Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2610.29404

Bounds on Attainable Rate Modulation in Fermi's Golden Rule

Kaisei Ohata, Jun-Yu Dong, Yasutaka Kitahama, Akihito Ishizaki, Keisuke Goda

quant-phphysics.chem-phSubmitted Oct 21, 2026• Announced Oct 22, 2026• 0 citations• Revised Oct 22, 2026 (v2)
v1 · Oct 21, 2026v2 · Oct 22, 2026
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Controlling transition rates is a central objective across quantum optics, condensed-matter physics, and chemical physics, encompassing processes such as spontaneous emission, energy and charge transfer, spin relaxation, and chemical reactions. Although Fermi's golden rule provides a powerful framework for calculating such rates of weakly coupled transitions, conventional calculations require the interaction to be specified in advance; the range of rate responses attainable over a broader interaction space remains unknown. We formulate spectral-overlap golden-rule rates as quadratic forms of the interaction and derive rigorous bounds on rate modulation over a specified interaction space. As an example, application to energy transfer from a donor to a molecular vibration coupled to an optical cavity reveals that enhancement and suppression depend jointly on the interaction and cavity detuning, including continuous reversal of the rate response for a fixed interaction. The same approach may elucidate rate control for other golden-rule processes, including excitation-energy transfer, nonadiabatic electron transfer, nonradiative electronic transitions, vibrational and spin relaxation, and spontaneous emission.

AI Summary

The paper asks how much a transition rate described by Fermi’s golden rule can be enhanced or suppressed when the interaction is allowed to vary within a specified space. This differs from calculating a rate for a single prescribed interaction: the objective is to constrain the range of attainable rate responses across a family of couplings. The approach expresses spectral-overlap golden-rule rates as quadratic forms in the interaction and uses this representation to derive rigorous bounds on rate modulation. The interaction space is therefore part of the specification of the bounds, rather than an unrestricted set of possible controls. The abstract does not provide explicit bound formulas, numerical values, or the mathematical conditions for attaining the bounds. The example concerns energy transfer from a donor to a molecular vibration coupled to an optical cavity. Enhancement and suppression depend jointly on the interaction and cavity detuning. In particular, varying the detuning can continuously reverse the rate response while keeping the interaction fixed. The stated framework concerns weakly coupled transitions described by spectral-overlap golden-rule rates. Extensions to excitation-energy transfer, electron transfer, nonradiative transitions, relaxation, and spontaneous emission are proposed as potential applications, not reported demonstrations. With only the abstract available, the tightness of the bounds and the assumptions underlying the cavity example cannot be assessed.

No sign of AI-generated textUnclear noveltyMissing comparison

Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the abstract only. Automated: it can be wrong.

Comments
6 pages, 2 figures

Related papers

Simulating Electronically Nonadiabatic Dynamics and Spectroscopy via Quantum Master Equations That Treats Off-Diagonal Electronic Coupling Perturbatively

Yifan Lai

The simulation of electronically nonadiabatic dynamics and spectroscopy remains as a central challenge in computational chemistry. Amongst the reduced dynamic methods, various forms of the perturbative quantum master equation (QME) including Fermi's golden rule (FGR), Redfield equation, and Marcus theory enjoy widespread use for their efficiency in the perturbative regime, and provides important physical intuition for the underlying dynamics. In the first chapter of this dissertation, the accuracy of various QMEs that treat off-diagonal electronic coupling perturbatively (OD-QME) will be examined on a spin-boson model. OD-QME works in the interaction picture, limiting its application to population dynamics. A novel way of retrieving Schrodinger picture coherences from interaction picture dynamics will be introduced, and the resulting dynamics will be compared against the numerically exact multi-configuration time dependent Hartree method. It will be shown that OD-QME can generate accurate population and coherence in appropriate parameter ranges, and that the time-nonlocal QME is more accurate than time-local QME, especially if the QME uses a population only projection. In the second chapter, the aforementioned method of calculating electronic coherence via OD-QME is applied to the simulation of absorption spectra. The result will be compared against the numerically exact hierarchical equations of motion, as well as the Redfield time-local QME which is widely applied in the context of spectroscopy. It will be shown that OD-QME exhibits comparable accuracy to Redfield QME over a wide parameter range. Both QMEs fail to predict the spectra accurately in the case of a high-frequency bath at a low temperature, and this error is likely to be linked to the quantum behavior of the bath. In the third chapter, the FGR rates of electronically nonadiabatic reactions enhanced by a microcavity is calculated. It will be shown that the cavity-enhanced reaction rates can be evaluated from the cavity-free FGR correlation function with minimum additional effort, and this method will be applied to a model CT reaction. While a high-frequency cavity enhances reactions in the Marcus inverted region selectively, a low-frequency cavity enhances reactions in all regions uniformly. In the fourth chapter, the FGR charge transfer rate constants for a molecular triad system solvated in explicit solvent is calculated via linear semiclassical (LSC) approach. A Marcus-like expression can be derived after applying a hierarchy of approximations. The validity of such approximations will be confirmed for the triad model. It will also be shown that the charge transfer rate depends deeply on the conformation of the molecule, the fluctuation between which is the rate-limiting step of the charge transfer.

