Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences

Ether-Drift Experiments at Mount Wilson

Dayton C. Miller

Published Jun 1, 1925• 64 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Mr. Simon and I have taken about 750 stereoscopic cloud expansion photographs, using apparatus such as that shown diagrammatically in figure 2. Our chief difficulty has been to eliminate stray X-rays, which give rise to meaningless tracks often indistinguishable from those due to scattered quanta.The results of the last 350 plates, in which these rays were reduced to a relatively low intensity, are shown in figure 3.Here I have plotted the deviation A of the observed tracks from the theoretical angle.On the spreading wave theory, the values of A should be nearly uniformly distributed between 0 and 180 degrees.On the quantum theory they should be concentrated near 0, as is obviously the case.The occurrence of tracks at other angles is explicable as due in part to stray X-rays and in part to the method of plotting the results.A more detailed account of the work will be published when further ex- periments, which are now in progress have been completed.The results already obtained, however, permit us to state, with very little uncertainty, that the direction in which a quantum of scattered X-rays can produce an effect is determined at the moment it is scattered, and can be predicted from the direction of motion of the recoil electrons.In other words, scattered X-rays proceed in directed quanta.It is possible to clothe this statement in the language of the wave-theory, if we keep in mind that a wave with a single quantum of energy can pro- duce an effect in only one direction.2

DOI
10.1073/pnas.11.6.306

Related papers

LXXII.The quantum theory of X-ray exposures on photographic emulsions

Ludwik Silberstein, A.P.H. Trivelli

The London Edinburgh and Dublin Philosophical Magazine and Journal of Science•May 1, 1930•20 citations

The wave mechanics of ∝-Ray tracks

Nevill Francis Mott

Abstract The present note is suggested by a recent paper by Prof. Darwin,* and is intended to show how one of the most typically particle-like properties of matter can be derived from the wave mechanics. In the theory of radioactive disintegration, as presented by Gamow, the ∝-particle is represented by a spherical wave which slowly leaks out of the nucleus. On the other hand, the ∝-particle, once emerged, has particle-like properties, the most striking being the ray tracks that it forms in a Wilson cloud chamber. It is a little difficult to picture how it is that an outgoing spherical wave can produce a straight track ; we think intuitively that it should ionise atoms at random throughout space. We could consider that Gamow’s outgoing spherical wave should give the probability of disintegration, but that, when the particle is outside the nucleus, it should be represented by a wave packet moving in a definite direction, so as to produce a straight track. But it ought not to be necessary to do this. The wave mechanics unaided ought to be able to predict the possible results of any observation that we could make on a system, without invoking, until the moment at which the observation is made, the classical particle-like properties of the electrons or α-particles forming that system. If we consider the ∝-ray alone as the system under consideration, then the gas of the Wilson chamber must be considered as the means by which we observe the particle ; so in this case we must consider the ∝-ray as α-particle as soon as it is outside the nucleus, because that is the moment at which the observation is made. If, however, we consider the α-particle and the gas together as one system, then it is ionised atoms that we observe ; interpreting the wave function should give us simply the probability that such and such an atom is ionised. Until this final interpretation is made, no mention should be made of the ∝-ray being a particle at all. The difficulty that we have in picturing how it is that a spherical wave can produce a straight track arises from our tendency to picture the wave as existing in ordinary three dimensional space, whereas we are really dealing with wave functions in the multispace formed by the co-ordinates both of the α-particle and of every atom in the Wilson chamber.

Proceedings of the Royal Society of London Series A Containing Papers of a Mathematical and Physical Character•Dec 2, 1929•237 citations

An Apparent Failure of the Photon Theory of Scattering

Robert S. Shankland

A test has been made of the photon theory of the scattering of high frequency radiation. The pairs of scattered photons and recoil electrons predicted by this theory have been looked for by means of specially designed Geiger-M\"uller counters. Coincident discharges in the electron and photon counters were recorded by means of a vacuum tube amplifying and adding circuit. The scatterers used were air, aluminum, beryllium, filter paper and paraffin. The radiation was the gamma-rays from radium C. Experiments were performed with the counters set at various angles, some where the photon theory predicts coincidences, and others where coincidences should not be expected. The experiments uniformly gave fewer coincidences in the correct positions than were expected, and those observed could in every case be accounted for as chance coincidences due to the finite resolving time of the apparatus. It has not been found possible to bring the results of these experiments into accord with the photon theory of scattering. The wave-mechanical theory of the scattering process has not yet been extended to include the gamma-ray region so that it is impossible to compare this theory with the present experiments. Unless it is shown that the two theories disagree in the gamma-ray region it does not seem possible to reconcile the present experiment with the Bothe-Geiger and Compton-Simon experiments.

Physical Review•Jan 1, 1936•38 citations

Chapter III Rotation of Helium II

Progress in low temperature physics•Jan 1, 1967•11 citations

XXVI. New contributions to interferometry.—Part I. A Reply

Samuel Tolansky

The London Edinburgh and Dublin Philosophical Magazine and Journal of Science•Mar 1, 1944•0 citations

A Correspondence Principle in the Compton Effect

GREGORY A. BREIT

Correspondence theorem for frequencies.---It is well known that the frequency emitted by a hydrogen atom as it falls from one of its quantized states to another may be expressed as a mean value of the frequency of motion of the electron (or overtone thereof) when averaged in the proper manner over orbits intermediate between the initial and final states. In the present paper it is proved that, similarly, the Compton shift is a properly taken mean of the classical Doppler shift. The quantum frequency actually scattered is thus a properly taken average of the frequency which would be scattered on the classical theory as the electron is accelerated from its state of rest to its final recoil condition.Correspondence principle for intensities.---In like manner, the amount of light scattered in various directions may be determined if it is assumed that the intensity in the quantum theory equals a proper average of the intensities scattered according to the classical theory. A comparison is made with observed data on the scattering of $\ensuremath{\gamma}$-rays.The characteristic feature of the present paper is that the corresponding classical electron is assumed to have the same direction of motion as the scattered quantum, whereas an actual classical electron would from symmetry recoil straight forward in the direction of the incident beam, as in Compton's and Woo's theories of intensities. This new point of view eliminates the difficulty of a constant correction-factor which has been encountered by Compton and Woo in their explanation of intensity relations.

