In Parts 1 and 2 and also in the first two references listed in Part 1, a deterministic system, namely a particle with pp/2m moving in a one-dimensional box, is analyzed using classical statistical mechanics. In particular, the second reference listed in Part 1 starts with the math equation d(pl) = l dp + p dl and multiplies it by (p/m) 1/l to establish the first law of thermodynamics to a deterministic system. Here we try to argue that a statistical treatment of such a classical system arises because one focuses on collective work, i,e. -Pressure dl. Pressure is due to the particle elastically bouncing off the walls and so the work becomes linked to the collective change dl and not dp (change in momentum). Ultimately, however, this is a Newtonian problem and so d (pp2/m) is due to the change dp, but in statistical mechanics, such a change is seen as dissipation or heat. Thus, classically one would write: d (pp2/m) = Force dl, with Force having nothing to do with pressure. In statistical mechanics, pressure seems to be the key idea. F=dp/dt = dp/dl v(ave) (Newtonian treatment) is not equivalent to P dl = (p/m) (1/l) dl. To take the statistical viewpoint seriously, one has to focus on the pressure, i.e. an average force on the wall with elastic collisions and treat the actual loss of pp/2m as linked to heat. We argue that ultimately the statistical view of the deterministic system yields d(pp/2m) with dl, the collective work not being of interest in the Newtonian picture. Thus, the statistical picture seems to be linked to the constraint l=constant more than any kind of random or probabilistic feature, we argue.
In Parts 1 and 2 and also in the first two references listed in Part 1, a deterministic system, namely a particle with pp/2m moving in a one-dimensional box, is analyzed using classical statistical mechanics. In particular, the second reference listed in Part 1 starts with the math equation d(pl) = l dp + p dl and multiplies it by (p/m) 1/l to establish the first law of thermodynamics to a deterministic system. Here we try to argue that a statistical treatment of such a classical system arises because one focuses on collective work, i,e. -Pressure dl. Pressure is due to the particle elastically bouncing off the walls and so the work becomes linked to the collective change dl and not dp (change in momentum). Ultimately, however, this is a Newtonian problem and so d (pp2/m) is due to the change dp, but in statistical mechanics, such a change is seen as dissipation or heat. Thus, classically one would write: d (pp2/m) = Force dl, with Force having nothing to do with pressure. In statistical mechanics, pressure seems to be the key idea. F=dp/dt = dp/dl v(ave) (Newtonian treatment) is not equivalent to P dl = (p/m) (1/l) dl. To take the statistical viewpoint seriously, one has to focus on the pressure, i.e. an average force on the wall with elastic collisions and treat the actual loss of pp/2m as linked to heat. We argue that ultimately the statistical view of the deterministic system yields d(pp/2m) with dl, the collective work not being of interest in the Newtonian picture. Thus, the statistical picture seems to be linked to the constraint l=constant more than any kind of random or probabilistic feature, we argue.
