Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2610.30998

A Personal History in Quantum Foundations: an Oral History Interview

Yakir Aharonov, Guy Hetzroni

physics.hist-phquant-phSubmitted Oct 22, 2026• Announced Oct 23, 2026• 1 citation• Revised Oct 26, 2026 (v2)
v1 · Oct 22, 2026v2 · Oct 26, 2026
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

This oral history interview provides Yakir Aharonov's personal and conceptual recollections from the 1950s to the 2000s, focusing on his academic trajectory, some of his major contributions to quantum foundations, and his perspective on the development of the field. The interview traces Aharonov's academic career through the Technion, University of Bristol, Brandeis University, Yeshiva University, University of South Carolina, Tel Aviv University, George Mason University, and Chapman University. The interview also traces the development of Aharonov's work and collaborations on the EPR paradox, time-energy uncertainty relations, quantum measurement theory, quantum frames of reference, the two-state vector formalism, weak values, protective measurements, and several other contributions. It includes recollections of meetings and discussions with David Bohm, Niels Bohr, John Clauser, Paul Dirac, Rudolf Peierls, Aage Petersen, and Abner Shimony. Also mentioned: David Albert, Jeeva Anandan, Peter Bergmann, Gideon Carmi, Avshalom Elitzur, Dave Finkelstein, Vladimir Fock, Itzhak Kalugai, Ed Lerner, Joel Lebowitz, Stanley Mandelstam, Yuval Ne'eman, Sandu Popescu, Maurice Pryce, Daniel Rohrlich, Nathan Rosen, Joseph Safko, Paul Singer, Daniele Struppa, Leonard Susskind, Lev Vaidman, Chien-Shiung Wu.

AI Summary

This oral history examines the development of quantum-foundations research from the 1950s to the 2000s through personal recollections of research, collaborations, institutional settings, and debates about measurement and interpretation. Conducted in 2025–2026, the interview covers early work on EPR correlations and time–energy uncertainty, quantum reference frames, the Aharonov–Bergmann–Lebowitz rule, the two-state-vector formalism, weak values, and protective measurements. The discovery and subsequent debates surrounding the Aharonov–Bohm effect are largely reserved for a separate interview. The technical content is retrospective rather than a presentation of new results. An explanatory box reviews weak-measurement coupling, the weak value $A_w=\langle\phi|A|\psi\rangle/\langle\phi|\psi\rangle$, anomalous pointer shifts under postselection, quantum Cheshire Cat weak values, and adiabatic protective measurements. The narrative describes conceptual motivations for these constructions and discussions surrounding early polarization-correlation experiments and claims that energy measurements can be arbitrarily short. Several qualifications are explicit. The early polarization analysis excluded a particular natural classical model, not every local classical explanation as in Bell’s theorem. Protective measurement is reconsidered as effectively involving an ensemble over time, rather than allowing arbitrary unknown nonorthogonal states to be distinguished using one system. Numerous historical details and origins of ideas are acknowledged as uncertain or forgotten. The evidence consists primarily of edited recollections, supplemented by contextual footnotes and references; interpretive claims about nonlocality, disturbance, and quantum reality are presented as personal positions rather than newly established results.

No sign of AI-generated text

Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.

Comments
29 pages, 2 figures. Oral history interview; accepted for publication in EPJ H

Related papers

Theoretical discovery, experiment, and controversy in the Aharonov-Bohm effect: an oral history interview

Yakir Aharonov, Guy Hetzroni

Abstract This oral history interview provides Yakir Aharonov’s perspective on the theoretical discovery of the Aharonov-Bohm effect in 1959, during his PhD studies in Bristol with David Bohm, the reception of the effect, the efforts to test it empirically (up to Tonomura’s experiment), and some of the debates regarding the existence of the effect and its interpretation. The interview also discusses related later developments until the 1980s, including modular momentum and Berry’s phase. It includes recollections from meetings with Werner Heisenberg, Richard Feynman, and Chen-Ning Yang, also mentioning John Bell, Robert Chambers, Werner Ehrenberg, Sir Charles Frank, Wendell Furry, Gunnar Källén, Maurice Pryce, Nathan Rosen, John Wheeler, and Eugene Wigner.

