Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Physical Chemistry Chemical Physics

Comment on “Scaling properties of information-theoretic quantities in density functional reactivity theory” by C. Rong, T. Lu, P. W. Ayers, P. K. Chattaraj and S. Liu, Phys. Chem. Chem. Phys., 2015, 17 , 4977–4988

Hugo J. Bohórquez

Published Jan 1, 2015• 7 citations
Publisher

Abstract

The scaling properties of density functionals are key for fundamentally understanding density functional theory. Accordingly, the dependence of density functionals on the number of particles is of paramount relevance. The numerical exploration by Rong et al. addressed N-scaling for a set of quantum information quantities; they found linear relationships between each one of them and the electronic population for atoms, molecules, and atoms in molecules. The main motivation for their computational work was that the theoretical scaling of these quantities is unknown; however, these scaling properties can be analytically determined. Here I reveal the derivation of the N-scaling rules for the quantities studied by Rong et al. by following the procedure introduced in Comput. Theor. Chem., 2015, 1053, 38. In addition, a new atomic scaling rule explains the linear relationship between atomic populations and atomic values of the same quantum information quantities.

DOI
10.1039/c5cp05140a

Related papers

Comment on “Legendre-transform functionals for spin-density-functional theory” [J. Chem. Phys. 124, 224108 (2006)]

A. Holas, Robert Balawender

In this Comment the authors propose an alternative formulation of the starting point to the analysis performed in the commented paper [P. W. Ayers and W. Yang, J. Chem. Phys.124, 224108 (2006)]. An important role of the z component of the vector of the total spin angular momentum operator for the considered many-electron system is indicated. The authors believe their approach to be mathematically cleaner and conceptually easier than the original treatment.

The Journal of Chemical Physics•Dec 26, 2006•15 citations

Comment on "Self-Consistent-Field Method for Correlated Many-Electron Systems with an Entropic Cumulant Energy"

Lexin Ding, Julia Liebert, Christian Schilling

In [Phys. Rev. Lett. 128, 013001 (2022)] a novel ground state method was proposed. It has been suggested that this $i$-DMFT would be a method within one-particle reduced density matrix functional theory (DMFT), capable of describing accurately molecules at various geometries with an information-theoretical nature. We reassess this work and its suggestions from a conceptual and practical point of view, leading to the following conclusions: i) A method which assigns to each molecule $\mathcal{M}$ its own functional $\mathcal{F}_{\!\mathcal{M}}$ is not a functional theory (striking violation of "universality") ii) even for the simplest systems $i$-DMFT yields incorrect one-particle reduced density matrices and iii) the use of an information-theoretical concept to describe molecular dissociation limits was not essential. The latter insight may help to fix the deficiency of $i$-DMFT to not reproduce correctly the smaller occupation numbers and thus to not recover the important dynamic correlations.

arXiv:2202.05532•Feb 11, 2022•8 citations

Comment on: “Transforms for idempotency purification of density matrices in linear-scaling electronic-structure calculations” [Chem. Phys. Lett. 340 (2001) 552–558]

Scott Habershon, Frederick R. Manby

Chemical Physics Letters•Mar 1, 2002•4 citations

Characterising and approximating exact density functionals for model electronic systems

Michael Entwistle

Accurate descriptions of the electronic properties of molecules, solids and other materials are crucial in the development of many modern technologies, and are therefore the subject of much scientific research. In tandem with experimental research, computational simulations play a huge role. Density functional theory (DFT) is the most popular method for performing ground-state electronic structure calculations due to its accuracy in many situations along with its computational efficiency. Its time-dependent extension (TDDFT) allows the modelling of the dynamics of systems of interacting electrons. (TD)DFT is an exact theory in principle, but requires approximations in practice, specifically to the many-body effects of electron exchange and correlation (xc), which are described by some unknown universal functional. Despite much success, it often proves inadequate in many scenarios of increasing interest. Therefore, we aim to contribute to the development of improved approximate density functionals. \n \nIn this thesis, we take the approach of studying small model systems for which we can compute the exact functionals. These systems are designed to exhibit the key features present in realistic quantum systems, such as atoms and molecules, which the exact universal (TD)DFT functional is capable of describing, but are often ill-described by the commonly used approximations. By analysing the nature of these exact functionals, we gain valuable insight into their fundamental properties, together with identifying where the current approximations are lacking, thereby allowing us to suggest how these approximations may be improved.

