Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Heisenberg's Uncertainty Principle: Three Faces, Two Roles

Paul Busch, Teiko Heinonen, PEKKA J. LAHTI

Published Sep 25, 2006• 3 citations
OpenAlex

Abstract

A review is given of precise formulations of three conceptually distinct but related manifestations of Heisenberg's Uncertainty Principle. This principle appears in the form of trade-off inequalities: for the widths of the position and momentum distributions in any quantum state; for the inaccuracies of any joint measurement of these quantities; and for the inaccuracy of a measurement of one of the quantities and the ensuing disturbance in the distribution of the other quantity. The uncertainty principle is often described as expressing a limitation of operational possibilities imposed by quantum mechanics. Here we demonstrate that apart from this negative role, the full content of the uncertainty principle also includes its positive role as a condition ensuring that mutually exclusive experimental options can indeed be reconciled if an appropriate trade-off is accepted. Finally, we survey models and experimental implementations of joint measurements of position and momentum and comment briefly on the status of experimental tests of the uncertainty principle.

Related papers

Heisenberg's Uncertainty Principle

Heisenberg's uncertainty principle is usually taken to express a limitation of operational possibilities imposed by quantum mechanics.Here we demonstrate that the full content of this principle also includes its positive role as a condition ensuring that mutually exclusive experimental options can be reconciled if an appropriate trade-off is accepted.The uncertainty principle is shown to appear in three manifestations, in the form of uncertainty relations: for the widths of the position and momentum distributions in any quantum state; for the inaccuracies of any joint measurement of these quantities; and for the inaccuracy of a measurement of one of the quantities and the ensuing disturbance in the distribution of the other quantity.Whilst conceptually distinct, these three kinds of uncertainty relations are shown to be closely related formally.Finally, we survey models and experimental implementations of joint measurements of position and momentum and comment briefly on the status of experimental tests of the uncertainty principle.

WORLD SCIENTIFIC eBooks•May 1, 2000•0 citations

Error and unsharpness in approximate joint measurements of position and momentum

Paul Busch, David B. Pearson

In recent years, novel quantifications of measurement error in quantum mechanics have for the first time enabled precise formulations of Heisenberg's famous but often challenged measurement uncertainty relation. These relations take the form of a trade-off for the necessary errors in joint approximate measurements of position and momentum and other incompatible pairs of observables. Here we review some of these error measures, examine their properties and suitability, and compare their relative strengths as criteria for "good" approximations.

arXiv:1405.6956•May 27, 2014•2 citations

Heisenberg uncertainty for qubit measurements

Paul Busch, PEKKA J. LAHTI, Reinhard F. Werner

Reports on experiments recently performed in Vienna [Erhard et al., Nature Phys. 8, 185 (2012)] and Toronto [Rozema et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 109, 100404 (2012)] include claims of a violation of Heisenberg's error-disturbance relation. In contrast, we have presented and proven a Heisenberg-type relation for joint measurements of position and momentum [Phys. Rev. Lett. 111, 160405 (2013)]. To resolve the apparent conflict, we formulate here a general trade-off relation for errors in qubit measurements, using the same concepts as we did in the position-momentum case. We show that the combined errors in an approximate joint measurement of a pair of $\ifmmode\pm\else\textpm\fi{}1$-valued observables $A,B$ are tightly bounded from below by a quantity that measures the degree of incompatibility of $A$ and $B$. The claim of a violation of Heisenberg is shown to fail because it is based on unsuitable measures of error and disturbance. Finally we show how the experiments mentioned may directly be used to test our error inequality.

arXiv:1311.0837•Physical Review A•Jan 31, 2014•117 citations

Measurement uncertainty: the problem of characterising optimal error bounds

Tom Bullock, Paul Busch

In standard formulations of the uncertainty principle, two fundamental features are typically cast as impossibility statements: two noncommuting observables cannot in general both be sharply defined (for the same state), nor can they be measured jointly. The pioneers of quantum mechanics were acutely aware and puzzled by this fact, and it motivated Heisenberg to seek a mitigation, which he formulated in his seminal paper of 1927. He provided intuitive arguments to show that the values of, say, the position and momentum of a particle can at least be unsharply defined, and they can be measured together provided some approximation errors are allowed. Only now, nine decades later, a working theory of approximate joint measurements is taking shape, leading to rigorous and experimentally testable formulations of associated error tradeoff relations. Here we briefly review this new development, explaining the concepts and steps taken in the construction of optimal joint approximations of pairs of incompatible observables. As a case study, we deduce measurement uncertainty relations for qubit observables using two distinct error measures. We provide an operational interpretation of the error bounds and discuss some of the first experimental tests of such relations.