arXiv:2508.08105•The European Physical Journal H•Sep 1, 2025•4 citations

Quantum coherence and reality : in celebration of the 60th birthday of Yakir Aharonov : International Conference on Fundamental Aspects of Quantum Theory, University of South Carolina, Columbia, USA, 10-12 December 1992

Jeeva S. Anandan, John L. Safko

Dynamic observation of flux lines based on the AB effect principle, A. Tonomura Aharonov effects for two slits and separated oscillatory fields interferences, N. Ramsey faster than Fourier, M. Berry quantum phase in action, A. Zee liberating exotic slaves, F. Wilczek evidence for a massive black hole in the center of our galaxy, C. Townes black holes, wormholes and the disappearance of global charge, S. Coleman unitarity of the black hole scattering matrix, G. t'Hooft topological phases and duality in electromagnetic and gravitational fields, J. Anandan non locality and objectivity in quantum state reduction, R. Penrose a non-polarization EPR experiment - observation of high-visibility Franson interference fringes, R.Y. Chiao et al toward It from Bit, J.A. Wheeler (para)bosons, (para)fermions, quons and other beasts in the menagerie of particle statistics, O.W. Greenberg et al a new formulation of quantum mechanics, Y. Aharonov. (Part contents).

WORLD SCIENTIFIC eBooks•Jan 1, 1994•11 citations

Foundations of Quantum Mechanics according to my teachers

P. B. Lerner

These are author's recollections of informal discussions on foundations of quantum mechanics, which happened in his presence in 1970-80s

arXiv:2001.05569•Jan 15, 2020•1 citation

Protective measurement of the wave function of a single system

Lev Vaidman A

My view on the meaning of the quantum wave function and its connection to protective measurements is described. The wave function and only the wave function is the ontology of the quantum theory. Protective measurements support this view although they do not provide a decisive proof. A brief review of the discovery and the criticism of protective measurement is presented. Protective measurements with postselection are discussed. Introduction In the first graduate course of quantum mechanics I remember asking the question: “Can we consider the wave function as a description of a single quantum system?” I got no answer. Twelve years later, in South Carolina, after I completed my Ph.D. studies at Tel Aviv University under the supervision of Yakir Aharonov in which we developed the theory of weak measurements [1], I asked Aharonov: Can we use weak measurement to observe the wave function of a single particle? At that time I had already become a strong believer in the many-worlds interpretation (MWI) of quantum mechanics [2] and had no doubt that a single system is described by the wave function. Yakir Aharonov never shared with me the belief in the MWI. When we realized that using what is called now protective measurement , we can, under certain conditions, observe the wave function of a single quantum system, he was really excited by the result. At 1992 I was invited to a conference on the Foundations of Quantum Mechanics in Japan where I presented this result: “The Schrödinger wave is observable after all!”[3]. Then I went home to Tel Aviv where I finished writing a letter which received mixed reviews in Phys. Rev. Lett. , while Jeeva Anandan, working on the topic with Aharonov in South Carolina, wrote a paper accepted in Phys. Rev. A [4]. After acceptance of the PRA paper it was hard to fight the referees in PRL, but PLA accepted it immediately [5].

