Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2610.32908

Nonclassicality from Incomplete Fock-State Statistics

Martin Žonda, Pavel Baláž, Lukáš Lachman, Darren W. Moore, Tomáš Novotný, Radim Filip

quant-phphysics.opticsSubmitted Oct 23, 2026• Announced Oct 26, 2026• 0 citations• Revised Oct 30, 2026 (v2)
v1 · Oct 23, 2026v2 · Oct 30, 2026
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Nonclassicality in bosonic systems can be certified directly from occupation probabilities without full state reconstruction. To complete a library of such criteria we introduce a numerical framework that constructs optimal linear nonclassicality witnesses from arbitrary subsets of measured occupation probabilities by solving a semi-infinite linear program. The method contains known analytical criteria as special cases while generally detecting substantially larger nonclassical regions. We provide an open-source implementation of the numerical optimization together with the analytical criteria discussed here, enabling direct application of the framework to measured occupation statistics across bosonic platforms. As a case study, we apply it to the resonant Jaynes--Cummings model with thermal states and reveal nonclassicality at short interaction times and close to thermal balance, where detection of nonclassicality is otherwise challenging.

AI Summary

Based on v1

The paper asks how much bosonic nonclassicality can be certified from an arbitrary finite subset of Fock-state probabilities, without tomography. Classical counting statistics are mixtures of Poisson distributions $p_k(\mu)=e^{-\mu}\mu^k/k!$. It optimizes linear witnesses $\lambda\cdot P-\sup_{\mu\geq0}\lambda\cdot p(\mu)>0$, with $|\lambda_i|\leq1$ fixing normalization. This tests incompatibility with classical counting statistics, rather than detecting nonclassicality invisible to number measurements. The optimization is formulated as a semi-infinite linear program and solved by an exchange procedure: solve a finite linear program, find the most violated Poisson constraint, and add it until a numerical tolerance is reached. The required global maximization reduces to evaluating a polynomial’s nonnegative stationary roots and the domain endpoints. An open-source Python implementation includes this procedure and the analytical criteria used for comparison. Comparisons with Klyshko-type, majorization, and counting-matrix criteria find additional detectable regions, including for sparse probability subsets where those analytical tests are unavailable. No discrepancy is found for $(P_0,P_n)$ or $(P_0,P_1,P_2)$; improvements appear with four consecutive probabilities. For resonant Jaynes–Cummings evolution from thermal oscillator and qubit states, numerical tests extend detection toward shorter interaction times and thermal balance, $\bar n=p_e/(1-2p_e)$. At $p_e=0.40$, ten consecutive probabilities improve on counting-matrix detection near $\bar n=2$. Numerical comparisons and independent characteristic-function checks indicate exponential narrowing of the undetected interval with interaction time. Exact balance remains classical. The paper reports increasing numerical instability when many probabilities are needed, motivating complementary analytical tests.

Little sign of AI-generated text

Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.

Comments
Main text: 7 pages, 5 figures; Supplemental Material: 22 pages, 12 figures

Related papers

Nonclassicality detection from few Fock-state probabilities

Luca Innocenti, Lukáš Lachman, Radim Filip

Abstract Experimentally certifying the nonclassicality of quantum states in a reliable and efficient way is a challenge that remains both fundamental and daunting. Despite decades of topical research, techniques that can exploit optimally the information available in a given experimental setup are lacking. Here, we introduce a different paradigm to tackle these challenges, that is both directly applicable to experimental realities, and extendible to a wide variety of circumstances. We demonstrate that Klyshko’s criteria, which remained a primary approach to tackle nonclassicality for the past 20 years, is a special case of a much more general class of nonclassicality criteria. We provide both analytical results and numerical evidence for the optimality of our approach in several different scenarios of interest for trapped-ion, superconducting circuits, optical and optomechanical experiments with photon-number resolving detectors. This work represents a significant milestone towards a complete characterisation of the nonclassicality detectable from the limited knowledge scenarios faced in experimental implementations.

