Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Physical Review A

Significance of an experiment of the Greenberger-Horne-Zeilinger kind

Henry Pierce Stapp

Published Feb 1, 1993• 32 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Restrictive conditions on the class of allowed physical theories are drawn from the assumption that the predictions of quantum theory are valid for an experiment of the kind proposed by Greenberger, Horne, and Zeilinger [in Bell's Theorem, Quantum Theory and Conceptions of the Universe, edited by M. Kafatos (Kluwer Academic, Dordrecht, 1989)]. It is shown that no theory can be compatible with the following four conditions. (1) The choices to be made by the three experimenters can be treated, in this context, as three independent free variables. (2) For each of the six possible local measurements under consideration, if that local measurement were to be performed, then exactly one of the alternative possible outcomes of this measurement must be selected as the actual outcome. (3) For each triad of measurements in a certain set of possible triads, if that triad were to be performed, then the corresponding triad of selected outcomes must satisfy the correlation condition predicted by quantum theory. (4) For each of the six possible local measurements, if that local measurement were to be performed, then the selected outcome must, according to the theory, be independent of which two experiments will later, in some frame of reference, be performed in the other two regions.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.47.847

Related papers

Future-input-dependent model for Greenberger-Horne-Zeilinger correlations

Izhar Neder, Nathan Argaman

It is widely appreciated, due to Bell's theorem, that quantum phenomena are inconsistent with local-realist models. In this context, locality refers to local causality, and there is thus an open possibility for reproducing the quantum predictions with models which internally violate the causal arrow of time, while otherwise adhering to the relevant locality condition. So far, this possibility has been demonstrated only at a toy-model level, and only for systems involving one or two spins (or photons). The present work extends one of these models to quantum correlations between three or more spins which are entangled in the Greenberger-Horne-Zeilinger state.

arXiv:2401.09398•Physical Review A•Sep 12, 2024•1 citation

Bell's theorem and beyond

Mark S. Hillery, Bernard Yurke

The authors survey what is known about correlations in physical systems. Bell (1964-6) found that locally realistic theories are limited in the types of correlations which they allow. The more recent results of Greenberger, Horne and Zeilinger (1992) and of Hardy (1989) have shown that local realism imposes even stronger restrictions than those found by Bell. It is less well known that quantum mechanics is also limited in the kinds of correlations it can produce. This was first discovered by Tsirelson (1980). The authors discuss Tsirelson's results and related work by Landau (1987). They conclude by presenting further conditions which quantum mechanical correlations must satisfy.

Quantum and Semiclassical Optics Journal of the European Optical Society Part B•Jun 1, 1995•19 citations

Bell's theorem and its optical tests

J. C. Garrison, R. Y. Chiao

This chapter begins with a review of the ideas of locality and realism which provide the basis for the Einstein–Podolsky–Rosen paradox. The general conditions defining a local, realistic theory are stated, and then used to prove Bell's theorem, which yields — for any local, realistic theory — an inequality satisfied by certain linear combinations of correlations. It is shown that this inequality is violated by quantum theory and by experiment. The chapter ends with a discussion of possible experimental loopholes and the alternative Greenberger–Horne–Zeilinger (GHZ) state, which would, in principle, make the use of statistical correlations unnecessary.

Oxford University Press eBooks•Jun 5, 2008•0 citations

Bell's Theorem Without Hidden Variables

Henry Pierce Stapp

Experiments motivated by Bell's theorem have led some physicists to conclude that quantum theory is nonlocal. However, the theoretical basis for such claims is usually taken to be Bell's Theorem, which shows only that if certain predictions of quantum theory are correct, and a strong hidden-variable assumption is valid, then a certain locality condition must fail. This locality condition expresses the idea that what an experimenter freely chooses to measure in one spacetime region can have no effect of any kind in a second region situated spacelike relative to the first. The experimental results conform closely to the predictions of quantum theory in such cases, but the most reasonable conclusion to draw is not that locality fails, but rather that the hidden-variable assumption is false. For this assumption conflicts with the quantum precept that unperformed experiments have no outcomes. The present paper deduces the failure of this locality condition directly from the precepts of quantum theory themselves, in a way that generates no inconsistency or any conflict with the predictions of relativistic quantum field theory.

