Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Conference on the Foundations of Quantum Mechanics: Historical Analysis and Open Questions

IF BERTLMANN HAD THREE FEET

Alexander Afriat

Published Jun 1, 2006• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

ABSTRACT: It is argued that perfect quantum correlations cannot be due to additive conservation. Dr. Bertlmann likes to wear two socks of different colours. Which colour he will have on a given foot on a given day is quite unpredictable. But when you see that the first sock is pink you can already be sure that the second sock will not be pink. Observation of the first, and experience of Bertlmann, gives immediate information about the second. Bell (1981) Most interesting features of quantum mechanics have at least something to do with interference, which will not, however, be at issue here at all. Interference is brought out by an appeal to different bases, but here the same (product) basis is adhered to throughout. It is often claimed, and even more often suspected, that conservation accounts for quantum correlations (by which perfect quantum correlations will be meant). The underlying intuition is well expressed by Bertlmann’s socks, or by the fact that the distribution of wine over two glasses can be worked out, provided one knows the total amount in both, by a measurement on one of them. Or consider a conservative classical Hamiltonian where T is kinetic energy and the potential energy V depends only on position. Conservation here means that exchanges of kinetic and potential energy along a trajectory have to satisfy where is the total energy of that motion. Kinetic energy will then be a function only of position, so that at any stage of the motion can be deduced from the potential; they are perfectly correlated. Or take two free classical particles, each one subject only to the influence of the other, with initial momenta and Irrespective of whether they collide their total momentum will remain the momentum of the primed particle can always be derived from the momentum p of the other. These cases are paradigmatic for additive conservation. (),H T V q = +

DOI
10.1142/9789812773258_0001

Related papers

BERTLMANN'S SOCKS AND THE NATURE OF REALITY

James S. Bell

The Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen correlations are very like many ordinary occurrences of everyday life. So it is a little difficult for the man in the street to understand immediately why there has been so much fuss about them. It must be recalled that the founding fathers of quantum mechanics had convinced themselves that it was necessary to abandon the idea of an objective reality at the microphysical level. But the correlations in question, together with the idea of local causality, were a formidable argument for such a reality. The founding fathers offered counter-arguments (neither very clear nor very convincing in my opinion) and each side held to its position. Since then it has been possible to push the analysis a little further, considering especially situations just a little different from those considered before. Then correlations appear, according to quantum mechanics, which are not at all like those of everyday life. As a result it is not now easy to believe, with Einstein, that quantum mechanical predictions are reconcilable with the notion of a Lorentz invariant objectively real microphysical world.

World Scientific series in 20th century physics•Sep 1, 1995•17 citations

Comment on “Dr. Bertlmann’s Socks in a Quaternionic World of Ambidextral Reality”

Richard David Gill

I point out critical errors in the article “Dr. Bertlmann's Socks in a Quaternionic World of Ambidextral Reality” by J. Christian, published in IEEE ACCESS. Christian's model does not generate the singlet correlations but in fact simply reproduces the Bertlmann effect. John Bell's colleague Reinhold Bertlmann of CERN, in his younger days, always wore one pink and one blue sock, at random. The moment you saw his left foot, you knew what colour sock would be on his right foot. Action at a distance? As John Bell liked to explain, quantum entanglement cannot be explained away in such an easy way. Yet Christian's model assigns the two particles of the EPR-B experiment an equal and opposite spin at the source, the choice being determined by a fair coin toss. However they are measured, these spins are recovered. Christian's computer simulation works by not actually simulating his model at all but by almost directly tracing the negative cosine built into his computer algebra package. Bell's theorem has not been disproved. Debate as to what it means for the foundations of physics as well as for quantum information engineering (quantum communication, computation) is more lively today than ever before. A possible role for Geometric Algebra is still wide open and deserves further investigation, informed by a proper understanding of the mathematical content of Bell's theorem.

arXiv:2001.11338•IEEE Access•Jan 1, 2021•6 citations

Quantum entanglement

Kenichi Konishi, Giampiero Paffuti

Abstract Two or more particles which have interacted in the past, may in general maintain nontrivial quantum mechanical correlations, described by non-factorized wave functions. These correlations, under optimal conditions, can manifest themselves no matter how far they travel away from each other and even when the separate parts cannot dynamically influence each other, leading to apparently paradoxical situations. These correlations are known as quantum entanglement. However counter-intuitive and surprising it may sometimes look, it is rather one of the more beautiful and experimentally well established predictions of quantum mechanics.

