Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

The Physics Teacher

Teaching Qualitative Energy-eigenfunction Shape with Physlets

Mario Belloni, Wolfgang Christian, Anne J. Cox

Published Oct 29, 2007• 5 citations
Publisher

Abstract

More than 35 years ago, French and Taylor1 outlined an approach to teach students and teachers alike how to understand “qualitative plots of bound-state wave functions.” They described five fundamental statements based on the quantum-mechanical concepts of probability and energy (total and potential), which could be used to deduce the shape of energy eigenfunctions. Despite these important and easy-to-follow statements, this approach has not been universally adopted in the teaching of quantum mechanics.2 For example, recent studies have shown that students' conceptual understanding of quantum mechanics on all levels is surprisingly lacking3 and that misconceptions are universal,4 including that of the relationship between the potential energy function and the resulting energy eigenfunction shape. At the same time, the teaching of quantum mechanical concepts in introductory physics has become increasingly important given the modern technological applications that are based on quantum theory (e.g., PET scans and MRIs). However, most treatments of quantum theory on the introductory level are cursory at best, leaving students with the impression that quantum mechanics is little more than abstract mathematics (a belief that remains with students in their future courses).

DOI
10.1119/1.2798360

Related papers

A First Course in Quantum Mechanics: Nonrelativistic Theory

Ahmad Amer

Based on years of teaching experience, this book provides a clearly structured and accessible introduction to the fundamental principles of quantum mechanics, tailored for undergraduate students. The text builds a strong conceptual and mathematical foundation while promoting intuitive understanding and critical thinking. Students progress from basic concepts such as wave mechanics to more advanced topics within matrix mechanics. Complex concepts are presented in a diligent and understandable way, achieving a balance between conceptual insight and mathematical rigor without oversimplifying the subject. Thoroughly class-tested, this book is designed to support both classroom instruction and independent study. It will serve as a great tool for undergraduates studying introductory and intermediate quantum mechanics, as well as modern physics and quantum systems for engineers.

CRC Press eBooks•Nov 5, 2025•0 citations

Making sense of quantum teleportation: an intervention study on students’ conceptions using a diagrammatic approach

Sebastian Kilde-Westberg, Andreas Johansson, Anna Pearson +1 more

Abstract Quantum physics education at the upper-secondary level traditionally follows a historical approach, rarely extending beyond early 20th-century ideas, leaving students unprepared for comprehending modern quantum technologies central to everyday life and many facets of modern industry. To address this gap, we investigated how upper-secondary students and pre-service teachers understand quantum teleportation when taught with a simplified diagrammatic formalism based on the ZX-calculus, which represents quantum processes as diagrams of wires and boxes. Through phenomenographic analysis of video-recorded group work sessions, written responses to exercises, and a group interview, with a total of $n=21$ n = 21 participants, we identified an outcome space consisting of four qualitatively different, hierarchically ordered categories of description encapsulating the different ways of experiencing quantum teleportation. The categories revealed that a conceptual progression depends on how one understands the temporality in quantum processes, the role of entanglement in quantum teleportation, the active nature of quantum measurements, and interpretations of mathematical operations in the diagrams. Our findings indicate that while a simplified diagrammatic formalism for teaching quantum physics can provide an accessible entry point at the upper-secondary level, it does not automatically resolve fundamental conceptual challenges, and requires careful consideration in terms of developing teaching and learning sequences. Finally, these results provide educators with a deeper understanding of conceptual affordances and challenges for designing and improving instruction, while also highlighting the need for further exploring how students and teachers alike understand quantum phenomena.

arXiv:2511.21443•EPJ Quantum Technology•Nov 13, 2026•1 citation

How to Teach Quantum Mechanics

David Z. Albert

I distinguish between two conceptually different kinds of physical space: a space of ordinary material bodies, which is the space of points at which I could imaginably place (say) the tip of my finger, or the center of a billiard-ball, and a space of elementary physical determinables, which is the smallest space of points such that stipulating what is happening at each one of those points, at every time, amounts to an exhaustive physical history of the universe. In all classical physical theories, these two spaces happen to coincide – and what we mean by calling a theory “classical”, and all we mean by calling a theory “classical”, is (I will argue) precisely that these two spaces coincide. But once the distinction between these two spaces in on the table, it becomes clear that there is no logical or conceptual reason why they must coincide – and it turns out (and this is the main topic of the present paper) that a very simple way of pulling them apart from one another gives us quantum mechanics.