arXiv:2007.10067•npj Quantum Information•Mar 18, 2022•18 citations

Local-oscillator-agnostic squeezing detection

Suchitra Krishnaswamy, Dhrithi Maria, Laura Ares +3 more

We address the problem of measuring nonclassicality in continuous-variable bosonic systems without having access to a known reference signal. To this end, we construct broader classes of criteria for nonclassicality which allow us to investigate quantum phenomena regardless of the quantumness of selected subsystems. Such witnesses are based on the notion of partial normal ordering. This approach is applied to balanced homodyne detection using arbitrary, potentially nonclassical local oscillator states, yet only revealing the probed signal's quantumness. Our framework is compared to standard techniques, and the robustness and advanced sensitivity of our approach is shown. Therefore, a widely applicable framework, well-suited for applications in quantum metrology and quantum information, is derived to assess the quantum features of a photonic system when a well-defined coherent laser as a reference state is not available in the physical domain under study.

quant-pharXiv:2601.22291•Feb 2, 2026•0 citations

Quantifying nonclassicality of mixed Fock states

Spencer Rogers, Tommy Muth, Wenchao Ge

Nonclassical states of bosonic modes are important resources for quantum-enhanced technologies. However, quantifying nonclassicality of these states, in particular mixed states, can be a challenge. Here we present results of quantifying the nonclassicality of a bosonic mode in a mixed Fock state via the operational resource theory measure [Phys. Rev. Res. 2, 023400 (2020)], which relates nonclassicality to metrological advantage. Generally speaking, evaluating a resource-theoretic measure for mixed states is challenging, since it involves finding a convex roof. However, we show that our problem can be reduced to a linear programming problem. By analyzing the results of numerical optimization, we are able to extract analytical results for the case where three or four neighboring Fock states have nonzero population. Interestingly, we find that such a mode can be in distinct phases, depending on the populations. Finally, we demonstrate how our method is generalizable to density matrices of higher ranks. Our findings suggest a viable method for evaluating nonclassicality of arbitrary mixed bosonic states and potentially for solving other convex roof optimization problems.

arXiv:2406.01717•Physical Review A•Oct 1, 2024•1 citation

Witnessing the degree of nonclassicality of light

Martin Mráz, Jan Sperling, W. Vogel +1 more

We introduce an experimentally accessible method to measure a unique degree of nonclassicality, based on the quantum superposition principle, for arbitrary quantum states. We formulate witnesses and test a given state for any particular value of this measure. The construction of optimal tests is presented as well as the general numerical implementation. We apply this approach on examples such as squeezed states, and we show how to formulate conditions to certify a particular degree of nonclassicality for single- and multimode radiation fields.

arXiv:1406.7094•Physical Review A•Sep 8, 2014•31 citations

Unified nonclassicality criteria

S. Ryl, Jan Sperling, Elizabeth Agudelo +4 more

In this work we generalize the Bochner criterion addressing the characteristic function, i.e., the Fourier transform, of the Glauber-Sudarshan phase-space function. For this purpose we extend the Bochner theorem by including derivatives of the characteristic function. The resulting necessary and sufficient nonclassicality criteria unify previously known moment-based criteria with those based on the characteristic function. For applications of the generalized nonclassicality probes, we provide direct sampling formulas for balanced homodyne detection. A squeezed vacuum state is experimentally realized and characterized with our method. This complete framework---theoretical unification, sampling approach, and experimental implementation---presents an efficient toolbox to characterize quantum states of light for applications in quantum technology.