•Dec 1, 2015•1 citation

Heisenberg Uncertainty Principle

The more precisely the position of a particle is determined, the less precisely its momentum can be known, and conversely. This is the content of Heisenberg’s uncertainty principle. First stated in 1927, the inequality Δ x Δ p ≥ ℏ /2 is not a limitation of measuring instruments but a fundamental feature of quantum mechanics: position and momentum are complementary observables whose simultaneous sharp values are excluded by the structure of the theory. Few relations have so thoroughly changed the meaning of physical knowledge at the microscopic scale.

WORLD SCIENTIFIC eBooks•Oct 26, 2026•0 citations

Unprincipling Heisenberg’s uncertainties

Jean-Marc Lévy-Leblond

The first part of this paper is a critical essay on the conceptual meaning of the so-called « Uncertainty principle ». It will be stressed that there is no independent principle underlying the Heisenberg’s inequalities as they derive from the fundamental theoretical structure of quantum theory. More to the point, it will be emphasized that the term « uncertainty » is a misnomer, leading to subjective interpretations about the limits of our knowledge. Recognizing at face value the conceptual nature of quantum physical quantities, as endowed with a spectrum of numerical values, one should rather call « dispersions », « extensions » or « spectrum widths » the magnitudes entering Heisenberg’s type inequalities. A historical inquiry about the origins of the conventional terminology, from German to other languages, will reveal the roots and extent of the confusion. The second part of the paper will review and assess many of the various formal definitions leading to Heisenberg’s type inequalities, well beyond the pairs of physical quantities, such as the position and velocity of a particle and the customary use of quadratic dispersions. Some still open issues, such as the time-energy inequality or the angle-phase inequality will be briefly discussed. A sobering conclusion will assess the concrete uses of Heisenberg’s inequalities and stress that their genuine relevance and indisputable importance lie mainly at the heuristic and qualitative level, thus somewhat reducing the interest of the continuous discussions concerning their mathematical validity and philosophical interpretation.