•Jan 7, 2019•1 citation

Theoretical Background

Anne‐Marie Sapse

Inadequate descriptions of atoms and molecules by the methods of classical physics led researchers to propose new ways to describe physical reality, giving birth to a totally new science, quantum mechanics. The methods of quantum mechanics are based on the introduction of a wave function, whose physical meaning is related to the probability of finding a certain particle, at a certain time in a volume element, positioned between x and x + dx in the x = direction, between y and y + dy in the y = direction, and between z and z + dz in the z = direction at certain time t. This wave function Ψ satisfies the Schrödinger equation, $$ \left( { - \frac{{{\hbar ^2}}}{{2m}}{\nabla ^2} + v} \right)\Psi = {\rm E}\Psi,\hbar = \frac{h}{{2\pi }}, $$ or for short, HΨ = EΨ, where H, the Hamiltonian operator, is defined by the expression $$ H = - \frac{{{\hbar ^2}}}{{2m}}{\nabla ^2} + V; $$ h is Planck’s constant; ∇2 is the sum of the partial second derivatives with respect to x, y, and z; m is the mass of the particle; and V is the potential energy of the system. The Hamiltonian H represents the quantum equivalent of the sum of the kinetic energy and potential energy, with V being the potential energy operator and $$ \frac{{ - {\hbar ^2}}}{{2m}}{\nabla ^2} $$ the kinetic energy operator. Finally, E is the total energy of the system and is a number, not an operator.

Birkhäuser Boston eBooks•Jan 1, 2000•2 citations

Pre-service physics teachers’ and physics students’ preferred descriptions of the concept of the photon in the context of quantum optics experiments

Aku Pajula, Maija Nousiainen, Ismo T. Koponen

Abstract Physics education research has revealed that students have multiple ways of understanding the concept of the photon and that students’ use of it is often incoherent and incomplete. In this study, we explore what kinds of statements pre-service physics teachers and university physics students choose on a multiple-choice questionnaire, designed to reveal students’ stances on three conceptual views of the photon (quantum state, quantum realistic, and naïve dualistic) in the context of quantum optical experiments. The questionnaire was conducted in a pre-post manner. The test group (pre-service physics teachers N = 13) attended an introductory quantum physics course which emphasised coherent use of natural language, and the control group (university physics students pre N = 33, post N = 25) attended a standard introductory course in quantum physics. Pre-test results show that both groups expressed incoherent use of the concept of the photon. The post-test results reveal that after teaching intervention, the test group showed significant improvement in the coherent use of the concept of the photon as a quantum state. The post-test results of the control group remained incoherent. The results show that paying attention to the coherent use of natural language in teaching quantum physics helps pre-service physics teachers to recognise and choose coherent expressions about the photon.