arXiv:1505.06089•Physical Review A•Jul 16, 2015•54 citations

Directly Estimating Nonclassicality

Andrea Mari, Konrad Kieling, B. Melholt Nielsen +2 more

We establish a method of directly measuring and estimating nonclassicality--operationally defined in terms of the distinguishability of a given state from one with a positive Wigner function. It allows us to certify nonclassicality, based on possibly much fewer measurement settings than necessary for obtaining complete tomographic knowledge, and is at the same time equipped with a full certificate. We find that even from measuring two conjugate variables alone, one may infer the nonclassicality of quantum mechanical modes. This method also provides a practical tool to eventually certify such features in mechanical degrees of freedom in opto-mechanics. The proof of the result is based on Bochner's theorem characterizing classical and quantum characteristic functions and on semidefinite programming. In this joint theoretical-experimental work we present data from experimental optical Fock state preparation.

arXiv:1005.1665•Physical Review Letters•Jan 7, 2011•104 citations
Nonclassicality in bosonic systems can be certified directly from occupation probabilities without full state reconstruction. To complete a library of such criteria we introduce a numerical framework that constructs optimal linear nonclassicality witnesses from arbitrary subsets of measured occupation probabilities by solving a semi-infinite linear program. The method contains known analytical criteria as special cases while generally detecting substantially larger nonclassical regions. We provide an open-source implementation of the numerical optimization together with the analytical criteria discussed here, enabling direct application of the framework to measured occupation statistics across bosonic platforms. As a case study, we apply it to the resonant Jaynes--Cummings model with thermal states and reveal nonclassicality at short interaction times and close to thermal balance, where detection of nonclassicality is otherwise challenging.
The paper asks how much bosonic nonclassicality can be certified from an arbitrary finite subset of Fock-state probabilities, without tomography. Classical counting statistics are mixtures of Poisson distributions pk(μ)=e−μμk/k!p_k(\mu)=e^{-\mu}\mu^k/k!pk​(μ)=e−μμk/k!. It optimizes linear witnesses λ⋅P−sup⁡μ≥0λ⋅p(μ)>0\lambda\cdot P-\sup_{\mu\geq0}\lambda\cdot p(\mu)>0λ⋅P−supμ≥0​λ⋅p(μ)>0, with ∣λi∣≤1|\lambda_i|\leq1∣λi​∣≤1 fixing normalization. This tests incompatibility with classical counting statistics, rather than detecting nonclassicality invisible to number measurements.
The optimization is formulated as a semi-infinite linear program and solved by an exchange procedure: solve a finite linear program, find the most violated Poisson constraint, and add it until a numerical tolerance is reached. The required global maximization reduces to evaluating a polynomial’s nonnegative stationary roots and the domain endpoints. An open-source Python implementation includes this procedure and the analytical criteria used for comparison.
Comparisons with Klyshko-type, majorization, and counting-matrix criteria find additional detectable regions, including for sparse probability subsets where those analytical tests are unavailable. No discrepancy is found for (P0,Pn)(P_0,P_n)(P0​,Pn​) or (P0,P1,P2)(P_0,P_1,P_2)(P0​,P1​,P2​); improvements appear with four consecutive probabilities.
For resonant Jaynes–Cummings evolution from thermal oscillator and qubit states, numerical tests extend detection toward shorter interaction times and thermal balance, nˉ=pe/(1−2pe)\bar n=p_e/(1-2p_e)nˉ=pe​/(1−2pe​). At pe=0.40p_e=0.40pe​=0.40, ten consecutive probabilities improve on counting-matrix detection near nˉ=2\bar n=2nˉ=2. Numerical comparisons and independent characteristic-function checks indicate exponential narrowing of the undetected interval with interaction time. Exact balance remains classical. The paper reports increasing numerical instability when many probabilities are needed, motivating complementary analytical tests.
Abstract Experimentally certifying the nonclassicality of quantum states in a reliable and efficient way is a challenge that remains both fundamental and daunting. Despite decades of topical research, techniques that can exploit optimally the information available in a given experimental setup are lacking. Here, we introduce a different paradigm to tackle these challenges, that is both directly applicable to experimental realities, and extendible to a wide variety of circumstances. We demonstrate that Klyshko’s criteria, which remained a primary approach to tackle nonclassicality for the past 20 years, is a special case of a much more general class of nonclassicality criteria. We provide both analytical results and numerical evidence for the optimality of our approach in several different scenarios of interest for trapped-ion, superconducting circuits, optical and optomechanical experiments with photon-number resolving detectors. This work represents a significant milestone towards a complete characterisation of the nonclassicality detectable from the limited knowledge scenarios faced in experimental implementations.