•Jan 1, 2022•0 citations

Quantum Rate Processes

Uri Peskin

The rates of charge transfer and energy transfer are essential for understanding nanoscale phenomena and processes. Here we introduce the general conditions for the emergence of rate processes in quantum mechanics. We refer to the generic scenario in which a transition is induced between eigenstates of a given Hamiltonian by a weak perturbation. Analysis reveals that when the initial and final states are pure states, the transition rate is time-dependent and fails to reach a finite constant value. If, however, the final state is a mixed ensemble that is sufficiently wide and dense in energy, a rate constant emerges, given by Fermi’s Golden Rule (FGR). When the initial state is also mixed, for example, a thermal equilibrium state, a thermal rate constant is formulated in terms of transition rates between specific eigenstates, summed over the final eigenstates, and averaging over the thermal distribution of the initial eigenstates.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•May 11, 2023•0 citations

Spontaneous Emission from Resonance (Metastable) Electronic States

Amir Sivan, Meir Orenstein, Milan Šindelka +1 more

We expand the fundamental theory of light-matter interactions by rigorously deriving spontaneous emission from quantum resonance states. The generalized Fermi golden rule unveils nontrivial dependence between the photon lifetime and the native resonance decay.

Conference on Lasers and Electro-Optics•Jan 1, 2025•0 citations

Emergence of Fermi’s Golden Rule

Tobias Micklitz, Alan Morningstar, Alexander Altland +1 more

Fermi's golden rule applies in the limit where an initial quantum state is weakly coupled to a continuum of other final states overlapping its energy. Here we investigate what happens away from this limit, where the set of final states is discrete, with a nonzero mean level spacing; this question arises in a number of recently investigated many-body systems. For different symmetry classes, we analytically and/or numerically calculate the universal crossovers in the average decay of the initial state as the level spacing is varied, with the golden rule emerging in the limit of a continuum. Among the corrections to the exponential decay of the initial state given by Fermi's golden rule is the appearance of the spectral form factor in the longtime regime for small but nonzero level spacing.

arXiv:2206.00704•Physical Review Letters•Sep 27, 2022•34 citations

Microcavity Lasers and QED

Gunnar G. Bjork

This chapter gives an overview of the field as it stands at the time of writing in mid 1995. It shows how the picture radically changes when there is more than one atom in the cavity. The simplest light-atom interaction one can think of is the coupling between a single atom and a single mode of the electromagnetic field. This system provides considerable insight into the fundamental physics of the light-atom coupling but the reader is warned that the more general many mode-many atom interactions are much richer in their dynamics. An atom in free space couples not only to one, but to a continuum of modes. The mathematics of the Weisskopf-Wigner theory of spontaneous emission tends to obscure the relatively simple physics of the emission process. An alternative, shorter way of calculating the single atom spontaneous emission rate is to use Fermi’s Golden rule, which is a prescription for calculating general transition rates to first order in perturbation theory.

