Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Physical Review

An Apparent Failure of the Photon Theory of Scattering

Robert S. Shankland

Published Jan 1, 1936• 38 citations
Publisher

Abstract

A test has been made of the photon theory of the scattering of high frequency radiation. The pairs of scattered photons and recoil electrons predicted by this theory have been looked for by means of specially designed Geiger-M\"uller counters. Coincident discharges in the electron and photon counters were recorded by means of a vacuum tube amplifying and adding circuit. The scatterers used were air, aluminum, beryllium, filter paper and paraffin. The radiation was the gamma-rays from radium C. Experiments were performed with the counters set at various angles, some where the photon theory predicts coincidences, and others where coincidences should not be expected. The experiments uniformly gave fewer coincidences in the correct positions than were expected, and those observed could in every case be accounted for as chance coincidences due to the finite resolving time of the apparatus. It has not been found possible to bring the results of these experiments into accord with the photon theory of scattering. The wave-mechanical theory of the scattering process has not yet been extended to include the gamma-ray region so that it is impossible to compare this theory with the present experiments. Unless it is shown that the two theories disagree in the gamma-ray region it does not seem possible to reconcile the present experiment with the Bothe-Geiger and Compton-Simon experiments.

DOI
10.1103/physrev.49.8

Related papers

A repetition of the Bothe-Geiger experiment

William Ernest Burcham, Wilfrid Bennett Lewis

A repetition has been made, with the introduction of electrical counting methods, of the experiment of Bothe and Geiger on the simultaneous production of a scattered quantum and of a recoil electron in the scattering of X-rays. Evidence has been obtained that such coincidences do actually occur, in agreement with the results of the original experiment, and with the Compton theory of scattering.

Mathematical Proceedings of the Cambridge Philosophical Society•Dec 1, 1936•4 citations

Simultaneity in the Compton Effect

R. Hofstadter, John A. Mcintyre

The Bothe-Geiger experiment has been repeated under improved conditions of time resolution, obtained by using stillbene scintillation counters. The recoil electron and scattered photon are emitted together within a time interval of less than 1.5\ifmmode\times\else\texttimes\fi{}${10}^{\ensuremath{-}8}$ second. The electron and photon are also projected without a delay larger than 1.5\ifmmode\times\else\texttimes\fi{}${10}^{\ensuremath{-}8}$ second after arrival of a quantum. The familiar concepts used in discussions of the Compton effect are shown to be valid.

Physical Review•Apr 1, 1950•20 citations

XXXIV. An experimental study of the quantum nature of X-rays

M. Parker Givens

A study has been made of the X-rays symmetrically diffracted by the (130) and (10) planes of NaCl. The object of the study was to determine whether or not X-rays are diffracted in both directions simultaneously. Two Geiger Muller counters were used to detect the X-rays. A coincidence circuit was connected to the two counters. Over 20 million quanta were counted by each counter, yet only 12 thousand apparent coincidences were observed. A detailed study of the data reveals that this small number of coincidences is best interpreted by assuming no coherence between the two diffracted X-ray beams and attributing the coincidence counts to the chance arrival of two quanta, one at each counter, separated in time by less than the resolving time of the coincidence circuit. This lack of coincidence is in accord with the quantum picture of radiation.

The London Edinburgh and Dublin Philosophical Magazine and Journal of Science•May 1, 1946•8 citations

The Reduced Compton Wavelength and the Energy-Position/Momentum- Time Uncertainties

Pavle Ilija Premović

The Compton scattering is an elastic collision of the x-ray or gamma photons with free electrons (or loosely bound valence shell electrons). This scattering is demonstrated in Fig. 1. In this communication we are combining Heisenberg's uncertainty principle and the Compton scattering. Note, that some of the expressions (including their derivations) of this communication can be found in modern physics textbooks. Figure 1. Schematic representation of Compton scattering, in which an incoming photon scatters from an electron at rest. The electron of the rest mass m e has the rest energy of E r = m e c 2. The Compton scattered electron (hereinafter the Compton electron) posses a relativistic kinetic energy, the relativistic speed υ e and the linear momentum p e = m e υ e. Before scattering, let the photon moves along the positive x-axis having an energy E 0 = hν 0 , frequency ν 0 , wavelength λ 0 and linear momentum p 0 = hν 0 /c, where h (= 6.63 × 10-34 J s) is the Planck constant and c (= 2.99792×10 8 m s-1) is the speed of light. After scattering, the photon moves at an angle θ off the x-axis with an energy E = hν, frequency ν, wavelength λ and momentum p = hν/c. The conservation of linear momentum of the electron after the collision yields, p e 2 = p 0 2 + p 2-2p 0 pcosθ.