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Nov 30, 2014•9 citations

The Bell inequalities: Commentary on the Nobel Prize in Physics 2022

Hong-Yi Su, Jing‐Ling Chen

The Nobel Prize in Physics 2022 was awarded to three experiment physicists: Alain Aspect, John F. Clauser and Anton Zeilinger, for their contributions to “experiments with entangled photons, establishing the violation of Bell inequalities and pioneering quantum information science”. In this paper, the history, basics, and applications related with the Bell inequalities are reviewed. The discussion of fundamental issues on quantum mechanics dated back to the year 1927 when the fifth Solvay conference was held, highlighting intense arguments between Albert Einstein and Niels Bohr. At the time, Einstein expressed, publicly for the first time, his critical attitude towards quantum mechanics. While the arguments did not reach a decisive conclusion, Bohr’s probabilistic interpretation of quantum mechanics, the Copenhagen interpretation, had since been well circulated among the community. Einstein’s arguments with Bohr lasted many years after the conference. The arguably most famous one was the Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen (EPR) paradox, proposed in a 1935 paper written by the three authors. They stated, by flawless reasoning, that quantum mechanics is ‘incomplete’. Bohr replied immediately. So did Erwin Schrödinger, who, in particular, coined the term ‘entangled’ for the first time to describe the bizarre quantum mechanical property. Nevertheless, the EPR paper received few citations at its publication, until 1990’s when quantum information science started blossoming. From today’s perspective, the paper resembles the ‘sleeping beauty’ who slumbered for decades before fully awakening. It has been widely accepted that it was John S. Bell who eventually resolved the EPR paradox. But many important figures before him should not go unnoticed, including John A. Wheeler, Chien-Shiung Wu, David Bohm, to name a few. In 1964, Bell wrote down a mathematical inequality which satisfies local hidden variable theory but which can be violated in quantum mechanics. The significance is that Bell’s inequality brings the rather philosophic debates on the EPR paradox down to be experimentally testable. Hence, an experiment is here appealing, as is the case in all fields of physics. To the end, John F. Clauser, alongside Stuart J. Freedman, conducted an experiment in 1972 to test a Bell inequality, the Bell-Clauser-Horne-Shimony-Holt (CHSH) inequality, proposed by him and his collaborators in 1969. The results, however, leaves loopholes open. One of the loopholes was closed in a later experiment led by Alain Aspect in 1982. The Bell-CHSH inequality was later tested under a much stricter condition by Anton Zeilinger’s team. Two most important loopholes were both closed by three teams in 2015 independently. Zeilinger’s team was among them. Almost all experiments to date have confirmed quantum mechanical predictions. Zeilinger’s team also performed the first teleportation of unknown quantum states, the first entanglement swapping, along with other contributions pioneering the quantum information science. In retrospect, the foundational study of quantum theory has been developed over a century. It once drew much of quantum physics founders’ attention, went virtually unnoticed while other physical fields advanced, had for quite a while been considered to have very weak relationship with major physics, and finally revived in recent decades leading to rapid progress in quantum information science and quantum technology. We believe that the Nobel Prize in Physics this year is not only an award and recognition to past achievements, but also heralds a new era of science in future.

Chinese Science Bulletin (Chinese Version)•Oct 26, 2022•2 citations

The dilemma of Einstein, Podolsky and Rosen - 60 years later : an International Symposium in Honour of Nathan Rosen - Haifa, March 1995

A. Mann, M. Revzen, Nathan Rosen

Some reflections on the EPR work, N. Rosen Philosophical reflections on EPR, A. Shimony Can EPR non-locality be geometrical? Y. Ne'Eman EPR in the 1990's: from paradox to crucial ingredient in frontier experiments, H.J. Lipkin Eistein-Podolsky-Rosen interferometry, A. Zeilinger Quantum phase, photon counting and EPR variables, M.T. Fontenelle, M. Freyberger, M. Heni, W.P. Schleich, M.S. Zubairy Fine structure of EPR state and universal quantum correlation, B.S. Tsirelson Locality, reality, EPR, and Bell's inequality, M. Lokajicek On the Pauli wave function and the EPR paradox, F. Piazzese Quantum nonreproducibility at the individual level as a resolution of quantum paradoxes, W. de Baere Quantum nonlocality and Bell's inequality, W.M. de Muynpk, W. De Baere On the conjecture that Bell's theorem is not true, E. Santos temporal Bell inequalities in quantum networks Quantum-optical Bell correlations in phase space, U. Leonhardt, J.A. Vaccaro More powerful tests of nonlocality by sequences of measurements, S. Popescu Nonlocality as an axiom for quantum theory, D. Rohrlich, S. Popescu Uncertainty principle for nonhermitian operators and its applications, L.P. Piyaevskii Measures of entanglement, A. Shimony Generalized two-mode squeezing and quantum entanglement Wave-particle duality for a single photon, A. Aspect Causality and nonlocality in faster- than- light photon travel Geometry of quantum inference, S.L. Braunstein Quantum information: how much information in a state vector? C.M. Caves, C.A. Fuchs Quantum and classical information transmission acts and reducibilities, C.H. Bennett Consequences and inconsequences of cryptic constrains, L.S. Schulman The meaning of protective measurements, Y. Aharonov, J. Anandan, L. Vaidman From E.P.R. to G.H.Z.: conference highlights, A. Peres.

