Quantum-chaotic systems share the same coarse-grained features characteristic of random matrices, such as Wigner-Dyson level-spacing statistics, yet can exhibit strikingly different eigenstate structure and many-body dynamics, including relaxation, transport, scrambling, and entanglement growth. This raises the fundamental question of whether these finer-grained features probe genuinely distinct aspects of quantum chaos or, instead, reflect different manifestations of a common underlying structure---and whether such structure provides a meaningful basis for regarding one many-body quantum system as "more chaotic" than another. Here, we address this question by introducing a quantum geometric framework that quantifies the susceptibility of many-body eigenstates to physically allowed deformations of the Hamiltonian, as constrained by spatial locality, symmetries, and conservation laws. The resulting geometric susceptibility is quantitative, providing a metric of chaos beyond traditional binary diagnostics; intrinsic, as it depends on the manifold of allowed Hamiltonian deformations rather than on the way the system is probed; and unifying, as it directly connects eigenstate structure with dynamics. For canonical models of quantum chaos, we find that minimal geometric susceptibility, maximal eigenstate randomness, broad spectral response of local operators, and the suppression of nonhydrodynamic slow structure coalesce in the same region of Hamiltonian control space. This suggests that these seemingly distinct signatures of chaos are different manifestations of a common underlying geometric structure. Our framework provides a route toward understanding the limits of relaxation and scrambling under physical constraints; in applications, it offers a means to engineer strongly chaotic regimes in programmable quantum systems with restricted controls.
Quantum-chaotic systems share the same coarse-grained features characteristic of random matrices, such as Wigner-Dyson level-spacing statistics, yet can exhibit strikingly different eigenstate structure and many-body dynamics, including relaxation, transport, scrambling, and entanglement growth. This raises the fundamental question of whether these finer-grained features probe genuinely distinct aspects of quantum chaos or, instead, reflect different manifestations of a common underlying structure---and whether such structure provides a meaningful basis for regarding one many-body quantum system as "more chaotic" than another. Here, we address this question by introducing a quantum geometric framework that quantifies the susceptibility of many-body eigenstates to physically allowed deformations of the Hamiltonian, as constrained by spatial locality, symmetries, and conservation laws. The resulting geometric susceptibility is quantitative, providing a metric of chaos beyond traditional binary diagnostics; intrinsic, as it depends on the manifold of allowed Hamiltonian deformations rather than on the way the system is probed; and unifying, as it directly connects eigenstate structure with dynamics. For canonical models of quantum chaos, we find that minimal geometric susceptibility, maximal eigenstate randomness, broad spectral response of local operators, and the suppression of nonhydrodynamic slow structure coalesce in the same region of Hamiltonian control space. This suggests that these seemingly distinct signatures of chaos are different manifestations of a common underlying geometric structure. Our framework provides a route toward understanding the limits of relaxation and scrambling under physical constraints; in applications, it offers a means to engineer strongly chaotic regimes in programmable quantum systems with restricted controls.