CRC Press eBooks•Dec 23, 2020•0 citations

Fermi’s Golden Rule for Spontaneous Emission in Absorptive and Amplifying Media

Sebastian Franke, Juanjuan Ren, Marten Richter +2 more

We demonstrate a fundamental breakdown of the photonic spontaneous emission (SE) formula derived from Fermi's golden rule, in absorptive and amplifying media, where one assumes the SE rate scales with the local photon density of states, an approach often used in more complex, semiclassical nanophotonics simulations. Using a rigorous quantization of the macroscopic Maxwell equations in the presence of arbitrary linear media, we derive a corrected Fermi's golden rule and master equation for a quantum two-level system (TLS) that yields a quantum pumping term and a modified decay rate that is net positive. We show rigorous numerical results of the temporal dynamics of the TLS for an example of two coupled microdisk resonators, forming a gain-loss medium, and demonstrate the clear failure of the commonly adopted formulas based solely on the local density of states.

arXiv:2102.13015•Physical Review Letters•Jun 29, 2021•49 citations
Controlling transition rates is a central objective across quantum optics, condensed-matter physics, and chemical physics, encompassing processes such as spontaneous emission, energy and charge transfer, spin relaxation, and chemical reactions. Although Fermi's golden rule provides a powerful framework for calculating such rates of weakly coupled transitions, conventional calculations require the interaction to be specified in advance; the range of rate responses attainable over a broader interaction space remains unknown. We formulate spectral-overlap golden-rule rates as quadratic forms of the interaction and derive rigorous bounds on rate modulation over a specified interaction space. As an example, application to energy transfer from a donor to a molecular vibration coupled to an optical cavity reveals that enhancement and suppression depend jointly on the interaction and cavity detuning, including continuous reversal of the rate response for a fixed interaction. The same approach may elucidate rate control for other golden-rule processes, including excitation-energy transfer, nonadiabatic electron transfer, nonradiative electronic transitions, vibrational and spin relaxation, and spontaneous emission.
The paper asks how much a transition rate described by Fermi’s golden rule can be enhanced or suppressed when the interaction is allowed to vary within a specified space. This differs from calculating a rate for a single prescribed interaction: the objective is to constrain the range of attainable rate responses across a family of couplings.
The approach expresses spectral-overlap golden-rule rates as quadratic forms in the interaction and uses this representation to derive rigorous bounds on rate modulation. The interaction space is therefore part of the specification of the bounds, rather than an unrestricted set of possible controls. The abstract does not provide explicit bound formulas, numerical values, or the mathematical conditions for attaining the bounds.
The example concerns energy transfer from a donor to a molecular vibration coupled to an optical cavity. Enhancement and suppression depend jointly on the interaction and cavity detuning. In particular, varying the detuning can continuously reverse the rate response while keeping the interaction fixed.
The stated framework concerns weakly coupled transitions described by spectral-overlap golden-rule rates. Extensions to excitation-energy transfer, electron transfer, nonradiative transitions, relaxation, and spontaneous emission are proposed as potential applications, not reported demonstrations. With only the abstract available, the tightness of the bounds and the assumptions underlying the cavity example cannot be assessed.
The simulation of electronically nonadiabatic dynamics and spectroscopy remains as a central challenge in computational chemistry. Amongst the reduced dynamic methods, various forms of the perturbative quantum master equation (QME) including Fermi's golden rule (FGR), Redfield equation, and Marcus theory enjoy widespread use for their efficiency in the perturbative regime, and provides important physical intuition for the underlying dynamics. In the first chapter of this dissertation, the accuracy of various QMEs that treat off-diagonal electronic coupling perturbatively (OD-QME) will be examined on a spin-boson model. OD-QME works in the interaction picture, limiting its application to population dynamics. A novel way of retrieving Schrodinger picture coherences from interaction picture dynamics will be introduced, and the resulting dynamics will be compared against the numerically exact multi-configuration time dependent Hartree method. It will be shown that OD-QME can generate accurate population and coherence in appropriate parameter ranges, and that the time-nonlocal QME is more accurate than time-local QME, especially if the QME uses a population only projection. In the second chapter, the aforementioned method of calculating electronic coherence