Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Physical review. B, Condensed matter

Vertex symmetry and the asymptotic frequency dependence of the self-energy

J. J. Deisz, D. W. Hess, Joseph W. Serene

Published Jan 15, 1997• 13 citations
Publisher

Abstract

We show that the exact 1/${\mathrm{\ensuremath{\varepsilon}}}_{\mathrm{n}}$ dependence of the self-energy for the Hubbard model for large ${\mathrm{\ensuremath{\varepsilon}}}_{\mathrm{n}}$ is obtained entirely from the second-order skeleton diagram evaluated with the exact propagator. Explicit calculation demonstrates that contributions from higher-order skeleton diagrams cancel exactly as a consequence of the crossing symmetry of the renormalized four-point vertex function. From an analysis of the skeleton diagram expansion and direct numerical calculation, we show that an imperfect cancellation of contributions from higher-order skeleton diagrams appears at third and fourth order in U for the shielded potential approximation and the fluctuation exchange approximation, respectively. By itself, this indication of crossing symmetry violation of the vertex function says little about the accuracy of the resulting self-energy and propagator, particularly at low frequency.

DOI
10.1103/physrevb.55.2089

Related papers

Frequency-dependent vertex functions of the ( t,t′ ) Hubbard model at weak coupling

Christoph Husemann, Kay-Uwe Giering, Manfred Salmhofer B

We present a functional renormalization group calculation for the two-dimensional $(t,{t}^{\ensuremath{'}})$-Hubbard model at Van Hove filling. Using a channel decomposition we describe the momentum and frequency dependence of the vertex function in the normal phase. Compared to previous studies that neglect frequency dependencies we find higher pseudocritical scales and a smaller region of $d$-wave superconductivity. A large contribution to the effective interaction is given by a forward-scattering process with finite frequency exchange. We test different frequency parametrizations and in a second calculation include the frequency dependence of the imaginary self-energy. We also generalize the channel decomposition to frequency-dependent fermion-boson vertex functions.

arXiv:1111.6802•Physical Review B•Feb 21, 2012•66 citations

Model Vertices Beyond the GW Approximation

Mikael Hindgren

We study the effects of local vertex corrections to the self energy of the electron gas. We find that a vertex derived from time-dependent density-functional theory can give accurate self energies without including the explicit time dependence of the exchange-correlation potential provided, however, that a proper decay at large momentum transfer (large q) is built into the vertex function. (The local-density approximation for the vertex fails badly.) Total energies are calculated from the Galitskii-Migdal formula and it is shown that a proper large-q behavior, results in a close consistency between the chemical potentials derived from these energies and those obtained directly from the self energy. We show that this internal consistency depends critically on including the same vertex correction in both the self-energy and the screening function. In addition the total energies become almost as accurate as those from elaborate quantum Monte-Carlo (QMC) calculations. We also study the accuracy and utility of the functional for the total energy proposed by Luttinger and Ward and a generalization by Almbladh, von Barth, and van Leeuwen. For the electron gas, even the simplest and readily evaluated approximations to these functionals yield total energies of similar quality as those of QMC calculations. The functionals depend on the one-electron Green's function and the screened Coulomb interaction and already rather crude approximations to these quantities produce accurate energies thus demonstrating the insensitivity of the functionals to their arguments. Different ways of incorporating vertex corrections beyond the $GW$ level are studied in simple, exactly soluble polaron-like models. We study models of a structureless core electron coupled to valence electrons and a local polaron model by Cini, Hewson and Newns. Our model results indicate that the first vertex correction alone will in general not suffice to improve the spectrum away from the quasi-particle peak. By including a subsequence of Mahan's fractal vertex series, however, we obtain results with correct physical properties which agree better with exact model results.

