arXiv:2610.27589
Fate of Discrete Time Crystals in Finite-Size Cavity QED Systems
Haimi Nguyen, David R. Reichman
Abstract
It has been shown that Discrete Time Crystal (DTC) behavior may arise in the periodically driven, open Dicke model in the thermodynamic limit ($N \rightarrow \infty$). In this work, we demonstrate that finite $N$ non-mean-field fluctuations in this model can lead to decay rates and amplitudes of transient DTCs that display a non-trivial non-monotonic behavior with an increasing number of atoms. We show that the second-order cumulant expansion fails to capture the finite-size dynamics, while a stochastic version of the Truncated Wigner Approximation (TWA) is remarkably accurate, particularly in the large atom ensemble limit. Using the TWA and the Monte Carlo Wave Function (MCWF) approach, we identify three distinct dynamical regimes of transient DTC behavior in the finite-size Dicke model. We outline the mechanism behind the non-monotonic finite size dynamical decay of DTC order and discuss the implications for experiments performed on finite-sized atomic assemblies.
AI Summary
The paper asks how finite atom number affects period-doubled discrete-time-crystal (DTC) dynamics in the periodically driven open Dicke model, whose DTC behavior was previously established at mean-field level. It studies a collective spin coupled to a lossy cavity, with atom–cavity coupling switched on and off during alternating half-periods. Lindblad evolution and Monte Carlo wave-function simulations are compared with full second-order cumulant closure and a stochastic truncated Wigner approximation (TWA). The cumulant closure can become unstable or misrepresent symmetry-breaking observables. TWA reproduces the benchmark dynamics more closely; across selected detunings, the mean absolute magnetization discrepancy over 100 drive cycles is below $0.05$ for $N>20$. Identical spin evolution allows the sampled spins to be grouped into four initial-state classes, making propagation cost independent of $N$. Simulations distinguish rapidly unstable, transient, and effectively nondecaying DTC responses over the observation window. Both decay rates and oscillation amplitudes can vary nonmonotonically with $N$, including amplitude suppression around $N\sim100$–$500$ before recovery toward mean field. Phase-space analysis attributes this to the shrinking initial fluctuation cloud sampling competing, opposite-phase attractor basins; chaotic decorrelation additionally contributes in transient regimes. The finite-size maps use exact methods for $N\leq20$ up to 1,500 periods and TWA for larger systems up to 5,000 periods. Long-time stability of the apparently nondecaying, termed “pre-thermal,” regime remains unresolved, and TWA has amplitude errors at small $N$. Experimental applicability requires a superradiant transition; the omitted diamagnetic $A^2$ term can preclude it in conventional cavity-QED settings.
Error found: The systematic TWA benchmark covers only 100 drive periods and does not establish quantitative accuracy of the long-time decay rates extracted from simulations extending to 5000 periods. The stated exact-method coverage stops at N=20, but several figures and benchmark statements report exact comparisons at larger N without explaining the numerical method used there. The Floquet construction freezes the longitudinal spin rather than linearizing about the driven orbit, and its printed propagator uses full-period evolution for each of the two half-period drive segments. Figure 4(a) labels linear instability as chaos, although instability of the approximate linear map does not establish chaos of the nonlinear driven system. The supplementary Wigner equation prints a cavity-loss diffusion coefficient twice the value required by both the Lindblad equation and the paper's correctly normalized stochastic equations.
Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.