Physical Review•Apr 1, 1926•54 citations
Mr. Simon and I have taken about 750 stereoscopic cloud expansion photographs, using apparatus such as that shown diagrammatically in figure 2. Our chief difficulty has been to eliminate stray X-rays, which give rise to meaningless tracks often indistinguishable from those due to scattered quanta.The results of the last 350 plates, in which these rays were reduced to a relatively low intensity, are shown in figure 3.Here I have plotted the deviation A of the observed tracks from the theoretical angle.On the spreading wave theory, the values of A should be nearly uniformly distributed between 0 and 180 degrees.On the quantum theory they should be concentrated near 0, as is obviously the case.The occurrence of tracks at other angles is explicable as due in part to stray X-rays and in part to the method of plotting the results.A more detailed account of the work will be published when further ex- periments, which are now in progress have been completed.The results already obtained, however, permit us to state, with very little uncertainty, that the direction in which a quantum of scattered X-rays can produce an effect is determined at the moment it is scattered, and can be predicted from the direction of motion of the recoil electrons.In other words, scattered X-rays proceed in directed quanta.It is possible to clothe this statement in the language of the wave-theory, if we keep in mind that a wave with a single quantum of energy can pro- duce an effect in only one direction.2
Abstract The present note is suggested by a recent paper by Prof. Darwin,* and is intended to show how one of the most typically particle-like properties of matter can be derived from the wave mechanics. In the theory of radioactive disintegration, as presented by Gamow, the ∝-particle is represented by a spherical wave which slowly leaks out of the nucleus. On the other hand, the ∝-particle, once emerged, has particle-like properties, the most striking being the ray tracks that it forms in a Wilson cloud chamber. It is a little difficult to picture how it is that an outgoing spherical wave can produce a straight track ; we think intuitively that it should ionise atoms at random throughout space. We could consider that Gamow’s outgoing spherical wave should give the probability of disintegration, but that, when the particle is outside the nucleus, it should be represented by a wave packet moving in a definite direction, so as to produce a straight track. But it ought not to be necessary to do this. The wave mechanics unaided ought to be able to predict the possible results of any observation that we could make on a system, without invoking, until the moment at which the observation is made, the classical particle-like properties of the electrons or α-particles forming that system. If we consider the ∝-ray alone as the system under consideration, then the gas of the Wilson chamber must be considered as the means by which we observe the particle ; so in this case we must consider the ∝-ray as α-particle as soon as it is outside the nucleus, because that is the moment at which the observation is made. If, however, we consider the α-particle and the gas together as one system, then it is ionised atoms that we observe ; interpreting the wave function should give us simply the probability that such and such an atom is ionised. Until this final interpretation is made, no mention should be made of the ∝-ray being a particle at all. The difficulty that we have in picturing how it is that a spherical wave can produce a straight track arises from our tendency to picture the wave as existing in ordinary three dimensional space, whereas we are really dealing with wave functions in the multispace formed by the co-ordinates both of the α-particle and of every atom in the Wilson chamber.
A test has been made of the photon theory of the scattering of high frequency radiation. The pairs of scattered photons and recoil electrons predicted by this theory have been looked for by means of specially designed Geiger-M\"uller counters. Coincident discharges in the electron and photon counters were recorded by means of a vacuum tube amplifying and adding circuit. The scatterers used were air, aluminum, beryllium, filter paper and paraffin. The radiation was the gamma-rays from radium C. Experiments were performed with the counters set at various angles, some where the photon theory predicts coincidences, and others where coincidences should not be expected. The experiments uniformly gave fewer coincidences in the correct positions than were expected, and those observed could in every case be accounted for as chance coincidences due to the finite resolving time of the apparatus. It has not been found possible to bring the results of these experiments into accord with the photon theory of scattering. The wave-mechanical theory of the scattering process has not yet been extended to include the gamma-ray region so that it is impossible to compare this theory with the present experiments. Unless it is shown that the two theories disagree in the gamma-ray region it does not seem possible to reconcile the present experiment with the Bothe-Geiger and Compton-Simon experiments.
Correspondence theorem for frequencies.---It is well known that the frequency emitted by a hydrogen atom as it falls from one of its quantized states to another may be expressed as a mean value of the frequency of motion of the electron (or overtone thereof) when averaged in the proper manner over orbits intermediate between the initial and final states. In the present paper it is proved that, similarly, the Compton shift is a properly taken mean of the classical Doppler shift. The quantum frequency actually scattered is thus a properly taken average of the frequency which would be scattered on the classical theory as the electron is accelerated from its state of rest to its final recoil condition.Correspondence principle for intensities.---In like manner, the amount of light scattered in various directions may be determined if it is assumed that the intensity in the quantum theory equals a proper average of the intensities scattered according to the classical theory. A comparison is made with observed data on the scattering of $\ensuremath{\gamma}$-rays.The characteristic feature of the present paper is that the corresponding classical electron is assumed to have the same direction of motion as the scattered quantum, whereas an actual classical electron would from symmetry recoil straight forward in the direction of the incident beam, as in Compton's and Woo's theories of intensities. This new point of view eliminates the difficulty of a constant correction-factor which has been encountered by Compton and Woo in their explanation of intensity relations.