•Jan 1, 1996•3 citations
This oral history interview provides Yakir Aharonov's personal and conceptual recollections from the 1950s to the 2000s, focusing on his academic trajectory, some of his major contributions to quantum foundations, and his perspective on the development of the field. The interview traces Aharonov's academic career through the Technion, University of Bristol, Brandeis University, Yeshiva University, University of South Carolina, Tel Aviv University, George Mason University, and Chapman University. The interview also traces the development of Aharonov's work and collaborations on the EPR paradox, time-energy uncertainty relations, quantum measurement theory, quantum frames of reference, the two-state vector formalism, weak values, protective measurements, and several other contributions. It includes recollections of meetings and discussions with David Bohm, Niels Bohr, John Clauser, Paul Dirac, Rudolf Peierls, Aage Petersen, and Abner Shimony. Also mentioned: David Albert, Jeeva Anandan, Peter Bergmann, Gideon Carmi, Avshalom Elitzur, Dave Finkelstein, Vladimir Fock, Itzhak Kalugai, Ed Lerner, Joel Lebowitz, Stanley Mandelstam, Yuval Ne'eman, Sandu Popescu, Maurice Pryce, Daniel Rohrlich, Nathan Rosen, Joseph Safko, Paul Singer, Daniele Struppa, Leonard Susskind, Lev Vaidman, Chien-Shiung Wu.
This oral history examines the development of quantum-foundations research from the 1950s to the 2000s through personal recollections of research, collaborations, institutional settings, and debates about measurement and interpretation. Conducted in 2025–2026, the interview covers early work on EPR correlations and time–energy uncertainty, quantum reference frames, the Aharonov–Bergmann–Lebowitz rule, the two-state-vector formalism, weak values, and protective measurements. The discovery and subsequent debates surrounding the Aharonov–Bohm effect are largely reserved for a separate interview.
The technical content is retrospective rather than a presentation of new results. An explanatory box reviews weak-measurement coupling, the weak value Aw=⟨ϕ∣A∣ψ⟩/⟨ϕ∣ψ⟩A_w=\langle\phi|A|\psi\rangle/\langle\phi|\psi\rangleAw​=⟨ϕ∣A∣ψ⟩/⟨ϕ∣ψ⟩, anomalous pointer shifts under postselection, quantum Cheshire Cat weak values, and adiabatic protective measurements. The narrative describes conceptual motivations for these constructions and discussions surrounding early polarization-correlation experiments and claims that energy measurements can be arbitrarily short.
Several qualifications are explicit. The early polarization analysis excluded a particular natural classical model, not every local classical explanation as in Bell’s theorem. Protective measurement is reconsidered as effectively involving an ensemble over time, rather than allowing arbitrary unknown nonorthogonal states to be distinguished using one system. Numerous historical details and origins of ideas are acknowledged as uncertain or forgotten. The evidence consists primarily of edited recollections, supplemented by contextual footnotes and references; interpretive claims about nonlocality, disturbance, and quantum reality are presented as personal positions rather than newly established results.
Abstract This oral history interview provides Yakir Aharonov’s perspective on the theoretical discovery of the Aharonov-Bohm effect in 1959, during his PhD studies in Bristol with David Bohm, the reception of the effect, the efforts to test it empirically (up to Tonomura’s experiment), and some of the debates regarding the existence of the effect and its interpretation. The interview also discusses related later developments until the 1980s, including modular momentum and Berry’s phase. It includes recollections from meetings with Werner Heisenberg, Richard Feynman, and Chen-Ning Yang, also mentioning John Bell, Robert Chambers, Werner Ehrenberg, Sir Charles Frank, Wendell Furry, Gunnar Källén, Maurice Pryce, Nathan Rosen, John Wheeler, and Eugene Wigner.