European Journal of Physics•May 5, 2026•0 citations

Approaches for improving students' understanding of quantum mechanics

Travis Norsen

In their article, Chandralekha Singh, Mario Belloni, and Wolfgang Christian focus exclusively on “functional understanding of quantum mechanics,” which they claim “is quite distinct from the foundational issues alluded to by Feynman.”But are the foundational and the functional really so distinct? The work of other physics education researchers suggests not. For example, in a classic article, Alan Van Heuvelen discusses students’ prevalent and frustrating use of “primitive formula-centered problem-solving strategies” 1 1. A. Van Heuvelen, Am. J. Phys. 59, 891 (1991). https://doi.org/10.1119/1.16667 and suggests that physical, intuitive understanding developed through qualitative diagrams and models “must come before students start using math in problem solving. The equations become crutches that short-circuit attempts at understanding.” Van Heuvelen also urges that “instead of thinking of [problems] as an effort to determine some unknown quantity, [teachers] might … encourage students to think of the problem statement as describing a physical process—a movie of a region of space during a short time interval or of an event at one instant of time.” I suspect Singh, Belloni, and Christian would agree with this advice. They comment that such “qualitative understanding of quantum mechanics is much more challenging than facility with the technical aspects.”But isn't the main barrier to such intuitive, qualitative understanding the nature of quantum mechanics itself—at least, the version of the theory advocated by Niels Bohr, Werner Heisenberg, and virtually every textbook writer since? Why should we expect students to invest the time and energy necessary to, say, visualize the time-dependence of |ψ|2 when we also preach the ambiguous and contradictory Copenhagen dogma that ψ does not represent anything physically real, yet still provides a complete description of physical reality? Why are we surprised that students are confused about, and don't take seriously, something that we assure them is, at best, some kind of algorithmic fantasy? Is there really any difference between “shut up and calculate” and “plug and chug”?Why not teach them Bohmian mechanics—an alternative (deterministic) version of quantum theory in which particles are particles (and really exist, all the time) and the same dynamical laws apply whether anyone is looking or not? 2 2. S. Goldstein, in Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/qm-bohm. About this alternative theory John S. Bell asked, “Why is [it] ignored in text books? Should it not be taught … as an antidote to the prevailing complacency? To show that vagueness, subjectivity, and indeterminism are not forced upon us by experimental facts, but by deliberate theoretical choice?” 3 3. J. S. Bell, Speakable and Unspeakable in Quantum Mechanics: Collected Papers on Quantum Philosophy, Cambridge U. Press, New York (2004), p. 173. https://doi.org/10.1017/CBO9780511815676.021 If we really want to help students understand quantum mechanics, the first step is to reject the confusion-spawning foundational vagueness, ambiguity, and philosophical absurdity of Copenhagen quantum theory, and adopt a clearer, more scientific, less fuzzy version. (See Sheldon Goldstein's two-part article “Quantum Theory Without Observers,” Physics Today, March 1998, page 42, and Physics Today, April 1998, page 38) The first step, in short, is to present them with a theory that can be understood.REFERENCESSection:ChooseTop of pageREFERENCES <<1. A. Van Heuvelen, Am. J. Phys. 59, 891 (1991). https://doi.org/10.1119/1.16667 , Google ScholarCrossref2. S. Goldstein, in Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/qm-bohm. Google Scholar3. J. S. Bell, Speakable and Unspeakable in Quantum Mechanics: Collected Papers on Quantum Philosophy, Cambridge U. Press, New York (2004), p. 173. https://doi.org/10.1017/CBO9780511815676.021 , Google ScholarCrossref© 2007 American Institute of Physics.