•Jan 1, 2018•0 citations

Theory of Compton scattering by interfering electromagnetic fields produced by two independent sources

M. Bertolotti, Concita Sibilia

The interference effect produced by two independent sources can be understood in terms of the detection process, owing to the inability of the detector to know from which of the two sources the photons come. Detection based on the Compton effect seems to be a powerful method for recording the interference between high-frequency coherent fields. It is shown that by taking advantage of the uncertainty over the photon momenta, the scattering probability for an electron in an interference fringe is very high when the electrons are not relativistic. When the fields have the same frequency in the laboratory system, relativistic electrons can "see" the interference only when the angles between the fields are very small. In general, relativistic electrons see interference when the fields are suitably shifted in frequency in the laboratory system.

Physical Review A•Jan 1, 1980•10 citations

The Interconnection of Wave- and Particle-Natures

Mituo Taketani, Masayuki Nagasaki

Although the calculation of the Compton effect on the basis of the theory of light quantum is well known through text books in modern physics, it is not so well known that Compton attempted to explain the result of X-ray scattering by means of the effect of interference, but confronted with a serious difficulty, and thus turned to the theory of light quantum. About the time of the discovery of the Compton effect, Schrödinger derived, by making use of the conservation law of energy and momentum, from the standpoint of the theory of light quantum, the formula for the Doppler effect, and Duane, by applying the quantum condition and also from the viewpoint of the theory of light quantum, the Bragg formula for X-ray scattering. It is interesting to see the process by which they came to apply the theory of light theory to wave phenomena. It should be noted especially that de Broglie's wave theory actually resulted from the theory of light quantum. As we shall see in the text, de Broglie's attempt to understand the particle-nature of light quantum by means of the rest mass of light quantum brought forth, rather, the concept of the wave-nature of material particles. Bohr, who was in doubt about the theory of light quantum, proposed in collaboration with Kramers and Slater the law of statistical conservation of energy and momentum and treated the dispersion of light as a typical wave phenomenon. They proposed the law of statistical conservation of energy and momentum and treated the dispersion of light as a typical wave phenomenon. Their proposal of the law of statistical conservation of energy and momentum was, however, negated immediately by Compton and Simon's experiment with the use of a Wilson chamber. It is scarcely told, so far, in textbooks on the history of science that Kramers and Heisenberg, in generalizing Kramers' wave-theoretical formula for the dispersion of light to include the case of incoherent scattering of light, took account of Smekal's study of the scattering of light on the basis of the theory of light quantum.

