Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1501.04960 · Physical Review B

On the dangers of partial diagrammatic summations: Benchmarks for the two-dimensional Hubbard model in the weak-coupling regime

Jan Gukelberger, Li Huang, Philipp Werner

Published Jun 9, 2015• 75 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We study the two-dimensional Hubbard model in the weak-coupling regime and compare the self-energy obtained from various approximate diagrammatic schemes to the result of diagrammatic Monte Carlo simulations, which sum up all weak-coupling diagrams up to a given order. While dynamical mean-field theory provides a good approximation for the local part of the self-energy, including its frequency dependence, the partial summation of bubble and/or ladder diagrams typically yields worse results than second-order perturbation theory. Even widely used self-consistent schemes such as $GW$ or the fluctuation-exchange approximation (FLEX) are found to be unreliable. Combining the dynamical mean-field self-energy with the nonlocal component of $GW$ in $GW + \mathrm{DMFT}$ yields improved results for the local self-energy and nonlocal self-energies of the correct order of magnitude, but here, too, a more reliable scheme is obtained by restricting the nonlocal contribution to the second-order diagram. FLEX + DMFT is found to give accurate results in the low-density regime, but even worse results than FLEX near half-filling.

DOI
10.1103/physrevb.91.235114

Related papers

Diagrammatic Monte Carlo approach for diagrammatic extensions of dynamical mean-field theory: Convergence analysis of the dual fermion technique

Jan Gukelberger, Evgeny Kozik, Hartmut Hafermann

The dual fermion approach provides a formally exact prescription for calculating properties of a correlated electron system in terms of a diagrammatic expansion around dynamical mean-field theory (DMFT). Most practical implementations, however, neglect higher-order interaction vertices beyond two-particle scattering in the dual effective action and further truncate the diagrammatic expansion in the two-particle scattering vertex to a leading-order or ladder-type approximation. In this work, we compute the dual fermion expansion for the two-dimensional Hubbard model including all diagram topologies with two-particle interactions to high orders by means of a stochastic diagrammatic Monte Carlo algorithm. We benchmark the obtained self-energy against numerically exact diagrammatic determinant Monte Carlo simulations to systematically assess convergence of the dual fermion series and the validity of these approximations. We observe that, from high temperatures down to the vicinity of the DMFT N\'eel transition, the dual fermion series converges very quickly to the exact solution in the whole range of Hubbard interactions considered ($4\ensuremath{\le}U/t\ensuremath{\le}12$), implying that contributions from higher-order vertices are small. As the temperature is lowered further, we observe slower series convergence, convergence to incorrect solutions, and ultimately divergence. This happens in a regime where magnetic correlations become significant. We find, however, that the self-consistent particle-hole ladder approximation yields reasonable and often even highly accurate results in this regime.

arXiv:1611.07523•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Jul 28, 2017•66 citations

Self-Consistent Calculation of Particle-Hole Diagrams on the Matsubara Frequency: Flex Approximation

José Jesús Rodríguez-Núñez, Sandra Schafroth

We implement the numerical method of summing Green function diagrams on the Matsubara frequency axis for the fluctuation exchange (FLEX) approximation. Our method has previously been applied to the attractive Hubbard model for low density. Here we apply our numerical algorithm to the Hubbard model close to half filling (ρ =0.40), and for T/t = 0.03, in order to study the dynamics of one- and two-particle Green functions. For the values of the chosen parameters we see the formation of three branches which we associate with the two-peak structure in the imaginary part of the self-energy. From the imaginary part of the self-energy we conclude that our system is a Fermi liquid (for the temperature investigated here), since Im Σ( k , ω) ≈ w2 around the chemical potential. We have compared our fully self-consistent FLEX solutions with a lower order approximation where the internal Green functions are approximated by free Green functions. These two approches, i.e., the fully self-consistent and the non-self-consistent ones give different results for the parameters considered here. However, they have similar global results for small densities.

arXiv:cond-mat/9707305•International Journal of Modern Physics C•Oct 1, 1997•1 citation

Comparison of Monte Carlo and diagrammatic calculations for the two-dimensional Hubbard model