Physics Today•Mar 1, 2007•0 citations
More than 35 years ago, French and Taylor1 outlined an approach to teach students and teachers alike how to understand “qualitative plots of bound-state wave functions.” They described five fundamental statements based on the quantum-mechanical concepts of probability and energy (total and potential), which could be used to deduce the shape of energy eigenfunctions. Despite these important and easy-to-follow statements, this approach has not been universally adopted in the teaching of quantum mechanics.2 For example, recent studies have shown that students' conceptual understanding of quantum mechanics on all levels is surprisingly lacking3 and that misconceptions are universal,4 including that of the relationship between the potential energy function and the resulting energy eigenfunction shape. At the same time, the teaching of quantum mechanical concepts in introductory physics has become increasingly important given the modern technological applications that are based on quantum theory (e.g., PET scans and MRIs). However, most treatments of quantum theory on the introductory level are cursory at best, leaving students with the impression that quantum mechanics is little more than abstract mathematics (a belief that remains with students in their future courses).
Based on years of teaching experience, this book provides a clearly structured and accessible introduction to the fundamental principles of quantum mechanics, tailored for undergraduate students. The text builds a strong conceptual and mathematical foundation while promoting intuitive understanding and critical thinking. Students progress from basic concepts such as wave mechanics to more advanced topics within matrix mechanics. Complex concepts are presented in a diligent and understandable way, achieving a balance between conceptual insight and mathematical rigor without oversimplifying the subject. Thoroughly class-tested, this book is designed to support both classroom instruction and independent study. It will serve as a great tool for undergraduates studying introductory and intermediate quantum mechanics, as well as modern physics and quantum systems for engineers.
Abstract Quantum physics education at the upper-secondary level traditionally follows a historical approach, rarely extending beyond early 20th-century ideas, leaving students unprepared for comprehending modern quantum technologies central to everyday life and many facets of modern industry. To address this gap, we investigated how upper-secondary students and pre-service teachers understand quantum teleportation when taught with a simplified diagrammatic formalism based on the ZX-calculus, which represents quantum processes as diagrams of wires and boxes. Through phenomenographic analysis of video-recorded group work sessions, written responses to exercises, and a group interview, with a total of n=21n=21n=21 n = 21 participants, we identified an outcome space consisting of four qualitatively different, hierarchically ordered categories of description encapsulating the different ways of experiencing quantum teleportation. The categories revealed that a conceptual progression depends on how one understands the temporality in quantum processes, the role of entanglement in quantum teleportation, the active nature of quantum measurements, and interpretations of mathematical operations in the diagrams. Our findings indicate that while a simplified diagrammatic formalism for teaching quantum physics can provide an accessible entry point at the upper-secondary level, it does not automatically resolve fundamental conceptual challenges, and requires careful consideration in terms of developing teaching and learning sequences. Finally, these results provide educators with a deeper understanding of conceptual affordances and challenges for designing and improving instruction, while also highlighting the need for further exploring how students and teachers alike understand quantum phenomena.
I distinguish between two conceptually different kinds of physical space: a space of ordinary material bodies, which is the space of points at which I could imaginably place (say) the tip of my finger, or the center of a billiard-ball, and a space of elementary physical determinables, which is the smallest space of points such that stipulating what is happening at each one of those points, at every time, amounts to an exhaustive physical history of the universe. In all classical physical theories, these two spaces happen to coincide – and what we mean by calling a theory “classical”, and all we mean by calling a theory “classical”, is (I will argue) precisely that these two spaces coincide. But once the distinction between these two spaces in on the table, it becomes clear that there is no logical or conceptual reason why they must coincide – and it turns out (and this is the main topic of the present paper) that a very simple way of pulling them apart from one another gives us quantum mechanics.
Inadequate descriptions of atoms and molecules by the methods of classical physics led researchers to propose new ways to describe physical reality, giving birth to a totally new science, quantum mechanics. The methods of quantum mechanics are based on the introduction of a wave function, whose physical meaning is related to the probability of finding a certain particle, at a certain time in a volume element, positioned between x and x + dx in the x = direction, between y and y + dy in the y = direction, and between z and z + dz in the z = direction at certain time t. This wave function Ψ satisfies the Schrödinger equation, (−ℏ22m∇2+v)Ψ=EΨ,ℏ=h2π, \left( { - \frac{{{\hbar ^2}}}{{2m}}{\nabla ^2} + v} \right)\Psi = {\rm E}\Psi,\hbar = \frac{h}{{2\pi }}, (−2mℏ2​∇2+v)Ψ=EΨ,ℏ=2πh​, or for short, HΨ = EΨ, where H, the Hamiltonian operator, is defined by the expression H=−ℏ22m∇2+V; H = - \frac{{{\hbar ^2}}}{{2m}}{\nabla ^2} + V; H=−2mℏ2​∇2+V; h is Planck’s constant; ∇2 is the sum of the partial second derivatives with respect to x, y, and z; m is the mass of the particle; and V is the potential energy of the system. The Hamiltonian H represents the quantum equivalent of the sum of the kinetic energy and potential energy, with V being the potential energy operator and −ℏ22m∇2 \frac{{ - {\hbar ^2}}}{{2m}}{\nabla ^2} 2m−ℏ2​∇2 the kinetic energy operator. Finally, E is the total energy of the system and is a number, not an operator.
