Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:quant-ph/0508041

Reversibility and Irreversibility within the Quantum Formalism

T. J. Jacobs, Christian Maes

Published Aug 4, 2005• 6 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

The discussion on time-reversal in quantum mechanics exists at least since Wigner's ``Uber die Operation der Zeitumkehr in der Quantenmechanik'' paper in 1932. If and how the dynamics of the quantum world is time-reversible has been the subject of many controversies. Some have seen quantum mechanics as fundamentally time-irreversible, see for example von Neumann, and some have seen in that the ultimate cause of time's arrow and second law behavior. In his best-selling book ``The Emperor's New Mind'', Roger Penrose argues similarly and concludes that ``our sought-for quantum gravity must be a time-asymmetric theory'' [p.351]. Not so long ago, we read yet about another project in Physicalia 26: to extend quantum mechanics into new fundamentally irreversible equations, thus proposing a new theory giving ``... une description fondamentale irreversible de tout systeme physique''.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.quant-ph/0508041

Related papers

Is Time ‘Handed’ in a Quantum World?

Craig Callender

In a classical mechanical world, the fundamental laws of nature are reversible. The laws of nature treat the past and future as mirror images of each other. Temporally asymmetric phenomena are ultimately said to arise from initial conditions. But are the laws of nature also reversible in a quantum world? This paper argues that they are not, that time in a quantum world prefers a particular ‘hand’ or ordering. I argue, first, that the probabilistic algorithm used in the theory picks out a preferred direction of time for almost all interpretations of the theory, and second, that contrary to the received wisdom the Schrödinger evolution is also irreversible. The status of Wigner reversal invariance is then discussed. I conclude that the quantum world is fundamentally irreversible, but manages to appear (thanks to Wigner reversal invariance) reversible at the classical level.

Proceedings of the Aristotelian Society (Hardback)•Jun 1, 2000•44 citations

Irreversibility in quantum mechanics

Robert C. Bishop, Arno Böhm, Manuel Gadella

Time asymmetry and irreversibility are signal features of our world. They are the reason of our aging and the basis for our belief that effects are preceded by causes. These features have many manifestations called arrows of time. In classical physics, some of these arrows are described by the increase of entropy or probability, and others by time‐asymmetric boundary conditions of time‐symmetric equations (e.g., Maxwell or Einstein). However, there is some controversy over whether probability or boundary conditions are more fundamental. For quantum systems, entropy increase is usually associated with the effects of an environment or measurement apparatus on a quantum system and is described by the von Neumann‐Liouville equation. But since the traditional (von Neumann) axioms of quantum mechanics do not allow time‐asymmetric boundary conditions for the dynamical differential equations (Schrödinger or Heisenberg), there is no quantum analogue of the radiation arrow of time. In this paper, we review consequences of a modification of a fundamental axiom of quantum mechanics. The new quantum theory is time asymmetric and accommodates an irreversible time evolution of isolated quantum systems.

Discrete Dynamics in Nature and Society•Jan 1, 2004•3 citations

Time-reversal of an unknown quantum state

A. V. Lebedev, V. M. Vinokur

Abstract For decades, researchers have sought to understand how the irreversibility of the surrounding world emerges from the seemingly time-symmetric, fundamental laws of physics. Quantum mechanics conjectured a clue that final irreversibility is set by the measurement procedure and that the time-reversal requires complex conjugation of the wave function, which is overly complex to spontaneously appear in nature. Building on this Landau-Wigner conjecture, it became possible to demonstrate that time-reversal is exponentially improbable in a virgin nature and to design an algorithm artificially reversing a time arrow for a given quantum state on the IBM quantum computer. However, the implemented arrow-of-time reversal embraced only the known states initially disentangled from the thermodynamic reservoir. Here we develop a procedure for reversing the temporal evolution of an arbitrary unknown quantum state. This opens the route for general universal algorithms sending temporal evolution of an arbitrary system backward in time.

arXiv:1912.12036•Communications Physics•Jul 21, 2020•3 citations

Time's Arrow and Irreversibility in Time‐Asymmetric Quantum Mechanics

Mario A Castagnino, Manuel Gadella, Olímpia Lombardi

The aim of this paper is to analyze time‐asymmetric quantum mechanics with respect to the problems of irreversibility and of time’s arrow. We begin with arguing that both problems are conceptually different. Then, we show that, contrary to a common opinion, the theory’s ability to describe irreversible quantum processes is not a consequence of the semigroup evolution laws expressing the non‐time‐reversal invariance of the theory. Finally, we argue that time‐asymmetric quantum mechanics, either in Prigogine’s version or in Bohm’s version, does not solve the problem of the arrow of time because it does not supply a substantial and theoretically founded criterion for distinguishing between the two directions of time.