Niyazi Bulut, Douglas J. Scalapino, Steven R. White

Monte Carlo results for a two-dimensional Hubbard model in the intermediate-coupling regime U=4t are compared with a diagrammatic spin-fluctuation approximation. Simulations on an 8\ifmmode\times\else\texttimes\fi{}8 lattice doped away from half filling were carried out down to temperatures of order 140 of the bandwidth. Results for the spin susceptibility \ensuremath{\chi}(q,i\ensuremath{\omega}${}_{\mathrm{m}}$), the electron self-energy \ensuremath{\Sigma}(p,i\ensuremath{\omega}${}_{\mathrm{n}}$), various pair-field susceptibilities, and the irreducible particle-particle scattering vertex \ensuremath{\Gamma}(p\ensuremath{'},i\ensuremath{\omega}${}_{\mathrm{n}\ensuremath{'}}$|p,i\ensuremath{\omega}${}_{\mathrm{n}}$) were obtained. A random-phase approximation for \ensuremath{\chi}(q,i\ensuremath{\omega}${}_{\mathrm{m}}$) with a renormalized Coulomb coupling U\ifmmode\bar\else\textasciimacron\fi{} is shown to provide a fit to the Monte Carlo data. A similar approximation for the Berk-Schrieffer spin-fluctuation interaction also provides a reasonable fit to the self-energy \ensuremath{\Sigma}(p,i\ensuremath{\omega}${}_{\mathrm{n}}$) in the region explored by the Monte Carlo data. However, a similar approximation for the irreducible particle-particle interaction failed to reproduce the Monte Carlo results. Higher-order vertex corrections were calculated, but significant discrepancies with Monte Carlo results for \ensuremath{\Gamma} remain.

Physical review. B, Condensed matter•Feb 1, 1993•102 citations

Diagrammatic Monte Carlo for dual fermions

Sergei Iskakov, Andrey E. Antipov, Emanuel Gull

We introduce a numerical algorithm to stochastically sample the dual fermion perturbation series around the dynamical mean field theory, generating all topologies of two-particle interaction vertices. We show results in the weak and strong coupling regime of the half-filled Hubbard model in two dimensions, illustrating that the method converges quickly where dynamical mean field theory is a good approximation, and show that corrections are large in the strong correlation regime at intermediate interaction. The fast convergence of dual corrections to dynamical mean field results illustrates the power of the approach and opens a practical avenue towards the systematic inclusion of nonlocal correlations in correlated materials simulations. An analysis of the frequency scale shows that only low-frequency propagators contribute substantially to the diagrams, putting the inclusion of higher order vertices within reach.

arXiv:1607.01401•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Jul 5, 2016•57 citations

FLEX+DMFT approach to the d -wave superconducting phase diagram of the two-dimensional Hubbard model

Motoharu Kitatani, Naoto Tsuji, Hideo Aoki

The dynamical mean-field theory (DMFT) combined with the fluctuation exchange (FLEX) method, namely, FLEX+DMFT, is an approach for correlated electron systems to incorporate both local and nonlocal long-range correlations in a self-consistent manner. We formulate FLEX+DMFT in a systematic way starting from a Luttinger-Ward functional, and apply it to study the $d$-wave superconductivity in the two-dimensional repulsive Hubbard model. The critical temperature $({T}_{c})$ curve obtained in the FLEX+DMFT exhibits a dome structure as a function of the filling, which has not been clearly observed in the FLEX approach alone. We trace back the origin of the dome to the local vertex correction from DMFT that renders a filling dependence in the FLEX self-energy. We compare the results with those of GW+DMFT, where the ${T}_{c}$-dome structure is qualitatively reproduced due to the same vertex correction effect, but a crucial difference from FLEX+DMFT is that ${T}_{c}$ is always estimated below the N\'eel temperature in GW+DMFT. The single-particle spectral function obtained with FLEX+DMFT exhibits a double-peak structure as a precursor of the Hubbard bands at temperatures above ${T}_{c}$.