A characteristic feature of “quantum chaotic” systems is that their eigenspectra and eigenstates display universal statistical properties described by random matrix theory (RMT). However, eigenstates of local systems also encode structure beyond RMT. To capture this feature, we introduce a framework that allows us to compare the properties of eigenstates in local systems with those of pure random states. In particular, our framework defines a notion of distance between quantum state ensembles that utilizes the Kullback-Leibler divergence to compare the microcanonical distribution of entanglement entropy (EE) of eigenstates with a reference RMT distribution generated by pure random states (with appropriate constraints). This notion gives rise to a quantitative metric for quantum chaos that not only accounts for averages of the distributions but also higher moments. The differences in moments are compared on a highly resolved scale set by the standard deviation of the RMT distribution, which is exponentially small in system size. As a result, the metric can distinguish between chaotic and integrable behaviors and, in addition, quantify and compare the of chaos (in terms of proximity to RMT behavior) between two systems that are assumed to be chaotic. We implement our framework in local, minimally structured, Floquet random circuits, as well as a canonical family of many-body Hamiltonians, the mixed-field Ising model (MFIM). Importantly, for Hamiltonian systems, we find that the reference random distribution must be appropriately constrained to incorporate the effect of energy conservation in order to describe the ensemble properties of midspectrum eigenstates. The metric captures deviations from RMT across all models and parameters, including those that have been previously identified as strongly chaotic, and for which other diagnostics of chaos such as level spacing statistics look strongly thermal. In Floquet circuits, the dominant source of deviations is the second moment of the distribution, and this persists for all system sizes. For the MFIM, we find significant variation of the KL divergence in parameter space. Notably, we find a small region where deviations from RMT are minimized, suggesting that “maximally chaotic” Hamiltonians may exist in fine-tuned pockets of parameter space. Published by the American Physical Society 2024
Our current understanding of quantum chaos in many-body quantum systems hinges on the random matrix theory (RMT) behavior of eigenstates and their energy level statistics. Although RMT has been remarkably successful in describing "coarse" features of many-body quantum Hamiltonians in chaotic regimes, such as the Wigner-Dyson level spacing statistics or the volume-law behavior of eigenstate entanglement entropy, it remains a challenge to describe their "finer" features, particularly those arising from spatial locality. Here, we show that we can accurately describe the statistical behavior of eigenstate ensembles in many-body Hamiltonians by using pure random states with physical constraints that capture the essential features of the Hamiltonian, specifically spatial locality and symmetries. We demonstrate our approach on local spin Hamiltonians with a scalar U(1) charge. By constructing ensembles of constrained random states that account for two commuting scalar charges playing the role of energy and magnetization, we describe the patterns of entanglement of midspectrum eigenstates beyond their average volume-law behavior, including O(1) corrections and fluctuations, analytically and numerically. When defining the correspondence between quantum chaotic eigenstates in many-body Hamiltonians and RMT ensembles, our work highlights the important role played by spatial locality in describing universal features beyond the volume-law behavior.
Quantum chaos concerns the emergence of universal statistical and dynamical prop- erties in quantum systems whose classical counterparts exhibit chaotic behavior. Unlike classical chaos, which can be characterized by sensitivity to initial conditions and exponential divergence of trajectories, quantum chaos manifests itself through a variety of indirect diagnostics, including spectral correlations, operator growth, and information scrambling. Understanding how these signatures arise from microscopic dynamics, and how they can be accessed in realistic many-body systems, is a central challenge in modern physics. This thesis investigates quantum chaos from complementary theoretical and practical perspectives. On the theoretical side, it develops effective descriptions of chaotic dy- namics in many-body systems with approximate symmetries, focusing on how weak symmetry breaking controls the exploration of Hilbert space and the crossover to random-matrix universality. Using perturbative arguments, numerical simulations, and a nonlinear sigma-model formulation, we identify a regime of Hilbert-space dif- fusion in which chaotic dynamics unfolds through a slow, collective spreading across nearly decoupled symmetry sectors. On the practical side, the thesis addresses the question of how paradigmatic chaotic models can be realized and probed in controlled experimental platforms. In partic- ular, it explores quantum simulation schemes for Sachdev–Ye–Kitaev (SYK) models using cavity quantum electrodynamics. By employing time-dependent disorder and Trotterized evolution in single-mode optical cavities, we demonstrate how low-rank interactions can be systematically promoted to effective all-to-all randomness, re- producing the spectral and dynamical signatures of SYK physics. Extensions to open-system dynamics are discussed, including Lindbladian realizations and the role of dissipation. The thesis thus highlights the connections between effective descriptions of quantum chaos and their implementation in controlled quantum simulation settings.
