Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

DIMACS series in discrete mathematics and theoretical computer science

An application of game theoretic techniques to cryptography

Michael J. Fischer, Rebecca N. Wright

Published Oct 25, 1993• 31 citations
Publisher

Abstract

This paper provides an application of game theoretic techniques to the analysis of a class of multiparty cryptographic protocols for secret bit exchange. 1 Introduction A cryptographic protocol is often thought of as a game between the honest participants in the protocol and a malicious adversary who tries to corrupt the protocol. In this paper, we consider a simple combinatorial game that arises in the analysis of the class of multiparty "key set" secret bit exchange protocols introduced in [FW92b]. We find an optimal strategy for the combinatorial game and show how this leads to a key set protocol that is optimal from among the class of all key set protocols. While key set protocols are too limited to be of much practical interest, this result is nevertheless interesting as an illustration of the close connection between protocols and games and the use of nontrivial game theoretic techniques in the analysis of protocols. The combinatorial game is a simple counting game a little l...

DOI
10.1090/dimacs/013/06

Related papers

Rational Multiparty Computation

John Ross Wallrabenstein

The field of rational cryptography considers the design of cryptographic protocols in the presence of rational agents seeking to maximize local utility functions. This departs from the standard secure multiparty computation setting, where players are assumed to be either honest or malicious. We detail the construction of both a two-party and a multiparty game theoretic framework for constructing rational cryptographic protocols. Our framework specifies the utility function assumptions necessary to realize the privacy, correctness, and fairness guarantees for protocols. We demonstrate that our framework correctly models cryptographic protocols, such as rational secret sharing, where existing work considers equilibrium concepts that yield unreasonable equilibria. Similarly, we demonstrate that cryptography may be applied to the game theoretic domain, constructing an auction market not realizable in the original formulation. Additionally, we demonstrate that modeling players as rational agents allows us to design a protocol that destabilizes coalitions. Thus, we establish a mutual benefit from combining the two fields, while demonstrating the applicability of our framework to real-world market environments. We also give an application of game theory to adversarial interactions where cryptography is not necessary. Specifically, we consider adversarial machine learning, where the adversary is rational and reacts to the presence of a data miner. We give a general extension to classification algorithms that returns greater expected utility for the data miner than existing classification methods.

•Jan 1, 2014•1 citation

Rational Protocol Design: Cryptography against Incentive-Driven Adversaries

Juan A. Garay, Jonathan I. Katz, Ueli M. Maurer +2 more

Existing work on "rational cryptographic protocols" treats each party (or coalition of parties) running the protocol as a selfish agent trying to maximize its utility. In this work we propose a fundamentally different approach that is better suited to modeling a protocol under attack from an external entity. Specifically, we consider a two-party game between an protocol designer and an external attacker. The goal of the attacker is to break security properties such as correctness or privacy, possibly by corrupting protocol participants; the goal of the protocol designer is to prevent the attacker from succeeding. We lay the theoretical groundwork for a study of cryptographic protocol design in this setting by providing a methodology for defining the problem within the traditional simulation paradigm. Our framework provides ways of reasoning about important cryptographic concepts (e.g., adaptive corruptions or attacks on communication resources) not handled by previous game-theoretic treatments of cryptography. We also prove composition theorems that-for the first time-provide a sound way to design rational protocols assuming "ideal communication resources" (such as broadcast or authenticated channels) and then instantiate these resources using standard cryptographic tools. Finally, we investigate the problem of secure function evaluation in our framework, where the attacker has to pay for each party it corrupts. Our results demonstrate how knowledge of the attacker's incentives can be used to circumvent known impossibility results in this setting.

Annual Symposium on Foundations of Computer Science•Oct 1, 2013•93 citations

Rational cryptography: novel constructions, automated verification and unified definitions

Oana Ciobotaru

Rational cryptography has recently emerged as a very promising field of research by combining notions and techniques from cryptography and game theory, because it offers an alternative to the rather inexible traditional cryptographic model. In contrast to the classical view of cryptography where protocol participants are considered either honest or arbitrarily malicious, rational cryptography models participants as rational players that try to maximize their benefit and thus deviate from the protocol only if they gain an advantage by doing so. The main research goals for rational cryptography are the design of more ecient protocols when players adhere to a rational model, the design and implementation of automated proofs for rational security notions and the study of the intrinsic connections between game theoretic and cryptographic notions. In this thesis, we address all these issues. First we present the mathematical model and the design for a new rational file sharing protocol which we call RatFish. Next, we develop a general method for automated verification for rational cryptographic protocols and we show how to apply our technique in order to automatically derive the rational security property for RatFish. Finally, we study the intrinsic connections between game theory and cryptography by defining a new game theoretic notion, which we call game universal implementation, and by showing its equivalence with the notion of weak stand-alone security.