Quantum mechanics is often compared with classical mechanics because both may deal with a single particle subject to a potential. Classical mechanics is said to be deterministic describing x(t) and its derivatives i.e showing how a particle moves and accelerates while bound state quantum mechanics produces a real wavefunction W(x) such that W(x)W(x) yields a spatial density profile. The comparison is carried further with the correspondence principle which states that at high energy levels quantum mechanics should mimic classical mechanics. Classical mechanics does not simply describe x(t) and its derivatives i.e. deterministic motion. It also includes two body scattering, force and torque balances for a stationary object etc. In the case of the classical statistical mechanics of an equilibrium ideal gas, the Maxwell-Boltzmann (MB) distribution in the absence of a potential is C1 exp(- pp/(2mT) ). If a potential V(x) is added, one may find P(x) two different ways using Newtonian ideas. The first is to consider the gas as a collective entity like a tiny macroscopic classical object at x. Then one may argue that equilibrium means the system is stationary and apply Newtonian statics i.e. a balance of pressures and -dV/dx to obtain exp(-V(x)/T) as is often done in textbooks. Alternatively, one may consider a single particle and apply Newtonian mechanics differently, namely use a conservation of energy equation: p1p1/2m + V(x1) = p2p2/2m + V(x2). Again one obtains exp(-V(x)/T). The spatial part of probability may be based on Newtonian mechanics indicating that it is not stochastic. The stochastic function is C1 exp(-pp/2mT). Interestingly, however, the two Newtonian approaches are different with respect to a single particle. A collective nonmoving set of particles acts as a stationary object, yet within it each particle seems to be “bouncing” off of an imaginary wall creating pressure. Thus one has an impulse free particle picture yet obtains the correct result exp(-V(x)/T). Alternatively one may think of a single particle accelerating which it does if it is not colliding with other particles. This is a very different picture of the single particle than of one bouncing back and forth hitting an imaginary wall. In fact, there is usually a wall holding the gas together and pressure and bouncing particles are the real picture there, but within the gas one would normally think of a single particle accelerating. Nevertheless there are two scenarios which yield the same result. The idea of pressure balance is more in keeping with an overall statistical picture of the gas. In other words, one may actually ignore the idea of following a single particle as it accelerates. (That is not to say that single particle acceleration does not exist - it does.) Quantum mechanics we argue is a statistical theory. In the case of a single bound particle one has a momentum distribution W(x)=wavefunction = Sum over p a(p)exp(ipx). One may apply conservation of average energy at each x to obtain the time-independent Schrodinger equation. In such a picture, like with the statistical mechanical gas, we argue that one may imagine impulse hits with the potential instead of considering acceleration. The quantity vrms(x) from KEclassical= .5m vrms(x)vrms(x) = -1/2m d/dx dW/dx / W does display acceleration, but this is a mathematical average. As energy levels become higher the correspondence principle is said to apply, but a classical particle exhibits acceleration. The quantum bound state does not, but like in the case of the statistical mechanical gas it may be that two scenarios lead to the same result. In other words, the quantum bound W(x) still has crests and troughs, but with low resolution one may only see an envelope roughly touching W(x)W(x) which matches a classical C2/v(x) where v(x) is classical velocity. Given that quantum mechanics is a statistical theory it may not be necessary to have it explicitly display acceleration.
Historically statistical mechanics was developed for gasses for which there are very large numbers of molecules (i.e. on the order of 10 to 23rd power). As a result factorial schemes were developed to count the number of arrangements possible, the ln taken of this result and Stirling’s approximation for large N applied. The Shannon’s entropy form S/(-k) = Sum over i P(ei)ln(P(ei)) is consistent with this large N approach. Furthermore, large N statistical mechanics was linked to thermodynamics, in particular the first law dE=TdS - PdV. Surprisingly then, statistical mechanical results were applied to systems with small numbers of particles (e.g. a nucleus with about 100 nucleons etc). In Parts I and II we argued that the first law of thermodynamics describes two separate kinds of changes associated with energy changes. The second, work, is linked to the change of a mechanical parameter such as the volume of a box etc. The energy of