Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Is time asymmetry logically prior to quantum mechanics

William K. Wootters

Published Jan 1, 1994• 3 citations
OpenAlex

Abstract

In trying to imagine how quantum mechanics might be derived from a more fundamental theory, the author is led to consider a framework in which timeasymmetric events, rather than reversible unitary transformations, are taken as basic. In such a scheme it seems likely that quantum mechanics and the second law of thermodynamics would emerge together, both being consequences of a deeper

Related papers

A time-symmetric formulation of quantum mechanics

Yakir Aharonov, Sandu Popescu, Jeff Tollaksen

Quantum mechanics allows one to independently select both the initial and final states of a single system. Such pre- and postselection reveals novel effects that challenge our ideas about what time is and how it flows.

Physics Today•Nov 1, 2010•228 citations

Alternative derivation of the classical second law of thermodynamics

Ian M. Bassett

One of the classical statements of the second law of thermodynamics is derived from an assumption about the behavior of an isolated heat reservoir, together with a further assumption, which seems to be a rather weak one, about initial states. The derivation is otherwise based on the unitary property of time evolution in quantum mechanics. An analogous derivation, within the framework of classical mechanics, is also given; in this case Liouville's theorem substitutes for unitarity.

Physical Review A•Nov 1, 1978•37 citations

Subjective Entropy and Time Asymmetry: A Quantum Channel Capacity Perspective

Bo Zhang

This work presents a conceptual and mathematical framework addressing the longstanding tension between microscopic reversibility in quantum mechanics and macroscopic irreversibility in thermodynamics. Rather than modifying unitary quantum dynamics or invoking ad hoc coarse-graining procedures, the paper proposes that the thermodynamic arrow of time arises as an information-theoretic consequence of the physical limitations of observers. The central hypothesis, termed the Holographic Shannon–Landauer (HSL) framework, models the observer as a finite-bandwidth quantum channel (a Completely Positive Trace-Preserving map). Within this framework, entropy is redefined not as an intrinsic property of matter, but as the quantum relative entropy between the true global quantum state and the state accessible to a bandwidth-limited observer. By formalizing observation as a channel-capacity–constrained physical process, the work derives a Bandwidth–Entropy Monotonicity Theorem, demonstrating that reduced observational resolution necessarily leads to increased observed entropy via the data processing inequality. The Second Law of Thermodynamics emerges naturally from the dynamical spreading of entanglement into degrees of freedom inaccessible to the observer, rather than from any fundamental time asymmetry in the underlying laws. This manuscript is intended as a foundational and unifying perspective, connecting quantum thermodynamics, information theory, and observer-dependent physics. It is archived here as a citable preprint to establish priority and provide a stable reference point for subsequent technical developments and potential journal submissions.

•Dec 21, 2025•0 citations

Reversibility and Irreversibility within the Quantum Formalism

T. J. Jacobs, Christian Maes

The discussion on time-reversal in quantum mechanics exists at least since Wigner's ``Uber die Operation der Zeitumkehr in der Quantenmechanik'' paper in 1932. If and how the dynamics of the quantum world is time-reversible has been the subject of many controversies. Some have seen quantum mechanics as fundamentally time-irreversible, see for example von Neumann, and some have seen in that the ultimate cause of time's arrow and second law behavior. In his best-selling book ``The Emperor's New Mind'', Roger Penrose argues similarly and concludes that ``our sought-for quantum gravity must be a time-asymmetric theory'' [p.351]. Not so long ago, we read yet about another project in Physicalia 26: to extend quantum mechanics into new fundamentally irreversible equations, thus proposing a new theory giving ``... une description fondamentale irreversible de tout systeme physique''.

arXiv:quant-ph/0508041•Aug 4, 2005•6 citations

Quantum Mechanics as Naturalized Time

Zachary Walton, Bernard S. McNamara, Tommaso Toffoli

We bring together two topics (quantum mechanics and time passage) with the goal of clarifying questions about each. Specifically, we claim that the formalism of quantum mechanics provides an answer to the question: "What is time passage?".

