The First Law of Thermodynamics and the Abstraction to a Lack of Information in a Deterministic System Part 3
Francesco R. Ruggeri
In Parts 1 and 2 and also in the first two references listed in Part 1, a deterministic system, namely a particle with pp/2m moving in a one-dimensional box, is analyzed using classical statistical mechanics. In particular, the second reference listed in Part 1 starts with the math equation d(pl) = l dp + p dl and multiplies it by (p/m) 1/l to establish the first law of thermodynamics to a deterministic system. Here we try to argue that a statistical treatment of such a classical system arises because one focuses on collective work, i,e. -Pressure dl. Pressure is due to the particle elastically bouncing off the walls and so the work becomes linked to the collective change dl and not dp (change in momentum). Ultimately, however, this is a Newtonian problem and so d (pp2/m) is due to the change dp, but in statistical mechanics, such a change is seen as dissipation or heat. Thus, classically one would write: d (pp2/m) = Force dl, with Force having nothing to do with pressure. In statistical mechanics, pressure seems to be the key idea. F=dp/dt = dp/dl v(ave) (Newtonian treatment) is not equivalent to P dl = (p/m) (1/l) dl. To take the statistical viewpoint seriously, one has to focus on the pressure, i.e. an average force on the wall with elastic collisions and treat the actual loss of pp/2m as linked to heat. We argue that ultimately the statistical view of the deterministic system yields d(pp/2m) with dl, the collective work not being of interest in the Newtonian picture. Thus, the statistical picture seems to be linked to the constraint l=constant more than any kind of random or probabilistic feature, we argue.
•Apr 7, 2026•0 citations