a bound quantum particle in a box with an infinite potential is proportional to nn/LL. Thus we argued that a pure quantum bound state may also be associated with the first law of thermodynamics with changes in L with n, the energy level, held constant representing pure work. We further argued that for a bound state two classical like probabilities exists P(x)=W(x)W(x) and P(p)=a(p)a(p) where W(x)=wavefunction = Sum over p a(p)exp(ipx) with P(x) being proportional to 1/L and P(p) to L. For a quantum adiabatic transformation (i.e. changing L with n staying constant) the term dS=0. If one wishes to create S from P(x) and P(p) and desires linearity i.e. S=Sp(n)+Sx, then Sp=Integral dp P(p)ln(P(p)) and Sx= Integral dx P(x) ln(P(x)) is a solution. If one next considers a quantum wavefunction for two levels W(x,t) = a(1)exp(-i E1 t) W1(x) + a(2) exp(-iE2 t) W2(x) with Eave = Sum over n en P(en) where Wn=a(n)a(n), one may again utilize the first law of thermodynamics. In Parts I and II we carried over the entropy form P(ei)ln(P(ei)). In this note we wish to argue that this form follows at the two energy level picture by considerations of a function which consists entirely of probabilities i.e. P(ei) and is linear in the sense that such a function for two identical two state systems should yield S1+S2 as the first law should apply to each system. Furthermore P(ei) should be a function of P(ei/T) where T is a parameter which behaves as 1/LL because ei is proportional to 1/LL. In this way any function of P(ei) remains unchanged under a quantum adiabatic transformation for which i’s stay constant, but L changes. As a result, the entropy at the quantum level seems to follow from such arguments and not from large N approximations of factorial counting approaches. In large N situations it is argued that P(ei)=C(T)exp(-ei/T) follows from maximizing S with respect to the form of P(ei) subject to constant average energy. For small N situations (e.g. the 2 level example) one may solve Sum over i ei d(a(i)a(i)) = T dS directly without maximization. The maximization approach follows directly from dE=TdS (work=0) because dE= Sum ei dP(ei) in such scenarios. This is of the form of a Lagrange constraint This has been pointed out in Part II. In this note, we argue that the maximization of entropy is not needed at all. For dE=Sum over i ei dP(ei) and the ln form of entropy P(ei) is the inverse function of ln. Thus we argue that linearity and not large N arguments are enough to obtain Shannon’s form of entropy and that this ln form suggests P(ei/T) = C(T)exp(-ei/T) if dE=Sum over ei dP(ei)= TdS (for dW=0). Thus maximization of entropy subject to constant average energy is also not needed (although it does follow mathematically from dE=TdS.)
Newtonian mechanics deals with two types of force delivery schemes, one linked to the variable x and the other to t. They may be written as: Integral Fdt (impulse) and Integral Fdx (work) and appear to be symmetric in the two variables. The problem is that expressed in terms of dp one sees an immediate difference linked to discrete versus continuous change. In particular: dp= Fdt ((1a)) and vdp = Fdx ((1a)). ((1a)) allows for a discrete change in p in a tiny interval of time. “X” does not come into play at all in the equation and one might think of the impulse occurring at a point x. Due to the discrete nature of integral dp changes, one may think in terms of probabilities because a given pA may have been obtained from discrete impulses: p1→p2→p3 or p4+p5. etc. The final p state is the same and so not only does there exist probability but also the notion of product probabilities such that exp( pi b) exp( pj b) = exp( (pi+pj) b) where b is a constant. Given that exp(pb) increases exponentially, one might rather use the periodic probability exp(i p b). One may note how impulse type hits and their discrete momentum results lead to stochasticity in a Maxwell-Boltzmann gas. The form vdp = Fdx is very different in that it does not allow discrete jumps of p because v=dx/dt. If one assumes a very large F at x1 and dx–0 such that the product is not 0, one might consider dp changing discretely, but what is then used for v? Instead one considers a range of x with a corresponding range in t such that x(t) in order to compute v. Thus this is a deterministic situation because x and t cannot be decoupled. It leads to the notion of a kinetic energy pp/2m associated with p. This kinetic energy is calculated by considering p change from 0 to p. An interesting feature arises because impulse = Integral Fdt may be thought of as discrete allowing p1 to jump to p2. Nevertheless, the deterministic approach states there is a kinetic energy associated with p1 and p2, namely p1p1/2m, p2p2/2m, even though no deterministic path in time and space was taken. The impulse was said to occur at x in a very tiny time range. Thus there seems to be a