Abstract We present a unified formalism which identifies chaos in both quantum and classical systems in an equivalent manner by means of adiabatic transformations . The complexity of adiabatic transformations which preserve classical time-averaged trajectories (quantum eigenstates) in response to Hamiltonian deformations serves as a measure of chaos. This complexity is quantified by the (properly regularized) fidelity susceptibility or, more generally, by the geometric tensor. Physically this measure quantifies (i) long time instabilities of physical observables due to small changes in the Hamiltonian of the system and (ii) irregularity of physical observables contained in low frequency noise. Our exposition clearly showcases the common structures underlying quantum and classical chaos and allows us to distinguish integrable, chaotic but non-thermalizing, and ergodic/mixing regimes. We apply the fidelity susceptibility to a model of two coupled spins and demonstrate that it successfully predicts the universal onset of chaos, both for finite spin S and in the classical limit S → ∞ . Interestingly, we find that finite S effects are anomalously large close to integrability.
Abstract We present a unified formalism which identifies chaos in both quantum and classical systems in an equivalent manner by means of adiabatic transformations . The complexity of adiabatic transformations which preserve classical time-averaged trajectories (quantum eigenstates) in response to Hamiltonian deformations serves as a measure of chaos. This complexity is quantified by the (properly regularized) fidelity susceptibility or, more generally, by the geometric tensor. Physically this measure quantifies (i) long time instabilities of physical observables due to small changes in the Hamiltonian of the system and (ii) irregularity of physical observables contained in low frequency noise. Our exposition clearly showcases the common structures underlying quantum and classical chaos and allows us to distinguish integrable, chaotic but non-thermalizing, and ergodic/mixing regimes. We apply the fidelity susceptibility to a model of two coupled spins and demonstrate that it successfully predicts the universal onset of chaos, both for finite spin S and in the classical limit S → ∞ . Interestingly, we find that finite S effects are anomalously large close to integrability.
The study of non-equilibrium dynamics is central to understanding how macroscopic irreversibility and thermal behavior emerge from microscopic reversible dynamics. A quintessential phenomenon that commonly occurs in non-equilibrium dynamics is the emergence of chaos. Chaos, whose theory originates from classical dynamics, is traditionally understood through a system's exponential sensitivity to initial conditions through microscopic dynamics. However, this definition does not fully capture classical and quantum many-body systems. This dissertation establishes and explores adiabatic transformations as a unifying framework for understanding chaos, integrability, and thermalization across both regimes. First, we show that the complexity of adiabatic transformations, which preserve classical time-averaged trajectories and quantum eigenstates under Hamiltonian deformations, serves as a measure of chaos. Physically, this measure quantifies the response of observables through their long-time instabilities and irregularities as manifested by their low-frequency noise. The applications of adiabatic transformations go beyond serving as a diagnostic of chaos, as they can be used to obtain a deeper understanding of the nature of chaos: a theme that drives the rest of this dissertation. Second, we uncover the geometric structure of integrability and chaos. By constructing adiabatic flows that minimize eigenstate deformations in quantum many-body systems parameterized by two independent couplings, we reveal that integrability acts as an attractor of these flows. This provides an a priori method for identifying integrable regions in complex many-body systems. Third, we investigate the timescales of thermalization and chaos in many-spin systems by studying the response of observables. We uncover a novel phenomenon, denoted as deconfined chaos, in the central spin model with XX interactions, where chaotic instabilities and thermalization occur on the same timescale. Fourth, we establish a correspondence between temperature and integrability-breaking perturbation for both classical and quantum many-spin systems. Therefore, we demonstrate that chaos is not determined solely by microscopic terms but can be renormalized by macroscopic thermodynamic temperature.
In the past decades, it was recognized that quantum chaos, which is essential for the emergence of statistical mechanics and thermodynamics, manifests itself in the effective description of the eigenstates of chaotic Hamiltonians through random matrix ensembles and the eigenstate thermalization hypothesis.Standard measures of chaos in quantum many-body systems are level statistics and the spectral form factor.In this work, we show that the norm of the adiabatic gauge potential, the generator of adiabatic deformations between eigenstates, serves as a much more sensitive measure of quantum chaos.We are able to detect transitions from integrable to chaotic behavior at perturbation strengths orders of magnitude smaller than those required for standard measures.Using this alternative probe in two generic classes of spin chains, we show that the chaotic threshold decreases exponentially with system size and that one can immediately detect integrability-breaking (chaotic) perturbations by analyzing infinitesimal perturbations even at the integrable point.In some cases, small integrability breaking is shown to lead to anomalously slow relaxation of the system, exponentially long in system size.