Dynamic observation of flux lines based on the AB effect principle, A. Tonomura Aharonov effects for two slits and separated oscillatory fields interferences, N. Ramsey faster than Fourier, M. Berry quantum phase in action, A. Zee liberating exotic slaves, F. Wilczek evidence for a massive black hole in the center of our galaxy, C. Townes black holes, wormholes and the disappearance of global charge, S. Coleman unitarity of the black hole scattering matrix, G. t'Hooft topological phases and duality in electromagnetic and gravitational fields, J. Anandan non locality and objectivity in quantum state reduction, R. Penrose a non-polarization EPR experiment - observation of high-visibility Franson interference fringes, R.Y. Chiao et al toward It from Bit, J.A. Wheeler (para)bosons, (para)fermions, quons and other beasts in the menagerie of particle statistics, O.W. Greenberg et al a new formulation of quantum mechanics, Y. Aharonov. (Part contents).
My view on the meaning of the quantum wave function and its connection to protective measurements is described. The wave function and only the wave function is the ontology of the quantum theory. Protective measurements support this view although they do not provide a decisive proof. A brief review of the discovery and the criticism of protective measurement is presented. Protective measurements with postselection are discussed. Introduction In the first graduate course of quantum mechanics I remember asking the question: “Can we consider the wave function as a description of a single quantum system?” I got no answer. Twelve years later, in South Carolina, after I completed my Ph.D. studies at Tel Aviv University under the supervision of Yakir Aharonov in which we developed the theory of weak measurements [1], I asked Aharonov: Can we use weak measurement to observe the wave function of a single particle? At that time I had already become a strong believer in the many-worlds interpretation (MWI) of quantum mechanics [2] and had no doubt that a single system is described by the wave function. Yakir Aharonov never shared with me the belief in the MWI. When we realized that using what is called now protective measurement , we can, under certain conditions, observe the wave function of a single quantum system, he was really excited by the result. At 1992 I was invited to a conference on the Foundations of Quantum Mechanics in Japan where I presented this result: “The Schrödinger wave is observable after all!”[3]. Then I went home to Tel Aviv where I finished writing a letter which received mixed reviews in Phys. Rev. Lett. , while Jeeva Anandan, working on the topic with Aharonov in South Carolina, wrote a paper accepted in Phys. Rev. A [4]. After acceptance of the PRA paper it was hard to fight the referees in PRL, but PLA accepted it immediately [5].
The Nobel Prize in Physics 2022 was awarded to three experiment physicists: Alain Aspect, John F. Clauser and Anton Zeilinger, for their contributions to “experiments with entangled photons, establishing the violation of Bell inequalities and pioneering quantum information science”. In this paper, the history, basics, and applications related with the Bell inequalities are reviewed. The discussion of fundamental issues on quantum mechanics dated back to the year 1927 when the fifth Solvay conference was held, highlighting intense arguments between Albert Einstein and Niels Bohr. At the time, Einstein expressed, publicly for the first time, his critical attitude towards quantum mechanics. While the arguments did not reach a decisive conclusion, Bohr’s probabilistic interpretation of quantum mechanics, the Copenhagen interpretation, had since been well circulated among the community. Einstein’s arguments with Bohr lasted many years after the conference. The arguably most famous one was the Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen (EPR) paradox, proposed in a 1935 paper written by the three authors. They stated, by flawless reasoning, that quantum mechanics is ‘incomplete’. Bohr replied immediately. So did Erwin Schrödinger, who, in particular, coined the term ‘entangled’ for the first time to describe the bizarre quantum