergent symmetry of the quantum Hall system. The location of the fixed points in the conductivity plane is consistent with the global, non-Abelian discrete symmetry Γ0(2)Γ_{0}(2)Γ0​(2), and the renormalisation group (RG) flow-lines agree closely with that found if the symmetry acts anti-holomorphically. We extend the analysis to consider the rate of the RG flow. For a specific model in which the Γ0(2)Γ_{0}(2)Γ0​(2) symmetry acts anti-holomorphically the scaling close to the fixed points gives a critical delocalisation exponent ν=2.38±0.02ν= 2.38\pm 0.02ν=2.38±0.02, in excellent greement with direct measurements and with numerical simulations. Both the predicted flow-lines and the flow rate also agree with the experimental measurements far away from the critical points, suggesting an emergent topological structure capable of stabilising the symmetry predictions. We hope that this agreement will stimulate further experimental study capable of conclusively testing the symmetry and exploring its associated dynamics.
We construct a family of holomorphic -functions whose renormalization group (RG) flow preserves the (2) modular symmetry and reproduces the observed stability of the Hall plateaus. The semicircle law relating the longitudinal and Hall conductivities that has been experimentally observed is obtained from the integration of the RG equations for any permitted transition which can be identified from the selection rules encoded in the flow diagram. The generic scale dependence of the conductivities is found to agree qualitatively with the present experimental data. The existence of a crossing point occurring in the crossover of the permitted transitions is discussed.
The phenomenological analysis of fully spin-polarized quantum Hall systems, based on holomorphic modular symmetries of the renormalization group (RG) flow, is generalized to more complicated situations where the spin or other ``flavors'' of charge carriers are relevant, and where the symmetry is different. We make the simplest possible ansatz for a family of RG potentials that can interpolate between these symmetries. It is parametrized by a single number aaa and we show that this suffices to account for almost all scaling data obtained to date. The potential is always symmetric under the main congruence group at level two, and when aaa takes certain values, this symmetry is enhanced to one of the maximal subgroups of the modular group. We compute the covariant RG $\ensuremath{\beta}$ function, which is a holomorphic vector field derived from the potential, and compare the geometry of this gradient flow with available temperature driven scaling data. The value of aaa is determined from experiment by finding the location of a quantum critical point, i.e., an unstable zero of the $\ensuremath{\beta}$ function given by a saddle point of the RG potential. The data are consistent with $a\ensuremath{\in}\mathbb{R}$, which together with the symmetry leads to a generalized semicircle law.
It is suggested that it is not necessary to solve the full non-perturbative problem of two-dimensional charge transport in order to obtain global information about the phase and flow diagrams for the quantum Hall system and its relatives. It is argued that the effective quantum field theories encoding the macroscopic properties of these systems are invariant under a symmetry contained in the modular group. New phase and flow diagrams are obtained which exhibit a hierarchy of only odd or only even phases (Hall plateaus). The Kramers-Wannier-like symmetry determines the exact location of all renormalization group fixed points, which appear to be in agreement with available scaling experiments on the quantum Hall system. It also explains the observed 'super-universality', of the delocalization exponent.
The new states of matter and concomitant quantum critical phenomena revealed by the quantum Hall effect appear to be accompanied by an emergent modular symmetry. The extreme rigidity of this infinite symmetry makes it easy to falsify, but two decades of experiments have failed to do so, and the location of quantum critical points predicted by the symmetry is in increasingly accurate agreement with scaling experiments. The symmetry severely constrains the structure of the effective quantum field theory that encodes the low energy limit of quantum electrodynamics of 1010 charges in two dirty dimensions. If this is a non-linear σ-model the target space is a torus, rather than the more familiar sphere. One of the simplest toroidal models gives a critical (correlation length) exponent that agrees with the value obtained from numerical simulations of the quantum Hall effect.
The scaling behavior near the transition between plateaus of the Integer Quantum Hall Effect (IQHE) has traditionally been interpreted on the basis of a two-parameter renormalization group (RG) flow conjectured from Pruisken's non-linear sigma model (NL σ M). Yet, the conformal field theory (CFT) describing the critical point remained elusive, and only fragments of a quantitative analytical understanding existed up to now. In the present paper we carry out a detailed analysis of the current-current correlation function for the conductivity tensor, initially in the Chalker-Coddington network model for the IQHE plateau transition and then in its exact reformulation as a supersymmetric vertex model. We develop a heuristic argument for the continuum limit of the non-local conductivity response function at criticality and thus identify a non-Abelian current algebra at level n = 4 . Based on precise lattice expressions for the CFT primary fields we predict the multifractal scaling exponents of critical wavefunctions to be Δ q = q ( 1 − q ) / 4 . The Lagrangian of the RG-fixed point theory for r retarded and r advanced replicas is proposed to be the GL ( r | r ) n = 4 Wess-Zumino-Witten model deformed by a truly marginal perturbation. The latter emerges from the NL σ M by a natural scenario of spontaneous symmetry breaking.
We construct an effective-field theory for the quantum Hall system which embodies both localization and fractional statistics. The latter involves a Chern-Simons interaction, while the former involves a generalization of conventional localization theory. The theory is invariant under ``complexified'' duality transformations of the conductivities which appear as effective parameters of the model. By exploiting these parameter space symmetries, as well as the conformal symmetry which appears at renormalization-group fixed points, we are able to extract a precise prediction for the whole scaling diagram. It exhibits both fractional and integer phases, the exact location of all fixed points, and universal scaling exponents. With a plausible identification of the universality class of the theory in the replica limit, the value of the critical exponent for the delocalization transition between plateaus in the Hall conductivity is found to be 7/3, in apparent agreement with available scaling experiments.