Oxford University Press eBooks•Mar 5, 2009•0 citations

Dr. Bertlmann’s Socks in a Quaternionic World of Ambidextral Reality

Joy Christian

Unlike our basic theories of space and time, quantum mechanics is not a locally causal theory. Moreover, it is widely believed that any hopes of restoring local causality within any realistic theory have been undermined by Bell's theorem and the experimental investigations it has inspired. In this pedagogical paper, John S. Bell's amusing example of Dr. Bertlmann's socks to illustrate the results of these experiments is reconsidered, first within a toy model of a two-dimensional one-sided world of a non-orientable Möbius strip, and then within a real world of three-dimensional quaternionic sphere, S3, which results from an addition of a single point to IR3at infinity. In the latter quaternionic world, which happens to be the spatial part of a solution of Einstein's field equations of general relativity, the singlet correlations between a pair of entangled fermions can be understood as classically as those between Dr. Bertlmann's colorful socks.

arXiv:1911.11578•IEEE Access•Jan 1, 2020•36 citations

BERTLMANN'S SOCKS AND THE NATURE OF REALITY

James S. Bell

Les corrélations d'Einstein, Podolsky et Rosen, sont assez semblables à beaucoup de phénomènes banals de la vie quotidienne. Il est donc un peu difficile pour le profane de comprendre au premier abord pourquoi un tel flot de paroles a coulé à ce sujet. Il faut rappeler que les grands théoriciens de la mécanique quantique étaient convaincus qu'il fallait abandonner l'idée d'une réalité objective sur le plan microphysique. Les corrélations en question, vues dans l'optique de l'hypothèse de causalité locale (absence d'action à distance), étaient un argument de taille pour une telle réalitié. Les physiciens quantiques ont développé des contre-arguments (ni très clairs ni très convaincants à mon avis) et les opposants sont restés sur leurs positions. Depuis il a été possible de pousser l'analyse un peu plus loin, en considérant surtout des situations voisines de celles envisagées par Einstein, Podolsky et Rosen. On trouve des corrélations qui ne sont pas du tout banales. Ce n'est plus aisé de croire, avec Einstein, que les prévisions de la mécanique quantique sont réconciliables avec la causalité locale et la réalité objective du monde microphysique. The Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen correlations are very like many ordinary occurrences of everyday life. So it is a little difficult for the man in the street to understand immediately why there has been so much fuss about them. It must be recalled that the founding fathers of quantum mechanics had convinced themselves that it was necessary to abandon the idea of an objective reality at the microphysical level. But the correlations in question, together with the idea of local causality, were a formidable argument for such a reality. The founding fathers offered counter-arguments (neither very clear nor very convincing in my opinion) and each side held to its position. Since then it has been possible to push the analysis a little further, considering especially situation just a little different from those considered before. Then correlations appear, according to quantum mechanics, which are not at all like those of everyday life. As a result it is not now easy to believe, with Einstein, that quantum mechanical predictions are reconcilable with the notion of a Lorentz invariant objectively real microphysical world.