WORLD SCIENTIFIC eBooks•Nov 1, 2001•0 citations
A test has been made of the photon theory of the scattering of high frequency radiation. The pairs of scattered photons and recoil electrons predicted by this theory have been looked for by means of specially designed Geiger-M"uller counters. Coincident discharges in the electron and photon counters were recorded by means of a vacuum tube amplifying and adding circuit. The scatterers used were air, aluminum, beryllium, filter paper and paraffin. The radiation was the gamma-rays from radium C. Experiments were performed with the counters set at various angles, some where the photon theory predicts coincidences, and others where coincidences should not be expected. The experiments uniformly gave fewer coincidences in the correct positions than were expected, and those observed could in every case be accounted for as chance coincidences due to the finite resolving time of the apparatus. It has not been found possible to bring the results of these experiments into accord with the photon theory of scattering. The wave-mechanical theory of the scattering process has not yet been extended to include the gamma-ray region so that it is impossible to compare this theory with the present experiments. Unless it is shown that the two theories disagree in the gamma-ray region it does not seem possible to reconcile the present experiment with the Bothe-Geiger and Compton-Simon experiments.
The Bothe-Geiger experiment has been repeated under improved conditions of time resolution, obtained by using stillbene scintillation counters. The recoil electron and scattered photon are emitted together within a time interval of less than 1.5\ifmmode\times\else\texttimes\fi{}${10}^{\ensuremath{-}8}$ second. The electron and photon are also projected without a delay larger than 1.5\ifmmode\times\else\texttimes\fi{}${10}^{\ensuremath{-}8}$ second after arrival of a quantum. The familiar concepts used in discussions of the Compton effect are shown to be valid.
A study has been made of the X-rays symmetrically diffracted by the (130) and (10) planes of NaCl. The object of the study was to determine whether or not X-rays are diffracted in both directions simultaneously. Two Geiger Muller counters were used to detect the X-rays. A coincidence circuit was connected to the two counters. Over 20 million quanta were counted by each counter, yet only 12 thousand apparent coincidences were observed. A detailed study of the data reveals that this small number of coincidences is best interpreted by assuming no coherence between the two diffracted X-ray beams and attributing the coincidence counts to the chance arrival of two quanta, one at each counter, separated in time by less than the resolving time of the coincidence circuit. This lack of coincidence is in accord with the quantum picture of radiation.
The Compton scattering is an elastic collision of the x-ray or gamma photons with free electrons (or loosely bound valence shell electrons). This scattering is demonstrated in Fig. 1. In this communication we are combining Heisenberg's uncertainty principle and the Compton scattering. Note, that some of the expressions (including their derivations) of this communication can be found in modern physics textbooks. Figure 1. Schematic representation of Compton scattering, in which an incoming photon scatters from an electron at rest. The electron of the rest mass m e has the rest energy of E r = m e c 2. The Compton scattered electron (hereinafter the Compton electron) posses a relativistic kinetic energy, the relativistic speed υ e and the linear momentum p e = m e υ e. Before scattering, let the photon moves along the positive x-axis having an energy E 0 = hν 0 , frequency ν 0 , wavelength λ 0 and linear momentum p 0 = hν 0 /c, where h (= 6.63 × 10-34 J s) is the Planck constant and c (= 2.99792×10 8 m s-1) is the speed of light. After scattering, the photon moves at an angle θ off the x-axis with an energy E = hν, frequency ν, wavelength λ and momentum p = hν/c. The conservation of linear momentum of the electron after the collision yields, p e 2 = p 0 2 + p 2-2p 0 pcosθ.
The interference effect produced by two independent sources can be understood in terms of the detection process, owing to the inability of the detector to know from which of the two sources the photons come. Detection based on the Compton effect seems to be a powerful method for recording the interference between high-frequency coherent fields. It is shown that by taking advantage of the uncertainty over the photon momenta, the scattering probability for an electron in an interference fringe is very high when the electrons are not relativistic. When the fields have the same frequency in the laboratory system, relativistic electrons can "see" the interference only when the angles between the fields are very small. In general, relativistic electrons see interference when the fields are suitably shifted in frequency in the laboratory system.
Although the calculation of the Compton effect on the basis of the theory of light quantum is well known through text books in modern physics, it is not so well known that Compton attempted to explain the result of X-ray scattering by means of the effect of interference, but confronted with a serious difficulty, and thus turned to the theory of light quantum. About the time of the discovery of the Compton effect, Schrödinger derived, by making use of the conservation law of energy and momentum, from the standpoint of the theory of light quantum, the formula for the Doppler effect, and Duane, by applying the quantum condition and also from the viewpoint of the theory of light quantum, the Bragg formula for X-ray scattering. It is interesting to see the process by which they came to apply the theory of light theory to wave phenomena. It should be noted especially that de Broglie's wave theory actually resulted from the theory of light quantum. As we shall see in the text, de Broglie's attempt to understand the particle-nature of light quantum by means of the rest mass of light quantum brought forth, rather, the concept of the wave-nature of material particles. Bohr, who was in doubt about the theory of light quantum, proposed in collaboration with Kramers and Slater the law of statistical conservation of energy and momentum and treated the dispersion of light as a typical wave phenomenon. They proposed the law of statistical conservation of energy and momentum and treated the dispersion of light as a typical wave phenomenon. Their proposal of the law of statistical conservation of energy and momentum was, however, negated immediately by Compton and Simon's experiment with the use of a Wilson chamber. It is scarcely told, so far, in textbooks on the history of science that Kramers and Heisenberg, in generalizing Kramers' wave-theoretical formula for the dispersion of light to include the case of incoherent scattering of light, took account of Smekal's study of the scattering of light on the basis of the theory of light quantum.