Abstract We present a unified formalism which identifies chaos in both quantum and classical systems in an equivalent manner by means of adiabatic transformations . The complexity of adiabatic transformations which preserve classical time-averaged trajectories (quantum eigenstates) in response to Hamiltonian deformations serves as a measure of chaos. This complexity is quantified by the (properly regularized) fidelity susceptibility or, more generally, by the geometric tensor. Physically this measure quantifies (i) long time instabilities of physical observables due to small changes in the Hamiltonian of the system and (ii) irregularity of physical observables contained in low frequency noise. Our exposition clearly showcases the common structures underlying quantum and classical chaos and allows us to distinguish integrable, chaotic but non-thermalizing, and ergodic/mixing regimes. We apply the fidelity susceptibility to a model of two coupled spins and demonstrate that it successfully predicts the universal onset of chaos, both for finite spin S and in the classical limit S → ∞ . Interestingly, we find that finite S effects are anomalously large close to integrability.
At the heart of physics lies the human fascination with natural phenomena and the wish to understand the underlying principles. A well-known example is the butterfly effect. It describes how small changes in the initial state can cause significantly different measurement outcomes at later times. Such sensitivity to initial conditions is a key signature of chaotic systems and reflects their instability under small perturbations. The principle underlying this phenomenon is information spreading: with time, information about the perturbation propagates through the system, changing measurement results even at distant locations. In quantum systems, information not only spreads but can also scramble, meaning that the precise details about the perturbation are hidden in highly nonlocal correlations. Information scrambling has emerged as a universal feature of quantum chaos and, together with other universal features, serves as an organizing principle for quantum systems. This motivates imposing structure like locality on quantum systems in order to probe the capabilities and limits of such organizing principles. There have been significant advances in both theoretical and experimental directions in recent years. The newly gained flexibility in designing experiments and simulations also inspires the analytical study of quantum systems from the bottom up, where tractable models offer insights into the generic features of quantum mechanics. In this thesis we build upon these advances to explore the implications of adding structure to chaotic quantum systems for the behavior of such features. In particular, we consider the measures entanglement entropy and Krylov complexity as probes of structure. These quantities are closely connected to information spreading. This motivates us to study the influence of structure on information spreading in the second part. In the first part, we begin with a detailed discussion of the behavior of entanglement in chaotic systems. We impose a minimal amount of local structure by separating the system into two parts, each modeled as a single spin. We validate the predicted entanglement for typical states in such systems and show that it saturates the Page limit as the Hilbert space dimension increases. We then study how different initially unentangled product states approach the Page limit under time evolution. We consider three types of product states, each representing a distinct case. Random product states represent generic states only restricted by the absence of entanglement. Random dipole and quadrupolar states represent two distinct types of semi-classical structure. The results on the entanglement generation in the three different types of states refine our earlier conclusion, demonstrating that the semi-classical limit can suppress the generation of extensive entanglement. This suppression does not occur for random product or quadrupolar states; where the imposed structure is insufficient. We conclude the second chapter by presenting two protocols that can stabilize the dynamics at finite spin sizes, similar to the semi-classical limit. In the following chapter, we move from measuring the complexity of time-evolved states using entanglement entropy to investigating time-evolved operators through the lens of Krylov complexity. After a short introduction to Krylov complexity for Hamiltonian dynamics, we generalize the framework for discrete time evolution. We identify the linear growth of Krylov complexity as a universal feature of generic systems and analyze its behavior as we transition from chaotic to increasingly structured systems. Dual-unitary circuits converge toward this universal behavior at rates that can be as fast as exponential, consistent with their classification as maximally chaotic. We then approximately restore energy conservation by considering trotterized systems, ranging from unstructured and chaotic to highly structured and integrable ones. We find these systems to thermalize on a scale set by the trotterization step, slowly approaching the universal linear Krylov complexity growth regime. Approaching the linear growth regime is a fundamental property of trotterized systems with an unbounded spectrum, while systems with a bounded energy spectrum can evade thermalization as probed by Krylov complexity. Instead, they have a nonanalytic transition as the Trotter step size increases. Our study of Krylov