via OD-QME is applied to the simulation of absorption spectra. The result will be compared against the numerically exact hierarchical equations of motion, as well as the Redfield time-local QME which is widely applied in the context of spectroscopy. It will be shown that OD-QME exhibits comparable accuracy to Redfield QME over a wide parameter range. Both QMEs fail to predict the spectra accurately in the case of a high-frequency bath at a low temperature, and this error is likely to be linked to the quantum behavior of the bath. In the third chapter, the FGR rates of electronically nonadiabatic reactions enhanced by a microcavity is calculated. It will be shown that the cavity-enhanced reaction rates can be evaluated from the cavity-free FGR correlation function with minimum additional effort, and this method will be applied to a model CT reaction. While a high-frequency cavity enhances reactions in the Marcus inverted region selectively, a low-frequency cavity enhances reactions in all regions uniformly. In the fourth chapter, the FGR charge transfer rate constants for a molecular triad system solvated in explicit solvent is calculated via linear semiclassical (LSC) approach. A Marcus-like expression can be derived after applying a hierarchy of approximations. The validity of such approximations will be confirmed for the triad model. It will also be shown that the charge transfer rate depends deeply on the conformation of the molecule, the fluctuation between which is the rate-limiting step of the charge transfer.
The rates of charge transfer and energy transfer are essential for understanding nanoscale phenomena and processes. Here we introduce the general conditions for the emergence of rate processes in quantum mechanics. We refer to the generic scenario in which a transition is induced between eigenstates of a given Hamiltonian by a weak perturbation. Analysis reveals that when the initial and final states are pure states, the transition rate is time-dependent and fails to reach a finite constant value. If, however, the final state is a mixed ensemble that is sufficiently wide and dense in energy, a rate constant emerges, given by Fermi’s Golden Rule (FGR). When the initial state is also mixed, for example, a thermal equilibrium state, a thermal rate constant is formulated in terms of transition rates between specific eigenstates, summed over the final eigenstates, and averaging over the thermal distribution of the initial eigenstates.
Fermi's golden rule applies in the limit where an initial quantum state is weakly coupled to a continuum of other final states overlapping its energy. Here we investigate what happens away from this limit, where the set of final states is discrete, with a nonzero mean level spacing; this question arises in a number of recently investigated many-body systems. For different symmetry classes, we analytically and/or numerically calculate the universal crossovers in the average decay of the initial state as the level spacing is varied, with the golden rule emerging in the limit of a continuum. Among the corrections to the exponential decay of the initial state given by Fermi's golden rule is the appearance of the spectral form factor in the longtime regime for small but nonzero level spacing.
This chapter gives an overview of the field as it stands at the time of writing in mid 1995. It shows how the picture radically changes when there is more than one atom in the cavity. The simplest light-atom interaction one can think of is the coupling between a single atom and a single mode of the electromagnetic field. This system provides considerable insight into the fundamental physics of the light-atom coupling but the reader is warned that the more general many mode-many atom interactions are much richer in their dynamics. An atom in free space couples not only to one, but to a continuum of modes. The mathematics of the Weisskopf-Wigner theory of spontaneous emission tends to obscure the relatively simple physics of the emission process. An alternative, shorter way of calculating the single atom spontaneous emission rate is to use Fermi’s Golden rule, which is a prescription for calculating general transition rates to first order in perturbation theory.
We demonstrate a fundamental breakdown of the photonic spontaneous emission (SE) formula derived from Fermi's golden rule, in absorptive and amplifying media, where one assumes the SE rate scales with the local photon density of states, an approach often used in more complex, semiclassical nanophotonics simulations. Using a rigorous quantization of the macroscopic Maxwell equations in the presence of arbitrary linear media, we derive a corrected Fermi's golden rule and master equation for a quantum two-level system (TLS) that yields a quantum pumping term and a modified decay rate that is net positive. We show rigorous numerical results of the temporal dynamics of the TLS for an example of two coupled microdisk resonators, forming a gain-loss medium, and demonstrate the clear failure of the commonly adopted formulas based solely on the local density of states.