contradiction. pp/2m requires a range of x and t with x(t). The impulse only occurs in time, with x decoupled but there must be an associated x range which is then not deterministic i.e. a decoupled x range. This suggests a characteristic length associated with a momentum p in which one does not follow time deterministically. If one does not follow x in t in this special length, then one has a probability distribution. A similar argument occurs for time. Consider Fdx with time absent. If dx becomes very tiny and F(x) very large , one may think that work is done at an instant in time, but there must be a time range for pp/2m. Thus there is a special time period not associated with x in which one has probabilistic behaviour i.e. not x(t). One may note from the notion of impulse that a given p may be obtained through different series of smaller impulses, e.g. {p1,p2,p3} and {p4,p5}. These are associated with kinetic energy series {p1p1/2m, p2p2/2m,p3p3/2m} and {p4p4/2m, p5p5/2m}. The final result is the same. Thus the discrete nature of changes leads to a probability scheme such that P(p1)P(p2) = P(p1+p2) and P(e1)P(e2)=P(e1+e2). This we argue leads to: P(p) = exp(i p b1) and P(e) = exp(i e b2) where b1 and b2 at first seem to be constant. We noted, however, that an impulse implies a probabilistic range in x and Fdx→finite when dx→0 a probabilistic range in t. Thus b1 may be replaced with x and b2 with t. At any given point in time or space, x and t are constants i.e. b1 and b2. Next, we consider the situation of special relativity i.e. a Lorentz boost. We consider an initial state of energy= mo, x=0, t=to and view it from a frame moving at a constant velocity v. Although one may use infinitesimal velocities, a main point we wish to make is that special relativity allows for the use of finite velocities which give the sense of discrete changes like in the impulse case.This should again be associated with probabilities. Special relativity yields the Lorentz invariant A = -Et+px where v=x/t. Nevertheless, x and t are written in the invariant as if they were independent. It may be noted that dA=0 if t changes on its own as hbar/E and x on its own as hbar/p. Thus one may obtain specific x and t probability ranges.This is again consistent with the probabilistic picture or exp(-iEt) and exp(-ipx). It may be noted that even with the probabilistic picture, a particle with constant p moves determinisitcally on average as x= p/m t. If x = hbar/p, then 1/t is not hbar/E and if t=hbar/E then x is not hbar/p. Thus the values hbar/E and hbar/p seem not to be linked with the current deterministic motion, but rather with the creation of p in the first place. E=pp/2m and this is obtained by considering p changing from 0 to p. Thus the “frequency” E seems to capture the information of the creation of p and we argue that the wavelength captures the creation of x as a probability distribution in x which one would usually associate with force/acceleration.
In Part 1, we considered Newtonian elastic scattering and proposed a probability exp(-iEt+ip dot r) to allow for equal product probability weights for any (ei, ej) (energy) and (pi, pj) (momentum vector) outcome pair. We insisted on the probability being a Lorentz scalar and argued that all free particles have the same real value weight, hence the modulus of 1. This notion is based on probability as it is applied to possible outcomes. This means that one does not have a fully deterministic situation because otherwise one would know the exact ei,ej, pi,pj outcome and would not require probabilities in the first place. In Part 2, we argued that a deterministic approach based on x=vt for a free particle contains no notion of probability and so this seems to contradict exp(-iEt+ipx) with its physical intervals: delta t = hbar/E and delta x = hbar/p. We then noted that these intervals and hence probability are found in the Action= Lagrangian * t = -Et+px with v=x/t. We concluded that x=vt, a solution of d/dt dL/dv partial - dL/dv = 0 loses some of the information present and that examining the action reveals more information because one is forced to deal with x,t, E and p at the same time. Here, we return to Newtonian elastic two-body scattering and assume that one has the following deterministic case: e1,e2, p1, p2 → e3,e4, p3,p4. One would then assume that no probability of any kind is present. We suggest that momentum is conserved due to action-reaction, something that Newton already proposed without any notion of probability required. Energy is conserved because it cannot be ultimately created or destroyed and we consider special elastic collisions. We then consider the Newtonian idea of a particle being acted upon by a force -dV(x)/dx, where V(x) is a potential. The interaction occurs for a dt, dx, but Newtonian physics assumes that dx→0, dt→0. Thus, Newtonian mechanics allows for a minimum dx->0 for