complexity establishes its universal properties for discrete time evolution. The presented results deepen our understanding of the thermalizing behavior of different classes of systems in relation to their spectral properties by introducing an intuitive notion of a bath with chaotic characteristics. We link this thermalization behavior to information spreading, which we explore in the second part of this thesis. Information scrambling, along with the associated spreading, is a key phenomenon in chaotic systems with local structure. In the fourth chapter, we investigate information spreading in proximity to an integrable system exhibiting spontaneous symmetry breaking, the transverse field Ising model (TFIM). As expected, integrability prevents the scrambling of information. At the same time, information spreading probed by quenched out-of-time ordered correlators (OTOCs) exhibits features reminiscent of the quantum phase transition present in the TFIM. We unravel the intricate behavior of these OTOCs and identify the underlying mechanism that stabilizes the long-time values of OTOCs: dynamical relocalization. We provide two variations of the TFIM in which the relocalization phenomenon is not directly related to the presence of a quantum phase transition. This shows that no direct, universal relation exists between the two. Finally, we discuss the effects of breaking the integrable structure of the TFIM. Our results show that for short times, chaotic systems in proximity of integrability can retain signatures of integrability. In contrast, we observe significant changes at large times. This suggests that information scrambling, as a universal feature of chaotic systems, is restored at large times—even in systems near integrability that exhibit order. Following the analysis of information spreading close to integrable regimes, we study the stability of information spreading in more generic systems. First, we consider charge-conserving random circuits. In these systems, charge-charge correlators exhibit large fluctuations across different circuit instances with a slow polynomial decay in time. At the same time, they remain stable against fine-tuned perturbations, which can be interpreted as dephasing noise in the eigenbasis of the charge density operators. Equivalently, charge-charge correlators are mostly insensitive to decoherence, with interference effects contributing only subleading corrections. In this sense, the charge information spreading probed by charge-charge correlators is effectively classical. We perform a detailed analysis and quantify the dephasing insensitivity of these correlators. This suggests that circuit-to-circuit fluctuations can be captured by considering small regions where “quantum” effects are included, embedded within otherwise “classical” dynamics. This observation motivates the development of an algorithm to compute charge-charge correlators for individual circuits on classical computers with high accuracy. We quantitatively relate the algorithm’s performance to the dephasing analysis. We demonstrate the algorithm’s accuracy numerically for charge-charge correlators. Then, we argue that in generic circuits without conservation laws, the information spreading, as probed by OTOCs, follows similar principles. We conclude by comparing OTOC values measured on quantum devices with up to 95 superconducting qubits and 1000 gates to predictions from the approximate algorithm. This cross-validates experimental measurements and theoretical predictions. In this thesis, we explore the implications of adding structure to chaotic quantum systems, contributing to a deeper understanding of the organizing principles governing quantum chaos. We establish that entanglement can be suppressed in the semiclassical limit and that Krylov complexity behaves differently in thermalizing or integrable time-dependent systems. We show that the phenomenon information scrambling is also present in chaotic quantum systems even in the vicinity of a quantum phase transition. Conversely, when charge conservation is added, information spreading is stabilized and becomes reminiscent of that in classical systems. This work opens up further research directions towards a better understanding of the quantum nature of chaotic quantum systems and the development of probes of chaos in time dependent systems with different types of structure.
Entanglement entropy is a fundamental diagnostic for quantum chaos, typically exhibiting volume-law scaling in highly excited eigenstates of chaotic many-body systems. In this work, we present a striking counterexample: a Floquet-driven quantum many-body system with a Rydberg-like blockade that, despite being fully chaotic as indicated by its Wigner-Dyson level statistics and local thermalization, exhibits a strict area-law entanglement entropy. Specifically, the entanglement entropy of every Floquet eigenstate is bounded by ln2, independent of system size. We trace this anomaly to the specific Hilbert space structure imposed by the blockades, which restricts the Schmidt rank across a bipartition. Furthermore, we generalize this discovery by establishing a duality between constrained many-body Hamiltonians and single-particle quantum walks on median graphs, and we outline a general procedure for constructing systems with an entanglement entropy bounded by a predetermined constant. Our results demonstrate that entanglement entropy alone is an insufficient diagnostic of many-body quantum chaos and highlight the profound impact of Hilbert space geometry on quantum dynamics and thermalization.