International Studies in the Philosophy of Science•Oct 1, 2005•14 citations

TIME AND QM

As we have seen [chapter 21], there can be spontaneous decoherence, such that the interference terms fall to zero in a relatively short time. It is natural to ask: Is it possible to generalize that model in order to build a microtheory in which the interference is lost and a deterministic history is gained? This is the aim of the consistent or decoherent- histories approach. The question is very interesting on the cosmological level, because, if the answer is affirmative, then we can describe quantum mechanically a consistent history of our universe. Another problem is the following: von Neumann assumed two types of evolution, an unitary reversible evolution and the reduction of the wave-packet. In part V we have showed how is possible to overcome the gap between micro- and macro-world postulated by von Neumann. But a problem remains: the basic equations of QM seem reversible, while decoherence seems to presuppose some type of reversibility. How to solve such a problem? Summing up: • In chapter 25 we analyse different proposals to build cosmological decoherent wave functions. • Then the ‘delayed choice’ issue is analysed theoretically and experimentally [ chapter 26 ], because of its enormous consequence on the theory, and in particular on the interpretation of QM. • While in chapter 26 time is treated of as an external parameter, in chapter 27 we discuss the problem of the reversibility and irreversibility of quantum systems, i.e. treating time as a dynamical observable of the system itself, following the discussion of the time operator [see subsection 10.2.3]. Even if the theme of this part has only taken a central place in scientific debate since the seventies, its connection with the preceding part and its importance for the successive two parts, justify its treatment here.

WORLD SCIENTIFIC eBooks•Jun 1, 2000•0 citations

Time-reversal invariance and irreversibility in time-asymmetric quantum mechanics

Mario A Castagnino, Manuel Gadella, Olímpia Lombardi

The aim of this paper is to analyze the concepts of time-reversal invariance and irreversibility in the so-called ’time-asymmetric quan-tum mechanics’. We begin with pointing out the difference between these two concepts. On this basis, we show that irreversibility is not as tightly linked to the semigroup evolution laws of the theory-which lead to its non time-reversal invariance- as usually suggested. In turn, we argue that the irreversible evolutions described by the theory are coarse-grained processes. 1 1