arXiv:quant-ph/0010047•Oct 11, 2000•9 citations

An exposition of Bell's theorem

Abner Shimony

The purpose of this lecture is to give a self-contained demonstration of a version of Bell's theorem and a discussion of the significance of the theorem and the experiments which it inspired. The lecture should be comprehensible to people who have had no previous acquaintance with the literature on Bell's theorem, but I hope that explicitness about premisses and consequences will make it useful even to those who are familiar with the literature. All versions of Bell's theorem are variations, and usually generalizations, of the pioneering paper of J. S. Bell of 1964, entitled “On the Einstein–Podolsky–Rosen Paradox.” All of them consider an ensemble of pairs of particles prepared in a uniform manner, so that statistical correlations may be expected between outcomes of tests performed on the particles of each pair. If each pair in the ensemble is characterized by the same quantum state φ, then the quantum mechanical predictions for correlations of the outcomes can in principle be calculated when the tests are specified. On the other hand, if it is assumed that the statistical behavior of the pairs is governed by a theory which satisfies certain independence conditions (always similar to the Parameter and Outcome Independence conditions stated below, though the exact details vary from version to version of Bell's theorem), then it is possible to derive a restriction upon the statistical correlations of the outcomes of tests upon the two particles.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Feb 26, 1993•1 citation

Analysis of Bell-Type Experiments and Its Local Realism

Koji Nagata, Tadao Nakamura

We investigate the violation factor of the original Bell-Mermin inequality. Until now, we have used an assumption that the results of measurement are . In this case, the maximum violation factor is as follows: and . The quantum predictions by n-partite Greenberger-Horne-Zeilinger state violate the Bell-Mermin inequality by an amount that grows exponentially with n. Recently, a new measurement theory is proposed [K. Nagata and T. Nakamura, International Journal of Theoretical Physics, 49, 162 (2010)]. The values of measurement outcome are . Here we use the new measurement theory. We consider a multipartite GHZ state. We use the original Bell-Mermin inequality. It turns out that the original Bell-Mermin inequality is satisfied irrespective of the number of particles. In this case, the maximum violation factor is as follows: and . Thus the original Bell-Mermin inequality is satisfied by the new measurement theory. We propose the following conjecture: All the two-orthogonal-settings experimental correlation functions admit local realistic theories irrespective of a state if we use the new measurement theory.