WORLD SCIENTIFIC eBooks•Aug 1, 2001•15 citations

Physics of the Observable. Mechanics

Adrian Faigon

Mechanics can be founded in a principle stating the uncertainty in the position of an observable particle delta-q as a function of its motion relative to the observer, expressed in a trajectory representation . From this principle, p.delta-q=const., being p the q-conjugated momentum, mechanical laws are derived and the meaning of the Lagrangian and Hamiltonian functions are discussed. The connection between the presented principle and Hamilton's Least Action Principle is examined. For a particle hidden from direct observation, the position uncertainty is determined by the enclosing boundaries, and is, thus, disengaged from its momentum. Heat, as a non-mechanical magnitude, stem from this fact, and thermodynamical magnitudes have direct expression in the presented formalism. It is finally shown that in terms of Information Theory, mechanical laws have simple interpretation. Kinetic and potential energies are expressions of the information on momentum and position respectively, and the law of conservation of energy expresses the absence of information exchange in mechanical interactions.

arXiv:physics/0112033•Dec 12, 2001•0 citations
ABSTRACT: It is argued that perfect quantum correlations cannot be due to additive conservation. Dr. Bertlmann likes to wear two socks of different colours. Which colour he will have on a given foot on a given day is quite unpredictable. But when you see that the first sock is pink you can already be sure that the second sock will not be pink. Observation of the first, and experience of Bertlmann, gives immediate information about the second. Bell (1981) Most interesting features of quantum mechanics have at least something to do with interference, which will not, however, be at issue here at all. Interference is brought out by an appeal to different bases, but here the same (product) basis is adhered to throughout. It is often claimed, and even more often suspected, that conservation accounts for quantum correlations (by which perfect quantum correlations will be meant). The underlying intuition is well expressed by Bertlmann’s socks, or by the fact that the distribution of wine over two glasses can be worked out, provided one knows the total amount in both, by a measurement on one of them. Or consider a conservative classical Hamiltonian where T is kinetic energy and the potential energy V depends only on position. Conservation here means that exchanges of kinetic and potential energy along a trajectory have to satisfy where is the total energy of that motion. Kinetic energy will then be a function only of position, so that at any stage of the motion can be deduced from the potential; they are perfectly correlated. Or take two free classical particles, each one subject only to the influence of the other, with initial momenta and Irrespective of whether they collide their total momentum will remain the momentum of the primed particle can always be derived from the momentum p of the other. These cases are paradigmatic for additive conservation. (),H T V q = +
The Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen correlations are very like many ordinary occurrences of everyday life. So it is a little difficult for the man in the street to understand immediately why there has been so much fuss about them. It must be recalled that the founding fathers of quantum mechanics had convinced themselves that it was necessary to abandon the idea of an objective reality at the microphysical level. But the correlations in question, together with the idea of local causality, were a formidable argument for such a reality. The founding fathers offered counter-arguments (neither very clear nor very convincing in my opinion) and each side held to its position. Since then it has been possible to push the analysis a little further, considering especially situations just a little different from those considered before. Then correlations appear, according to quantum mechanics, which are not at all like those of everyday life. As a result it is not now easy to believe, with Einstein, that quantum mechanical predictions are reconcilable with the notion of a Lorentz invariant objectively real microphysical world.
I point out critical errors in the article “Dr. Bertlmann's Socks in a Quaternionic World of Ambidextral Reality” by J. Christian, published in IEEE ACCESS. Christian's model does not generate the singlet correlations but in fact simply reproduces the Bertlmann effect. John Bell's colleague Reinhold Bertlmann of CERN, in his younger days, always wore one pink and one blue sock, at random. The moment you saw his left foot, you knew what colour sock would be on his right foot. Action at a distance? As John Bell liked to explain, quantum entanglement cannot be explained away in such an easy way. Yet Christian's model assigns the two particles of the EPR-B experiment an equal and opposite spin at the source, the choice being determined by a fair coin toss. However they are measured, these spins are recovered. Christian's computer simulation works by not actually simulating his model at all but by almost directly tracing the negative cosine built into his computer algebra package. Bell's theorem has not been disproved. Debate as to what it means for the foundations of physics as well as for quantum information engineering (quantum communication, computation) is more lively today than ever before. A possible role for Geometric Algebra is still wide open and deserves further investigation, informed by a proper understanding of the mathematical content of Bell's theorem.