•Jan 1, 2012•0 citations

Verifiable secret sharing and multiparty protocols with honest majority

Tal Rabin, Michael Ben-Or

Under the assumption that each participant can broadcast a message to all other participants and that each pair of participants can communicate secretly, we present a verifiable secret sharing protocol, and show that any multiparty protocol, or game with incomplete information, can be achieved if a majority of the players are honest. The secrecy achieved is unconditional and does not rely on any assumption about computational intractability. Applications of these results to Byzantine Agreement are also presented.

ACM Symposium on Theory of Computing (STOC)•Jan 1, 1989•956 citations

A Compiler of Two-Party Protocols for Composable and Game-Theoretic Security, and Its Application to Oblivious Transfer.

Shota Goto, Junji Shikata

In this paper, we consider the following question: Does composing protocols having game-theoretic security result in a secure protocol in the sense of game-theoretic security? In order to discuss the composability of game-theoretic properties, we study security of cryptographic protocols in terms of the universal composability (UC) and game theory simultaneously. The contribution of this paper is the following: (i) We propose a compiler of two-party protocols in the local universal composability (LUC) framework such that it transforms any two-party protocol secure against semi-honest adversaries into a protocol secure against malicious adversaries in the LUC framework; (ii) We consider the application of our compiler to oblivious transfer (OT) protocols, by which we obtain a construction of OT meeting both UC security and game-theoretic-security.

•Jan 1, 2015•0 citations

The match-making problem

Jeroen van de Graaf, van de

. This paper discusses a cryptographic protocol to evaluate an and-gate such that a party can keep his input bit secret from the other party. Such a protocol is of interest, because it can be generalized to any logical circuit for any number of participants. A formal statement of this generalization reads as follows: n participants want to compute together a function f(x1 ; x2 ; :::; xn) with x i being their inputs; nobody wants to reveal information about his input except what can be logically be deduced from the output. The paper contains no new results but provides an illustration of a sub-field of cryptography, and introduces several interesting protocols and protocol design techniques. 1 Introduction Suppose Alice and Bob meet for the first time. They want to find out whether they are interested in each other, so both engage in a cryptographic protocol transmitted in infra-red through their watches. The protocol has to be such that if both parties show interest they find out, bu...