Journal of Applied Mathematics and Physics•Jan 1, 2015•1 citation
Restrictive conditions on the class of allowed physical theories are drawn from the assumption that the predictions of quantum theory are valid for an experiment of the kind proposed by Greenberger, Horne, and Zeilinger [in Bell's Theorem, Quantum Theory and Conceptions of the Universe, edited by M. Kafatos (Kluwer Academic, Dordrecht, 1989)]. It is shown that no theory can be compatible with the following four conditions. (1) The choices to be made by the three experimenters can be treated, in this context, as three independent free variables. (2) For each of the six possible local measurements under consideration, if that local measurement were to be performed, then exactly one of the alternative possible outcomes of this measurement must be selected as the actual outcome. (3) For each triad of measurements in a certain set of possible triads, if that triad were to be performed, then the corresponding triad of selected outcomes must satisfy the correlation condition predicted by quantum theory. (4) For each of the six possible local measurements, if that local measurement were to be performed, then the selected outcome must, according to the theory, be independent of which two experiments will later, in some frame of reference, be performed in the other two regions.
It is widely appreciated, due to Bell's theorem, that quantum phenomena are inconsistent with local-realist models. In this context, locality refers to local causality, and there is thus an open possibility for reproducing the quantum predictions with models which internally violate the causal arrow of time, while otherwise adhering to the relevant locality condition. So far, this possibility has been demonstrated only at a toy-model level, and only for systems involving one or two spins (or photons). The present work extends one of these models to quantum correlations between three or more spins which are entangled in the Greenberger-Horne-Zeilinger state.
The authors survey what is known about correlations in physical systems. Bell (1964-6) found that locally realistic theories are limited in the types of correlations which they allow. The more recent results of Greenberger, Horne and Zeilinger (1992) and of Hardy (1989) have shown that local realism imposes even stronger restrictions than those found by Bell. It is less well known that quantum mechanics is also limited in the kinds of correlations it can produce. This was first discovered by Tsirelson (1980). The authors discuss Tsirelson's results and related work by Landau (1987). They conclude by presenting further conditions which quantum mechanical correlations must satisfy.
This chapter begins with a review of the ideas of locality and realism which provide the basis for the Einstein–Podolsky–Rosen paradox. The general conditions defining a local, realistic theory are stated, and then used to prove Bell's theorem, which yields — for any local, realistic theory — an inequality satisfied by certain linear combinations of correlations. It is shown that this inequality is violated by quantum theory and by experiment. The chapter ends with a discussion of possible experimental loopholes and the alternative Greenberger–Horne–Zeilinger (GHZ) state, which would, in principle, make the use of statistical correlations unnecessary.
Experiments motivated by Bell's theorem have led some physicists to conclude that quantum theory is nonlocal. However, the theoretical basis for such claims is usually taken to be Bell's Theorem, which shows only that if certain predictions of quantum theory are correct, and a strong hidden-variable assumption is valid, then a certain locality condition must fail. This locality condition expresses the idea that what an experimenter freely chooses to measure in one spacetime region can have no effect of any kind in a second region situated spacelike relative to the first. The experimental results conform closely to the predictions of quantum theory in such cases, but the most reasonable conclusion to draw is not that locality fails, but rather that the hidden-variable assumption is false. For this assumption conflicts with the quantum precept that unperformed experiments have no outcomes. The present paper deduces the failure of this locality condition directly from the precepts of quantum theory themselves, in a way that generates no inconsistency or any conflict with the predictions of relativistic quantum field theory.
The purpose of this lecture is to give a self-contained demonstration of a version of Bell's theorem and a discussion of the significance of the theorem and the experiments which it inspired. The lecture should be comprehensible to people who have had no previous acquaintance with the literature on Bell's theorem, but I hope that explicitness about premisses and consequences will make it useful even to those who are familiar with the literature. All versions of Bell's theorem are variations, and usually generalizations, of the pioneering paper of J. S. Bell of 1964, entitled “On the Einstein–Podolsky–Rosen Paradox.” All of them consider an ensemble of pairs of particles prepared in a uniform manner, so that statistical correlations may be expected between outcomes of tests performed on the particles of each pair. If each pair in the ensemble is characterized by the same quantum state φ, then the quantum mechanical predictions for correlations of the outcomes can in principle be calculated when the tests are specified. On the other hand, if it is assumed that the statistical behavior of the pairs is governed by a theory which satisfies certain independence conditions (always similar to the Parameter and Outcome Independence conditions stated below, though the exact details vary from version to version of Bell's theorem), then it is possible to derive a restriction upon the statistical correlations of the outcomes of tests upon the two particles.
We investigate the violation factor of the original Bell-Mermin inequality. Until now, we have used an assumption that the results of measurement are . In this case, the maximum violation factor is as follows: and . The quantum predictions by n-partite Greenberger-Horne-Zeilinger state violate the Bell-Mermin inequality by an amount that grows exponentially with n. Recently, a new measurement theory is proposed [K. Nagata and T. Nakamura, International Journal of Theoretical Physics, 49, 162 (2010)]. The values of measurement outcome are . Here we use the new measurement theory. We consider a multipartite GHZ state. We use the original Bell-Mermin inequality. It turns out that the original Bell-Mermin inequality is satisfied irrespective of the number of particles. In this case, the maximum violation factor is as follows: and . Thus the original Bell-Mermin inequality is satisfied by the new measurement theory. We propose the following conjecture: All the two-orthogonal-settings experimental correlation functions admit local realistic theories irrespective of a state if we use the new measurement theory.