Quantum-chaotic systems share the same coarse-grained features characteristic of random matrices, such as Wigner-Dyson level-spacing statistics, yet can exhibit strikingly different eigenstate structure and many-body dynamics, including relaxation, transport, scrambling, and entanglement growth. This raises the fundamental question of whether these finer-grained features probe genuinely distinct aspects of quantum chaos or, instead, reflect different manifestations of a common underlying structure---and whether such structure provides a meaningful basis for regarding one many-body quantum system as "more chaotic" than another. Here, we address this question by introducing a quantum geometric framework that quantifies the susceptibility of many-body eigenstates to physically allowed deformations of the Hamiltonian, as constrained by spatial locality, symmetries, and conservation laws. The resulting geometric susceptibility is quantitative, providing a metric of chaos beyond traditional binary diagnostics; intrinsic, as it depends on the manifold of allowed Hamiltonian deformations rather than on the way the system is probed; and unifying, as it directly connects eigenstate structure with dynamics. For canonical models of quantum chaos, we find that minimal geometric susceptibility, maximal eigenstate randomness, broad spectral response of local operators, and the suppression of nonhydrodynamic slow structure coalesce in the same region of Hamiltonian control space. This suggests that these seemingly distinct signatures of chaos are different manifestations of a common underlying geometric structure. Our framework provides a route toward understanding the limits of relaxation and scrambling under physical constraints; in applications, it offers a means to engineer strongly chaotic regimes in programmable quantum systems with restricted controls.
We define quantum chaos and integrability in open quantum many-body systems as a dynamical property of single stochastic realizations, referred to as quantum trajectories. This definition relies on the predictions of random matrix theory applied to the subset of the Liouvillian eigenspectrum involved in each quantum trajectory. Our approach, which we name (SSQT), enables a natural distinction between transient and steady-state quantum chaos as general phenomena in open setups. We test the generality and reliability of the SSQT criterion on several dissipative systems, further showing that an open system with a chaotic structure can evolve towards either a chaotic or integrable steady state. We apply our theoretical framework to two driven-dissipative bosonic systems. First, we study the driven-dissipative Bose-Hubbard model, a paradigmatic example of a quantum simulator, clarifying the interplay of integrability, transient, and steady-state chaos across its phase diagram. Our analysis shows the existence of an emergent dissipative quantum chaotic phase, whereas the classical and semiclassical limits display an integrable behavior. In this regime, chaos arises from the quantum and classical fluctuations associated with the dissipation mechanisms. Second, we investigate dissipative quantum chaos in the dispersive readout of a transmon qubit: a measurement technique ubiquitous in superconducting-based quantum hardware. Through the SSQT, we distinguish several regimes where the performance of the measurement instrument can be connected to the integrable or chaotic nature of the underlying driven-dissipative bosonic system. Our work offers a general understanding of the integrable and chaotic dynamics of open quantum systems and paves the way for the investigation of dissipative quantum chaos and its consequences on state-of-the-art noisy intermediate-scale quantum devices.
Developing measures of quantum ergodicity and chaos stands as a foundational task in the study of quantum many-body systems. In this work, we propose metrics for these effects based on Hamiltonian learning that unify multiple advantages of existing metrics. In particular, we show how ergodicity and chaos improve the robustness of Hamiltonian learning to small errors and furthermore demonstrate that this robustness can be used as a metric for such phenomena. We analytically and numerically show that our metrics not only distinguish between integrable and ergodic regimes in various spin chains but also quantify chaos and ergodicity, allowing us to locate regions of parameter space displaying maximal ergodicity and maximal sensitivity to local perturbations. Our approach not only provides conceptual ways to study quantum chaos and ergodicity but also presents viable experimental methods for quantum simulators.
We show that the onset of quantum chaos at infinite temperature in two many-body one-dimensional lattice models, the perturbed spin-1/2 XXZ and Anderson models, is characterized by universal behavior. Specifically, we show that the onset of quantum chaos is marked by maxima of the typical fidelity susceptibilities that scale with the square of the inverse average level spacing, saturating their upper bound, and that the strength of the integrability- or localization-breaking perturbation at these maxima decreases with increasing system size. We also show that the spectral function below the ``Thouless'' energy (in the quantum-chaotic regime) diverges when approaching those maxima. Our results suggest that, in the thermodynamic limit, arbitrarily small integrability- or localization-breaking perturbations result in quantum chaos in the many-body quantum systems studied here.