•Jul 1, 2020•0 citations

Pair Densities in Density Functional Theory

Huajie Chen, Gero Friesecke

The exact interaction energy of a many-electron system is determined by the electron pair density, which is not well-approximated in standard Kohn--Sham density functional models. Here we study the (complicated but well-defined) exact universal map from density to pair density. We survey how many common functionals, including the most basic version of the local density approximation (Dirac exchange with no correlation contribution), arise from particular approximations of this map. We develop an algorithm to compute the map numerically and apply it to one-parameter families $\{\alpha\rho(\alpha x)\}_{\alpha>0}$ of one-dimensional homogeneous and inhomogeneous single-particle densities. We observe that the pair density develops remarkable multiscale patterns which strongly depend on both the particle number and the “width” $\alpha^{-1}$ of the single-particle density. The simulation results are confirmed by rigorous asymptotic results in the limiting regimes $\alpha\gg$ and $\alpha\ll1$. For one-dimensional homogeneous systems, we show that the whole spectrum of patterns is reproduced surprisingly well by a simple asymptotics-based ansatz which slowly smoothens out the “strictly correlated” $\alpha=0$ pair density while slowly turning on the $\alpha=\infty$ “exchange” terms as $\alpha$ increases. Our findings lend theoretical support to the celebrated semi-empirical idea [A. D. Becke, J. Chem. Phys., 98 (1993), pp. 5648--5652] to mix in a fractional amount of exchange, albeit not to assuming the mixing to be additive and taking the fraction to be a system-independent constant.

arXiv:1503.07539•Multiscale Modeling and Simulation•Jan 1, 2015•21 citations

Introduction

H. Eschrig

Density functional theory provides a powerful tool for computations of the quantum state of atoms, molecules and solids, and of ab-initio molecular dynamics. It was conceived in its initial naïve and approximative version by Thomas and Fermi immediately after the foundation of quantum mechanics, in 1927. Just thirty years ago, in the middle of the sixties, Hohenberg, Kohn and Sham on the one hand established a logically rigorous density functional theory of the quantum groundstate on the basis of quantum mechanics, and on the other hand, guided by this construction, introduced an approximative explicit theory called the local-density approximation, which for computations of the quantum groundstate of many-particle systems proved to be superior to both Thomas-Fermi and Hartree-Fock theories. From that time on, density functional theory has grown vastly in popularity, and a flood of computational work in molecular and solid state physics has been the result. Motivated by its success, there has been always a tendency to widen the fields of application of density functional theory, and in these developments, some points which were left somewhat obscure in the basic theory, were brought into focus from time to time. This led in the early eighties to a deepening of the logical basis, essentially by Levy and Lieb, and finally Lieb gave the basic theory a form of final mathematical rigour. Since that treatment, however, is based on the tools of modern convex functional analysis, its implications only gradually became known to the many people who apply density functional theory. A thorough treatment of the dependence on particle number on the basis of Lieb’s theory is given for the first time in the present text.