mechanical property. Nevertheless, the EPR paper received few citations at its publication, until 1990’s when quantum information science started blossoming. From today’s perspective, the paper resembles the ‘sleeping beauty’ who slumbered for decades before fully awakening. It has been widely accepted that it was John S. Bell who eventually resolved the EPR paradox. But many important figures before him should not go unnoticed, including John A. Wheeler, Chien-Shiung Wu, David Bohm, to name a few. In 1964, Bell wrote down a mathematical inequality which satisfies local hidden variable theory but which can be violated in quantum mechanics. The significance is that Bell’s inequality brings the rather philosophic debates on the EPR paradox down to be experimentally testable. Hence, an experiment is here appealing, as is the case in all fields of physics. To the end, John F. Clauser, alongside Stuart J. Freedman, conducted an experiment in 1972 to test a Bell inequality, the Bell-Clauser-Horne-Shimony-Holt (CHSH) inequality, proposed by him and his collaborators in 1969. The results, however, leaves loopholes open. One of the loopholes was closed in a later experiment led by Alain Aspect in 1982. The Bell-CHSH inequality was later tested under a much stricter condition by Anton Zeilinger’s team. Two most important loopholes were both closed by three teams in 2015 independently. Zeilinger’s team was among them. Almost all experiments to date have confirmed quantum mechanical predictions. Zeilinger’s team also performed the first teleportation of unknown quantum states, the first entanglement swapping, along with other contributions pioneering the quantum information science. In retrospect, the foundational study of quantum theory has been developed over a century. It once drew much of quantum physics founders’ attention, went virtually unnoticed while other physical fields advanced, had for quite a while been considered to have very weak relationship with major physics, and finally revived in recent decades leading to rapid progress in quantum information science and quantum technology. We believe that the Nobel Prize in Physics this year is not only an award and recognition to past achievements, but also heralds a new era of science in future.
Some reflections on the EPR work, N. Rosen Philosophical reflections on EPR, A. Shimony Can EPR non-locality be geometrical? Y. Ne'Eman EPR in the 1990's: from paradox to crucial ingredient in frontier experiments, H.J. Lipkin Eistein-Podolsky-Rosen interferometry, A. Zeilinger Quantum phase, photon counting and EPR variables, M.T. Fontenelle, M. Freyberger, M. Heni, W.P. Schleich, M.S. Zubairy Fine structure of EPR state and universal quantum correlation, B.S. Tsirelson Locality, reality, EPR, and Bell's inequality, M. Lokajicek On the Pauli wave function and the EPR paradox, F. Piazzese Quantum nonreproducibility at the individual level as a resolution of quantum paradoxes, W. de Baere Quantum nonlocality and Bell's inequality, W.M. de Muynpk, W. De Baere On the conjecture that Bell's theorem is not true, E. Santos temporal Bell inequalities in quantum networks Quantum-optical Bell correlations in phase space, U. Leonhardt, J.A. Vaccaro More powerful tests of nonlocality by sequences of measurements, S. Popescu Nonlocality as an axiom for quantum theory, D. Rohrlich, S. Popescu Uncertainty principle for nonhermitian operators and its applications, L.P. Piyaevskii Measures of entanglement, A. Shimony Generalized two-mode squeezing and quantum entanglement Wave-particle duality for a single photon, A. Aspect Causality and nonlocality in faster- than- light photon travel Geometry of quantum inference, S.L. Braunstein Quantum information: how much information in a state vector? C.M. Caves, C.A. Fuchs Quantum and classical information transmission acts and reducibilities, C.H. Bennett Consequences and inconsequences of cryptic constrains, L.S. Schulman The meaning of protective measurements, Y. Aharonov, J. Anandan, L. Vaidman From E.P.R. to G.H.Z.: conference highlights, A. Peres.