We address the problem of measuring nonclassicality in continuous-variable bosonic systems without having access to a known reference signal. To this end, we construct broader classes of criteria for nonclassicality which allow us to investigate quantum phenomena regardless of the quantumness of selected subsystems. Such witnesses are based on the notion of partial normal ordering. This approach is applied to balanced homodyne detection using arbitrary, potentially nonclassical local oscillator states, yet only revealing the probed signal's quantumness. Our framework is compared to standard techniques, and the robustness and advanced sensitivity of our approach is shown. Therefore, a widely applicable framework, well-suited for applications in quantum metrology and quantum information, is derived to assess the quantum features of a photonic system when a well-defined coherent laser as a reference state is not available in the physical domain under study.
Nonclassical states of bosonic modes are important resources for quantum-enhanced technologies. However, quantifying nonclassicality of these states, in particular mixed states, can be a challenge. Here we present results of quantifying the nonclassicality of a bosonic mode in a mixed Fock state via the operational resource theory measure [Phys. Rev. Res. 2, 023400 (2020)], which relates nonclassicality to metrological advantage. Generally speaking, evaluating a resource-theoretic measure for mixed states is challenging, since it involves finding a convex roof. However, we show that our problem can be reduced to a linear programming problem. By analyzing the results of numerical optimization, we are able to extract analytical results for the case where three or four neighboring Fock states have nonzero population. Interestingly, we find that such a mode can be in distinct phases, depending on the populations. Finally, we demonstrate how our method is generalizable to density matrices of higher ranks. Our findings suggest a viable method for evaluating nonclassicality of arbitrary mixed bosonic states and potentially for solving other convex roof optimization problems.
We introduce an experimentally accessible method to measure a unique degree of nonclassicality, based on the quantum superposition principle, for arbitrary quantum states. We formulate witnesses and test a given state for any particular value of this measure. The construction of optimal tests is presented as well as the general numerical implementation. We apply this approach on examples such as squeezed states, and we show how to formulate conditions to certify a particular degree of nonclassicality for single- and multimode radiation fields.
In this work we generalize the Bochner criterion addressing the characteristic function, i.e., the Fourier transform, of the Glauber-Sudarshan phase-space function. For this purpose we extend the Bochner theorem by including derivatives of the characteristic function. The resulting necessary and sufficient nonclassicality criteria unify previously known moment-based criteria with those based on the characteristic function. For applications of the generalized nonclassicality probes, we provide direct sampling formulas for balanced homodyne detection. A squeezed vacuum state is experimentally realized and characterized with our method. This complete framework---theoretical unification, sampling approach, and experimental implementation---presents an efficient toolbox to characterize quantum states of light for applications in quantum technology.
We establish a method of directly measuring and estimating nonclassicality--operationally defined in terms of the distinguishability of a given state from one with a positive Wigner function. It allows us to certify nonclassicality, based on possibly much fewer measurement settings than necessary for obtaining complete tomographic knowledge, and is at the same time equipped with a full certificate. We find that even from measuring two conjugate variables alone, one may infer the nonclassicality of quantum mechanical modes. This method also provides a practical tool to eventually certify such features in mechanical degrees of freedom in opto-mechanics. The proof of the result is based on Bochner's theorem characterizing classical and quantum characteristic functions and on semidefinite programming. In this joint theoretical-experimental work we present data from experimental optical Fock state preparation.