Quarterly - Centrum voor Wiskunde en Informatica•Jun 1, 1995•0 citations
This paper provides an application of game theoretic techniques to the analysis of a class of multiparty cryptographic protocols for secret bit exchange. 1 Introduction A cryptographic protocol is often thought of as a game between the honest participants in the protocol and a malicious adversary who tries to corrupt the protocol. In this paper, we consider a simple combinatorial game that arises in the analysis of the class of multiparty "key set" secret bit exchange protocols introduced in [FW92b]. We find an optimal strategy for the combinatorial game and show how this leads to a key set protocol that is optimal from among the class of all key set protocols. While key set protocols are too limited to be of much practical interest, this result is nevertheless interesting as an illustration of the close connection between protocols and games and the use of nontrivial game theoretic techniques in the analysis of protocols. The combinatorial game is a simple counting game a little l...
The field of rational cryptography considers the design of cryptographic protocols in the presence of rational agents seeking to maximize local utility functions. This departs from the standard secure multiparty computation setting, where players are assumed to be either honest or malicious. We detail the construction of both a two-party and a multiparty game theoretic framework for constructing rational cryptographic protocols. Our framework specifies the utility function assumptions necessary to realize the privacy, correctness, and fairness guarantees for protocols. We demonstrate that our framework correctly models cryptographic protocols, such as rational secret sharing, where existing work considers equilibrium concepts that yield unreasonable equilibria. Similarly, we demonstrate that cryptography may be applied to the game theoretic domain, constructing an auction market not realizable in the original formulation. Additionally, we demonstrate that modeling players as rational agents allows us to design a protocol that destabilizes coalitions. Thus, we establish a mutual benefit from combining the two fields, while demonstrating the applicability of our framework to real-world market environments. We also give an application of game theory to adversarial interactions where cryptography is not necessary. Specifically, we consider adversarial machine learning, where the adversary is rational and reacts to the presence of a data miner. We give a general extension to classification algorithms that returns greater expected utility for the data miner than existing classification methods.
Existing work on "rational cryptographic protocols" treats each party (or coalition of parties) running the protocol as a selfish agent trying to maximize its utility. In this work we propose a fundamentally different approach that is better suited to modeling a protocol under attack from an external entity. Specifically, we consider a two-party game between an protocol designer and an external attacker. The goal of the attacker is to break security properties such as correctness or privacy, possibly by corrupting protocol participants; the goal of the protocol designer is to prevent the attacker from succeeding. We lay the theoretical groundwork for a study of cryptographic protocol design in this setting by providing a methodology for defining the problem within the traditional simulation paradigm. Our framework provides ways of reasoning about important cryptographic concepts (e.g., adaptive corruptions or attacks on communication resources) not handled by previous game-theoretic treatments of cryptography. We also prove composition theorems that-for the first time-provide a sound way to design rational protocols assuming "ideal communication resources" (such as broadcast or authenticated channels) and then instantiate these resources using standard cryptographic tools. Finally, we investigate the problem of secure function evaluation in our framework, where the attacker has to pay for each party it corrupts. Our results demonstrate how knowledge of the attacker's incentives can be used to circumvent known impossibility results in this setting.
Rational cryptography has recently emerged as a very promising field of research by combining notions and techniques from cryptography and game theory, because it offers an alternative to the rather inexible traditional cryptographic model. In contrast to the classical view of cryptography where protocol participants are considered either honest or arbitrarily malicious, rational cryptography models participants as rational players that try to maximize their benefit and thus deviate from the protocol only if they gain an advantage by doing so. The main research goals for rational cryptography are the design of more ecient protocols when players adhere to a rational model, the design and implementation of automated proofs for rational security notions and the study of the intrinsic connections between game theoretic and cryptographic notions. In this thesis, we address all these issues. First we present the mathematical model and the design for a new rational file sharing protocol which we call RatFish. Next, we develop a general method for automated verification for rational cryptographic protocols and we show how to apply our technique in order to automatically derive the rational security property for RatFish. Finally, we study the intrinsic connections between game theory and cryptography by defining a new game theoretic notion, which we call game universal implementation, and by showing its equivalence with the notion of weak stand-alone security.
Under the assumption that each participant can broadcast a message to all other participants and that each pair of participants can communicate secretly, we present a verifiable secret sharing protocol, and show that any multiparty protocol, or game with incomplete information, can be achieved if a majority of the players are honest. The secrecy achieved is unconditional and does not rely on any assumption about computational intractability. Applications of these results to Byzantine Agreement are also presented.
In this paper, we consider the following question: Does composing protocols having game-theoretic security result in a secure protocol in the sense of game-theoretic security? In order to discuss the composability of game-theoretic properties, we study security of cryptographic protocols in terms of the universal composability (UC) and game theory simultaneously. The contribution of this paper is the following: (i) We propose a compiler of two-party protocols in the local universal composability (LUC) framework such that it transforms any two-party protocol secure against semi-honest adversaries into a protocol secure against malicious adversaries in the LUC framework; (ii) We consider the application of our compiler to oblivious transfer (OT) protocols, by which we obtain a construction of OT meeting both UC security and game-theoretic-security.
. This paper discusses a cryptographic protocol to evaluate an and-gate such that a party can keep his input bit secret from the other party. Such a protocol is of interest, because it can be generalized to any logical circuit for any number of participants. A formal statement of this generalization reads as follows: n participants want to compute together a function f(x1 ; x2 ; :::; xn) with x i being their inputs; nobody wants to reveal information about his input except what can be logically be deduced from the output. The paper contains no new results but provides an illustration of a sub-field of cryptography, and introduces several interesting protocols and protocol design techniques. 1 Introduction Suppose Alice and Bob meet for the first time. They want to find out whether they are interested in each other, so both engage in a cryptographic protocol transmitted in infra-red through their watches. The protocol has to be such that if both parties show interest they find out, bu...