Abstract Physics education research has revealed that students have multiple ways of understanding the concept of the photon and that students’ use of it is often incoherent and incomplete. In this study, we explore what kinds of statements pre-service physics teachers and university physics students choose on a multiple-choice questionnaire, designed to reveal students’ stances on three conceptual views of the photon (quantum state, quantum realistic, and naïve dualistic) in the context of quantum optical experiments. The questionnaire was conducted in a pre-post manner. The test group (pre-service physics teachers N = 13) attended an introductory quantum physics course which emphasised coherent use of natural language, and the control group (university physics students pre N = 33, post N = 25) attended a standard introductory course in quantum physics. Pre-test results show that both groups expressed incoherent use of the concept of the photon. The post-test results reveal that after teaching intervention, the test group showed significant improvement in the coherent use of the concept of the photon as a quantum state. The post-test results of the control group remained incoherent. The results show that paying attention to the coherent use of natural language in teaching quantum physics helps pre-service physics teachers to recognise and choose coherent expressions about the photon.
In their article, Chandralekha Singh, Mario Belloni, and Wolfgang Christian focus exclusively on “functional understanding of quantum mechanics,” which they claim “is quite distinct from the foundational issues alluded to by Feynman.”But are the foundational and the functional really so distinct? The work of other physics education researchers suggests not. For example, in a classic article, Alan Van Heuvelen discusses students’ prevalent and frustrating use of “primitive formula-centered problem-solving strategies” 1 1. A. Van Heuvelen, Am. J. Phys. 59, 891 (1991). https://doi.org/10.1119/1.16667 and suggests that physical, intuitive understanding developed through qualitative diagrams and models “must come before students start using math in problem solving. The equations become crutches that short-circuit attempts at understanding.” Van Heuvelen also urges that “instead of thinking of [problems] as an effort to determine some unknown quantity, [teachers] might … encourage students to think of the problem statement as describing a physical process—a movie of a region of space during a short time interval or of an event at one instant of time.” I suspect Singh, Belloni, and Christian would agree with this advice. They comment that such “qualitative understanding of quantum mechanics is much more challenging than facility with the technical aspects.”But isn't the main barrier to such intuitive, qualitative understanding the nature of quantum mechanics itself—at least, the version of the theory advocated by Niels Bohr, Werner Heisenberg, and virtually every textbook writer since? Why should we expect students to invest the time and energy necessary to, say, visualize the time-dependence of |ψ|2 when we also preach the ambiguous and contradictory Copenhagen dogma that ψ does not represent anything physically real, yet still provides a complete description of physical reality? Why are we surprised that students are confused about, and don't take seriously, something that we assure them is, at best, some kind of algorithmic fantasy? Is there really any difference between “shut up and calculate” and “plug and chug”?Why not teach them Bohmian mechanics—an alternative (deterministic) version of quantum theory in which particles are particles (and really exist, all the time) and the same dynamical laws apply whether anyone is looking or not? 2 2. S. Goldstein, in Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/qm-bohm. About this alternative theory John S. Bell asked, “Why is [it] ignored in text books? Should it not be taught … as an antidote to the prevailing complacency? To show that vagueness, subjectivity, and indeterminism are not forced upon us by experimental facts, but by deliberate theoretical choice?” 3 3. J. S. Bell, Speakable and Unspeakable in Quantum Mechanics: Collected Papers on Quantum Philosophy, Cambridge U. Press, New York (2004), p. 173. https://doi.org/10.1017/CBO9780511815676.021 If we really want to help students understand quantum mechanics, the first step is to reject the confusion-spawning foundational vagueness, ambiguity, and philosophical absurdity of Copenhagen quantum theory, and adopt a clearer, more scientific, less fuzzy version. (See Sheldon Goldstein's two-part article “Quantum Theory Without Observers,” Physics Today, March 1998, page 42, and Physics Today, April 1998, page 38) The first step, in short, is to present them with a theory that can be understood.REFERENCESSection:ChooseTop of pageREFERENCES <<1. A. Van Heuvelen, Am. J. Phys. 59, 891 (1991). https://doi.org/10.1119/1.16667 , Google ScholarCrossref2. S. Goldstein, in Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/qm-bohm. Google Scholar3. J. S. Bell, Speakable and Unspeakable in Quantum Mechanics: Collected Papers on Quantum Philosophy, Cambridge U. Press, New York (2004), p. 173. https://doi.org/10.1017/CBO9780511815676.021 , Google ScholarCrossref© 2007 American Institute of Physics.