•Jan 1, 1997•1 citation

Correlation induced magnetic symmetry breaking

M. Bartkowiak, K. A. Chao

Using the diagrammatic technique for Hubbard operators we construct a linked-cluster perturbation expansion around the atomic limit of the Hubbard model. We first perform a computer-aided fourth-order calculation. The results clarify discrepances in earlier expansions around the large- U limit. Next, we construct a partial vertex renormalization in the second order of the linked-cluster expansion. The vertex renormalization leads to a selfconsistent magnetic symmetry breaking and allows to study explicitly magnetic oderings of the system in the whole range of temperatures and for arbitrary electron density. The presented results for the case of a half-filled energy band indicate that our approach for the Hubbard model is analogous to the mean-field theory for spin systems, and can serve as a starting point for developing advanced selfconsistent schemes which become exact in the large- U limit. We present results of a systematic numerical study of the non-half-filled-band case. In particular, the vertex-renormalized second-order calculation leads to a qualitatively correct sharp decrease of the Néel temperature as a function of concentration of holes.

Physica Scripta•Jan 1, 1992•0 citations

Accidental accuracy and vertex corrections in $GW$: Exact benchmarks for the extended Hubbard model

Michael O. Atambo

The $GW$ approximation is the standard tool for quasiparticle predictions in materials, yet its regime of validity in correlated systems remains poorly quantified, because \textit{ab initio} vertex corrections are computationally prohibitive. Using exact diagonalization of the half-filled extended Hubbard model on finite rings as a numerically exact reference, we construct the corresponding model-space $GW$ theory on the identical Hilbert space and quantify its error as a function of local ($U$) and non-local ($V$) interaction strength. We find that the required vertex correction changes character across the phase diagram: in the weak-coupling regime the effective vertex $Γ_{\rm eff} < 1$, reflecting the suppression of RPA charge fluctuations by exact short-range correlations, whereas in the Mott regime $Γ_{\rm eff}$ grows monotonically (to $\sim 3$ at $U=8t$ for $N=6$), reflecting the local dynamical self-energy structure required to open the Hubbard gap. Vertex corrections in the electron-hole (polarizability) channel are shown to \emph{worsen} the gap error, indicating that reproducing the Mott gap requires dynamical self-energy structure rather than improved screening. For $V=0$, static COHSEX is accidentally exact at a single crossover $U^* \approx 3.5\,t$; finite $V$, through non-local Fock exchange, splits this point into a double-crossover window that collapses toward weak coupling. Even at the crossover, however, the exact spectral function retains Hubbard-band structure that no static functional reproduces, so gap agreement does not imply functional accuracy. These results yield quantitative diagnostics for the reliability of $GW$ in correlated materials.

arXiv:2608.24838•Aug 25, 2026•3 citations

On the dangers of partial diagrammatic summations: Benchmarks for the two-dimensional Hubbard model in the weak-coupling regime

Jan Gukelberger, Li Huang, Philipp Werner

We study the two-dimensional Hubbard model in the weak-coupling regime and compare the self-energy obtained from various approximate diagrammatic schemes to the result of diagrammatic Monte Carlo simulations, which sum up all weak-coupling diagrams up to a given order. While dynamical mean-field theory provides a good approximation for the local part of the self-energy, including its frequency dependence, the partial summation of bubble and/or ladder diagrams typically yields worse results than second-order perturbation theory. Even widely used self-consistent schemes such as $GW$ or the fluctuation-exchange approximation (FLEX) are found to be unreliable. Combining the dynamical mean-field self-energy with the nonlocal component of $GW$ in $GW + \mathrm{DMFT}$ yields improved results for the local self-energy and nonlocal self-energies of the correct order of magnitude, but here, too, a more reliable scheme is obtained by restricting the nonlocal contribution to the second-order diagram. FLEX + DMFT is found to give accurate results in the low-density regime, but even worse results than FLEX near half-filling.

arXiv:1501.04960•Physical Review B•Jun 9, 2015•75 citations

Approximating the frequency dependence of the effective interaction in the functional renormalization group for many-fermion systems