arXiv:1505.04865•Physical Review B•Aug 3, 2015•58 citations

Algorithm for computing perturbation series of dynamical mean field theory

Corentin Bertrand, Michel Ferrero, Olivier Parcollet

We show how to use diagrammatic techniques to compute the weak-coupling perturbation series of the self-consistent solution to a dynamical mean field theory (DMFT) problem. This approach constitutes an alternative to using diagrammatic techniques directly as an impurity solver. It allows one to bypass the need of multiple perturbative series resummations within the DMFT self-consistency loop. It can be applied at or out of equilibrium, with any diagrammatic formalism, such as real times, imaginary times, or Matsubara frequencies formalisms. As a proof of principle, we illustrate our method with the half-filled Hubbard model on the Bethe lattice in the DMFT approximation, using quantum quasi Monte Carlo (QQMC) to obtain the impurity perturbation series on the real time axis.

arXiv:2410.00497•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Apr 14, 2025•1 citation
We study the two-dimensional Hubbard model in the weak-coupling regime and compare the self-energy obtained from various approximate diagrammatic schemes to the result of diagrammatic Monte Carlo simulations, which sum up all weak-coupling diagrams up to a given order. While dynamical mean-field theory provides a good approximation for the local part of the self-energy, including its frequency dependence, the partial summation of bubble and/or ladder diagrams typically yields worse results than second-order perturbation theory. Even widely used self-consistent schemes such as GWGWGW or the fluctuation-exchange approximation (FLEX) are found to be unreliable. Combining the dynamical mean-field self-energy with the nonlocal component of GWGWGW in GW+DMFTGW + \mathrm{DMFT}GW+DMFT yields improved results for the local self-energy and nonlocal self-energies of the correct order of magnitude, but here, too, a more reliable scheme is obtained by restricting the nonlocal contribution to the second-order diagram. FLEX + DMFT is found to give accurate results in the low-density regime, but even worse results than FLEX near half-filling.
The dual fermion approach provides a formally exact prescription for calculating properties of a correlated electron system in terms of a diagrammatic expansion around dynamical mean-field theory (DMFT). Most practical implementations, however, neglect higher-order interaction vertices beyond two-particle scattering in the dual effective action and further truncate the diagrammatic expansion in the two-particle scattering vertex to a leading-order or ladder-type approximation. In this work, we compute the dual fermion expansion for the two-dimensional Hubbard model including all diagram topologies with two-particle interactions to high orders by means of a stochastic diagrammatic Monte Carlo algorithm. We benchmark the obtained self-energy against numerically exact diagrammatic determinant Monte Carlo simulations to systematically assess convergence of the dual fermion series and the validity of these approximations. We observe that, from high temperatures down to the vicinity of the DMFT N\'eel transition, the dual fermion series converges very quickly to the exact solution in the whole range of Hubbard interactions considered ($4\ensuremath{\le}U/t\ensuremath{\le}12$), implying that contributions from higher-order vertices are small. As the temperature is lowered further, we observe slower series convergence, convergence to incorrect solutions, and ultimately divergence. This happens in a regime where magnetic correlations become significant. We find, however, that the self-consistent particle-hole ladder approximation yields reasonable and often even highly accurate results in this regime.
We implement the numerical method of summing Green function diagrams on the Matsubara frequency axis for the fluctuation exchange (FLEX) approximation. Our method has previously been applied to the attractive Hubbard model for low density. Here we apply our numerical algorithm to the Hubbard model close to half filling (ρ =0.40), and for T/t = 0.03, in order to study the dynamics of one- and two-particle Green functions. For the values of the chosen parameters we see the formation of three branches which we associate with the two-peak structure in the imaginary part of the self-energy. From the imaginary part of the self-energy we conclude that our system is a Fermi liquid (for the temperature investigated here), since Im Σ( k , ω) ≈ w2 around the chemical potential. We have compared our fully self-consistent FLEX solutions with a lower order approximation where the internal Green functions are approximated by free Green functions. These two approches, i.e., the fully self-consistent and the non-self-consistent ones give different results for the parameters considered here. However, they have similar global results for small densities.