WORLD SCIENTIFIC eBooks•Jul 1, 2026•0 citations
A review is given of precise formulations of three conceptually distinct but related manifestations of Heisenberg's Uncertainty Principle. This principle appears in the form of trade-off inequalities: for the widths of the position and momentum distributions in any quantum state; for the inaccuracies of any joint measurement of these quantities; and for the inaccuracy of a measurement of one of the quantities and the ensuing disturbance in the distribution of the other quantity. The uncertainty principle is often described as expressing a limitation of operational possibilities imposed by quantum mechanics. Here we demonstrate that apart from this negative role, the full content of the uncertainty principle also includes its positive role as a condition ensuring that mutually exclusive experimental options can indeed be reconciled if an appropriate trade-off is accepted. Finally, we survey models and experimental implementations of joint measurements of position and momentum and comment briefly on the status of experimental tests of the uncertainty principle.
Heisenberg's uncertainty principle is usually taken to express a limitation of operational possibilities imposed by quantum mechanics.Here we demonstrate that the full content of this principle also includes its positive role as a condition ensuring that mutually exclusive experimental options can be reconciled if an appropriate trade-off is accepted.The uncertainty principle is shown to appear in three manifestations, in the form of uncertainty relations: for the widths of the position and momentum distributions in any quantum state; for the inaccuracies of any joint measurement of these quantities; and for the inaccuracy of a measurement of one of the quantities and the ensuing disturbance in the distribution of the other quantity.Whilst conceptually distinct, these three kinds of uncertainty relations are shown to be closely related formally.Finally, we survey models and experimental implementations of joint measurements of position and momentum and comment briefly on the status of experimental tests of the uncertainty principle.
In recent years, novel quantifications of measurement error in quantum mechanics have for the first time enabled precise formulations of Heisenberg's famous but often challenged measurement uncertainty relation. These relations take the form of a trade-off for the necessary errors in joint approximate measurements of position and momentum and other incompatible pairs of observables. Here we review some of these error measures, examine their properties and suitability, and compare their relative strengths as criteria for "good" approximations.
Reports on experiments recently performed in Vienna [Erhard et al., Nature Phys. 8, 185 (2012)] and Toronto [Rozema et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 109, 100404 (2012)] include claims of a violation of Heisenberg's error-disturbance relation. In contrast, we have presented and proven a Heisenberg-type relation for joint measurements of position and momentum [Phys. Rev. Lett. 111, 160405 (2013)]. To resolve the apparent conflict, we formulate here a general trade-off relation for errors in qubit measurements, using the same concepts as we did in the position-momentum case. We show that the combined errors in an approximate joint measurement of a pair of $\ifmmode\pm\else\textpm\fi{}1$-valued observables A,BA,BA,B are tightly bounded from below by a quantity that measures the degree of incompatibility of AAA and BBB. The claim of a violation of Heisenberg is shown to fail because it is based on unsuitable measures of error and disturbance. Finally we show how the experiments mentioned may directly be used to test our error inequality.
In standard formulations of the uncertainty principle, two fundamental features are typically cast as impossibility statements: two noncommuting observables cannot in general both be sharply defined (for the same state), nor can they be measured jointly. The pioneers of quantum mechanics were acutely aware and puzzled by this fact, and it motivated Heisenberg to seek a mitigation, which he formulated in his seminal paper of 1927. He provided intuitive arguments to show that the values of, say, the position and momentum of a particle can at least be unsharply defined, and they can be measured together provided some approximation errors are allowed. Only now, nine decades later, a working theory of approximate joint measurements is taking shape, leading to rigorous and experimentally testable formulations of associated error tradeoff relations. Here we briefly review this new development, explaining the concepts and steps taken in the construction of optimal joint approximations of pairs of incompatible observables. As a case study, we deduce measurement uncertainty relations for qubit observables using two distinct error measures. We provide an operational interpretation of the error bounds and discuss some of the first experimental tests of such relations.
The more precisely the position of a particle is determined, the less precisely its momentum can be known, and conversely. This is the content of Heisenberg’s uncertainty principle. First stated in 1927, the inequality Δ x Δ p ≥ ℏ /2 is not a limitation of measuring instruments but a fundamental feature of quantum mechanics: position and momentum are complementary observables whose simultaneous sharp values are excluded by the structure of the theory. Few relations have so thoroughly changed the meaning of physical knowledge at the microscopic scale.
The first part of this paper is a critical essay on the conceptual meaning of the so-called « Uncertainty principle ». It will be stressed that there is no independent principle underlying the Heisenberg’s inequalities as they derive from the fundamental theoretical structure of quantum theory. More to the point, it will be emphasized that the term « uncertainty » is a misnomer, leading to subjective interpretations about the limits of our knowledge. Recognizing at face value the conceptual nature of quantum physical quantities, as endowed with a spectrum of numerical values, one should rather call « dispersions », « extensions » or « spectrum widths » the magnitudes entering Heisenberg’s type inequalities. A historical inquiry about the origins of the conventional terminology, from German to other languages, will reveal the roots and extent of the confusion. The second part of the paper will review and assess many of the various formal definitions leading to Heisenberg’s type inequalities, well beyond the pairs of physical quantities, such as the position and velocity of a particle and the customary use of quadratic dispersions. Some still open issues, such as the time-energy inequality or the angle-phase inequality will be briefly discussed. A sobering conclusion will assess the concrete uses of Heisenberg’s inequalities and stress that their genuine relevance and indisputable importance lie mainly at the heuristic and qualitative level, thus somewhat reducing the interest of the continuous discussions concerning their mathematical validity and philosophical interpretation.