Teubner-Texte zur Physik•Jan 1, 1996•0 citations
The scaling properties of density functionals are key for fundamentally understanding density functional theory. Accordingly, the dependence of density functionals on the number of particles is of paramount relevance. The numerical exploration by Rong et al. addressed N-scaling for a set of quantum information quantities; they found linear relationships between each one of them and the electronic population for atoms, molecules, and atoms in molecules. The main motivation for their computational work was that the theoretical scaling of these quantities is unknown; however, these scaling properties can be analytically determined. Here I reveal the derivation of the N-scaling rules for the quantities studied by Rong et al. by following the procedure introduced in Comput. Theor. Chem., 2015, 1053, 38. In addition, a new atomic scaling rule explains the linear relationship between atomic populations and atomic values of the same quantum information quantities.
In [Phys. Rev. Lett. 128, 013001 (2022)] a novel ground state method was proposed. It has been suggested that this iii-DMFT would be a method within one-particle reduced density matrix functional theory (DMFT), capable of describing accurately molecules at various geometries with an information-theoretical nature. We reassess this work and its suggestions from a conceptual and practical point of view, leading to the following conclusions: i) A method which assigns to each molecule M\mathcal{M}M its own functional F ⁣M\mathcal{F}_{\!\mathcal{M}}FM​ is not a functional theory (striking violation of "universality") ii) even for the simplest systems iii-DMFT yields incorrect one-particle reduced density matrices and iii) the use of an information-theoretical concept to describe molecular dissociation limits was not essential. The latter insight may help to fix the deficiency of iii-DMFT to not reproduce correctly the smaller occupation numbers and thus to not recover the important dynamic correlations.
Accurate descriptions of the electronic properties of molecules, solids and other materials are crucial in the development of many modern technologies, and are therefore the subject of much scientific research. In tandem with experimental research, computational simulations play a huge role. Density functional theory (DFT) is the most popular method for performing ground-state electronic structure calculations due to its accuracy in many situations along with its computational efficiency. Its time-dependent extension (TDDFT) allows the modelling of the dynamics of systems of interacting electrons. (TD)DFT is an exact theory in principle, but requires approximations in practice, specifically to the many-body effects of electron exchange and correlation (xc), which are described by some unknown universal functional. Despite much success, it often proves inadequate in many scenarios of increasing interest. Therefore, we aim to contribute to the development of improved approximate density functionals. \n \nIn this thesis, we take the approach of studying small model systems for which we can compute the exact functionals. These systems are designed to exhibit the key features present in realistic quantum systems, such as atoms and molecules, which the exact universal (TD)DFT functional is capable of describing, but are often ill-described by the commonly used approximations. By analysing the nature of these exact functionals, we gain valuable insight into their fundamental properties, together with identifying where the current approximations are lacking, thereby allowing us to suggest how these approximations may be improved.
The exact interaction energy of a many-electron system is determined by the electron pair density, which is not well-approximated in standard Kohn--Sham density functional models. Here we study the (complicated but well-defined) exact universal map from density to pair density. We survey how many common functionals, including the most basic version of the local density approximation (Dirac exchange with no correlation contribution), arise from particular approximations of this map. We develop an algorithm to compute the map numerically and apply it to one-parameter families {αρ(αx)}α>0\{\alpha\rho(\alpha x)\}_{\alpha>0}{αρ(αx)}α>0​ of one-dimensional homogeneous and inhomogeneous single-particle densities. We observe that the pair density develops remarkable multiscale patterns which strongly depend on both the particle number and the “width” α−1\alpha^{-1}α−1 of the single-particle density. The simulation results are confirmed by rigorous asymptotic results in the limiting regimes α≫\alpha\ggα≫ and α≪1\alpha\ll1α≪1. For one-dimensional homogeneous systems, we show that the whole spectrum of patterns is reproduced surprisingly well by a simple asymptotics-based ansatz which slowly smoothens out the “strictly correlated” α=0\alpha=0α=0 pair density while slowly turning on the α=∞\alpha=\inftyα=∞ “exchange” terms as α\alphaα increases. Our findings lend theoretical support to the celebrated semi-empirical idea [A. D. Becke, J. Chem. Phys., 98 (1993), pp. 5648--5652] to mix in a fractional amount of exchange, albeit not to assuming the mixing to be additive and taking the fraction to be a system-independent constant.
Density functional theory provides a powerful tool for computations of the quantum state of atoms, molecules and solids, and of ab-initio molecular dynamics. It was conceived in its initial naïve and approximative version by Thomas and Fermi immediately after the foundation of quantum mechanics, in 1927. Just thirty years ago, in the middle of the sixties, Hohenberg, Kohn and Sham on the one hand established a logically rigorous density functional theory of the quantum groundstate on the basis of quantum mechanics, and on the other hand, guided by this construction, introduced an approximative explicit theory called the local-density approximation, which for computations of the quantum groundstate of many-particle systems proved to be superior to both Thomas-Fermi and Hartree-Fock theories. From that time on, density functional theory has grown vastly in popularity, and a flood of computational work in molecular and solid state physics has been the result. Motivated by its success, there has been always a tendency to widen the fields of application of density functional theory, and in these developments, some points which were left somewhat obscure in the basic theory, were brought into focus from time to time. This led in the early eighties to a deepening of the logical basis, essentially by Levy and Lieb, and finally Lieb gave the basic theory a form of final mathematical rigour. Since that treatment, however, is based on the tools of modern convex functional analysis, its implications only gradually became known to the many people who apply density functional theory. A thorough treatment of the dependence on particle number on the basis of Lieb’s theory is given for the first time in the present text.