•Sep 1, 2005•0 citations
The discussion on time-reversal in quantum mechanics exists at least since Wigner's Uber die Operation der Zeitumkehr in der Quantenmechanik'' paper in 1932. If and how the dynamics of the quantum world is time-reversible has been the subject of many controversies. Some have seen quantum mechanics as fundamentally time-irreversible, see for example von Neumann, and some have seen in that the ultimate cause of time's arrow and second law behavior. In his best-selling book The Emperor's New Mind'', Roger Penrose argues similarly and concludes that our sought-for quantum gravity must be a time-asymmetric theory'' [p.351]. Not so long ago, we read yet about another project in Physicalia 26: to extend quantum mechanics into new fundamentally irreversible equations, thus proposing a new theory giving ... une description fondamentale irreversible de tout systeme physique''.
In a classical mechanical world, the fundamental laws of nature are reversible. The laws of nature treat the past and future as mirror images of each other. Temporally asymmetric phenomena are ultimately said to arise from initial conditions. But are the laws of nature also reversible in a quantum world? This paper argues that they are not, that time in a quantum world prefers a particular ‘hand’ or ordering. I argue, first, that the probabilistic algorithm used in the theory picks out a preferred direction of time for almost all interpretations of the theory, and second, that contrary to the received wisdom the Schrödinger evolution is also irreversible. The status of Wigner reversal invariance is then discussed. I conclude that the quantum world is fundamentally irreversible, but manages to appear (thanks to Wigner reversal invariance) reversible at the classical level.
Time asymmetry and irreversibility are signal features of our world. They are the reason of our aging and the basis for our belief that effects are preceded by causes. These features have many manifestations called arrows of time. In classical physics, some of these arrows are described by the increase of entropy or probability, and others by time‐asymmetric boundary conditions of time‐symmetric equations (e.g., Maxwell or Einstein). However, there is some controversy over whether probability or boundary conditions are more fundamental. For quantum systems, entropy increase is usually associated with the effects of an environment or measurement apparatus on a quantum system and is described by the von Neumann‐Liouville equation. But since the traditional (von Neumann) axioms of quantum mechanics do not allow time‐asymmetric boundary conditions for the dynamical differential equations (Schrödinger or Heisenberg), there is no quantum analogue of the radiation arrow of time. In this paper, we review consequences of a modification of a fundamental axiom of quantum mechanics. The new quantum theory is time asymmetric and accommodates an irreversible time evolution of isolated quantum systems.
Abstract For decades, researchers have sought to understand how the irreversibility of the surrounding world emerges from the seemingly time-symmetric, fundamental laws of physics. Quantum mechanics conjectured a clue that final irreversibility is set by the measurement procedure and that the time-reversal requires complex conjugation of the wave function, which is overly complex to spontaneously appear in nature. Building on this Landau-Wigner conjecture, it became possible to demonstrate that time-reversal is exponentially improbable in a virgin nature and to design an algorithm artificially reversing a time arrow for a given quantum state on the IBM quantum computer. However, the implemented arrow-of-time reversal embraced only the known states initially disentangled from the thermodynamic reservoir. Here we develop a procedure for reversing the temporal evolution of an arbitrary unknown quantum state. This opens the route for general universal algorithms sending temporal evolution of an arbitrary system backward in time.
The aim of this paper is to analyze time‐asymmetric quantum mechanics with respect to the problems of irreversibility and of time’s arrow. We begin with arguing that both problems are conceptually different. Then, we show that, contrary to a common opinion, the theory’s ability to describe irreversible quantum processes is not a consequence of the semigroup evolution laws expressing the non‐time‐reversal invariance of the theory. Finally, we argue that time‐asymmetric quantum mechanics, either in Prigogine’s version or in Bohm’s version, does not solve the problem of the arrow of time because it does not supply a substantial and theoretically founded criterion for distinguishing between the two directions of time.
As we have seen [chapter 21], there can be spontaneous decoherence, such that the interference terms fall to zero in a relatively short time. It is natural to ask: Is it possible to generalize that model in order to build a microtheory in which the interference is lost and a deterministic history is gained? This is the aim of the consistent or decoherent- histories approach. The question is very interesting on the cosmological level, because, if the answer is affirmative, then we can describe quantum mechanically a consistent history of our universe. Another problem is the following: von Neumann assumed two types of evolution, an unitary reversible evolution and the reduction of the wave-packet. In part V we have showed how is possible to overcome the gap between micro- and macro-world postulated by von Neumann. But a problem remains: the basic equations of QM seem reversible, while decoherence seems to presuppose some type of reversibility. How to solve such a problem? Summing up: • In chapter 25 we analyse different proposals to build cosmological decoherent wave functions. • Then the ‘delayed choice’ issue is analysed theoretically and experimentally [ chapter 26 ], because of its enormous consequence on the theory, and in particular on the interpretation of QM. • While in chapter 26 time is treated of as an external parameter, in chapter 27 we discuss the problem of the reversibility and irreversibility of quantum systems, i.e. treating time as a dynamical observable of the system itself, following the discussion of the time operator [see subsection 10.2.3]. Even if the theme of this part has only taken a central place in scientific debate since the seventies, its connection with the preceding part and its importance for the successive two parts, justify its treatment here.
The aim of this paper is to analyze the concepts of time-reversal invariance and irreversibility in the so-called ’time-asymmetric quan-tum mechanics’. We begin with pointing out the difference between these two concepts. On this basis, we show that irreversibility is not as tightly linked to the semigroup evolution laws of the theory-which lead to its non time-reversal invariance- as usually suggested. In turn, we argue that the irreversible evolutions described by the theory are coarse-grained processes. 1 1