Monte Carlo results for a two-dimensional Hubbard model in the intermediate-coupling regime U=4t are compared with a diagrammatic spin-fluctuation approximation. Simulations on an 8\ifmmode\times\else\texttimes\fi{}8 lattice doped away from half filling were carried out down to temperatures of order 140 of the bandwidth. Results for the spin susceptibility \ensuremath{\chi}(q,i\ensuremath{\omega}m{}_{\mathrm{m}}m​), the electron self-energy \ensuremath{\Sigma}(p,i\ensuremath{\omega}n{}_{\mathrm{n}}n​), various pair-field susceptibilities, and the irreducible particle-particle scattering vertex \ensuremath{\Gamma}(p\ensuremath{'},i\ensuremath{\omega}${}_{\mathrm{n}\ensuremath{'}}$|p,i\ensuremath{\omega}n{}_{\mathrm{n}}n​) were obtained. A random-phase approximation for \ensuremath{\chi}(q,i\ensuremath{\omega}m{}_{\mathrm{m}}m​) with a renormalized Coulomb coupling U\ifmmode\bar\else\textasciimacron\fi{} is shown to provide a fit to the Monte Carlo data. A similar approximation for the Berk-Schrieffer spin-fluctuation interaction also provides a reasonable fit to the self-energy \ensuremath{\Sigma}(p,i\ensuremath{\omega}n{}_{\mathrm{n}}n​) in the region explored by the Monte Carlo data. However, a similar approximation for the irreducible particle-particle interaction failed to reproduce the Monte Carlo results. Higher-order vertex corrections were calculated, but significant discrepancies with Monte Carlo results for \ensuremath{\Gamma} remain.
We introduce a numerical algorithm to stochastically sample the dual fermion perturbation series around the dynamical mean field theory, generating all topologies of two-particle interaction vertices. We show results in the weak and strong coupling regime of the half-filled Hubbard model in two dimensions, illustrating that the method converges quickly where dynamical mean field theory is a good approximation, and show that corrections are large in the strong correlation regime at intermediate interaction. The fast convergence of dual corrections to dynamical mean field results illustrates the power of the approach and opens a practical avenue towards the systematic inclusion of nonlocal correlations in correlated materials simulations. An analysis of the frequency scale shows that only low-frequency propagators contribute substantially to the diagrams, putting the inclusion of higher order vertices within reach.
The dynamical mean-field theory (DMFT) combined with the fluctuation exchange (FLEX) method, namely, FLEX+DMFT, is an approach for correlated electron systems to incorporate both local and nonlocal long-range correlations in a self-consistent manner. We formulate FLEX+DMFT in a systematic way starting from a Luttinger-Ward functional, and apply it to study the ddd-wave superconductivity in the two-dimensional repulsive Hubbard model. The critical temperature (Tc)({T}_{c})(Tc​) curve obtained in the FLEX+DMFT exhibits a dome structure as a function of the filling, which has not been clearly observed in the FLEX approach alone. We trace back the origin of the dome to the local vertex correction from DMFT that renders a filling dependence in the FLEX self-energy. We compare the results with those of GW+DMFT, where the Tc{T}_{c}Tc​-dome structure is qualitatively reproduced due to the same vertex correction effect, but a crucial difference from FLEX+DMFT is that Tc{T}_{c}Tc​ is always estimated below the N\'eel temperature in GW+DMFT. The single-particle spectral function obtained with FLEX+DMFT exhibits a double-peak structure as a precursor of the Hubbard bands at temperatures above Tc{T}_{c}Tc​.
We show how to use diagrammatic techniques to compute the weak-coupling perturbation series of the self-consistent solution to a dynamical mean field theory (DMFT) problem. This approach constitutes an alternative to using diagrammatic techniques directly as an impurity solver. It allows one to bypass the need of multiple perturbative series resummations within the DMFT self-consistency loop. It can be applied at or out of equilibrium, with any diagrammatic formalism, such as real times, imaginary times, or Matsubara frequencies formalisms. As a proof of principle, we illustrate our method with the half-filled Hubbard model on the Bethe lattice in the DMFT approximation, using quantum quasi Monte Carlo (QQMC) to obtain the impurity perturbation series on the real time axis.