Timo Reckling, Carsten Honerkamp A

The functional renormalization group has become a widely used tool for the analysis of the leading low-temperature correlations in weakly to moderately coupled many-fermion lattice systems. A bottleneck for quantitatively more precise results is that the treatment of the frequency dependence of the flowing interactions is numerically quite demanding. Yet the frequency dependence is needed to compute relevant self-energies and hence for controlled results on the energy scales for ordering or for the quasiparticle properties. Here we explore an approximate parametrization of the frequency dependence of the interaction vertex that is inspired by established simplifications in the theory of superconductivity and that keeps the numerical effort bounded. We demonstrate the validity of the approximation for Cooper pairing problems and apply it to the two-dimensional Hubbard model.

arXiv:1803.08431•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Aug 8, 2018•9 citations
We show that the exact 1/\ensuremathεn{\mathrm{\ensuremath{\varepsilon}}}_{\mathrm{n}}\ensuremathεn​ dependence of the self-energy for the Hubbard model for large \ensuremathεn{\mathrm{\ensuremath{\varepsilon}}}_{\mathrm{n}}\ensuremathεn​ is obtained entirely from the second-order skeleton diagram evaluated with the exact propagator. Explicit calculation demonstrates that contributions from higher-order skeleton diagrams cancel exactly as a consequence of the crossing symmetry of the renormalized four-point vertex function. From an analysis of the skeleton diagram expansion and direct numerical calculation, we show that an imperfect cancellation of contributions from higher-order skeleton diagrams appears at third and fourth order in U for the shielded potential approximation and the fluctuation exchange approximation, respectively. By itself, this indication of crossing symmetry violation of the vertex function says little about the accuracy of the resulting self-energy and propagator, particularly at low frequency.
We present a functional renormalization group calculation for the two-dimensional $(t,{t}^{\ensuremath{'}})$-Hubbard model at Van Hove filling. Using a channel decomposition we describe the momentum and frequency dependence of the vertex function in the normal phase. Compared to previous studies that neglect frequency dependencies we find higher pseudocritical scales and a smaller region of ddd-wave superconductivity. A large contribution to the effective interaction is given by a forward-scattering process with finite frequency exchange. We test different frequency parametrizations and in a second calculation include the frequency dependence of the imaginary self-energy. We also generalize the channel decomposition to frequency-dependent fermion-boson vertex functions.
We study the effects of local vertex corrections to the self energy of the electron gas. We find that a vertex derived from time-dependent density-functional theory can give accurate self energies without including the explicit time dependence of the exchange-correlation potential provided, however, that a proper decay at large momentum transfer (large q) is built into the vertex function. (The local-density approximation for the vertex fails badly.) Total energies are calculated from the Galitskii-Migdal formula and it is shown that a proper large-q behavior, results in a close consistency between the chemical potentials derived from these energies and those obtained directly from the self energy. We show that this internal consistency depends critically on including the same vertex correction in both the self-energy and the screening function. In addition the total energies become almost as accurate as those from elaborate quantum Monte-Carlo (QMC) calculations. We also study the accuracy and utility of the functional for the total energy proposed by Luttinger and Ward and a generalization by Almbladh, von Barth, and van Leeuwen. For the electron gas, even the simplest and readily evaluated approximations to these functionals yield total energies of similar quality as those of QMC calculations. The functionals depend on the one-electron Green's function and the screened Coulomb interaction and already rather crude approximations to these quantities produce accurate energies thus demonstrating the insensitivity of the functionals to their arguments. Different ways of incorporating vertex corrections beyond the GWGWGW level are studied in simple, exactly soluble polaron-like models. We study models of a structureless core electron coupled to valence electrons and a local polaron model by Cini, Hewson and Newns. Our model results indicate that the first vertex correction alone will in general not suffice to improve the spectrum away from the quasi-particle peak. By including a subsequence of Mahan's fractal vertex series, however, we obtain results with correct physical properties which agree better with exact model results.