conservation of momentum. By going into the center-of-mass frame of two particles which collide elastically, one has p and -p in this frame. When the two particles come together at x,t, for a tiny time one has a joint particle with no net momentum which is interacting and breaking apart. Then, in the 1D case, one particle moves out with p1 and the other with -p1 in the cm-frame. If one considers A= -Et+px for one particle, then Newton’s dt->0, dx->0 as well as x=0, t=0 yield A=0. It is known from special relativity, however, that there is a jump in x for a particle viewed from a moving frame. In particular, if the particle is at x=0 at t in the rest frame (cm frame), then in the moving frame: x’ = g(v) v t where g(v)=1/sqrt(1-vv/cc).This is linked to the person in the moving frame (-v) measuring the particle which seems to move to him/her. This measurement takes some minimum amount of time. Thus, it seems that one must reject dx→0 on the grounds of special relativity. The question then becomes: What is the smallest dx and dt one may have based on special relativity? We suggest that given the A=0 case, one may have delta x =hbar/p and delta t = hbar/E. Even in a deterministic elastic interaction, the notion that dt and dx cannot be 0 leads to minimal values for these which are probabilistic, i.e. they are based on special relativity and not on the actual interaction. If one has initial uncertainty in x and t, even if the particle then moves with x=vt, this uncertainty should also be propagated along as well, because the dx, dt uncertainty cannot simply vanish. We suggest that the notion of exp(-iEt+ipx) emerges even if one removes the initial probabilistic assumption of elastic scattering with unknown outcomes. Known outcomes still lead to uncertain dx=hbar/p and dt =hbar/E in keeping with the uncertainty contained in Lt= -Et+px, which is used for deterministic calculations. Thus, it is special relativity which places a constraint on how small dx and dt may be in a physical reaction and one cannot simply use the Newtonian dx→0, dt→0.
Newtonian mechanics focuses on dx and dt units which tend to zero and so presents, it seems, a smoothed over or averaged type of motion. This motion in principle extends to dx and dt values which are almost zero. There is, however, a priori no reason not to expect that such a smooth averaging is at some length scale based on another kind of motion. The question is: What should that “other” kind of motion be? If it is deterministic in x and t, one may reapply the idea of this motion breaking down at yet some smaller scale. Thus it seems one should consider decoupling of x and t because one cannot follow a particle from one x point to another in time within some small length scale as this would be deterministic. The opposite approach seems to be a probabilistic one with t and x decoupled. The external ruler and clock which exist in the Newtonian picture, however, do not disappear simply because a length scale is small. Thus having x positions based on probabilities at some length scale still uses the notion of the probability itself being smoothed over because it contains x which may take on any value. This is not necessarily a problem because the probabilistic behaviour must still appear to be Newtonian on average and so x and t based on the external clock/ruler with infinite resolution need to “appear” again. (For example, an electron has a wavelength and exhibits interference from two slits, but while moving towards the slits, distance = velocity* time with distance and time measured by an external clock. It is a mathematical generalization, however, to expect that d=vt actually fully describes motion (i.e. other than on average) within a wavelength length. If it did there would be no interference pattern. The idea of a smoothed over (or averaged motion) based on probabilistic motion also appears in the classical world, but for many particles. For example, a Maxwell-Boltzmann gas with no potential has uniform density. If one considers a hypothetical box containing many molecules, it is like a Newtonian stationary object with a balance of pressure. In the case of a potential (1-D) one may consider a dx unit (with many molecules) and balance Force(x) density(x) with the difference of pressure to find the density distribution proportional to exp(- V(x)/T). These ideas are completely Newtonian, but they are smoothed over average notions. At a microscopic level molecules undergo probabilistic collisions linked to T (temperature). Thus the microscopic picture is not static - it is only the equilibrium average or big picture which is static. Even in the case of no potential, focusing on a tiny region of space smaller than the interparticle average separation and arguing that density is constant seems to be an average argument which bypasses much of the reality. If x and t may then become probabilistic and -Et+px is a Lorentz invariant, then why should there not be stochasticity linked with E and p? In fact we argue they are == as shown by Maxwell’s solution of a photon from his electromagnetic equations. E and p (energy and momentum) are average values. Their density is given by: .5C1( Electric field dot Electric field + C2 Magnetic field dot Magnetic field) and the Poynting vector for momentum. Both the Electric field and Magnetic field fluctuate as cos(-Et+px) with E and p being average values. At first this was ascribed to wave motion in a medium, but in 1905 Einstein’s photoelectric arguments against energy being spread out seem to suggest a breakdown of deterministic physics describing a wave in a medium. Instead a photon is probabilistic and has a wavefunction of Electric + i Magnetic field. (2)
In Part 1, we argued that P(x)dx=dx/L (where L is an arbitrary length) applies to a particle at rest. If one views such a particle from a frame moving at constant -v, it is moving. We argued that in such a case, the relevant probability is not simply linked to the position x, but also to the momentum p at x because this delivers an impulse hit. In particular, probability is presumably to be used in a physical problem with interactions and probability and a dynamical particle requires a dynamical probability describing both x,t and E,p. This led to exp(-iEt+px) which actually predicts intervals in space hbar/p and time hbar/E. In other words, a probabilistic view point leads to these results. Here, we ask the question: What if one simply wishes to use deterministic physics to describe a moving particle? After all, Newtonian mechanics is deterministic and one does not really need to focus on P(x)=1/L or its modification for a moving particle. In such a case, a particle moving with constant v (starting at x=0, t=0) is described by x/t=v both in Newtonian mechanics and special relativity. There is no uncertainty in x and t here which begs the question: Why does it appear in the probabilistic formalism of Part 1? In particular, exp(-iEt+ipx) derived in Part 1 implies physical regions: dx = hbar/p and dt=hbar/E and these seem to be absent in x/t=v and this is a problem. We suggest that a probabilistic approach is buried in the Lagrangian formalism which leads to the result d/dt v = 0, i.e describes the particle’s motion in space. This motion is actually x/t=v, but this equation only presents a subset of the description of a particle that is moving with constant speed, even in a deterministic Lagrangian/Action approach. We have already pointed this out in (1). We briefly explain it again here, but the real question is why does one need to consider the Lagrangian in order to describe x/t=v? In other words, the probabilistic approach associated with v=x/t only emerges in the Lagrangian formalism using a relativistic action Lt = -Et+px, with x/t=v. Ignoring the action and Lagrangian leads to an absence of hbar/p and hbar/E and one is only concerned with x/t=v. We note that the Lagrangian is primarily linked to the result: p = dL/dv partial and so argue that one is not simply interested in motion (x/t=v), but also in interaction because p is associated with an impulse hit. Thus, the Lagrangian approach is more than simply a mechanism which describes x,t motion, it is associated with p and E (through Hamiltonian = E = pv-L.) Using the Lagrangian approach suggests that it does not suffice to consider x and t by themselves when p and E are present. One must consider all four variables x,t,E,p which is the same point made in Part 1. The physics of the problem dictates that it is not enough to simply think in terms of x,t,v. The Lagrangian approach, which is constructed to ultimately yield x/t=v, when written in terms of E, p, i.e. Lt = -Et+px demonstrates uncertainty in x, hbar/p and t, hbar/E as shown in (1). This uncertainty must then be written in terms of a probability which is Lorentz invariant and leads to exp(-iEt+ipx). The point is that one would not even consider a probability if one did not consider E,p and x,t together as a complete treatment of a moving particle. In other words, x/t=v is an incomplete description of the state of a particle moving with constant speed, even in a deterministic framework.. At first this might seem surprising, but it is well known that energy and p are linked to interactions. In special relativity, one does not consider x,t,v alone and then compute p and E from these, but considers four vectors and Lorentz invariant equations. It is possible to create a Lorentz invariant equation involving all four state variables x,t,E,p and it turns out that this is the relativistic Lagrangian which describes motion, so this approach is more general than simply stating x/t=v. Thus, delta x = hbar/p and delta t= hbar/E appear in both the probabilistic approach of Part 1 and the deterministic one of the Lagrangian used here.