Abstract Two or more particles which have interacted in the past, may in general maintain nontrivial quantum mechanical correlations, described by non-factorized wave functions. These correlations, under optimal conditions, can manifest themselves no matter how far they travel away from each other and even when the separate parts cannot dynamically influence each other, leading to apparently paradoxical situations. These correlations are known as quantum entanglement. However counter-intuitive and surprising it may sometimes look, it is rather one of the more beautiful and experimentally well established predictions of quantum mechanics.
Unlike our basic theories of space and time, quantum mechanics is not a locally causal theory. Moreover, it is widely believed that any hopes of restoring local causality within any realistic theory have been undermined by Bell's theorem and the experimental investigations it has inspired. In this pedagogical paper, John S. Bell's amusing example of Dr. Bertlmann's socks to illustrate the results of these experiments is reconsidered, first within a toy model of a two-dimensional one-sided world of a non-orientable Möbius strip, and then within a real world of three-dimensional quaternionic sphere, S3, which results from an addition of a single point to IR3at infinity. In the latter quaternionic world, which happens to be the spatial part of a solution of Einstein's field equations of general relativity, the singlet correlations between a pair of entangled fermions can be understood as classically as those between Dr. Bertlmann's colorful socks.
Les corrélations d'Einstein, Podolsky et Rosen, sont assez semblables à beaucoup de phénomènes banals de la vie quotidienne. Il est donc un peu difficile pour le profane de comprendre au premier abord pourquoi un tel flot de paroles a coulé à ce sujet. Il faut rappeler que les grands théoriciens de la mécanique quantique étaient convaincus qu'il fallait abandonner l'idée d'une réalité objective sur le plan microphysique. Les corrélations en question, vues dans l'optique de l'hypothèse de causalité locale (absence d'action à distance), étaient un argument de taille pour une telle réalitié. Les physiciens quantiques ont développé des contre-arguments (ni très clairs ni très convaincants à mon avis) et les opposants sont restés sur leurs positions. Depuis il a été possible de pousser l'analyse un peu plus loin, en considérant surtout des situations voisines de celles envisagées par Einstein, Podolsky et Rosen. On trouve des corrélations qui ne sont pas du tout banales. Ce n'est plus aisé de croire, avec Einstein, que les prévisions de la mécanique quantique sont réconciliables avec la causalité locale et la réalité objective du monde microphysique. The Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen correlations are very like many ordinary occurrences of everyday life. So it is a little difficult for the man in the street to understand immediately why there has been so much fuss about them. It must be recalled that the founding fathers of quantum mechanics had convinced themselves that it was necessary to abandon the idea of an objective reality at the microphysical level. But the correlations in question, together with the idea of local causality, were a formidable argument for such a reality. The founding fathers offered counter-arguments (neither very clear nor very convincing in my opinion) and each side held to its position. Since then it has been possible to push the analysis a little further, considering especially situation just a little different from those considered before. Then correlations appear, according to quantum mechanics, which are not at all like those of everyday life. As a result it is not now easy to believe, with Einstein, that quantum mechanical predictions are reconcilable with the notion of a Lorentz invariant objectively real microphysical world.
Mechanics can be founded in a principle stating the uncertainty in the position of an observable particle delta-q as a function of its motion relative to the observer, expressed in a trajectory representation . From this principle, p.delta-q=const., being p the q-conjugated momentum, mechanical laws are derived and the meaning of the Lagrangian and Hamiltonian functions are discussed. The connection between the presented principle and Hamilton's Least Action Principle is examined. For a particle hidden from direct observation, the position uncertainty is determined by the enclosing boundaries, and is, thus, disengaged from its momentum. Heat, as a non-mechanical magnitude, stem from this fact, and thermodynamical magnitudes have direct expression in the presented formalism. It is finally shown that in terms of Information Theory, mechanical laws have simple interpretation. Kinetic and potential energies are expressions of the information on momentum and position respectively, and the law of conservation of energy expresses the absence of information exchange in mechanical interactions.