arXiv:2004.12052•Apr 25, 2020•0 citations

Irreversibility, equilibrium and measurement in quantum mechanics

Christopher J. N. Coveney, Peter V. Coveney

Quantum mechanics is widely recognised as being incomplete. It is not consistent with the second law of thermodynamics and does not provide a scientifically credible physical account of the measurement process, the means by which coherence is broken and classically observable states are recorded. This has led to many ad hoc assumptions being used to account for various properties of quantum systems, among which is the coherence time of quantum devices that determines their ability to perform computations. Here, we show that all these properties can be accommodated naturally and consistently in the context of mixing quantum systems which exhibit continuous spectra, as arises in the thermodynamic limit in quantum statistical mechanics and quantum gravity. In particular, for isolated systems we show that the time-reversal symmetry associated with unitary time evolution of the quantum state gives rise to time-symmetry breaking and a semi-group evolution which attains thermodynamic equilibrium at long times. Moreover, the emergence of this non-unitary time-asymmetry leads to microcanonical equilibrium states in which all quantum coherence is lost and is accompanied by the transformation of pure states into mixtures, leading in turn to an increase in entropy. Inclusion of a macroscopic measurement apparatus shows how the outcome of a measurement corresponds to the von Neumann projection postulate, arising with probabilities in conformance with the Born rule. The mathematical structure of the theory which applies to quantum systems with continuous spectra is closely analogous to the classical ergodic theory of dynamical systems and the conditions under which they attain equilibrium states.

quant-pharXiv:2607.19142•Jul 22, 2026•0 citations
In trying to imagine how quantum mechanics might be derived from a more fundamental theory, the author is led to consider a framework in which timeasymmetric events, rather than reversible unitary transformations, are taken as basic. In such a scheme it seems likely that quantum mechanics and the second law of thermodynamics would emerge together, both being consequences of a deeper
This work presents a conceptual and mathematical framework addressing the longstanding tension between microscopic reversibility in quantum mechanics and macroscopic irreversibility in thermodynamics. Rather than modifying unitary quantum dynamics or invoking ad hoc coarse-graining procedures, the paper proposes that the thermodynamic arrow of time arises as an information-theoretic consequence of the physical limitations of observers. The central hypothesis, termed the Holographic Shannon–Landauer (HSL) framework, models the observer as a finite-bandwidth quantum channel (a Completely Positive Trace-Preserving map). Within this framework, entropy is redefined not as an intrinsic property of matter, but as the quantum relative entropy between the true global quantum state and the state accessible to a bandwidth-limited observer. By formalizing observation as a channel-capacity–constrained physical process, the work derives a Bandwidth–Entropy Monotonicity Theorem, demonstrating that reduced observational resolution necessarily leads to increased observed entropy via the data processing inequality. The Second Law of Thermodynamics emerges naturally from the dynamical spreading of entanglement into degrees of freedom inaccessible to the observer, rather than from any fundamental time asymmetry in the underlying laws. This manuscript is intended as a foundational and unifying perspective, connecting quantum thermodynamics, information theory, and observer-dependent physics. It is archived here as a citable preprint to establish priority and provide a stable reference point for subsequent technical developments and potential journal submissions.
The discussion on time-reversal in quantum mechanics exists at least since Wigner's ``Uber die Operation der Zeitumkehr in der Quantenmechanik'' paper in 1932. If and how the dynamics of the quantum world is time-reversible has been the subject of many controversies. Some have seen quantum mechanics as fundamentally time-irreversible, see for example von Neumann, and some have seen in that the ultimate cause of time's arrow and second law behavior. In his best-selling book ``The Emperor's New Mind'', Roger Penrose argues similarly and concludes that ``our sought-for quantum gravity must be a time-asymmetric theory'' [p.351]. Not so long ago, we read yet about another project in Physicalia 26: to extend quantum mechanics into new fundamentally irreversible equations, thus proposing a new theory giving ``... une description fondamentale irreversible de tout systeme physique''.
Quantum mechanics is widely recognised as being incomplete. It is not consistent with the second law of thermodynamics and does not provide a scientifically credible physical account of the measurement process, the means by which coherence is broken and classically observable states are recorded. This has led to many ad hoc assumptions being used to account for various properties of quantum systems, among which is the coherence time of quantum devices that determines their ability to perform computations. Here, we show that all these properties can be accommodated naturally and consistently in the context of mixing quantum systems which exhibit continuous spectra, as arises in the thermodynamic limit in quantum statistical mechanics and quantum gravity. In particular, for isolated systems we show that the time-reversal symmetry associated with unitary time evolution of the quantum state gives rise to time-symmetry breaking and a semi-group evolution which attains thermodynamic equilibrium at long times. Moreover, the emergence of this non-unitary time-asymmetry leads to microcanonical equilibrium states in which all quantum coherence is lost and is accompanied by the transformation of pure states into mixtures, leading in turn to an increase in entropy. Inclusion of a macroscopic measurement apparatus shows how the outcome of a measurement corresponds to the von Neumann projection postulate, arising with probabilities in conformance with the Born rule. The mathematical structure of the theory which applies to quantum systems with continuous spectra is closely analogous to the classical ergodic theory of dynamical systems and the conditions under which they attain equilibrium states.