Using the diagrammatic technique for Hubbard operators we construct a linked-cluster perturbation expansion around the atomic limit of the Hubbard model. We first perform a computer-aided fourth-order calculation. The results clarify discrepances in earlier expansions around the large- U limit. Next, we construct a partial vertex renormalization in the second order of the linked-cluster expansion. The vertex renormalization leads to a selfconsistent magnetic symmetry breaking and allows to study explicitly magnetic oderings of the system in the whole range of temperatures and for arbitrary electron density. The presented results for the case of a half-filled energy band indicate that our approach for the Hubbard model is analogous to the mean-field theory for spin systems, and can serve as a starting point for developing advanced selfconsistent schemes which become exact in the large- U limit. We present results of a systematic numerical study of the non-half-filled-band case. In particular, the vertex-renormalized second-order calculation leads to a qualitatively correct sharp decrease of the Néel temperature as a function of concentration of holes.
Accidental accuracy and vertex corrections in GWGWGW: Exact benchmarks for the extended Hubbard model
The GWGWGW approximation is the standard tool for quasiparticle predictions in materials, yet its regime of validity in correlated systems remains poorly quantified, because \textit{ab initio} vertex corrections are computationally prohibitive. Using exact diagonalization of the half-filled extended Hubbard model on finite rings as a numerically exact reference, we construct the corresponding model-space GWGWGW theory on the identical Hilbert space and quantify its error as a function of local (UUU) and non-local (VVV) interaction strength. We find that the required vertex correction changes character across the phase diagram: in the weak-coupling regime the effective vertex Γeff<1Γ_{\rm eff} < 1Γeff​<1, reflecting the suppression of RPA charge fluctuations by exact short-range correlations, whereas in the Mott regime ΓeffΓ_{\rm eff}Γeff​ grows monotonically (to ∼3\sim 3∼3 at U=8tU=8tU=8t for N=6N=6N=6), reflecting the local dynamical self-energy structure required to open the Hubbard gap. Vertex corrections in the electron-hole (polarizability) channel are shown to \emph{worsen} the gap error, indicating that reproducing the Mott gap requires dynamical self-energy structure rather than improved screening. For V=0V=0V=0, static COHSEX is accidentally exact at a single crossover U∗≈3.5 tU^* \approx 3.5\,tU∗≈3.5t; finite VVV, through non-local Fock exchange, splits this point into a double-crossover window that collapses toward weak coupling. Even at the crossover, however, the exact spectral function retains Hubbard-band structure that no static functional reproduces, so gap agreement does not imply functional accuracy. These results yield quantitative diagnostics for the reliability of GWGWGW in correlated materials.
We study the two-dimensional Hubbard model in the weak-coupling regime and compare the self-energy obtained from various approximate diagrammatic schemes to the result of diagrammatic Monte Carlo simulations, which sum up all weak-coupling diagrams up to a given order. While dynamical mean-field theory provides a good approximation for the local part of the self-energy, including its frequency dependence, the partial summation of bubble and/or ladder diagrams typically yields worse results than second-order perturbation theory. Even widely used self-consistent schemes such as GWGWGW or the fluctuation-exchange approximation (FLEX) are found to be unreliable. Combining the dynamical mean-field self-energy with the nonlocal component of GWGWGW in GW+DMFTGW + \mathrm{DMFT}GW+DMFT yields improved results for the local self-energy and nonlocal self-energies of the correct order of magnitude, but here, too, a more reliable scheme is obtained by restricting the nonlocal contribution to the second-order diagram. FLEX + DMFT is found to give accurate results in the low-density regime, but even worse results than FLEX near half-filling.
The functional renormalization group has become a widely used tool for the analysis of the leading low-temperature correlations in weakly to moderately coupled many-fermion lattice systems. A bottleneck for quantitatively more precise results is that the treatment of the frequency dependence of the flowing interactions is numerically quite demanding. Yet the frequency dependence is needed to compute relevant self-energies and hence for controlled results on the energy scales for ordering or for the quasiparticle properties. Here we explore an approximate parametrization of the frequency dependence of the interaction vertex that is inspired by established simplifications in the theory of superconductivity and that keeps the numerical effort bounded. We demonstrate the validity of the approximation for Cooper pairing problems and apply it to the two-dimensional Hubbard model.